Contents13 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
A shower toilet rarely fails because of the nozzle. Usually it fails because of the wall behind it. Many people compare the dryer, seat heating and app first and only realize at the appointment with the plumber that there’s no permitted power outlet next to the toilet or that the old ceramic bowl doesn’t fit the seat. For a bathroom renovation with a concealed cistern, we consider a straightforward complete unit such as the Geberit AquaClean Sela the most sensible choice; for rental apartments, the Tuma Comfort seat is the better fit. And if you have no power at the toilet and don’t want to have it installed, you end up with the TECEone.
A complete unit or just a new seat?
A complete unit replaces the entire ceramic bowl. Technology, nozzle and connections are housed inside, and the lines disappear behind the toilet. At Geberit, water comes in on the left and power on the right, both concealed. For plumbing professionals, the manufacturer estimates about 2.5 to 3 hours of installation. That suits new builds and complete renovations, when the tiles are being replaced anyway.
A bidet seat only replaces the seat and lid. The ceramic bowl stays. According to Geberit, a professional can do it in about an hour, without remodeling, and when you move, the device moves with you. It sounds simpler than it is: not every bowl takes every seat. Geberit provides a ceramic compatibility calculator for this. Fill it out before you buy, not afterwards.
If all you really want is a sturdier or quieter lid, a regular seat is enough. What matters there is covered in our toilet seat guide (in German).
Sort out power and water first
Warm wash water takes power. In its operating manuals, Geberit states a power consumption of 2,000 watts for the Tuma Comfort and Mera Comfort, and 850 watts for the smaller Alba. According to Geberit, electrical work on the device may only be carried out by qualified electricians. Bathrooms also have their own rules. Germany’s VDE standards require a residual current device with a rated residual current of no more than 30 mA there. Outlets are not permitted in protection zones 0, 1 and 2. Zone 2 extends 60 centimeters out from the tub or shower. If the toilet is in a narrow bathroom directly next to the tub, an outlet right beside it is often ruled out for that reason. Then the connection goes behind the ceramic bowl, and that’s a job for the electrician.
The water requirements are more modest. Geberit and Grohe specify a flow pressure of 0.5 to 10 bar. The TECEone is supplied directly from the household line and needs at least 1.5 bar for the shower. The Geberit complete units come with a connection set for the company’s own Sigma and Omega concealed cisterns with a depth of 12 cm. For the Sensia Arena, Grohe recommends a Rapid SLX frame with an installation height of 1.13 m. If a cistern from another manufacturer is in your wall, ask your plumber before ordering.
Dryer, odor extraction and what’s left of them
A dryer and odor extraction turn a shower toilet into a comfort appliance. At Geberit, only the Mera Comfort, Mera Classic and Tuma Comfort have both; at Grohe, the Sensia Arena. The extraction has follow-up costs. Geberit requires an annual filter change, because according to the manual a dirty filter can pollute the air you breathe.
We find two inconspicuous figures more important. First, the wash duration: the Alba heats via a storage tank and, according to its data sheet, washes for 20 seconds, while the Sela and Tuma Comfort manage 50 seconds with an instantaneous water heater. Second, limescale. Geberit requires descaling at least once a year, more often with hard water above 14 °dH (German degrees of hardness). If you live in a hard-water region, plan for it. The Tuma Comfort, for example, signals it with a light flashing blue and red.
Seven shower toilets side by side
| Model | Design | Features according to the manufacturer | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Geberit AquaClean Alba | Complete unit, wall-hung | Storage tank, 20 s wash, no lady wash, dryer or extraction, 850 W | An entry point for renovations |
| Geberit AquaClean Sela | Complete unit, wall-hung | Instantaneous heater, 50 s, lady wash, orientation light, no dryer | Most renovations |
| Geberit AquaClean Mera Comfort | Complete unit, wall-hung | Dryer, odor extraction, seat heating, automatic lid, 2,000 W | Full feature set |
| Geberit AquaClean Tuma Comfort (seat) | Seat for an existing bowl | Dryer, odor extraction, seat heating, lady wash, 50 s, 2,000 W | Rental apartment, moving |
| GROHE Sensia Arena | Complete unit, wall-hung | Dryer, odor filter, automatic lid, instantaneous heater | Comfort with a Grohe frame |
| GROHE Sensia | Complete unit, wall-hung | Two spray arms with lady wash, instantaneous heater, soft close | Good basic features |
| TECEone | Ceramic bowl with shower wand, no power | Thermostat 10 to 38 °C, min. 1.5 bar, seat sold separately | No power at the toilet |
Geberit AquaClean Alba
In Geberit’s model overview, the Alba is the most sparsely equipped complete unit. It washes with WhirlSpray in five intensities, oscillates if desired and comes with a remote control. You can only set the temperature and spray arm position in the app, however. With a 20-second wash and no lady wash, it remains a basic device.
Geberit AquaClean Sela
The Sela has what counts in everyday use. An instantaneous water heater delivers 34 to 40 °C for 50 seconds, plus a dedicated lady wash nozzle and an orientation light in seven colors. Dryer, seat heating and extraction are missing. That’s exactly why, for us, it’s the choice with the most benefit per component.
