Contents10 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
A cordless massager that only ever runs in the armchair in the evening is often the wrong buy. At home, a model that plugs into the wall usually suits better, such as the Beurer MG 153: no worrying about charging, it switches off after about 15 minutes, and the cover is washable. A battery only pays off if the device really moves around. To the office, onto the balcony, to a desk without a power outlet.
One thing up front, because many boxes suggest otherwise. A neck massager is a wellness device. Beurer states explicitly in the MG 153 manual that the device cannot replace medical treatment, and Medisana warns against using the NM 990 as a substitute for medical applications. If your neck has been hurting for weeks, have a doctor look at it first.
Five neck massagers compared
| Model | Design and power | Heat and auto shut-off (according to the manufacturer) | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Beurer MG 153 | Wrap-around, power adapter, 1.79 kg | Heat can be switched on, shuts off after approx. 15 min. | A fixed spot at home |
| Beurer MG 154 | Wrap-around, battery up to 2 hrs, USB-C, 1.16 kg | Heat can be switched on, shuts off after approx. 10 min. | Office and changing locations |
| Medisana NM 990 | Wrap-around, 2,200 mAh battery, USB-C, approx. 1.3 kg | Heat can be switched on, shuts off after 15 min. | People who want to control the pressure themselves |
| Medisana NM A81 | Shiatsu pillow, power adapter, cable approx. 180 cm, approx. 1.5 kg | Heat not mentioned on the manufacturer’s site | Small budget, entry level |
| Comfier CF-6108G | Shiatsu massage pillow, power adapter | Heat can be switched on, shut-off not stated (retailer information) | Neck, back and legs in turn |
Cord or battery, heat, auto shut-off
„Shiatsu“ here means kneading rollers: rotating massage heads that are meant to imitate the pressure of fingers. That is not the same as a shiatsu treatment by a trained practitioner. Look for a change of direction and at least two speeds.
Heat is a comfort feature. You should be able to switch it off separately from the massage, and manufacturers are often vague about the temperature. Corded models are heavier but run without a break. The two battery models here weigh just over a kilogram and charge via USB-C.
- Auto shut-off: Beurer and Medisana recommend no more than 15 minutes at a time and switch their devices off automatically after that. We would not buy one without this feature.
- Washable cover: The device rests directly on your skin. A removable cover is a must, not a luxury.
When the manufacturers themselves advise against it
The contraindications are not in the marketing copy but in the instructions for use. For the MG 153, Beurer lists, among other things: not during pregnancy, not with injuries or pathological changes in the area being massaged (such as a herniated disc), not on inflamed or injured skin, not while sleeping, not after taking medication or alcohol, not in a motor vehicle. According to Beurer, people with a pacemaker or implants, with thrombosis, diabetes, serious illnesses or pain of unknown cause should ask their doctor first.
Medisana lists similar points for the NM 990, including pregnancy, pacemakers, artificial joints, circulatory disorders and varicose veins. Then there is a sentence many people skip over: never use the device while driving a vehicle. So do actually read the manual for your model before you switch it on for the first time.
Beurer MG 153: the solid corded standard
Four kneading rollers and two clamping nodes, plus change of direction, two speeds and switchable heat. The cover goes into the washing machine at 30 degrees, and the device switches off after about 15 minutes. At just under 1.8 kilograms it is noticeably heavier than the battery models, but in return it sits firmly on the shoulders. Beurer offers a three-year warranty.
Beurer MG 154: the same idea without a cord
The battery version: four massage heads, two massage fingers, heat at the push of a button. According to Beurer, the lithium-ion battery lasts up to two hours and charges via USB-C. Here it switches off after about ten minutes. If you rarely change places, you pay extra for the battery without getting much out of it.
Medisana NM 990: pressure via the hand loops
Hand-shaped massage heads with three speeds and two directions of rotation. The interesting part is how you operate it: according to the manual, pulling on the hand loops increases the pressure. Medisana does not state a running time, only the battery capacity of 2,200 mAh. It stops after 15 minutes.
