Contents11 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
The floor is spotless, and yet a gray ring of sunscreen, pollen and limescale runs around the pool at the waterline. That’s exactly where you end up standing with the brush again. Many robotic pool cleaners keep the floor clean and ignore this edge. For in-ground pools with floor, walls and waterline, we consider a mid-range battery-powered robot such as the Aiper Scuba V3 the sensible step. If the robot runs daily and the cord doesn’t bother you, a corded Dolphin or Zodiac is no worse.
What do I need to know about my pool?
A robot for a shallow above-ground pool is a different device from one for a masonry pool with steps and vertical walls. Many inexpensive models only drive over a flat floor. That’s why runtimes come later.
First, the size. Corded units state the maximum pool length; for the Dolphin E35i, it’s 12 meters according to Maytronics. Battery manufacturers calculate in square meters, and their figures sometimes differ considerably depending on the country and version. Then walls and waterline: if that isn’t explicitly mentioned in the spec sheet, the unit can’t do it. Some models have their own waterline mode, others only cover the edge in the full program. Any basket catches leaves and sand. For fine dust and algae residue, you need a fine filter in the range of a few micrometers, which clogs faster, however, and has to be rinsed out more often. That leaves lifting it out. With a full basket, a wet robot quickly weighs eight kilos or more, and units that park at the waterline or at the surface spare you fishing with a hook.
Battery or cord?
The cord has a bad reputation that it only half deserves. A corded robot runs as long as you let it, and there is no battery that weakens after a few seasons. The price for that is a power supply at the pool edge and a cable that can get tangled. Maytronics and Zodiac therefore build in swivels.
Battery units get into the water and back out faster. Their runtime figures almost always apply to an economy mode. Depending on the page and version, Aiper states 150, 180 or 270 minutes for the Scuba S1; in its own articles on the C2, WYBOT states significantly less than in its shop. Assume the lower figure. Cold water in spring costs additional runtime.
Our rule of thumb: if the pool should be cleaned almost daily from May to September, a cord is more relaxed. For two to three cleanings a week, after which the robot goes back into the garage, battery.
Which models are worth considering?
| Model | Power | Cleaning areas | Filter | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aiper Scuba V3 | Battery, up to 180 min | Floor, walls, waterline | Multi-layer fine filter | In-ground pool, little effort |
| Aiper Scuba S1 | Battery, runtime depends on version | Floor, walls, waterline, up to 150 m² | Basket 180 µm, 3 µm fine filter extra | Tighter budget |
| WYBOT C2 | Battery, up to 180 min (Eco) | Floor, walls, waterline | 180 µm + 10 µm, 3 l basket | Targeted waterline cleaning |
| Beatbot AquaSense 2 Ultra | Battery, 13,400 mAh | Floor, walls, waterline, surface, up to 320 m² | 150 + 250 µm, 3.7 l basket | Large pools, leaves on the surface |
| Dolphin E35i | 17 m cord, 2-hour cycle | Floor, walls, pools up to 12 m | Combination filter, ultra-fine filter included | Daily cleaning |
| Zodiac CNX 30 iQ | Cord | Floor, walls, waterline, pools up to 12 × 6 m | Two-stage | Family pool with app control |
Aiper Scuba V3
Aiper’s mid-range model with camera recognition. According to the manufacturer, the V3 cleans the floor, the walls and, with its own nozzle, the waterline, with a maximum runtime of 180 minutes. After the program, it waits at the waterline so you can take it out. Aiper gives contradictory figures on filter fineness. Check beforehand which filter comes in the box.
Aiper Scuba S1
According to Aiper, the S1 also handles walls and waterline and is designed for pools up to 150 square meters. On Amazon.de, it costs noticeably less than the V3. The savings come from the filter: as standard, the basket catches particles from 180 micrometers according to Aiper, and the 3-micrometer fine filter is an accessory. There are also several versions with different runtimes. Pay close attention to which one you order.
WYBOT C2
According to WYBOT, the C2 combines a 180 µm basket with a 10 µm fine filter, and the basket holds three liters. The interesting part is its dedicated waterline-only mode, plus schedules via app and automatic parking when the battery is low. Weight according to WYBOT: 7.9 kilos. The area figures vary between 150 and 200 square meters depending on the country site.
Beatbot AquaSense 2 Ultra
For large pools and yards with lots of leaves. According to Beatbot, the Ultra also cleans the water surface, for up to ten hours, and Beatbot states five hours for the floor. The dual filter, however, only retains particles from 150 micrometers; a finer fleece basket is optional. In an ordinary backyard pool without trees, you pay a lot here for features you rarely need. Beatbot no longer carries its predecessor, the AquaSense 2 Pro.