Geberit AquaClean Mera Comfort
The Mera Comfort is Geberit’s fully loaded model: a dryer with five airflow levels, odor extraction with a ceramic honeycomb filter, heated seat, automatic lid. According to Geberit, it uses about one extra liter per wash, twice as much as the Sela and Tuma. It’s mainly worth it if several people really use the extras.
Geberit AquaClean Tuma Comfort as a seat
The seat brings most of the Mera Comfort’s features to an existing ceramic bowl. The automatic lid and orientation light are missing. Seat and lid are rated for 150 kg, and the power cord is two meters long. That often makes it long enough to reach an outlet outside the protection zones. Check your bowl in the manufacturer’s calculator beforehand.
GROHE Sensia Arena
Grohe equips the Sensia Arena with a warm-air dryer, an odor filter with activated carbon and an automatically opening lid. Added to that is an ion technology that Grohe calls PlasmaCluster. Look for article number 39354SH1. Grohe lists the older SH0 version as no longer available.
GROHE Sensia
The simpler Sensia, number 36507SH0, relies on two self-cleaning spray arms, one of them for the lady wash, either oscillating or as a massage spray. An instantaneous water heater heats the water. Grohe doesn’t list a dryer or extraction for this model.
TECEone
The TECEone works purely hydraulically. A thermostat mixes hot and cold water continuously between 10 and 38 °C, and a rotary knob on the side extends the self-cleaning shower wand. No cable, no electrician. In return, there is neither a dryer nor seat heating, and you order the seat separately. TECE also offers a cold-water-only version in case there is no hot water line at the toilet.
How we would decide
- Renovation with a Geberit concealed cistern, comfort without frills: AquaClean Sela.
- Tight budget and short washes are enough: AquaClean Alba.
- Rental apartment or a move on the horizon: Tuma Comfort as a seat, once the ceramic calculator has given the go-ahead.
- Dryer and extraction are firmly planned: Mera Comfort, or the Sensia Arena if there’s a Grohe frame in the bathroom.
- There’s no power at the toilet and there shouldn’t be: TECEone.
Whichever device it ends up being: have the outlet and residual current device checked before you buy. A shower toilet plugged into an impermissible outlet is no gain in comfort.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a complete shower toilet and a bidet seat?
A complete unit replaces the entire ceramic bowl, the lines disappear behind the toilet, and Geberit estimates about 2.5 to 3 hours for installation. A seat only replaces the seat and lid, in about an hour according to Geberit, and moves with you. Not every bowl takes every seat; Geberit offers a ceramic compatibility calculator for this.
What power connection does a shower toilet need?
Geberit states a power consumption of 2,000 watts for the Tuma Comfort and Mera Comfort. In bathrooms, Germany's VDE standards require a residual current device (RCD/GFCI) with a maximum of 30 mA, and outlets are not permitted in zones 0, 1 and 2. If the toilet is directly next to the tub, the electrician often places the connection behind the bowl.
What water pressure does a shower toilet need?
Geberit and Grohe specify a flow pressure of 0.5 to 10 bar. The TECEone needs at least 1.5 bar from the household supply for the shower. The Geberit complete units fit the company's own Sigma and Omega concealed cisterns. If a cistern from another manufacturer is in the wall, ask your plumber first.
Are a dryer and odor extraction on a shower toilet worth it?
They turn a shower toilet into a comfort appliance, but have follow-up costs. Geberit requires an annual filter change for the extraction. According to Geberit, the Mera Comfort uses about one extra liter per wash. It's mainly worth it if several people really use the extras.
How do you maintain a shower toilet?
Geberit requires descaling at least once a year, more often with hard water above 14 °dH (German degrees of hardness). The Tuma Comfort signals this with a light flashing blue and red. Models with odor extraction also need an annual filter change, because according to the manual a dirty filter can pollute the air you breathe.
Is there a shower toilet without a power connection?
Yes, the TECEone works purely hydraulically. A thermostat mixes hot and cold water continuously between 10 and 38 °C, and a rotary knob extends the self-cleaning shower wand. There is no dryer or seat heating, and you order the seat separately. TECE also offers a cold-water-only version.
Sources
- Geberit: shower toilet models compared (in German)
- Geberit: frequently asked questions about AquaClean (in German)
- Geberit: installing a shower toilet (in German)
- Geberit catalog: AquaClean Alba
- Geberit catalog: AquaClean Sela
- Geberit catalog: AquaClean Mera Comfort
- Geberit catalog: AquaClean Tuma Comfort shower toilet seat
- Geberit: AquaClean Tuma Comfort operating manual (PDF)
- Geberit: AquaClean Alba operating manual (PDF)
- Geberit: AquaClean Mera Comfort operating manual (PDF)
- GROHE: Sensia Arena 39354SH1
- GROHE: Sensia 36507SH0
- TECE: TECEone
- TECE: TECEone 9700200 data sheet (PDF)
- VDE: electrical appliances in the bathroom
Where to buy
- Geberit AquaClean SelaCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Geberit AquaClean AlbaCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Geberit AquaClean Mera ComfortCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Geberit AquaClean Tuma Comfort (Aufsatz)Check price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- GROHE Sensia Arena 39354SH1Check price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- GROHE SensiaCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- TECEone Dusch-WC 9700200Check price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
