Contents6 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
Where does the cable run? With this choice, it’s not the smart home system that decides first but the wiring in the wall. If the electric heater’s circuit already runs through the thermostat box today, replace the old unit with the Eberle UTE 3800-U and control it via Matter from Apple Home. If that wiring is missing, or the thermostat should go on a different wall, the Homematic IP set of a wireless wall thermostat and a 16-amp actuator is the cleaner solution. You then don’t have to run any new wiring.
Both devices appear in our guide to room thermostats for electric heating (in German) together with four other controllers, from a simple dial to a Z-Wave thermostat.
One device on the wall or two separate parts
The Eberle UTE 3800-U is an insert for 55 mm frames, the standard switch size in Germany. It measures the room temperature and switches the heater in the same housing, via a 16-amp relay. For that, mains power, neutral and the cable to the heater all have to arrive in exactly this box. In many buildings with electric heating that is the case, because an old bimetal controller already hangs there.
With the Homematic set, measuring and switching are separate. According to ELV, the HmIP-WTH-3 wall thermostat runs for about two years on two AAA batteries and can be mounted with adhesive strips or screws. Switching happens in the HmIP-FSI16-2 flush-mounted actuator, which goes into an ordinary switch or junction box near the heater. The two pair directly with each other wirelessly.
A difference that is easy to overlook.
The specs compared
| Model | Switching capacity | Controls and display | Connectivity | Price class (as of November 2026) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Eberle UTE 3800-U | Relay (normally open), 16 (4) A; PWM or on/off control | Touch buttons, LEDs for heating, away, window open and Wi-Fi; remote sensor can be connected | Matter over Wi-Fi: Apple Home, Google Home, Alexa; also usable without Wi-Fi | 150-euro class (Eberle recommended price) |
| Homematic IP Set for electric heating control | HmIP-FSI16-2 actuator: continuous 14 A or 3,220 W resistive | Battery wall thermostat with backlit display, dial, weekly schedules and humidity reading | Homematic IP wireless, usable without a hub; later Access Point or Home Control Unit | 110-euro class (ELV, as of November 8, 2026) |
The switching capacity of both is enough for typical supplementary heaters. A 2,000-watt element draws just under 8.7 amps at 230 volts, which both handle continuously. At 3,500 watts things get tight with the Homematic actuator, because ELV specifies a continuous load of 3,220 watts for it. Check the heater’s rating plate before you order.
Apple Home, Homematic or no app at all
For iPhone households, the Eberle is the direct route. According to Eberle, it joins Apple Home, Google Home or Alexa via Matter over Wi-Fi; it needs no separate app or manufacturer gateway. You then build schedules and scenes in the Home app. If you don’t want to connect it, you operate it via the menu directly on the device, since Eberle explicitly allows for installation without Wi-Fi.
The Homematic set initially works entirely without internet, app or hub. According to ELV, you pair the thermostat and actuator at the push of a button, and the weekly schedule with separate times for weekdays and weekends runs in the thermostat. Up to eight actuators can be linked to one thermostat, handy for several heaters in one room. ELV does not, however, list Apple Home among its supported systems. If you want remote control later, you need the Homematic IP Access Point or the Home Control Unit. More about the system is in our guide to Homematic heating sets (in German).
And homee? So far homee only supports Matter as a bridge to other systems; it does not add a Matter device like the Eberle. The Homematic set is not on homee’s device list either.
Why a dial is sometimes enough
A supplementary heater next to a heat pump should rarely run. Set it one to two degrees below the temperature the heat pump maintains anyway; that is our assessment based on physics, not a manufacturer promise. The heating element then only kicks in on cold days. For a job like that, a weekly program is unnecessary. How a plain bimetal controller holds up over eleven years is described in our hands-on report on the Eberle RTR-E.
Smart control gets interesting when the heater runs often. Then you can see in the app when it switches on, and lower the temperature at night.
Choose the Eberle if … and the set if …
Choose the Eberle UTE 3800-U if Apple Home is your hub, there is stable Wi-Fi at the installation spot and the heater cable already runs through the thermostat box. It sits flush within the switch range and needs no batteries.
Choose the Homematic IP set if there is no cable between where you want the thermostat and the heater, if you already use Homematic IP, or if you want a display with a weekly program and no app at all.
For both: the connection to 230 volts belongs in the hands of a licensed electrician.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between the Eberle UTE 3800-U and the Homematic IP set?
The Eberle UTE 3800-U measures and switches in a single device in the thermostat box, via a 16-amp relay. The Homematic IP set separates measuring and switching: the battery-powered HmIP-WTH-3 wall thermostat sits anywhere on the wall, the HmIP-FSI16-2 actuator switches in a box near the heater, and the two pair wirelessly.
Does the Eberle UTE 3800-U work with Apple Home?
Yes. According to Eberle, it joins Apple Home, Google Home or Alexa via Matter over Wi-Fi, without a separate app or manufacturer gateway. It can also be operated directly on the device without any Wi-Fi at all.
Does the Homematic IP set need a hub?
No. According to ELV, the thermostat and actuator pair at the push of a button, and the weekly schedule runs in the thermostat, without internet or an app. If you want remote control later, you need the Homematic IP Access Point or the Home Control Unit. ELV does not list Apple Home as a supported system.
Is the switching capacity enough for my electric heater?
For typical supplementary heaters, yes: a 2,000-watt element draws just under 8.7 amps at 230 volts. At 3,500 watts things get tight with the Homematic actuator; ELV specifies a continuous load of 3,220 watts. Check the heater's rating plate before ordering.
Which thermostat fits if there is no wiring in the thermostat box?
Then the Homematic IP set. The wireless wall thermostat goes wherever you want it, the actuator into a switch or junction box near the heater, and you don't have to run any new wiring. The Eberle needs mains power, neutral and the cable to the heater in exactly its own box.
Can the thermostats be used with homee?
Not so far. homee only supports Matter as a bridge to other systems and does not add a Matter device like the Eberle. The Homematic set is not on homee's device list either.
Sources
- Eberle: temperature controller catalog (UTE 3800-U), in German
- Eberle: illustrated price list 2026, in German
- ELV: Homematic IP set for electric heating control with HmIP-WTH-3 and HmIP-FSI16-2
- homee: compatible devices
Where to buy
- Eberle UTE 3800-UCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Homematic IP Set ElektroheizungssteuerungView at ELVAvailable in Germany: ELV
