Contents13 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
A concealer that hides dark circles well is often the wrong choice for a blemish. Under the eye you need light and a smooth texture; on a red spot, on the other hand, you need pigment and exactly your own skin tone. For shadows under the eyes, we therefore recommend the NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer; for redness and blemishes, the much cheaper Catrice Liquid Camouflage. Both come in a wide range of skin tones.
The brand is secondary. What matters is what you want to disappear.
Three questions before you pick a tube
First, the cause. Bluish or purple shadows under the eyes call for something different than flushed cheeks or a single inflamed spot on the chin. Next comes the shade. Maybelline recommends going no more than one shade lighter than your foundation under the eyes, and using the exact matching shade on blemishes. If you use a lighter shade there, you put a highlight right on the spot that is actually supposed to disappear.
Then the applicator. A wide sponge spreads a lot of product across the area under the eye in seconds. For a small blemish it is too coarse; a narrow tip or a fine brush works more precisely there. Fill volume is also easily overlooked. In our list it ranges from 4.5 to 10 ml, which puts some price differences into perspective.
For very strong discoloration, a color corrector under the concealer can help. According to Maybelline, green neutralizes redness and visible veins, pink bluish dark circles and yellow purple tones. A very thin layer of skin-tone concealer goes on top.
Six concealers side by side
| Model | Coverage and finish (according to the manufacturer) | Volume and application | Who it is for |
|---|---|---|---|
| NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer | medium, buildable; radiant | 6 ml | Dark circles, normal skin, premium budget |
| Charlotte Tilbury Beautiful Skin Radiant Concealer | medium, buildable; radiant | 7.2 ml, sponge with a pointed and a rounded side | Dark circles with a glow, premium budget |
| Maybelline Instant Anti-Age Effekt Concealer | no rating given; liquid, fine texture | 6.8 ml, wide sponge tip | Dark circles on a drugstore budget |
| Catrice Liquid Camouflage High Coverage Concealer | high; up to 12 hours, waterproof | 5 ml, flocked applicator | Redness and blemishes, also green shade 200 Anti-Red |
| Catrice True Skin High Cover Concealer | high; soft matte | 4.5 ml | Blemishes on normal to dry skin |
Route 1: Shadows under the eyes
The skin under the eye is thin and moves with every smile. A very matte, heavy-coverage concealer settles into fine lines there more easily. Complaints like this show up in reviews of very different products, including popular drugstore classics. Under the eyes, we therefore lean toward medium, buildable coverage with a little sheen. And toward good skincare beforehand, see eye creams compared (in German).
NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer
NARS describes the coverage as medium and buildable and the finish as radiant. It is said to last up to 16 hours. The tube holds 6 ml. In the NARS online store, shades can be filtered by depth and undertone, which makes finding the right one noticeably easier. It is still expensive. We would not spend that money just to cover individual blemishes. On Amazon, the seller matters. A few customers describe tubes that did not match the description.
Charlotte Tilbury Beautiful Skin Radiant Concealer
A similar direction, just with a longer list of skincare ingredients. Charlotte Tilbury states 7.2 ml, medium buildable coverage, a radiant finish and 30 shades in four depth groups. The sponge has a pointed side for precise application and a rounded side for blending. Fragrance is also among the ingredients. If you have sensitive eyes, read the list before buying. On Amazon the selection is patchy; several shades were recently out of stock.
Maybelline Instant Anti-Age Effekt Concealer
The drugstore classic. Despite the name, it is simply a liquid concealer with 6.8 ml and a wide sponge on a stem, which Maybelline calls a micro-corrector applicator. Maybelline does not give a coverage level, but it does state suitability for mature skin. Besides the skin tones, the range includes a Brightener (05) and a Neutralizer (06). Some reviews complain that the texture settles into fine lines after a few hours. Applying thinly and setting with powder is then likely to do more than a second layer.
Route 2: Red patches on the nose, chin and cheeks
Redness needs more pigment than an under-eye shadow, but no light-reflecting effect. Shine tends to emphasize it. What counts here is the exact matching shade.
Catrice Liquid Camouflage High Coverage Concealer
For a drugstore price you get high coverage, according to Catrice up to 12 hours of wear, waterproof and silicone-free. The 5 ml are applied with a flocked applicator. In addition to the eleven skin tones, there is the green shade 200 Anti-Red, which goes thinly onto the redness before the skin tone is blended on top. For redness, this is the cheapest combination in our list. Under the eyes, we would use the formula only sparingly; it is designed for strong coverage.
Route 3: Blemishes and breakouts
A blemish is small, often raised, and any shine draws the eye right to it. So you need a matte concealer, high coverage and your exact skin tone. We would not put an applicator that was just on an inflamed spot straight back into the tube. A small brush that is cleaned regularly is the more hygienic solution; suitable shapes are shown in the makeup brush comparison (in German).