Medisana NM A81: inexpensive, but look closely
In terms of price, the NM A81 sits well below the other devices. Medisana describes a shiatsu massage, a 12-volt power adapter and a cable of around 1.80 meters. The manufacturer’s site does not mention a heat function, but some retailer listings do. If heat matters to you, check which version is being offered before you order.
Comfier CF-6108G: a massage pillow for several parts of the body
A massage pillow does not wrap around your neck; you lean against it. That is more comfortable in an armchair, and the pillow also works on your back or thighs. According to the retailer, it uses rotating kneading heads, the heat has its own button, and power comes from an adapter. The retailer does not state a shut-off time and recommends 15 to 20 minutes per session. So you have to keep an eye on the clock yourself. And a pillow like this does not belong behind the steering wheel. Beurer and Medisana rule out use in a vehicle for their devices or prohibit it while driving.
Who should pick which device
For a fixed spot on the sofa or at the desk, the Beurer MG 153. Mains power, auto shut-off, washable cover. You rarely need more. For changing locations and the office, the Beurer MG 154 or the Medisana NM 990 fit the bill, the latter especially if you prefer to control the pressure with your hands. The Medisana NM A81 remains the choice for a tight budget, provided you can do without heat or check the features beforehand. Neck and back with one device? Then the Comfier CF-6108G as a massage pillow.
Working on individual muscles in a targeted way is the domain of massage guns (in German). Pure warmth without any mechanics comes from a heated blanket (in German). And often the cause of a stiff neck lies in the workstation; for that, see our guide to the ergonomic office chair.
Frequently asked questions
Battery or cord for a neck massager?
Corded models are heavier but run without a break; the Beurer MG 153 weighs just under 1.8 kilograms. The battery models in our comparison weigh just over a kilogram and charge via USB-C. If you rarely change places, you pay extra for the battery without getting much out of it.
Can a neck massager replace treatment?
No. Beurer states explicitly in the MG 153 manual that the device cannot replace medical treatment, and Medisana warns against using the NM 990 as a substitute for medical applications. If your neck has been hurting for weeks, have a doctor look at it first.
Who should not use a neck massager?
For the MG 153, Beurer lists, among other things, pregnancy, injuries or pathological changes in the area being massaged, and inflamed skin. People with a pacemaker, implants, thrombosis or diabetes should ask their doctor first. Medisana additionally lists artificial joints, circulatory disorders and varicose veins.
How long can you use a neck massager?
Beurer and Medisana recommend no more than 15 minutes at a time and switch their devices off automatically after that; the Beurer MG 154 does so after only about ten minutes. For the Comfier CF-6108G, the retailer does not state a shut-off time, so you have to keep an eye on the clock yourself.
What does shiatsu mean for neck massagers?
It refers to rotating massage heads, i.e. kneading rollers meant to imitate the pressure of fingers. That is not the same as a shiatsu treatment by a trained practitioner. Look for a change of direction and at least two speeds.
Can you use a neck massager in the car?
No, at least not while driving. Beurer rules out use in a motor vehicle, and Medisana prohibits use while driving a vehicle. A massage pillow does not belong behind the steering wheel either.
Sources
- Beurer: 4D neck massager MG 153
- Beurer: MG 153 instructions for use (PDF)
- Beurer: cordless neck massager MG 154
- Medisana: cordless neck massager NM 990
- Medisana: NM 990 instructions for use
- Medisana: neck massager NM A81
- Nahdi: Comfier CF-6108G (retailer information)
Where to buy
- Beurer MG 153Check price at Amazon.de
- Beurer MG 154Check price at Amazon.de
- Medisana NM 990Check price at Amazon.de
- Medisana NM A81Check price at Amazon.de
- Comfier CF-6108GCheck price at Amazon.de
