Black Friday Woche ab 19.11.: unsere Wahl je Ratgeber
Independent buying adviceEvery claim with a sourceNo paid verdicts1,731 guides and reviews in German How we test
handgetestet

Deutsch

Buying Eyebrow Products 2026: Pencil, Gel, Tint, Lift

Eyebrow products 2026: pencil, pomade, gel, tinting and lifting at home. Seven products from NYX to BeautyLash, with shades and allergy warnings.

handgetestet editorial team · Updated November 16, 2026
Contents13 sections

This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.

If you want to define your brows for the first time, you don’t need a six-piece kit. A fine pencil with a spoolie and a tinted gel are enough. As a starting point, we consider the NYX Micro Brow Pencil the most sensible choice, because it comes in twelve shades and draws thin strokes that look like individual hairs. Everything else, from pomade to lamination, is a question of time, hair texture and patience with chemicals.

The mistakes you regret later rarely happen at the checkout. More often at the bathroom mirror.

Pencil, pomade or gel: which suits my brows?

The answer depends less on the brand than on what your brows are missing. If they’re thick but unruly, a gel that holds the hairs in shape is enough. If there are individual gaps, a pencil draws in the missing hairs. Pomade covers larger areas and, according to the manufacturers, lasts longer, but it’s less forgiving: use too much, and the brow looks painted on.

  • Thin or patchy brows: fine pencil, then a gel to set.
  • Light, barely visible hairs: tinted gel with fibers, or tinting.
  • Sports, sauna, long days: waterproof pomade or a color that lasts several days.
  • Bushy brows that should point upward: Brow Glue or a lift.

Our advice is simple: work in daylight. A well-lit mirror helps more than a third product; we present models for this in our guide to makeup mirrors.

Which shade if I’m torn between two?

Take the lighter one. You can always add more, but you can’t take it away without removing your makeup. For the Brow Glue, NYX states explicitly that the color can be built up in layers. With tints, the manufacturers set the direction. BeautyLash assigns its Brown shade to dark blonde to medium brown hair, Dark Brown to medium to dark brown hair, and Black only to dark hair. RefectoCil recommends mixing Natural Brown with Graphite if the result should look cooler, and with Red or Chestnut for a softer tone.

Seven products, sorted by effort

ProductTypeKey data according to manufacturerBest for
NYX Micro Brow PencilPencil with spoolieultra-thin twist-up tip, 12 shades, veganFilling gaps with hair-fine strokes
essence make me BROW eyebrow gel mascaraTinted gel with fibers3.8 ml, 7 shades, vegan, free of oil and fragranceLight or fine brows, quick routine
Maybelline Tattoo Brow Pomade PotPomade in a potmatte, waterproof, up to 24 hours; angled brush and spoolieFull shape, long days
NYX The Brow Glue Instant Brow StylerSetting gelup to 16 hours of hold, waterproof, 5 shades incl. clearLaminated look without chemicals
Maybelline Tattoo Brow AugenbrauenfarbePeel-off gelpeel off after 20 minutes at the earliest, color lasts up to 3 daysVacation, weekend, trial run
BeautyLash Brow & Lash ColourTint kit, two gelsno mixing, up to 6 weeks, up to 10 applicationsTinting at home
BeautyLash Brow Lift KitLift kitperm 6 minutes, setting 4 minutes, up to 8 applicationsExperienced users with non-sensitive skin

The starting point: NYX Micro Brow Pencil

Twist-up tip at one end, spoolie at the other. NYX recommends short strokes in the direction of hair growth, then blending with the spoolie. The range goes from 01 Taupe through 05.5 Cool Ash Brown to 08 Black, plus 07.5 Grey. For longer hold, the manufacturer itself recommends a gel on top. That’s honest, and it shows the limit of a pencil alone.

Two minutes in the morning: essence make me BROW

The tinted gel contains tiny fibers that cling to the hairs and make the brow look fuller. Seven shades from blondy brows to Black Brows are available, vegan and free of oil, parabens and fragrance, according to essence. On very patchy brows, the skin underneath remains visible. There, you’ll need the pencil as well.

When the shape needs to last until evening: Maybelline Tattoo Brow Pomade Pot

Creamy, highly pigmented, matte. Maybelline describes the formula as waterproof and states up to 24 hours without smudging. The included applicator has an angled brush side for the outline and a spoolie side for blending. Our recommendation is to draw the lower edge first and only sweep the front of the brow with what’s left on the brush. Otherwise you get the hard block familiar from photos. If you work with brushes more often, you’ll find tips on shapes and bristles in our guide to makeup brushes (in German).

Look laminated without laminating: NYX The Brow Glue

According to the manufacturer, the gel holds the hairs in place for up to 16 hours without sticking or flaking, and it’s waterproof. There are five versions, one of them clear. NYX recommends brushing the brows upward at the end. That creates the brushed-up look of a lamination. In the evening, it’s gone again, and that’s exactly why it makes sense to start with.

Color for a few days: Maybelline Tattoo Brow Augenbrauenfarbe

The gel is applied, dries and can be peeled off after 20 minutes at the earliest. What remains is a tint that, according to Maybelline, lasts up to three days after a two-hour drying time. No developer is needed. Even so, Maybelline recommends in its FAQ a test on an inconspicuous patch of skin before first use, and stopping immediately if redness or burning occurs.

