Contents14 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
When booking a vacation, a mistake about who your contractual partner is costs the most. More than any pricing error. If you book flight and hotel together with a tour operator, a package holiday gives you a whole set of statutory rights under German law, from insolvency protection to price reductions. If you book yourself, you may save on a few components, but when problems arise you often stand alone in front of three different companies. Families and anyone who does not want to negotiate on vacation therefore usually have an easier time with a package holiday.
Package or individual parts: where the law draws the line
Under § 651a of the German Civil Code (BGB), a package holiday is a combination of at least two different types of travel services for the same trip. Classically, that means flight and hotel. Whether the catalog defines the package or you click it together yourself makes no difference.
This is exactly where it gets interesting for portal customers. Under § 651b BGB, a provider is also considered a tour operator if you select the services in a single booking process, if it states a total price or advertises the whole thing as a „package holiday.“ The European Consumer Centre Germany (EVZ) calls this dynamic packaging. According to the EVZ, being forwarded from a flight to a hotel provider with your data passed on within 24 hours can also constitute a package holiday.
In between are „linked travel arrangements“ under § 651w BGB. You select and pay separately, just on the same website. The agent then only protects the payments it receives itself. The German consumer advice center (Verbraucherzentrale) explicitly calls this the weaker protection.
Adopted but not yet in force: in spring 2026, the EU revised the Package Travel Directive as Directive (EU) 2026/1024. Germany still has to transpose it into the BGB. According to the IHK Osnabrück (Chamber of Commerce), the new rules are expected to take effect in Germany in 2029. The intermediate level of linked travel arrangements is then set to disappear, and customers will be able to reject a voucher instead of a refund within 14 days. Until then, everything stated here applies unchanged.
What you are entitled to as a package traveler
- A trip free of defects: The tour operator owes you the trip as agreed (§ 651i BGB).
- Report immediately: You must report the defect without delay (§ 651o BGB), to the tour guide or the tour operator, not at the hotel reception. Otherwise you risk losing price reductions and damages.
- Price reduction: For the duration of the defect, the price is reduced (§ 651m BGB), by estimate if necessary. According to the Verbraucherzentrale, the Kempten and Frankfurt tables (German reference tables) only provide guidance.
- Two years‘ time: Claims expire two years after the planned end of the trip (§ 651j BGB).
- Price increase: only for reasons specified by law and no later than 20 days before departure (§ 651f BGB).
- Cancellation: You may cancel at any time before the trip begins, but owe reasonable compensation (§ 651h BGB). There is no 14-day right of withdrawal as with online purchases.
The insolvency certificate comes before the deposit
If the tour operator goes bankrupt, your money must be returned and, if you are already traveling, your journey home must be secured as well (§ 651r BGB). Since November 1, 2021, larger tour operators in Germany have met this requirement through a travel guarantee fund. The operator may only demand payments before the end of the trip if this protection exists and you have received the name and contact details of the insurer (§ 651t BGB). The proof is called a Sicherungsschein (insolvency certificate). Without it, no deposit.
According to the Verbraucherzentrale, this does not protect against the bankruptcy of an airline booked separately. For deposits of more than 20 percent, it recommends seeking legal advice.
Six providers, three roles
The table reflects what the providers themselves write. It is not a ranking. As of November 2026.
