Contents12 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
If your polish chips at the tips after three days, the shade is rarely to blame. Usually a step was missing. For hands that wash dishes, type and carry bags all day, we recommend essie gel couture: two coats of color, a matching top coat, up to 15 days of wear according to the manufacturer, and no lamp. If, on the other hand, you are still painting at ten in the evening and want to be in bed by half past, Sally Hansen Insta-Dri serves you better.
In between are three-step systems, polishes with no base or top coat at all, and treatment polishes that are not meant to add color. Which one fits depends less on the brand than on how much time you spend at the sink.
Why polish gives up at the edge first
A classic nail polish is a film that only forms as it dries. In the ingredient lists of polishes from essie, OPI and Catrice, ethyl acetate and butyl acetate come first, along with nitrocellulose. The solvents evaporate, leaving a thin, hard layer. Applied thickly, it dries on the outside and stays soft inside. Then a pillowcase is enough to ruin it.
That is why manufacturers unanimously advise thin coats. For its Infinite Shine system, OPI specifies a one- to two-minute pause after each coat and recommends painting the free edge of the nail as well. That is exactly where everyday wear rubs first. Catrice describes the base coat as a primer that improves the vibrancy and coverage of the color, especially with light shades. The top coat seals and protects the color. With essie gel couture, you should reapply it after seven days if you want the polish to last longer.
And what does „gel“ mean without a lamp? OPI explains it for Infinite Shine like this: the polymer chains in the polish are already pre-crosslinked, adhere to the nail like gel, and still come off with regular remover. Real gel polish, by contrast, only cures under UV or LED light and has to be soaked off. If you expect two to three weeks of wear, you end up with gel and a suitable lamp for gel nails.
Six bottles, six jobs
| Model | Steps | Wear according to the manufacturer | Who it’s for |
|---|---|---|---|
| essie gel couture | 2 coats of color, 1 top coat, no base coat needed | up to 15 days | Everyday life with lots of hand washing |
| OPI Infinite Shine | Base, 2 coats of color, top coat | up to 11 days | People who like to work precisely |
| Sally Hansen Insta-Dri | 1 step, base and top coat built in | dry in 60 seconds | Painting under time pressure |
| Catrice GEL AFFAIR Nail Lacquer | Color without base or top coat | up to 7 days | Trying out colors, weekends |
| essie base & top coat all-in-one | one bottle as base and top coat | no figure in days | Wearing regular polish longer |
| OPI Nail Envy Original | Treatment polish, alone or as a base | Reapply daily, remove after 7 days | Soft, splitting nails |
essie gel couture
We start here because this system demands the least discipline. With its matching top coat, essie promises up to 15 days of wear and a gel-like shine without a UV lamp. The routine is short: two coats of color, one coat of top coat; according to the manufacturer, a base coat is not needed. The polish comes off with both acetone and acetone-free remover, without soaking. Without the matching top coat, however, the day count does not apply; the bottle alone is only half the solution.
OPI Infinite Shine
Three steps instead of two, but the most precisely described system. OPI quotes up to 11 days of wear, a wide brush and a vegan formula. After the top coat, the polish is touch-dry in about five minutes, according to OPI.
Sally Hansen Insta-Dri
Here the clock is what counts. Sally Hansen states a drying time of 60 seconds and builds base and top coat directly into the formula. According to the manufacturer, the polish lasts 33 percent longer and chips less than the old formula. Sally Hansen gives no wear time in days. For nails right before an appointment, it is an honest solution; for a two-week vacation, less so.
Catrice GEL AFFAIR Nail Lacquer
Catrice quotes up to seven days of wear, and that without base or top coat. The bottle holds 10.5 ml, the formula is vegan according to the manufacturer, and açaí oil is on the ingredient list. The cap is made of recycled plastic, the bottle of at least 20 percent recycled glass.
essie base & top coat all-in-one
One bottle for underneath and on top. essie recommends one coat on the bare nail, two coats of color, then all-in-one once more to seal. According to the manufacturer, the formula is vegan and formaldehyde-free; argan oil is on the ingredient list.
OPI Nail Envy Original
Not a color polish but a treatment polish with biotin, calcium and vitamins A, C and E. OPI recommends two coats on the bare nail, then one more coat daily, and removing it after seven days. According to OPI, it also works as a base coat under color. The claim „95 percent stronger nails in one week“ comes from the manufacturer itself, with use as directed.
Formaldehyde-free, 9-free, vegan: what the labels are worth
For Nail Envy, OPI lists nine substances that are not included, among them formaldehyde, toluene and triphenyl phosphate. Lists like that sound reassuring but say little about the rest of the formula. The Austrian food safety agency AGES states that formaldehyde is banned for nail hardening. In a targeted inspection in 2021, it objected to three out of 30 nail hardeners that advertised being formaldehyde-free, because that merely meets a legal minimum requirement. In another sample, it detected 1.6 percent formaldehyde.