Tarte Shape Tape Concealer
On Amazon.de, Shape Tape is sold almost exclusively by third-party sellers, which is why it is not on our shopping list. If you order it there, pay close attention to the seller. Full coverage and a natural matte finish is how Tarte describes the classic of the line. At 10 ml, the tube is the largest in our comparison. On redness and blemishes the formula plays to its strengths; under dry eyes it can be too much of a good thing. For that case, Tarte offers a Radiant version with medium coverage under the same name. Some reviews there mention counterfeits.
Catrice True Skin High Cover Concealer
The second Catrice option. It suits blemishes on normal to dry skin, because those are exactly the skin types Catrice lists. High coverage, soft matte, 4.5 ml and 14 shades with suffixes such as Neutral, Warm and Cool in their names. Sodium hyaluronate is included, and so is fragrance. Catrice recommends tapping the concealer in with your ring finger. Some offers on Amazon call it a concealer for combination skin; we go by the manufacturer’s information.
How we would decide
- Bluish dark circles: NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer, with a pink corrector underneath for very dark shadows.
- Dark circles, small budget: Maybelline Instant Anti-Age Effekt Concealer, no more than one shade lighter than your foundation.
- Redness: Catrice Liquid Camouflage in your skin tone, with 200 Anti-Red underneath for strong redness.
- Blemishes, full coverage: Tarte Shape Tape or, much cheaper, again Catrice Liquid Camouflage.
- Blemishes on dry skin: Catrice True Skin High Cover.
- Glow instead of matte: Charlotte Tilbury, provided your shade is currently in stock.
One last thought on the order of things. Maybelline’s shade rule refers to the shade of your foundation, so think of the two together. Which foundation suits which skin is explained in our foundation guide. Defined lashes, by the way, draw attention away from the shadows beneath them; products for that are collected in the mascara guide (in German).
Frequently asked questions
Which concealer shade goes under the eyes and which on blemishes?
Maybelline recommends going no more than one shade lighter than your foundation under the eyes, and using the exact matching shade on blemishes. If you cover a blemish with a lighter shade, you put a highlight right on the spot that is supposed to disappear. The shade rule refers to your foundation, so think of the two together.
Which concealer does not settle into fine lines under the eyes?
The skin under the eye is thin and moves with every expression. A very matte, heavy-coverage concealer settles into fine lines there more easily. Medium, buildable coverage with a little sheen works better, such as NARS or Charlotte Tilbury; apply it thinly and moisturize well beforehand.
What are green, pink or yellow concealers for?
For very strong discoloration, a color corrector under the concealer can help. According to Maybelline, green neutralizes redness and visible veins, pink bluish dark circles and yellow purple tones. A very thin layer of skin-tone concealer goes on top. Catrice, for example, offers the green shade 200 Anti-Red.
Which concealer is suitable for blemishes and breakouts?
You need a matte concealer, high coverage and your exact skin tone, because any shine draws the eye there. The Catrice Liquid Camouflage offers high coverage and is waterproof; for dry skin, the soft-matte Catrice True Skin High Cover is a good fit. Instead of putting the applicator back into the tube, a cleaned brush is more hygienic.
What should I look for when buying a concealer?
First the cause: shadows, redness or blemishes. Then shade and applicator, because a wide sponge is too coarse for a small blemish. Fill volume matters too: in our comparison it ranges from 4.5 to 10 ml, which puts some price differences into perspective. If you have sensitive eyes, check the ingredient list for fragrance.
What should I watch out for when buying luxury concealers on Amazon?
Pay attention to the seller. On Amazon.de, Tarte Shape Tape is sold almost exclusively by third-party sellers, and some reviews mention counterfeits. With the NARS concealer, too, a few customers describe tubes that did not match the description. At Charlotte Tilbury, several shades were recently out of stock.
Sources
- Maybelline: Finding the right concealer shade
- Maybelline: Instant Anti-Age Effekt Concealer
- NARS: Radiant Creamy Concealer
- Charlotte Tilbury: Beautiful Skin Radiant Concealer
- Catrice: Liquid Camouflage High Coverage Concealer
- Catrice: Liquid Camouflage, shade 200 Anti-Red
- Catrice: True Skin High Cover Concealer
- Tarte: Shape Tape Concealer
- Tarte: Shape Tape, fill volume details
Where to buy
- NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer (Vanilla)Check price at Amazon.de
- Catrice Liquid Camouflage High Coverage ConcealerCheck price at Amazon.de
- Maybelline Instant Anti-Age Effekt ConcealerCheck price at Amazon.de
- Charlotte Tilbury Beautiful Skin Radiant ConcealerCheck price at Amazon.de
- Catrice True Skin High Cover Concealer (002 Neutral Ivory)Check price at Amazon.de