| Provider | Role according to its own terms | Cancellation and flex options according to the provider | Reviews on its own platform | Customer service |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| TUI | Tour operator (operator brand, its own insolvency certificate) | Flex fare for a surcharge: free cancellation up to 15 or 29 days before arrival, with exceptions | not checked | Phone daily 8 a.m. to 11 p.m., myTUI customer account |
| HolidayCheck | Agent (package holidays, linked and individual services) | according to the tour operator’s terms, no fees of its own for rebooking or cancellation | yes, hotel reviews by travelers | Phone for booking assistance, contact form, email |
| CHECK24 Reisen | exclusively an agent | Offers marked „24h Flex“ or „48h Flex“ can be canceled free of charge within 24 or 48 hours | Customer reviews of its own service; hotel reviews not checked | Chat and voice assistant around the clock, email, callback |
| Booking.com | Platform, no responsibility for the trip itself | free cancellation depending on the offer; otherwise a 90 percent flat fee for accommodation in Germany | yes, guest reviews after booking | Help pages, phone, message, mail |
| Expedia | Agent (according to provider, not confirmed) | free cancellation at selected hotels (according to provider, not confirmed) | yes, only after booking (according to provider, not confirmed) | not reliably checked |
| ab-in-den-urlaub | exclusively a travel agent (§§ 651v, 651w BGB) | Cancellation in the customer account, costs according to the tour operator’s terms | Hotel reviews displayed, origin not checked | Chat and WhatsApp around the clock, phone 8 a.m. to 11 p.m., email, callback |
TUI: the tour operator itself
With TUI, the contractual partner is also the tour operator. According to TUI, it includes the insolvency certificate with every booking confirmation for a package holiday. The Flex fare costs extra and does not apply to all brands; according to TUI, X-TUI, ltur, tours and cruises are excluded, as is direct debit.
HolidayCheck: review portal with a booking function
HolidayCheck states clearly in its terms and conditions that the travel contract is never concluded with HolidayCheck, but with the named tour operator. Look for the tour operator’s name in the confirmation: it is your contact for defects.
CHECK24 Reisen: comparison with a short cooling-off period
CHECK24 only acts as an agent. The Flex label is a real help for spontaneous bookers, but it is short: if you do not get in touch within 24 or 48 hours, the booking is binding. After that, according to the terms and conditions, cancellation fees of up to 100 percent may apply depending on the tour operator.
Booking.com: strong on accommodation, no package protection
According to its own terms, Booking.com provides the platform, not the trip. If you book additional services via a link within 24 hours, the terms explicitly point out that package holiday rights do not apply in that case. For a vacation rental on its own, that works; for flight plus hotel, less so.
Expedia: information only partially verifiable
We did not have access to the complete legal texts of Expedia.de. The information in the table is based only on brief statements from the provider. Check the role and cancellation terms in the offer yourself before booking.
ab-in-den-urlaub: agent with many channels
The Leipzig-based portal describes itself in its terms and conditions exclusively as a travel agent and lists offers from more than 80 tour operators. The customer account shows cancellation costs in advance; according to the help page, the refund is the tour operator’s responsibility. At night, a digital assistant answers first.
When the price grows at checkout
„Drip pricing“ is the name for the trick of adding mandatory fees only at the last booking step. In an EU-wide check of 314 online retailers, the European Commission found it at 10 percent and calls hiding additional costs until the end unlawful (announcement of March 26, 2026). The Verbraucherzentrale adds for travel: final prices must include VAT and mandatory ancillary services, and no separate fees may be charged for card payments. So only compare the price on the last page before „book with obligation to pay.“
Little helpers for the trip
A luggage scale such as the Soehnle Travel (up to 50 kg according to the listing) saves arguments at check-in if your fare only includes one free bag. A 2nd-generation Apple AirTag in your suitcase helps you find it, but requires an iPhone or iPad. According to the listing, the Skross MUV USB is a travel adapter with USB charging, but not a voltage converter. Packing cubes (Eagle Creek Pack-It) and neck pillows (Cabeau Evolution S3) are a matter of comfort. What belongs in your toiletry bag is covered in our toiletry bag guide (in German); if you have yet to choose a luggage tracker, our Bluetooth tracker guide (in German) will help.
Our assessment
Family, flight plus hotel, long-haul destination? Then a package holiday from a tour operator or through an agent, and ask for the insolvency certificate before paying the deposit. For a city trip by train with a vacation rental, booking yourself is a reasonable option.
