Contents15 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
The giant box for a first birthday? Better not. A small starter set with a figure-eight loop is enough at the beginning and can be expanded later. For children under three, only the BRIO My First Railway line is an option; from age three, we consider the BRIO Travel Train Starter Set A the most sensible choice. A battery engine is best added once the child wants to build the track themselves.
Which train set suits which age?
According to the manufacturers, almost all sets in this overview are rated for ages 3 and up. The exception is the BRIO My First Railway line, which is explicitly designed for toddlers.
Read the warning label. On its train sets, Eichhorn carries the warning „Achtung! Nicht geeignet für Kinder unter 3 Jahren. Erstickungsgefahr durch Kleinteile.“ (Warning! Not suitable for children under 3 years. Choking hazard due to small parts.) The BRIO sets mentioned here, by contrast, state „No warnings required“.
What does German law require for warning labels?
Section 11 of the German Toy Safety Ordinance (2. ProdSV) stipulates that warnings must begin with the word „Achtung“ (Warning) and be written in German. Information relevant to the purchase decision, such as the minimum age, must be clearly visible before purchase. This explicitly applies to online purchases as well. If such a notice is missing from an online listing, check the manufacturer’s website. Conversely, the same provision prohibits warnings that contradict the intended use. A train set for toddlers therefore does not carry a „not under 3 years“ warning.
How much railway is in a set?
Less than the number of pieces suggests. 55 pieces sounds like a lot, but that includes trees, signs and figures. Eichhorn states a track length of 500 cm for its train set with bridge, which is a useful benchmark.
Information about the wood is sparse. BRIO and Eichhorn cite FSC-certified beech, while Bigjigs says it mainly uses rubberwood. And with a battery engine, check the battery type and number beforehand. According to the manufacturer, the BRIO battery engines we looked at do not come with batteries.
Do the tracks fit together?
Almost everyone who already has a few tracks in the basement asks this question. Less is documented than many stores promise. IKEA writes about the LILLABO basic set that it fits „most train sets on the market“. Bigjigs calls its tracks compatible with other leading brands. BRIO only promises that all parts of its own BRIO World fit together. On the Eichhorn and Hape websites, we found no statement of their own about other brands; in retail, however, the Eichhorn engines are offered as compatible with many wooden railways.
Whether the magnetic couplings of different brands hold together reliably could not be clearly established. A battery engine draws its power from its own compartment, not from the track. So it does not need a particular track system, but it does need a profile it runs smoothly in.
Which sets are worth considering?
| Model | Contents according to the manufacturer | Drive | Age according to the manufacturer | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| BRIO World Travel Train Starter Set A (36079) | 22 pieces, 12 wooden tracks, viaduct | Push | 3 years and up | First set with room to expand |
| BRIO My First Railway Battery Train Set (33710) | 25 pieces | 1 × AA, not included | Toddlers, see text | Children under three |
| Eichhorn Train Set with Bridge (100006204) | 55 pieces, 500 cm of track, 5-part train | Push | 3 years and up | Lots of track from the start |
| Eichhorn Battery Locomotive (100006601) | 1 engine, 10.5 cm | Battery, up to 60 min running time | 3 years and up | Upgrading an existing railway |
| Hape Busy City Rail Set („Verkehrsreiche Stadt“, E3730) | 51 pieces, passenger and freight train | Push | 3 years and up | Role play with station and crane |
| Hape Battery Powered Engine No. 1 (E3703) | 1 engine, 9.5 cm | 2 batteries | 3 years and up | Small extra engine |
| Bigjigs Rail Figure of Eight Set | Figure-eight loop with viaduct | Push | 3 years and up (retailer information) | Alternative with the manufacturer’s compatibility promise |
BRIO World Travel Train Starter Set A
Small but well thought out. According to BRIO, the box contains an engine, a passenger car, twelve wooden tracks, two viaduct bridge pieces, two figures, a piece of luggage, a platform and two platform tracks. This makes a figure eight with a bridge, expandable with any part of the BRIO World. If you want more later, buy additional track rather than a second set right away.
BRIO My First Railway Battery Train Set
The only choice here for children under three. The engine runs on its own at the push of a button and needs an AA battery, which is not included. BRIO itself is inconsistent about the age: the data field states 18 months, the description text „from 24 months“. For children aged three and up, the line is rather too simple.
Eichhorn Train Set with Bridge
If you want a big loop from the start, according to the manufacturer you get 55 pieces here with curves, straights, switches and a bridge, and around five meters of track. The tracks are made of FSC-certified beech. Eichhorn explicitly points out small parts and only approves the set from age three. With younger siblings in the household, that is a real concern.
