Contents12 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
A good snorkel set starts with the mask. It needs tempered glass and a soft silicone skirt, and it has to seal tightly against your face before the snorkel, color or fins even matter. For adults, we consider the Seac Set Bis Giglio Valve a solid entry point; for children, the sets from Mares and Seac that come in dedicated junior sizes. We advise against full-face masks.
What a diving mask needs to do
In its instructor handbook on snorkel diving (2nd edition, 2018), the DLRG, Germany’s lifesaving association, describes how to recognize a suitable mask. The lens should be made of safety glass and be marked „Tempered“, „Tempered Glass“ or „Safety-Glass“. The DLRG rejects plastic lenses because they constantly fog up and scratch quickly. The mask body should be made of silicone, and the strap should split into two bands at the back of the head. Whether single-lens or two-lens is a matter of taste, according to the handbook. There is one exception: if you want prescription lenses fitted, you need a two-lens mask.
You can tell whether a mask fits in ten seconds. Hold the mask against your face without the strap, inhale through your nose, hold your breath. If it stays in place due to the suction, it seals. If it falls off, your face doesn’t fit this model, and tightening the strap won’t change that. According to the handbook, a purge valve on the mask brings no advantage and becomes a weak point as it ages.
Swim goggles, by the way, are no substitute. They don’t enclose the nose, so equalizing pressure is impossible. Which goggles work for swimming laps is covered in our swim goggles guide (in German).
Full-face masks: comfortable on land, questionable in the water
The large masks that cover the whole face and let you breathe through your nose seem beginner-friendly at first glance. The DLRG sees it differently. In its instructor handbook, it calls such snorkel masks dangerous and unsuitable for diving, because the inside increasingly fills with used air that is breathed in again and again. Full-face masks are not permitted in DLRG courses; the local chapter in Weinheim states that they do not offer the necessary protection.
A study in the journal Diving and Hyperbaric Medicine (2023) backs this up. Twenty participants breathed on land, at rest and under light to moderate exertion, through full-face masks and through regular snorkels. Under light exertion, the measurement had to be stopped because of excessive carbon dioxide in the breath in 45 percent of the runs with a full-face mask, compared with 20 percent with a regular snorkel. The researchers found evidence of rebreathing in all full-face masks. Even light movement was enough.
Short, smooth, no corrugated hose: the snorkel
The numbers are strict here. Under the European standard DIN EN 1972, which the DLRG handbook cites, a snorkel for adults may be no more than 35 cm long, and for children under 150 cm tall no more than 30 cm. According to the DLRG, longer tubes are life-threatening because the lungs have to draw air against the water pressure. At a depth of just 70 cm, controlled breathing is no longer possible. The inner cross-section should be at least 1.8 cm², and the diameter should not exceed 2.5 cm. A corrugated hose at the mouthpiece is a water trap. An orange band of at least 3 cm at the top end makes it easy to see.
Valves are controversial. For training, the DLRG recommends snorkels with no valve at all. In stores, however, models with a splash guard, dry top or purge valve dominate, including in every set in this overview. For calm snorkeling at the surface, we consider that acceptable. If you are planning a course or regularly dive down, it’s better to buy the snorkel separately and keep it simple.
Fins: closed heel or adjustable strap?
For snorkeling, the DLRG recommends full-foot fins whose foot pocket encloses the entire foot except the toes. The blade shouldn’t be so stiff that your calves cramp after twenty minutes. Try fins on the way you will wear them later, meaning with booties if you use them. Open-heel fins with a strap are a compromise. Adjustable models such as the Seac Sprint cover three sizes according to the manufacturer, which helps with growing children’s feet. With neoprene booties, they also protect you at rocky entry points. The handbook is, however, critical of heavy scuba fins for inexperienced swimmers.
5 snorkel sets at a glance
| Model | Mask | Snorkel | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Seac Set Bis Giglio Valve | Single lens, tempered glass, hypoallergenic silicone | Splash guard, purge valve | Adults, smaller MD version for teens |
| Mares Combo Wahoo | Two lenses, soft silicone | Semi-dry, splash guard, silicone mouthpiece | Adults |
| Seac Set Tris Sprint Dry | Giglio, Giglio MD or Bella depending on size | With watertight cap, splash guard on kids‘ version | Families, EU shoe sizes 32 to 47, with fins |
| Mares Combo Pirate | Silicone, wide field of view | Junior, splash guard, silicone mouthpiece | Children aged 8 to 14 |
| Seac Set Bis Bella | Two lenses, tempered glass, clear silicone | Splash guard, jaw-friendly mouthpiece | Children from age 3 |
Seac Set Bis Giglio Valve
A single-lens mask with tempered glass and a hypoallergenic silicone skirt, plus the Fast Tech snorkel with a splash guard at the top and a purge valve at the bottom. Seac offers the set for adults and as an MD version with a smaller mask for younger snorkelers. The valve goes against the DLRG line for courses, but it doesn’t get in the way when snorkeling on a reef on vacation. For adults, this is where we would start.