Dolphin E35i
Maytronics has been building robotic pool cleaners for decades, and the E35i shows why a cord doesn’t have to be old-fashioned. According to the manufacturer: a 17-meter cord with swivel, pools up to 12 meters, two hours per cycle, control via the MyDolphin Plus app, two-year warranty. An ultra-fine filter is included. Maytronics only advertises waterline cleaning on the larger E40i.
Zodiac CNX 30 iQ
Cyclonic suction, spiral brushes and two-stage filtration. According to Zodiac, the pool can be up to 12 by 6 meters, and cycle time and remote control run via the iAquaLink app. The filter is accessible from the top and has a viewing window. A lift system that lets the water drain out before lifting is only available from the CNX 40 iQ upward.
So which one suits my pool?
For an in-ground pool cleaned two to three times a week, we recommend the Aiper Scuba V3: battery, walls and waterline, parking for easy removal. For the same pool on a smaller budget, the Aiper Scuba S1 is enough, provided you buy the fine filter separately if needed. If the gray ring is the main problem, the dedicated waterline mode and factory-fitted fine filter speak for the WYBOT C2.
Daily cleaning throughout the season? Then the corded Dolphin E35i or Zodiac CNX 30 iQ. A large pool under trees justifies the Beatbot AquaSense 2 Ultra, because of its surface cleaning.
And the shallow above-ground pool? None of these units. A floor cleaner is enough here, and wall climbing is tricky with soft walls anyway.
In the yard, some people already mow with a robotic mower without a boundary wire (in German), and in the house there may be a robot vacuum with mopping function (in German). The principle is the same: navigation decides whether the corners get clean. The pool edge and patio are a job for the pressure washer (in German).
For frame, steel-wall and quick-up pools, see our guide Robotic pool cleaners for above-ground pools (in German).
New to the field is the ULTRAMARINE P1 from Ecovacs. According to the manufacturer, it cleans the floor, walls and waterline and combines a 180-micrometer mesh with a 3-micrometer fine filter. The manual requires a water depth of 50 centimeters, and the shop and manual give different battery figures (5,200 and 4,600 mAh). For us, it’s an option, not a recommendation, as long as independent experience is lacking.
For in-ground pools, our guide Robotic pool cleaners by pool shape (in German) will help.
For storage, read Robotic pool cleaners: care and winter storage (in German).
Frequently asked questions
Robotic pool cleaner with battery or with cord?
A corded robot runs as long as you let it, and there is no battery that weakens after a few seasons. In return, there is a power supply at the pool edge and a cable that can get tangled. Battery units get into the water and back out faster. Rule of thumb: near-daily cleaning from May to September speaks for a cord.
How realistic are the battery runtimes of robotic pool cleaners?
The figures almost always apply to an economy mode. Depending on the page and version, Aiper states 150, 180 or 270 minutes for the Scuba S1, and WYBOT states significantly less for the C2 in its own articles than in its shop. Assume the lower figure; cold water in spring costs additional runtime.
Does every robotic pool cleaner also clean the waterline?
No. Many units keep the floor clean and ignore the gray ring of sunscreen, pollen and limescale. If walls and waterline aren't explicitly mentioned in the spec sheet, the unit can't do it. The WYBOT C2 has its own waterline mode; Maytronics only advertises the waterline on the larger E40i.
Which filter matters on a robotic pool cleaner?
Any basket catches leaves and sand. For fine dust and algae residue, you need a fine filter in the range of a few micrometers, which clogs faster, however, and has to be rinsed out more often. On the Aiper Scuba S1, the basket catches particles from 180 micrometers according to Aiper; the 3-micrometer fine filter is an accessory.
Do I need a robotic pool cleaner with wall cleaning for an above-ground pool?
No, none of the units in this comparison is designed for that. For a shallow above-ground pool, a floor cleaner is enough, and wall climbing is tricky with soft walls anyway. For frame, steel-wall and quick-up pools, there is a separate guide to robotic cleaners for above-ground pools.
Which pools is the Beatbot AquaSense 2 Ultra worth it for?
For large pools under trees, because according to Beatbot it also cleans the water surface, for up to ten hours. The dual filter, however, only retains particles from 150 micrometers; a finer fleece basket is optional. In an ordinary backyard pool without trees, you pay a lot for rarely used features.
Sources
- Aiper: Scuba V3
- Aiper: Scuba S1
- Aiper: 3-micrometer filter for the S1
- WYBOT: C2
- Beatbot: AquaSense 2 Ultra
- Beatbot: help center (filter, battery)
- Maytronics: Dolphin E35i
- Zodiac: CNX 30 iQ
Where to buy
- Aiper Scuba V3Check price at Amazon.de
- Aiper Scuba S1Check price at Amazon.de
- WYBOT C2Check price at Amazon.de
- Beatbot AquaSense 2 UltraCheck price at Amazon.de
- Dolphin E35iCheck price at Amazon.de
- Zodiac CNX 30 iQCheck price at Amazon.de
- ULTRAMARINE P1View at Ecovacs
