Contents13 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
Many foundation mistakes start in the drugstore aisle under fluorescent light. A swipe on the back of the hand, the shade looks right, and at home the bathroom mirror reveals a sharp line along the jaw. For long days and rather oily skin, we consider Estée Lauder’s Double Wear the most solid choice, and on a small budget, Maybelline’s Super Stay Active Wear. Both are matte. If you have dry skin and like a fresh glow, neither of them will make you happy.
Matte, glow or satin: which finish suits my skin?
The finish determines satisfaction more than the logo on the bottle. Matte formulas take the shine out of the face. Maybelline explicitly states that the Super Stay Active Wear is also suitable for oily and combination skin. Glow foundations such as Dior Forever Skin Glow, on the other hand, leave light on the skin. On dry cheeks, that can look fresh; on a forehead that is already shiny, it quickly becomes too much.
Satin sits in between.
With combination skin and dry patches, matte is not automatically right. A thin layer of a luminous formula and a little powder only on the forehead, nose and chin often looks more natural than a fully matte foundation that settles into fine flakes on the cheeks. And whatever the formula: without well-prepared skin, none of them will last. We’ve sorted suitable skincare to wear underneath in our moisturizer guide.
How do I find my shade without buying three bottles?
Lightness is only half the answer. Just as important is the undertone, that is, whether your skin looks more rosy (cool), golden (warm) or balanced (neutral). Brands almost always put it in the shade name these days. At Estée Lauder, it’s in the code as C, N or W, for example 2C2 or 3N2. Clinique separates into CN and WN, and Dior works with Neutral, Warm, Cool and in-between levels like Warm Olive.
Test on the jawbone. Three narrow stripes side by side, then into the daylight by the window. The right shade is the one that simply disappears at the transition to the neck. Give the stripes a quarter of an hour, because foundation looks different wet than dry.
Online, it gets trickier. On Amazon.de, each shade is sold as a separate listing, and the names sometimes differ from the manufacturer’s: the 130 of L’Oréal Infaillible is called True Beige by L’Oréal, but Cool Rose in one Amazon listing. So rely on the number and compare it with the manufacturer’s shade finder.
What do 24, 30 or 36 hours on the packaging tell you?
Less than they promise. The figures come from the brands‘ own tests, whose procedures the product pages usually don’t disclose. Maybelline states 30 hours, L’Oréal 32, Dior 24. In Germany, Estée Lauder now advertises the Double Wear with 36 hours; older packaging still says 24. An office day with a phone at your ear, followed by a workout and a summer wedding on the weekend, is a completely different load than a test protocol. More revealing is what a formula is supposed to resist. Fenty lists sweat, humidity and transfer for the Pro Filt’r, and Dior says it had its Glow formula tested for heat and humidity.
Does the SPF in makeup replace sunscreen?
No. Laboratories determine the SPF with a thick layer of 2 milligrams per square centimeter of skin, as described by the German consumer advice center Verbraucherzentrale. Hardly anyone applies that much foundation. SPF 25 from L’Oréal or 20 from Clinique is a pleasant extra for the walk to the train. If you spend longer outdoors, you need separate sun protection underneath. We’ve compiled which products wear well under makeup in our guide to facial sunscreen (in German).
Six foundations you can get on Amazon.de
| Model | Finish | Wear (manufacturer’s claim) | SPF | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Estée Lauder Double Wear Stay-in-Place | matte | 36 hours | 10 | oily and combination skin, long days |
| Dior Forever Skin Glow | radiant | 24 hours | depending on version | normal to dry skin, those who like a glow |
| Maybelline Super Stay Active Wear 30H | soft matte, high coverage | 30 hours | none stated | small budget, shiny skin |
| L’Oréal Paris Infaillible 32H Fresh Wear | liquid and light, finish not stated | 32 hours | 25 | office days, mid-range budget |
| Fenty Beauty Pro Filt’r Soft Matte Longwear | soft matte, buildable | no hour figure | none stated | very fair or very dark shades |
| Clinique Even Better Clinical Serum Foundation | satin matte | no hour figure | 20, mineral | those looking for satin rather than matte |
Estée Lauder Double Wear Stay-in-Place
For many years, the foundation that long-wear formulas have to be measured against. Matte, SPF 10, 30 ml and, according to Estée Lauder, more than 55 shades with the undertone in the code. On very dry skin, it can look mask-like. On Amazon.de, it pays to take a second look at the name, because right next to it is the Double Wear Maximum Cover, a camouflage version with considerably heavier coverage.
Dior Forever Skin Glow
The opposite direction to the Double Wear: radiant finish, 24 hours of wear according to the manufacturer, more than 40 shades. Price-wise, it’s at the upper end. On Amazon.de, perfumeries also sell it as third-party sellers alongside Amazon, so shipping costs and returns differ from listing to listing.