Eichhorn Battery Locomotive
A compact engine with start, light, forward and reverse, and four-wheel drive; Eichhorn states a running time of up to 60 minutes. The color, red or yellow, is supplied at random. Reviews on Amazon are scarce so far. A few buyers report weak pulling power on inclines once cars are attached.
Hape Busy City Rail Set
Here, the focus is on play around the railway: station, railroad crossing with a barrier, bridge, crane with a magnetic winch, passenger and freight train. Hape cites 51 pieces. For children who would rather make up stories than build tracks, that is the better direction. It takes up a corresponding amount of space.
Hape Battery Powered Engine No. 1
A small red steam engine with a headlight that runs forward and backward at the push of a button and pulls cars by magnet. It needs two batteries. Hape and the retailers give different information on whether they are included, so check before giving it as a gift.
Bigjigs Rail Figure of Eight Set
The British manufacturer is the only one here that itself promises compatibility with other major brands. The set forms a figure eight with a viaduct. Bigjigs does not provide a detailed parts list online. So check the contents in the respective listing.
And IKEA LILLABO?
The 20-piece LILLABO basic set is sold exclusively by IKEA, which is why it is not in the table. IKEA recommends it from age three and says it fits most systems on the market. For a second set at the grandparents‘ house, that is often enough.
So which train set?
For a first wooden railway from age three, the BRIO Travel Train Starter Set A, with more track bought later. If the child is younger than three, only BRIO My First Railway is an option, and only that line.
- A big layout right away: Eichhorn Train Set with Bridge, if no toddlers are playing along.
- Role play instead of track building: Hape Busy City Rail Set.
- Adding a battery engine: an engine from the same manufacturer as your existing track; then there is no debate about fit.
Already thinking further ahead? We also have a guide to the starter set for an electric model railway (in German). For the rest of the kids‘ room, see our overviews of play kitchens and toy shops (in German) and building bricks (in German).
Frequently asked questions
From what age is a wooden train set suitable?
According to the manufacturers, almost all sets in this overview are rated for ages 3 and up. The exception is BRIO My First Railway, which is explicitly designed for toddlers. BRIO itself is inconsistent about the age: the data field states 18 months, the description text 24 months and up. Eichhorn warns of small parts for children under 3 on its train sets.
Do tracks from different brands fit together?
Less is documented than many stores promise. IKEA says LILLABO fits most systems, and Bigjigs promises compatibility with other leading brands. BRIO only promises that all parts of its own BRIO World fit together. Whether magnetic couplings from different brands hold reliably remains unclear.
How much track is in a wooden train set?
Less than the number of pieces suggests, because trees, signs and figures count too. Eichhorn states 55 pieces and a track length of 500 cm for its train set with bridge, which is a useful benchmark. The BRIO Starter Set A has twelve wooden tracks and two viaduct bridge pieces.
Which battery engine fits my wooden railway?
The easiest choice is an engine from the same manufacturer as your existing track; then there is no debate about fit. A battery engine draws power from its own compartment but needs a track profile it runs smoothly in. Check the battery type and number beforehand; according to the manufacturer, BRIO does not include batteries.
What must a warning label on toys say?
Under Section 11 of the German Toy Safety Ordinance, warnings in Germany begin with the word "Achtung" (Warning) and are written in German. Information such as the minimum age must be clearly visible before purchase, including online. If such a notice is missing from an online listing, check the manufacturer's website.
Which set is suitable for role play rather than track building?
The Hape Busy City Rail Set with 51 pieces includes a station, a railroad crossing with a barrier, a bridge, a crane with a magnetic winch, and a passenger and freight train. For children who would rather make up stories than build tracks, that is the better direction. It takes up a corresponding amount of space.
Sources
- BRIO: Travel Train Starter Set A
- BRIO: My First Railway Battery Train Set
- Eichhorn: Train Set with Bridge
- Eichhorn: Battery Locomotive for wooden railways
- Hape: Busy City Rail Set
- Hape: Battery Powered Engine No. 1
- Bigjigs Toys: Bigjigs Rail
- IKEA: LILLABO train set, 20-piece basic set
- Second Ordinance on the German Product Safety Act (Toy Safety Ordinance), Section 11 (in German)
Where to buy
- BRIO World Reisezug Starter Set ACheck price at Amazon.de
- BRIO My First Railway Bahn Set mit BatterielokCheck price at Amazon.de
- Eichhorn Bahnset mit BrückeCheck price at Amazon.de
- Eichhorn Batterie-LokomotiveCheck price at Amazon.de
- Hape Eisenbahn-Set Verkehrsreiche StadtCheck price at Amazon.de
- Hape Batteriebetriebene Lokomotive Nr. 1Check price at Amazon.de
- Bigjigs Rail Achterbahn-SetCheck price at Amazon.de