Still unsure whether you will go? Read the flex options carefully; the deadlines range from 24 hours after booking to a few weeks before arrival. And if you book the flight separately, keep in mind that there is no insolvency certificate if an airline goes bankrupt.
No destination yet for the cold season? Our overview of winter travel destinations (in German) offers ideas.
Once the destination is set, it is time to book. What applies to insolvency certificates, deposits and defects can be found in our guide to booking a package holiday (in German), and for excursions on site in our guide to booking a rental car (in German).
And in case something comes up: what a cancellation costs and when it is free is explained in our guide to canceling a package holiday (in German).
Frequently asked questions
When is a trip a package holiday?
Under § 651a of the German Civil Code (BGB), when at least two different types of travel services are combined for the same trip, classically flight and hotel. Packages you click together yourself also count if they are selected in one booking process, a total price is stated or the whole thing is advertised as a package holiday. The European Consumer Centre (EVZ) calls this dynamic packaging.
What is the difference between a package holiday and linked travel arrangements?
With linked travel arrangements under § 651w BGB, you select and pay separately, just on the same website. The agent then only protects the payments it receives itself. The German consumer advice center (Verbraucherzentrale) explicitly calls this the weaker protection. The revised EU directive is set to abolish this intermediate level in the future.
What is a Sicherungsschein (insolvency certificate)?
Proof that your money will be returned and your journey home secured if the tour operator goes bankrupt. Under § 651t BGB, the operator may only demand payments before the end of the trip if this protection exists and you have the insurer's details. No certificate, no deposit. It does not protect against the bankruptcy of an airline booked separately.
What rights do I have if a package holiday has defects?
You must report the defect without delay to the tour guide or the tour operator, not at the hotel reception. For the duration of the defect, the price is reduced under § 651m BGB. Claims expire two years after the planned end of the trip. According to the Verbraucherzentrale, the Kempten and Frankfurt tables (German reference tables for price reductions) only provide guidance.
Is there a right of withdrawal for package holidays?
No, there is no 14-day right of withdrawal as with online purchases. You may cancel at any time before the trip begins, but owe reasonable compensation. Flex options help: at CHECK24, offers marked 24h Flex or 48h Flex can be canceled free of charge within that period; after that, the booking is binding.
Who is my contractual partner at HolidayCheck or CHECK24?
Not the portal. HolidayCheck states in its terms and conditions that the travel contract is concluded with the named tour operator, and CHECK24 and ab-in-den-urlaub describe themselves as agents. Look for the tour operator's name in the booking confirmation; it is your contact for defects. With TUI, the contractual partner is also the tour operator.
Sources
- German Civil Code (BGB) §§ 651a, 651b, 651f, 651h, 651i, 651j, 651m, 651o, 651r, 651t, 651v, 651w (gesetze-im-internet.de)
- Verbraucherzentrale: Online travel agencies
- Verbraucherzentrale: Defects on package holidays
- European Consumer Centre Germany: Package holidays
- IHK Osnabrück-Emsland-Grafschaft Bentheim: New Package Travel Directive
- European Commission: EU check of misleading sales practices (March 26, 2026)
- Provider pages (deliberately not linked): TUI Flex fare and help (tui.com), HolidayCheck terms and contact (holidaycheck.de), CHECK24 travel terms, FAQ and contact (urlaub.check24.de, check24.de), Booking.com terms and conditions (booking.com), ab in den urlaub terms, contact and cancellation (ab-in-den-urlaub.de), Expedia brief statements only (expedia.de); accessed on November 1, 2026
Where to buy
- Soehnle Gepäckwaage TravelCheck price at Amazon.de
- CHECK24 ReisenView at CHECK24
- Apple AirTag (2. Generation)Check price at Amazon.de
- SKROSS World Travel Adapter MUV USBCheck price at Amazon.de
- Eagle Creek Pack-It Reveal Packwürfel-Set (XS/S/M, schwarz)Check price at Amazon.de
- Cabeau Evolution S3 ReisekissenCheck price at Amazon.de
