Contents13 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
With cordless tools, the most consequential decision comes right at the start, and hardly anyone notices. People buy whichever drill/driver happens to be on sale. Two years later, it is exactly the saw, string trimmer or impact wrench that is missing from that system. So choose the platform first, then the tool. DIYers who also tend their garden with battery power are usually best served by a broad DIY system or a cross-brand alliance. If you are on a job site every day, take the system in which your own specialty tools exist.
Why the battery matters more than the machine
In the first kit, batteries and charger are often the biggest cost item. After that, only bare tools without batteries get added. That is exactly where a well-chosen system saves money year after year.
So do not just count drill/drivers. Does the system have tools for your next projects, such as a jigsaw, multi-tool, hedge trimmer or lawn mower? Alliances across brand boundaries bring a lot of choice. In the POWER FOR ALL ALLIANCE (Bosch Green, Gardena and others), with AMPShare (Bosch Professional, Fein, Rothenberger and others) and in the Cordless Alliance System CAS around Metabo, several brands share one battery. CAS alone lists over 50 brands and more than 500 machines.
Bosch has a trap. Green DIY tools and blue professional tools belong to two separate systems with their own alliances. If you mix both colors, you need two sets of batteries.
On voltage: 12 volts stands for compact, lightweight tools; 18 volts is the broad standard. Higher classes such as 40 or 54 volts are only worth the extra cost for saws, cut-off saws and heavy rotary hammers. And it makes sense to buy the first tool as a kit with two batteries and a charger, and everything after that as bare tools. Otherwise, five chargers will soon be piling up on the shelf.
Take a close look at the warranty. Almost all manufacturers extend their manufacturer’s warranty only if the tool is registered online within four weeks or 30 days. Batteries and chargers are often covered for a shorter period or excluded entirely. The retailer’s statutory warranty remains unaffected, as Makita, for example, explicitly points out in its terms.
Seven systems side by side
| System | Tools according to the manufacturer | Warranty according to the manufacturer | Who it’s for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch Professional 18V (AMPShare) | over 430 tools from more than 35 brands | 3 years after registration in PRO360, including batteries and chargers | Trades and serious DIY builders |
| Bosch Green 18V (Power for All) | over 150 products from more than 10 brands | 2 years, 3 years after MyBosch registration (excluding batteries and chargers) | House and garden |
| Makita LXT 18V / XGT 40V | LXT over 430, XGT over 230 | 3 years machine, 2 years Li-ion battery after registration | Professionals, large gardens |
| Milwaukee M12 / M18 | M12 over 125, M18 over 325 solutions | 1 year, up to 3 years after registration; batteries 2 years max. | Trades, installation |
| DeWalt XR 18V / 54V FlexVolt | 54 V battery in around 160 further machines | 1 year, 3 years after registration; batteries mostly 1 year | Job site, timber construction |
| Einhell Power X-Change | over 350 tools | Battery 3 years after registration, not for commercial use | Budget-conscious DIYers |
| Ryobi ONE+ 18V | over 200 tools | 3 years (terms from the manufacturer) | House, garden, hobby |
All tool counts come from the manufacturers and in some cases include variants, accessories or country versions. That is enough for rough orientation. Not for an exact comparison.
Bosch Professional with AMPShare: blue and widely branched
Backward compatible with the 18-volt tools from 2008: that is how Bosch describes its blue system. Via AMPShare, the batteries also fit tools from Fein, Rothenberger, Steinel or Wagner, and for saws and rotary hammers there is a more powerful battery series, ProCORE18V. If you only hang a shelf now and then, you are buying far more system here than you need.
Bosch Green and Power for All: strong in the garden
Gardena, Husqvarna, Flymo and other brands use the same 18-volt battery, which Bosch describes as compatible since 2007. If a lawn mower and hedge trimmer are on the list anyway, our guides to the cordless lawn mower (in German) and to cordless hedge trimmers and string trimmers (in German) will help.
Makita LXT and XGT: two worlds with a bridge
With over 430 LXT tools, Makita has one of the largest 18-volt ranges, and many garden tools run on two 18-volt batteries. XGT with 40 volts is a separate system. Its batteries do not fit LXT tools, but according to Makita the XGT charger can also charge LXT batteries with an adapter. At home, LXT is almost always enough.
Milwaukee M12 and M18: compact and heavy-duty, one charger
At Milwaukee, two systems run in parallel and share a charger. The manufacturer calls M12 the largest compact system on the market, popular in electrical and plumbing work. M18 is there for the heavy jobs. For household use, Milwaukee tends to be expensive.
