Contents12 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
The tube says „silicone-free“, and yet the product does not fit the Curly Girl routine. The reason: silicones are only one of several ingredients this method avoids. Our advice up front: start with a silicone-free leave-in cream without proteins, such as the got2b Curlz Styling Creme, and only layer a gel on top if your curls fall too soft after drying. The back of the bottle decides. Not the label on the front.
What does the Curly Girl Method actually require?
There is no binding standard. In a press release on got2b, Henkel describes the method as a care routine that avoids silicones, sulfates, drying alcohols such as ethanol and isopropanol, parabens, mineral oils and wax, and does without heat when styling. That is a usable working definition. However, no independent body confirms whether a product is „Curly Girl approved“; such claims are manufacturer statements.
One example shows why it pays to look at the ingredient list: the Garnier Fructis Locken Methode Flexi Hold Gel belongs to a range that even by its name („curl method“) sounds like a curl routine. In the ingredient list that Garnier itself publishes, sodium lauryl sulfate is in seventh place. So if you follow the rules strictly, you will pass on this one. If you only want hold, you can still use it.
Silicones, sulfates, proteins: what is proven?
The evidence is thinner than the strict rules suggest. In a 2019 test of silicone-free shampoos, the German consumer magazine Öko-Test wrote that silicones make hair look smoother and easier to comb, but that with continuous use hair can look limp. There is also an environmental argument: according to Öko-Test, the siloxanes D4 and D5 are considered persistent, and the EU has restricted them in shampoos since 2020. Stiftung Warentest, Germany’s leading consumer testing organization, considered the problem of heavy, sticky hair largely solved as early as 2006. You can recognize silicones on the ingredient list by names ending in „-methicone“.
On sulfates, the scientific literature is cautious. A review in the International Journal of Trichology (Gavazzoni Dias, 2015) states that anionic surfactants such as sodium lauryl sulfate or sodium laureth sulfate cleanse strongly and can increase the negative charge on the hair surface, which increases frizz and friction. But the same paper also says there are no published studies on the cleansing power or gentleness of sulfate-free shampoos. So sulfate-free is plausible, but not a proven advantage.
According to the same paper, proteins and polypeptides adhere well to hair because they have many charged sites. No study can predict for you whether your hair will benefit or feel like straw. That is why we mark in the table where hydrolyzed proteins or keratin amino acids appear on the list. Incidentally, a leave-in cannot „repair“ hair damage; such claims are the manufacturer’s marketing language.
Seven curl products and what is in them
| Model | Type and size | Ingredients according to the manufacturer | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| got2b Curlz Styling Creme (gotCurlz) | Leave-in cream, 200 ml | Silicone-free; shea butter, coconut, castor and argan oil; no hydrolyzed protein on the list | Curls and coils that need moisture; also as a mask |
| got2b Curlz Jelly Stylinggel | Gel, 150 ml, light hold | Silicone-free; glycerin, carrageenan from red algae; no protein on the list | Second step on top of a cream |
| Garnier Fructis Locken Methode Flexi Hold | Gel, 370 ml, flexible hold | Hyaluronic acid; sodium lauryl sulfate and PEG-40 on the list | Everyday hold, not for strict Curly Girl rules |
| Briogeo Curl Charisma Leave-In Defining Crème | Cream, 59 or 177 ml | Rice amino acids, avocado oil; keratin amino acids and hydrolyzed quinoa | Waves to coils that tolerate protein |
| Briogeo Curl Charisma Frizz Control Gel | Gel, light to medium hold | Carrageenan, rice amino acids; keratin amino acids and hydrolyzed quinoa | Definition with protein, without a hard cast |
| Cantu Shea Butter Coconut Curling Cream | Styling cream | Free of mineral oil, sulfates, parabens, silicones; shea butter | Thick curls that should fall longer |
| Cantu Shea Butter Moisturizing Curl Activator Cream | Leave-in cream | Free of mineral oil, sulfates, parabens, silicones; shea butter | Wash-and-go, refreshing on day two |
got2b Curlz Styling Creme
Our starting point. Schwarzkopf publishes the complete ingredient list, and it contains neither silicones nor sulfates nor hydrolyzed proteins. According to the manufacturer, the cream can be applied as a leave-in to towel-dried hair, used in a small amount the next day to refresh, or used as a pre-shampoo treatment and mask. One limitation: perfume and fragrance ingredients such as linalool, limonene and citral are on the list. If your scalp is sensitive to fragrance, that is a reason to keep looking.
got2b Curlz Jelly Stylinggel
A short, water-based formula with glycerin and carrageenan. The manufacturer states light hold and recommends applying the gel generously to wet hair, scrunching upward and drying with a diffuser or in the air. If you already use the cream above, you get a routine from a single brand, with both ingredient lists openly available.
Garnier Fructis Locken Methode Flexi Hold
Garnier promises protection against humidity for up to 100 hours; that is a manufacturer claim, not a measurement by an independent body. According to the instructions, the gel can be applied to damp or dry hair and is not rinsed out. Because of the sulfate, it is not suitable for a routine according to Henkel’s definition. If you want to style without silicones and can live with a sulfate in your gel, you get 370 ml here.