Mares Combo Wahoo
Mares combines a two-lens mask with a soft silicone skirt and easily adjustable buckles with the Breezer Guard Pro, a semi-dry snorkel with a splash guard. Mares gives no information on the type of glass or on prescription lenses for this set. If you wear glasses, ask the manufacturer before buying.
Seac Set Tris Sprint Dry
The complete set with fins and a mesh bag that lets you carry the gear even when wet. What makes it interesting for families is the split by size: from EU shoe size 39, it comes with the Giglio mask and the Fast Tech Dry snorkel; in 36/38 with the smaller Giglio MD; in 32/35 with the Bella kids‘ mask and a kids‘ snorkel. The Sprint fins have a strap with six settings and, according to Seac, cover three sizes. The blade is made of transparent polyolefin resin.
Mares Combo Pirate
Designed for children between 8 and 14. According to Mares, the mask has a silicone face skirt and a wide field of view, and the junior snorkel has a silicone mouthpiece and a splash guard. With bigger kids, watch the snorkel length: under 150 cm tall, the 30 cm from the standard applies.
Seac Set Bis Bella
The set for the littlest ones. Seac rates it as suitable from age three: a two-lens mask with tempered glass, a polycarbonate frame and a clear silicone skirt, plus the Miniflash snorkel with a splash guard and a jaw-friendly mouthpiece. From about age eight, the manufacturer points to its junior sets. For children at the water, what the DLRG advises all snorkelers applies anyway: never go into the water alone, always with someone watching.
How we would decide
- Adults without glasses, vacation by the sea: Seac Set Bis Giglio Valve; try on full-foot fins separately.
- Prefer two lenses: Mares Combo Wahoo.
- Family with different shoe sizes and fins in the luggage: Seac Set Tris Sprint Dry.
- School kids aged 8 to 14: Mares Combo Pirate.
- Preschoolers: Seac Set Bis Bella, only within reach of an adult.
A word on care. New masks almost always fog up because silicone residue from the factory sits on the glass. The DLRG advises cleaning the glass several times with dish soap. After every day in salt or chlorinated water, rinse everything with fresh water. Even warm water cools you down. According to the DLRG, that can happen below 30 °C. If you stay out longer or snorkel from a board, you’ll find tips in our SUP board guide (in German).
Frequently asked questions
How do you recognize a good diving mask?
The DLRG, Germany's lifesaving association, names safety glass marked "Tempered" or "Safety-Glass", a silicone mask body and a strap that splits at the back of the head. Plastic lenses fog up and scratch quickly. For prescription lenses, you need a two-lens mask.
How do you check whether a snorkel mask seals?
Hold the mask against your face without the strap, inhale through your nose and hold your breath. If it stays in place due to the suction, it seals. If it falls off, your face doesn't fit this model, and tightening the strap won't change that.
Are full-face snorkel masks dangerous?
The DLRG calls them dangerous because the inside fills with used air that is breathed in again; they are not permitted in DLRG courses. A study in Diving and Hyperbaric Medicine found evidence of rebreathing in all full-face masks, even under light exertion.
How long can a snorkel be?
Under the European standard EN 1972, no more than 35 cm for adults and 30 cm for children under 150 cm tall. According to the DLRG, longer tubes are life-threatening because the lungs have to draw air against the water pressure. A corrugated hose at the mouthpiece acts as a water trap.
Which fins are suitable for snorkeling?
The DLRG recommends full-foot fins and a blade that isn't so stiff that your calves cramp. Adjustable strap fins such as the Seac Sprint cover three sizes according to the manufacturer, which helps with growing children's feet.
Why does a new diving mask fog up?
New masks almost always fog up because silicone residue from the factory sits on the glass. The DLRG advises cleaning the glass several times with dish soap. After every day in salt or chlorinated water, rinse the gear with fresh water.
Sources
- DLRG: instructor handbook on snorkel diving, 2nd edition 2018 (in German)
- DLRG Weinheim: snorkeling (in German)
- Grundemann et al.: Full-face snorkel masks, Diving and Hyperbaric Medicine 2023
- Seac: Set Bis Giglio Valve
- Seac: Set Tris Sprint Dry
- Seac: Sprint fins
- Seac: Set Bis Bella
- Mares: Combo Wahoo
- Mares: Combo Pirate
Where to buy
- Seac Set Bis Giglio ValveCheck price at Amazon.de
- Mares Combo Wahoo (blau)Check price at Amazon.de
- Seac Set Tris Sprint DryCheck price at Amazon.de
- Mares Combo PirateCheck price at Amazon.de
- Seac Set Bis BellaCheck price at Amazon.de
