Contents14 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
The box says S3, so there must be a steel sole inside? Since the standard was revised, that is true, but not necessarily for shoes from old stock. For workshops, warehouses and interior finishing, we recommend a low shoe in class S3S with a choice of widths, such as the Elten Maddox Low ESD S3S. If you work on structural construction sites between formwork boards full of nails, you are better off following the recommendation of the German Social Accident Insurance (DGUV) and choosing a steel insert, meaning true S3.
The letter after the three is what decides it.
What do S1, S2, S3, S3L and S3S mean under EN ISO 20345:2022?
Every safety shoe has a toe cap that must withstand an impact of 200 joules and a compression of 15 kilonewtons. According to DGUV Rule 112-191, that roughly corresponds to a 20-kilogram mass falling from a height of one meter, or a weight of 1,500 kilograms. The classes build on this, and the DGUV breaks them down for the 2022 version of the standard as follows:
- S1: closed heel area, antistatic, shock absorption in the heel area
- S2: like S1, plus protection against water penetration and water absorption in the upper
- S3: like S2, plus a cleated sole and a metallic insert against penetration
- S3L: like S3, but with a non-metallic insert, tested with a 4.5-millimeter nail
- S3S: non-metallic insert, tested with the thinner 3-millimeter nail
- S6 and S7: like S2 and S3 respectively, but the entire shoe is also waterproof (S7L, S7S accordingly)
Penetration protection without a cleated sole and upper protection also exists. In that case, the S1 is followed by a P for steel, a PL or a PS. If you work in dry halls, you should check with your employer whether that is sufficient.
And the old stock? Shoes certified to EN ISO 20345:2011 could be called S3 regardless of whether steel or textile was under the foot. They were only tested with the 4.5-millimeter nail, and stating the material was not required. So check the year on the label inside the shaft as well.
Steel or textile under the sole?
There are reasons for both. The DGUV states that where nails thinner than 3 millimeters are to be expected, only a metallic insert provides sufficient protection in the protected sole area. In its list of examples, it explicitly recommends the steel insert for building and civil engineering, carpentry, scaffolding and demolition. Textile inserts, on the other hand, cover the entire sole area, while a steel plate leaves a narrow edge uncovered due to its design. They are more flexible and insulate better against cold and heat. Where there are no nails on the floor, for example in a carpentry shop or warehouse, that comfort counts for more in everyday use.
The standard does not prescribe a material for the toe cap. Steel deforms permanently after a hard blow, while plastic and composite caps partially spring back. In both cases, according to manufacturers, a cap that has taken a hit should be checked and replaced if necessary.
Which additional markings do I really need?
The basic slip resistance test is carried out on ceramic tiles with a soap solution. SR means that the sole has also passed on tiles with glycerin, a sensible addition for oily workshop floors. FO stands for fuel-resistant, HRO for behavior under contact heat, HI and CI for heat and cold insulation of the sole construction. LG means better grip on ladders, SC an abrasion-resistant toe cover. ESD shoes are tested to a separate standard, DIN EN IEC 61340. According to the DGUV, a shoe is considered electrostatically dissipative if the resistance is at most 100 megohms, and antistatic between 100 kilohms and 1,000 megohms. If you work with sensitive electronics, clarify the requirement with your employer beforehand.
How do I find the right width?
Width is not standardized. The DGUV describes it as the volume of the forefoot at the ball and advises always trying safety shoes on. Uvex offers the uvex 2 in widths 10, 11, 12 and 14, and Elten offers the Maddox in a separate version for wide feet. According to the DGUV, there is no universal marking for widths. So width 12 at uvex says nothing about a 12 at another brand.
Five safety shoes compared
| Model | Marking | Toe cap and insert | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Elten Maddox Low ESD S3S | S3S FO SR, low shoe | Steel toe cap, non-metallic insert | Workshop, warehouse, assembly; wide feet too |
| uvex 2 low shoe | S3L FO SC SR, ESD | Plastic toe cap, non-metallic insert | Metal-free, four widths |
| Elten LEX Steel ESD S3 | S3 FO SR LG, low boot | Steel toe cap, steel insert | Structural construction, scaffolding, demolition |
| HAIX Connexis Safety+ GTX mid | S7S HI CI SC SR HRO FO | Nano-carbon toe cap, non-metallic insert | Outdoors in wet and cold conditions |
| LOWA Renegade Work GTX Lo | S3S WR (S7S) FO HI HRO CI | Steel toe cap, textile insert | Field service, gardening and landscaping |
Elten Maddox Low ESD S3S
A low shoe without leather, with a steel toe cap and a non-metallic insert that passes the 3-millimeter nail test. Elten states a TPU/PU sole with a cushioning core made of BASF Infinergy and sizes 34 to 52 (EU). For wide feet, there is the W version. The shoe is certified with several systems for orthopedic insoles. For indoor work outside structural construction, this is the shoe we recommend.
uvex 2 low shoe
Completely metal-free: according to uvex, the toe cap and midsole are made of the plastic xenova, and the sole of two layers of polyurethane. The manufacturer lists widths 10 to 14 and sizes 35 to 52 (EU), plus ESD with less than 100 megohms. The DGUV requires metal-free shoes, for example, for explosive ordnance detection. S3L, however, means: tested with the thicker 4.5-millimeter nail, not with the thinner one as with S3S.
Elten LEX Steel ESD S3
Cowhide leather, nubuck and microfiber, steel toe cap and steel insert. Elten marks the shoe under EN ISO 20345:2022 as S3 with FO, SR and LG in form B, that is, as a low boot. This makes it suitable for the tasks for which the DGUV specifies a metallic insert. According to the DGUV, steel is less flexible than fabric. In return, it also protects against thin nails.