Briogeo Curl Charisma Leave-In Defining Crème
Briogeo aims the cream at waves, curls and coils and recommends a small, coin-sized amount in damp hair. According to the manufacturer, it is vegan and 95 percent of natural origin. The list contains keratin amino acids and hydrolyzed quinoa. For protein-sensitive hair, that is the wrong choice; for fine hair that quickly goes limp, exactly this content may be desirable.
Briogeo Curl Charisma Frizz Control Gel
The matching gel for the cream, according to Briogeo with light to medium hold and no stiffness. One to two coin-sized portions go into damp hair, followed by air drying or a diffuser. Here too, keratin amino acids and quinoa are on the list.
Cantu Coconut Curling Cream and Curl Activator Cream
Cantu lists both creams as free of mineral oil, sulfates, parabens, silicones, phthalates, paraffin and propylene glycol. According to the manufacturer, the Curling Cream should be applied section by section from root to tip in damp hair, while the Activator Cream is intended for a quick wash-and-go and can be reapplied to dry hair. Cantu does not provide a complete ingredient list on its website, and the information there refers to the US market. So check the jar before adding it to a strict routine.
Diffuser or air: which is gentler on curls?
The Curly Girl rule „no heat“ sounds clear-cut, but the research is not. A study in the Annals of Dermatology (Lee and colleagues, 2011) dried hair strands 30 times using different methods. The hotter and closer the dryer, the more the surface suffered, most of all at 95 °C from 5 cm away. Air drying took over two hours and was the only method that damaged the cell membrane complex inside the hair. The authors conclude that a dryer held 15 cm away and kept constantly moving does less damage than staying wet for a long time.
In everyday terms, that means: low setting, diffuser attachment, keep your distance. Which hair dryers come with a diffuser and how their temperature settings differ is covered in our hair dryer guide. If you would rather create curls with heat than enhance your own, you will find the tools in our curling iron guide (in German).
Which combination for which hair?
- Strict Curly Girl routine without protein: got2b Curlz Styling Creme, with the Curlz Jelly on top if needed.
- Fine waves that quickly go limp: Briogeo cream or gel, provided your hair tolerates protein.
- Thick, kinky curls and coils: one of the Cantu creams, but check the ingredients on the jar first.
- Just hold against frizz, rules do not matter: Garnier Flexi Hold.
A switch takes patience. Öko-Test points out that hair can look damaged at first after switching to silicone-free care. So give a new routine more than two or three washes before you judge. And do not buy five products at once.
Frequently asked questions
Which ingredients does the Curly Girl Method avoid?
There is no binding standard. Henkel describes the method as a routine without silicones, sulfates, drying alcohols such as ethanol, parabens, mineral oils and wax, and without heat when styling. Claims such as "Curly Girl approved" are not confirmed by any independent body; they are manufacturer statements.
Are sulfate-free products really better for curls?
Plausible, but not proven. A review in the International Journal of Trichology describes how sulfates cleanse strongly and can increase frizz. But the same paper says there are no published studies on the cleansing power or gentleness of sulfate-free shampoos.
How do I recognize silicones on the ingredient list?
You can recognize silicones by names ending in "-methicone". Also look out for sulfates such as sodium lauryl sulfate: the Garnier Fructis Locken Methode Flexi Hold Gel sounds like a curl routine product, but according to Garnier it contains it in seventh place.
What should you keep in mind about proteins in curl products?
No study can predict for you whether your hair tolerates proteins well or feels like straw afterwards. The Briogeo products contain keratin amino acids and hydrolyzed quinoa, so they are not the right choice for protein-sensitive hair. The got2b Curlz cream lists no hydrolyzed protein.
Air drying or diffuser: which is gentler on curls?
A study in the Annals of Dermatology found that very hot dryer air from close up damages the surface, but long air drying damages the cell membrane complex inside. The authors consider a dryer held 15 cm away and kept constantly moving to be gentler. In everyday terms: low setting, diffuser, keep your distance.
How long does the switch to silicone-free care take?
The German consumer magazine Öko-Test points out that hair can look damaged at first after switching. Give a new routine more than two or three washes before you judge, and do not buy five products at once.
Sources
- got2b: Curlz Styling Creme
- got2b: Curlz Jelly Stylinggel
- Henkel: press release on got2b gotWAVEZ and gotCURLZ (PDF)
- Garnier: Fructis Locken Methode Flexi Hold
- Briogeo: Curl Charisma Leave-In Defining Crème
- Briogeo: Curl Charisma Frizz Control Gel
- Cantu: Coconut Curling Cream
- Cantu: Moisturizing Curl Activator Cream
- Öko-Test: silicone-free shampoo (2019)
- Stiftung Warentest: silicones in shampoos (2006)
- Gavazzoni Dias: Hair Cosmetics, An Overview. Int J Trichology 2015
- Lee et al.: Hair Shaft Damage from Heat and Drying Time of Hair Dryer. Ann Dermatol 2011
Where to buy
- got2b Curlz Styling CremeCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- got2b Curlz Jelly StylinggelCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Garnier Fructis Locken Methode Flexi HoldCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Briogeo Curl Charisma Leave-In Defining CrèmeCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Briogeo Curl Charisma Frizz Control GelCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Cantu Shea Butter Coconut Curling CreamCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Cantu Shea Butter Moisturizing Curl Activator CreamCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
