Contents12 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
One size bigger so they’ll „still fit next winter“: that’s how many ice skates end up in the shopping cart. It backfires. A foot that slides around in the boot can’t find an edge, and then skating becomes tiring and frustrating. For growing children, size-adjustable models such as the Roces Jokey Ice 3.0 are therefore the more sensible choice, adults skating for fun are well served by a soft, warmly lined boot, and anyone who wants to take up hockey or figure skating seriously needs a stiff boot from that discipline.
Discipline first, then the brand
Ice skates look similar but are built for very different movements. Before you compare models, five things should be clear.
First, the blade shape. Figure skating blades have toe picks at the front for jumps and spins. Hockey blades are shorter, more strongly curved at the front and back, and make quick changes of direction easier. Both work for just skating laps, but beginners tend to trip over their own toe picks.
Then the stiffness of the boot. Soft recreational boots are comfortable but give the ankle less support. Graf rates its Davos Gold recreational figure skate at a stiffness of 15 out of 100 and its Edmonton Special competition model at 80 to 90. There’s a whole world in between.
When it comes to size, foot length is what counts. Measure your foot in centimeters and compare it with the manufacturer’s chart. K2 and Graf state foot lengths. For hockey skates, specialist retailers often advise choosing one to one and a half sizes smaller than your street shoe.
Adjustable kids‘ skates cover four to seven sizes, depending on the model. That saves buying a new pair every winter. And the blade? On entry-level models, the blade is usually riveted on permanently. Replaceable steel blades only come with more expensive hockey skates.
Sharpening: what new blades need and what they don’t
Almost every blade has a hollow grind. Between two edges there is a shallow groove, and the skate grips the ice on those edges. A deeper hollow gives more grip in turns but also slows you down more. A Brock University study with hockey players found that friction increases with a smaller grinding radius.
According to the manufacturers, K2 and Roces ship their recreational and kids‘ models pre-sharpened. That’s enough for the first winter. There is no fixed rule for how often to resharpen. If you play hockey regularly, you’ll notice it when the skate slides out sideways in tight turns. If you only skate a few times a winter, you’ll sharpen correspondingly less often; it mainly depends on how often and how hard the blade is used. Have it done at a specialist shop or at the ice rink. Sharpening them yourself is not a good idea for beginners; a wrong angle ruins the feel faster than any dull blade.
Seven ice skates, seven purposes
| Model | Design | Sizes and adjustment | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Powerslide Rutscherla II | Glider with double blade, straps over the winter boot | 7-way adjustable, EU shoe size 24 to 31 | Toddlers taking their first steps |
| Roces Jokey Ice 3.0 | Kids‘ hockey style, laces, buckle, Velcro strap | Adjustable in four-size ranges from EU 26 to 41 | Growing children |
| K2 Raider Ice | Kids‘ soft boot, speed lacing, buckle | Five sizes per skate, from EU 26 up | Children who value comfort |
| K2 Alexis Ice / F.I.T. Ice | Soft boot for women and men respectively, hockey blade | Fixed sizes, women’s from EU 34 | Adults skating for fun |
| Graf Davos Gold | Recreational figure skate, stiffness 15/100 | Fixed sizes from FR 25 to 43 | Recreational skaters keen on figure skating |
| CCM Tacks AS-550 | Entry-level hockey skate, fixed blade | Fixed sizes, junior to senior | Hockey beginners and hobby players |
| Bauer Vapor X4 | Hockey skate with replaceable blade, heat-moldable | Senior 7 to 12, three widths (Fit 1 to 3) | Club players with regular training |
Powerslide Rutscherla II
Not an ice skate in the strict sense, but a glider with two parallel stainless steel blades that, according to Powerslide, straps over regular shoes or thick winter boots with two buckles. The double blade gives a wide stance and hardly wobbles. For the very first attempts, it’s an honest start at a low price. As soon as the child glides independently, however, the Rutscherla has reached its limit.
Roces Jokey Ice 3.0
For the Jokey Ice 3.0, Roces lists laces, a micro buckle and a Velcro strap at the cuff, an insulating liner and a stainless steel hockey blade. Sizes are cut in ranges of four, from EU 26 to 41. Roces offers it in a boys‘ and a girls‘ version. A hockey blade is more forgiving with beginners than a blade with toe picks.
K2 Raider Ice
K2 brings its soft boot from inline skates to the ice. According to the manufacturer, each skate grows with the child across five sizes; it’s laced with one pull on the speed lacing system, plus a buckle at the cuff. According to reports from some buyers, the size adjusted itself after a fall because the button was pressed in. So check the setting briefly before every skate.
K2 Alexis Ice and F.I.T. Ice
The women’s Alexis and the men’s F.I.T. are recreational skates with a soft-boot construction, classic lacing, a water-repellent liner and a pre-sharpened stainless steel blade in hockey shape. If you go out on the pond or to the ice rink twice a winter, you don’t need more. For hockey, the boot is too soft. That’s the compromise.