Maybelline Super Stay Active Wear 30H
The cheapest of the six, on Amazon.de about a third of the price of the Estée Lauder, depending on the shade. Maybelline promises high coverage, a soft matte finish and up to 30 hours of wear. It is said to be suitable for all skin types, including sensitive skin. If you have very dry skin, you should still lean toward the glow camp.
L’Oréal Paris Infaillible 32H Fresh Wear
The middle ground from the drugstore. L’Oréal describes a liquid, light texture with SPF 25 and 32 hours of wear, but doesn’t commit to a finish. Because of the different shade names on Amazon.de, it’s better to order by number.
Fenty Beauty Pro Filt’r Soft Matte Longwear
Fenty offers the Pro Filt’r in 50 shades. Especially at the ends of the scale, that is, for very fair or very dark skin, the selection is larger than with many competitors. Fenty describes it as waterproof and resistant to sweat, humidity and transfer, but gives no hour figure. Several listings on Amazon.de come from sellers in the UK, so check delivery time and shipping beforehand.
Clinique Even Better Clinical Serum Foundation
Clinique states SPF 20 with mineral filters and lists 42 shades in the CN and WN system. The listing on Amazon.de describes the finish as satin matte. An option for faces that don’t want shine but don’t want a powdery surface either.
So which one should I choose?
- Long days, oily or combination skin, budget secondary: Estée Lauder Double Wear.
- The same profile on a tight budget: Maybelline Super Stay Active Wear 30H.
- Dry skin and a desire for radiance: Dior Forever Skin Glow.
- Very fair or very dark complexion: Fenty Pro Filt’r, then Estée Lauder.
- A bottle with SPF for office days: L’Oréal Infaillible, though it still doesn’t replace sunscreen.
One more word about the evening. Long-wear foundation doesn’t come off well with water alone; a thorough cleanser is part of the routine, and our facial cleanser guide (in German) presents candidates. If you tend to react to cosmetics, apply anything new to a small spot on your neck first, and discuss known allergies to ingredients with your dermatologist.
Frequently asked questions
Which foundation finish suits my skin?
Matte formulas take away shine and suit oily and combination skin. Glow foundations such as Dior Forever Skin Glow leave light on the skin, which can look fresh on dry cheeks. For combination skin with dry areas, a thin luminous layer with a little powder on the forehead, nose and chin often looks more natural.
How do I find the right foundation shade?
Besides lightness, the undertone matters: cool, warm or neutral. Test three narrow stripes on your jawbone and check them in daylight by the window. The right shade is the one that disappears at the transition to the neck. Give the stripes a quarter of an hour; foundation looks different once it has dried.
What should I watch out for when buying foundation on Amazon?
Each shade is sold as a separate listing, and the shade names sometimes differ from the manufacturer's. The 130 of L'Oréal Infaillible is called True Beige by L'Oréal, but Cool Rose in one Amazon listing. So order by the number and compare it with the manufacturer's shade finder.
What do 24, 30 or 36 hours of wear on the packaging mean?
Less than the number promises. The figures come from the brands' own tests, whose procedures the product pages usually don't disclose. More revealing is what a formula is supposed to resist: Fenty lists sweat, humidity and transfer for the Pro Filt'r, and Dior says it had its Glow formula tested for heat and humidity.
Does foundation with SPF replace sunscreen?
No. According to the German consumer advice center Verbraucherzentrale, laboratories determine the sun protection factor using 2 milligrams per square centimeter of skin, and hardly anyone applies that much foundation. SPF 25 from L'Oréal or 20 from Clinique is an extra for short trips. If you spend longer outdoors, you need separate sun protection underneath.
Which foundation is available for very fair or very dark skin?
Fenty Beauty Pro Filt'r comes in 50 shades, and especially at the ends of the scale, the selection is larger than with many competitors. Next comes Estée Lauder Double Wear with more than 55 shades. Several Fenty listings come from sellers in the UK, so check delivery time and shipping beforehand.
Sources
- Estée Lauder: Double Wear Stay-in-Place Foundation SPF 10
- Dior Beauty: Forever Skin Glow
- Maybelline: Super Stay Active Wear Foundation
- L’Oréal Paris: Infaillible 32H Fresh Wear Make-up
- Fenty Beauty: Pro Filt’r Soft Matte Longwear Foundation
- Clinique: Even Better Clinical Serum Foundation SPF 20
- Verbraucherzentrale: sunscreen, what to look out for (German)
Where to buy
- Estée Lauder Double Wear Stay-in-Place FoundationCheck price at Amazon.de
- Maybelline Super Stay Active Wear 30H FoundationCheck price at Amazon.de
- Dior Forever Skin Glow FoundationCheck price at Amazon.de
- L'Oréal Paris Infaillible 32H Fresh Wear Foundation (130 True Beige)Check price at Amazon.de
- Fenty Beauty Pro Filt'r Soft Matte Longwear Foundation (170)Check price at Amazon.de
- Clinique Even Better Clinical Serum FoundationCheck price at Amazon.de