HAIX Connexis Safety+ GTX mid
According to its 2025 EU declaration of conformity, the boot carries S7S HI CI SC SR HRO FO under EN ISO 20345:2022+A1:2024. So it is waterproof as a whole, with a Gore-Tex membrane, nano-carbon toe cap and quick-release fastening. According to HAIX, a band running through the shoe is meant to stimulate the fascia of the sole of the foot; that is a manufacturer claim. For orthopedic adaptations, HAIX lists its own insoles and Hartmann.
LOWA Renegade Work GTX Lo
Elten carries this shoe in the LOWA Work Collection. The data sheet states S3S WR, which corresponds to S7S, plus FO, HI, HRO and CI. The Vibram rubber sole has a 4.5-millimeter tread, according to the data sheet withstands around 200 degrees Celsius permanently and 300 degrees briefly, and remains flexible down to about minus 20 degrees. Available in sizes 39 to 47 (EU), so not for very small or very large feet.
Can I use my own insoles?
No, at least not just any. Under DGUV Rule 112-191, the EU type-examination certificate becomes void if insoles other than those tested with the shoe are worn. The reason is concrete: a thicker insole can reduce the residual height under the toe cap or impair the dissipative properties. If you need orthopedic insoles, choose a shoe that is certified with a suitable insole system. In Germany, according to the DGUV, the costs can be covered by vocational rehabilitation funding bodies, such as the accident or pension insurance and the employment agency. They usually have the share that would be attributable to a normal safety shoe reimbursed by the employer.
When does a safety shoe have to go?
There is no fixed deadline. In German workplaces, the employer selects foot protection based on the risk assessment and provides it, and employees check it for damage before work. The DGUV names the following reasons to retire it: worn tread, a loose, broken or torn sole, open seams, an exposed or deformed toe cap and laces that no longer hold. For heavily sweating feet, the BG BAU, the statutory accident insurance institution for the construction industry, advises switching pairs daily so that each pair can dry out. A shoe dryer (in German) helps with that.
Which shoe for which job?
- Workshop, warehouse, assembly: Elten Maddox Low ESD S3S, in the W version for a wide forefoot.
- Structural construction, scaffolding, demolition: Elten LEX Steel ESD S3 with steel insert.
- Metal-free or very wide feet: uvex 2 in width 12 or 14.
- Lots of time outdoors, wet and cold: HAIX Connexis Safety+ GTX mid or LOWA Renegade Work GTX Lo.
Feet are only part of the protective equipment. Suitable work gloves (in German) and safety glasses (in German) belong in the same box.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between S3, S3L and S3S?
Under EN ISO 20345:2022, S3 has a metallic insert against penetration. S3L uses a non-metallic insert, tested with a 4.5-millimeter nail, and S3S a non-metallic one tested with the thinner 3-millimeter nail. For shoes certified to the old 2011 version, S3 says nothing about the material.
Steel insert or textile: which is better in a safety shoe?
Where nails thinner than 3 millimeters are to be expected, only a metallic insert provides sufficient protection according to the DGUV, for example in building construction, scaffolding and demolition. Textile inserts cover the entire sole, are more flexible and insulate better against cold and heat. In a warehouse or carpentry shop, that comfort counts for more.
What do SR, FO and ESD mean on safety shoes?
SR means the sole has also passed on tiles with glycerin, which makes sense for oily workshop floors. FO stands for fuel-resistant. According to the DGUV, ESD shoes are considered dissipative if the resistance is at most 100 megohms. If you work with sensitive electronics, clarify the requirement with your employer beforehand.
How do I find the right width for safety shoes?
Width is not standardized, and the DGUV advises always trying safety shoes on. Uvex offers the uvex 2 in widths 10, 11, 12 and 14, and Elten offers the Maddox as a W version for wide feet. A 12 at uvex says nothing about a 12 at another brand.
Can I put my own insoles in safety shoes?
Not just any. Under DGUV Rule 112-191, the EU type-examination certificate becomes void if insoles other than those tested with the shoe are worn, because they can change the residual height under the toe cap or the dissipative properties. If you need orthopedic insoles, choose a shoe that is certified with a suitable insole system.
When does a safety shoe need to be replaced?
There is no fixed deadline. The DGUV names worn tread, a loose or broken sole, open seams, an exposed or deformed toe cap and laces that no longer hold as reasons. For heavily sweating feet, the German construction trade association BG BAU advises switching pairs daily so that each pair can dry out.
Sources
- DGUV Rule 112-191 Use of foot and knee protection, December 2025 edition (in German)
- DGUV foot protection section: List of examples for foot protection under the 2022 series of standards (in German)
- BG BAU module E 600 Foot protection (in German)
- Elten: Maddox black-red Low ESD S3S
- Elten: Maddox W black-red Low ESD S3S
- Elten: LEX Steel ESD S3
- uvex: uvex 2 low shoe
- HAIX: EU declaration of conformity Connexis Safety+ GTX mid
- HAIX: Press release Connexis Safety+
- HAIX: Overview of orthopedic modifications
- LOWA Work Collection: Renegade Work GTX black Lo data sheet
- Elten: LOWA Work Collection
Where to buy
- Elten Maddox Black-Grey Low ESD S3SCheck price at Amazon.de
- uvex 2 HalbschuhCheck price at Amazon.de
- Elten LEX Steel ESD S3Check price at Amazon.de
- HAIX Connexis Safety+ GTX mid (grau-silber)Check price at Amazon.de
- LOWA Renegade Work GTX Lo (schwarz)Check price at Amazon.de