Graf Davos Gold
Graf is a Swiss manufacturer based in Kreuzlingen and explicitly describes the Davos Gold as a recreational model for occasional skating. Synthetic leather upper, breathable lining, felt tongue, and the blade is riveted on permanently. With a stiffness rating of 15 out of 100, it won’t support jumps. If you’re starting figure skating at a club, ask your coach to recommend a stiffer boot and have it fitted at a specialist retailer.
CCM Tacks AS-550
The AS-550 is the entry-level model in the Tacks line. Retailers list an injection-molded boot, a microfiber lining, a felt tongue and a permanently mounted, pre-sharpened stainless steel blade. For hobby players and kids in their first club year, that’s a solid foundation. The blade can’t be replaced, so after many sharpenings the skate is done.
Bauer Vapor X4
At Bauer, the Vapor X4 marks the start of the mid-range for players with regular training. The boot is heat-moldable, and according to retailer information the blade sits in the Tuuk LightSpeed Edge holder and is swapped via a trigger. Bauer offers three widths, from narrow and low (Fit 1) to wide with a high instep (Fit 3). Recreational skaters are paying here for technology they will hardly use.
How we would decide
- Toddler, first winter: Powerslide Rutscherla II. Inexpensive, stable to stand on, but only for the first attempts.
- Child who already skates independently: Roces Jokey Ice 3.0. It grows with them, and the combination of laces and buckle provides secure support. If you want more padding, look at the K2 Raider Ice.
- Adults skating for fun: K2 Alexis Ice or F.I.T. Ice if comfort counts. Graf Davos Gold if it should be a figure skate.
- Trying out hockey: CCM Tacks AS-550.
- Club hockey: Bauer Vapor X4, ideally tried on at a specialist retailer in the right width.
If you’re still in the mood for snow after skating, we have a guide to sleds for kids and adults (in German), an overview of buying cross-country skis (in German) and tips on snowshoes for winter hikes (in German).
Frequently asked questions
Should you buy ice skates one size bigger?
No. A foot that slides around in the boot can't find an edge, and skating becomes tiring and frustrating. For growing children, adjustable models make more sense; depending on the model, they cover four to seven sizes and save buying a new pair every winter.
Hockey blade or figure skating blade for beginners?
Figure skating blades have toe picks at the front for jumps and spins, while hockey blades are shorter and more strongly curved. Both work for just skating laps, but beginners tend to trip over their own toe picks. A hockey blade is more forgiving with beginners.
How do I find the right ice skate size?
Foot length is what counts. Measure your foot in centimeters and compare it with the manufacturer's chart; K2 and Graf state foot lengths. For hockey skates, specialist retailers often advise choosing one to one and a half sizes smaller than your street shoe.
Do new ice skates need to be sharpened?
According to the manufacturers, K2 and Roces ship their recreational and kids' models pre-sharpened, which is enough for the first winter. There is no fixed rule for resharpening; it depends on how often and how hard the blade is used. Have it done at a specialist shop or at the ice rink, not yourself.
Which ice skates for toddlers?
For the very first attempts, the Powerslide Rutscherla II fits: a glider with two parallel stainless steel blades that straps over regular shoes or winter boots. The double blade gives a wide stance and hardly wobbles. As soon as the child glides independently, it has reached its limit.
What does the stiffness of the boot mean?
Soft recreational boots are comfortable but give the ankle less support. Graf rates its Davos Gold recreational skate at a stiffness of 15 out of 100 and the Edmonton Special competition model at 80 to 90. If you are starting figure skating at a club, ask your coach to recommend a stiffer boot.
Sources
- Roces: Jokey Ice 3.0 Boy
- K2 Skates: Raider Ice
- K2 Skates: Alexis Ice
- K2 Skates: F.I.T. Ice
- Graf Figure: Davos Gold
- Graf Figure: Edmonton Special
- Powerslide: Rutscherla II
- HockeyMonkey: CCM Tacks AS-550 Senior (retailer information)
- HockeyMonkey: Bauer Vapor X4 Senior (retailer information)
- Brock University: The Effect of Recommended Sharpening Characteristics on Skating Speed
- Planet Outdoor: sharpening ice skates (in German)
Where to buy
- Roces Jokey Ice 3.0 (Boy)Check price at Amazon.de
- Powerslide Rutscherla IICheck price at Amazon.de
- K2 Raider IceCheck price at Amazon.de
- K2 Alexis Ice (Damen, grau/grün)Check price at Amazon.de
- Graf Davos GoldCheck price at Amazon.de
- CCM Tacks AS-550 (Senior)Check price at Amazon.de
- Bauer Vapor X4 (Senior)Check price at Amazon.de