At OPI, „vegan“ means no ingredients or by-products of animal origin. It says nothing about how well your skin tolerates it. If your dermatologist has given you a list of substances to avoid, compare it with the full ingredient list. essie, OPI and Catrice publish these on their product pages.
Removing polish without damage
Acetone or acetone-free? Öko-Test, a German consumer testing magazine, examined 23 removers advertised as acetone-free; the report appeared in October 2025. The result is sobering. Whether acetone, ethyl acetate or alcohol: all solvents strip oils from skin and nails. Two of the supposedly acetone-free products still contained acetone in relevant amounts. The dermatologist quoted in the report advises moisturizing your hands after removing polish, for example with urea or glycerin, and giving your nails a few weeks without polish now and then. Otherwise, with constant use, white spots can form, so-called keratin granulations. You will find a rich cream in our guide to hand creams (in German).
Do not scrape off leftovers. Catrice recommends a soaked cotton pad, drawn with light pressure from the nail bed to the tip. And do not simply paint over leftovers either. If you do not want to let any polish dry at all, our guide to press-on nails (in German) covers the route via artificial nails.
Which polish for which routine?
- Lots of water, lots of keyboard, little desire for touch-ups: essie gel couture with the matching top coat.
- You like to work carefully and take a bit more time: OPI Infinite Shine, all three steps.
- Five minutes until you are out the door: Sally Hansen Insta-Dri.
- Trying new colors without buying into a whole system: Catrice GEL AFFAIR.
- Keeping your old polishes and wearing them longer: essie base & top coat all-in-one.
- Nails that tear when you open a can: OPI Nail Envy first, color later.
If your nails keep splitting despite care, or become discolored, that belongs in a dermatologist’s office and not under another coat of polish.
Frequently asked questions
Why does nail polish chip at the tips first?
Everyday wear rubs the free edge of the nail first. OPI therefore recommends painting the edge as well and waiting one to two minutes after each coat. Polish applied thickly dries on the outside and stays soft inside, which is why manufacturers unanimously advise thin coats.
What is the difference between gel-effect polish without a lamp and real gel polish?
In polishes like OPI Infinite Shine, the polymer chains are already pre-crosslinked, according to OPI; they adhere like gel and come off with regular remover. Real gel polish only cures under UV or LED light and has to be soaked off. For two to three weeks of wear, the way leads to gel and a lamp.
Do I need a base coat and a top coat?
That depends on the system. According to the manufacturer, essie gel couture needs no base coat but does need the matching top coat. Catrice GEL AFFAIR does without both, and Sally Hansen Insta-Dri has both built into the formula. According to Catrice, the base coat improves vibrancy and coverage; the top coat seals the color.
Which nail polish dries fastest?
Sally Hansen states a drying time of 60 seconds for Insta-Dri and builds base and top coat into the formula. The manufacturer gives no figure for wear time in days. That works for nails right before an appointment, less so for a two-week vacation.
What does formaldehyde-free on the label tell you?
Not much. According to the Austrian agency AGES, formaldehyde is banned for nail hardening anyway. In a targeted inspection in 2021, it objected to three out of 30 nail hardeners that advertised being formaldehyde-free. If you need to avoid certain substances, you are better off comparing the full ingredient list on the product page.
Is acetone-free nail polish remover gentler?
Not necessarily. Öko-Test (a German consumer testing magazine) examined 23 removers advertised as acetone-free: all solvents strip oils from skin and nails, and two products still contained acetone in relevant amounts. After removing polish, moisturize your hands and give your nails a few weeks without polish now and then.
Sources
- essie: gel couture nail polish (application, ingredients)
- essie: gel couture top coat
- essie: base & top coat all-in-one
- OPI: Infinite Shine (product page)
- OPI: How to apply Infinite Shine
- OPI: Questions about the Infinite Shine formula
- OPI: Nail Envy Nail Strengthener
- Sally Hansen: Insta-Dri Nail Color
- Catrice: GEL AFFAIR Nail Lacquer
- Catrice: Applying and removing nail polish
- AGES: Formaldehyde in nail hardeners (2021)
- Öko-Test: Nail polish removers (October 2025)
Where to buy
- essie gel coutureCheck price at Amazon.de
- essie gel couture Top CoatCheck price at Amazon.de
- OPI Infinite Shine (Dulce de Leche)Check price at Amazon.de
- Sally Hansen Insta-Dri (413 Expresso)Check price at Amazon.de
- Catrice GEL AFFAIR Nail Lacquer (010 Nude)Check price at Amazon.de
- essie base & top coat all-in-oneCheck price at Amazon.de
- OPI Nail Envy OriginalCheck price at Amazon.de