Tinted for weeks: BeautyLash Brow & Lash Colour

BeautyLash is the home-use line of GW Cosmetics, the maker of RefectoCil. The kit works with two gels applied one after the other: gel 1 works for two minutes, gel 2 for one minute. The skin around the brow should be protected beforehand with kohl pencil or a rich cream, but none of it may get on the hairs themselves. According to the manufacturer, the result lasts up to six weeks. The ingredient list of gel 2 includes silver nitrate; p-phenylenediamine or toluene-2,5-diamine don’t appear there.

Lamination at home: BeautyLash Brow Lift Kit

This is where it gets chemical. The Brow Perm works for six minutes, the setting lotion for four. The kit contains thiolactic acid and ammonia for this, and the setting lotion contains hydrogen peroxide. The instructions require keeping the skin around the brow as free of product as possible. The comparison with the professional kit from the same group of companies is striking: the RefectoCil Brow Lamination Kit lists almost the same active ingredients and carries the warning „For professional use only,“ along with „Avoid contact with eyes“ and „Wear suitable gloves.“

Our position: if you want to lift your brows for the first time, have it done at a salon and watch. At home, then, only with a steady hand, gloves and no irritated skin.

Tinting and allergies: what do the authorities and manufacturers say?

Classic salon tints like RefectoCil’s are oxidative. They are mixed 1:1 with a three-percent developer, work for five to ten minutes and last up to six weeks. No. 3 Natural Brown contains toluene-2,5-diamine, which RefectoCil itself labels as phenylenediamine. The manufacturer warns of severe allergic reactions, excludes people under 16 and advises against use with a facial rash, after previous reactions to hair dye or after a „black henna“ tattoo. An allergy alert test is recommended 48 hours before every application.

The German Federal Institute for Risk Assessment (Bundesinstitut für Risikobewertung, BfR) is critical of exactly this self-test. In its opinion 015/2014, it writes that p-phenylenediamine has a high allergenic potential and that a self-test doubles the number of skin contacts, which can increase the risk of sensitization. According to the BfR, a PPD allergy, once acquired, cannot be cured. What this means for consumers: oxidative brow tints belong in experienced hands, and whether and how testing is done is something to clarify at the salon. If you’ve already reacted to hair dye, have it checked by a doctor beforehand.

How we would decide

  • To get to know it: NYX Micro Brow Pencil in the right shade, plus NYX The Brow Glue in Clear.
  • As little effort as possible: essence make me BROW, one sweep in the morning, done.
  • Long days, sports: Maybelline Tattoo Brow Pomade Pot, applied sparingly.
  • Test first, then tint: Maybelline Tattoo Brow Augenbrauenfarbe for a weekend.
  • Tinting at home without mixing: BeautyLash Brow & Lash Colour.
  • Lifting: start at a salon, and use the BeautyLash Brow Lift Kit only once you have experience.

And since brows are rarely done on their own, a look at our mascara guide (in German) on brushes and formulas makes sense next.

Frequently asked questions

Pencil, pomade or gel: which suits my brows?

It depends on what your brows are missing. Thick, unruly brows only need a gel that holds the hairs in shape. Where there are gaps, a pencil draws in the missing hairs. Pomade covers larger areas and, according to the manufacturers, lasts longer, but it's less forgiving: too much of it looks painted on.

Which shade do I choose if I'm torn between two?

Take the lighter one. You can always add more, but you can't take it away without removing your makeup. For the Brow Glue, NYX states explicitly that the color can be built up in layers. With tints, the manufacturers assign their shades to specific hair colors.

How do I get the laminated look without chemicals?

With a setting gel such as NYX The Brow Glue, which according to the manufacturer holds the hairs for up to 16 hours and is waterproof. NYX recommends brushing the brows upward at the end. In the evening, the look is gone again, and that's exactly why it makes sense to start with.

Can you lift your eyebrows at home?

It's possible with the BeautyLash Brow Lift Kit, but it works with thiolactic acid, ammonia and hydrogen peroxide. A professional kit with almost the same active ingredients carries the warning "For professional use only." For the first time, we think a salon is the right place; at home, only with gloves and without irritated skin.

How long does eyebrow tint last?

According to the manufacturer, the Maybelline Tattoo Brow peel-off gel tint lasts up to three days. The BeautyLash tint kit with two gels states up to six weeks, as do oxidative salon tints such as RefectoCil. Maybelline recommends a test on an inconspicuous patch of skin before first use.

What should I know about allergies and brow tint?

Oxidative tints can contain p-phenylenediamine or related substances, and RefectoCil warns of severe allergic reactions. The German Federal Institute for Risk Assessment (BfR) is critical of self-testing, because it doubles skin contact, and states that a PPD allergy cannot be cured. If you've already reacted to hair dye, have it checked by a doctor beforehand.

Sources

Where to buy

Sale, delivery, warranty and product safety are the sole responsibility of the respective retailer and manufacturer. All information without guarantee; prices and availability may change.

Links marked as affiliate links earn us a small commission if you buy through them. The price stays the same for you, and our verdict stays independent. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.