DeWalt XR and FlexVolt: the battery switches over
According to the manufacturer, 54-volt FlexVolt batteries run in almost all 18-volt XR machines and switch over on their own. That offers a gentle path to power-hungry saws without needing a second system. However, DeWalt gives only one year of warranty on most batteries.
Einhell Power X-Change: broad and affordable
Einhell lists over 350 tools for one battery type, and some tools work with two batteries and up to 36 volts. Price-wise, it sits in the lower to middle range. Commercial use is excluded from the extended battery warranty. Only the Professional tools are exempt from that.
Ryobi ONE+: lots of niches
Ryobi speaks of over 200 tools for one battery, including many niche tools for house, garden and hobby. According to Ryobi, new batteries fit ONE+ tools that are up to 25 years old. Good if you are looking for many different occasional-use tools.
And Hilti Nuron?
A single 22-volt platform with more than 100 tools by now, and all Nuron batteries fit all Nuron tools. Hilti clearly targets businesses, for example with its own service models such as fleet management. For private use, the system hardly makes sense. That is why it is missing from the table.
Questions from businesses: warranty, job-site data, switching
Is there a uniform warranty across several battery platforms?
No. Even within an alliance, the warranty remains the responsibility of the brand on the rating plate. Bosch says this explicitly for AMPShare: service and warranty for battery, charger or tool are handled by the company whose name is on the device, and the contact is the service department of the respective member. A business that wants uniform terms should therefore buy from one brand where possible.
And there, it pays to look at the batteries. After registration in PRO360, Bosch Professional grants three years for batteries and chargers too. Makita gives two years on Li-ion batteries, DeWalt one year on most batteries, and Einhell’s extended battery warranty does not apply to commercial use. The registration deadlines belong in the purchasing process, not in a drawer.
Which battery system delivers useful data from the job site?
The systems built for tool fleets go furthest. With Hilti Nuron, the tools store data in the battery; when charging, according to Hilti, it goes securely and anonymously to the cloud and can be viewed via ON!Track in the browser and in the app. Hilti promises that this helps find lost tools and flags battery replacements in good time.
Milwaukee describes ONE-KEY as digital inventory management, tool tracking and personnel planning, with Bluetooth tracking, barcode scanning and geofencing; this requires tools with ONE-KEY. At Bosch Professional, the GCY 42 Bluetooth module transfers data to the smartphone; according to Bosch, parameters and working modes can be set this way.
Whether it pays off depends on your own workflow. With many job sites and changing crews, tracking saves search time. With two vans, a good list is often enough.
Which platform grows with a renovation business?
The one in which the next tools already exist. Write down what should be added over the next two years and check it tool by tool. The alliances and the big 18-volt systems report the largest selection: Bosch Professional with AMPShare over 430 tools from more than 35 brands, Makita LXT over 430 tools, Milwaukee M18 over 325 solutions, the Cordless Alliance System around Metabo more than 500 machines from over 50 brands. Each manufacturer counts differently, variants included. What counts for the decision is your own list, not the biggest number.
Is it worth it for a small renovation team to switch to Hilti Nuron?
Only with good reason. Nuron is a single 22-volt platform with more than 100 tools, all batteries fit all tools, and Hilti builds services such as fleet management around it. For a team with batteries from another system, however, switching means completely new batteries and chargers. So calculate beforehand which specialty tools are missing from your current system and what the switch costs. If nothing essential is missing, stay put and buy bare tools.
How we would decide
In an apartment, for furniture and pictures, a compact 12-volt or a simple 18-volt kit is enough. You do not need more platform than that, and which drill/driver fits is covered in our cordless drill/driver guide (in German).
With a house and garden, we end up at Bosch Green with Power for All, Einhell or Ryobi. Check beforehand whether the right lawn mower is part of the system. For renovation, interior finishing and lots of wood, powerful batteries and robust saws count, meaning Bosch Professional, Makita LXT or DeWalt XR.
Trade businesses take the system in which their specialty tools exist, even if it is called Milwaukee or Hilti; the warranty registration deadlines then belong directly in the purchasing process. Already have batteries in the basement? Stick with them and buy bare tools. A switch rarely pays off.
Frequently asked questions
Which battery system suits house and garden?
Bosch Green with Power for All, Einhell Power X-Change or Ryobi ONE+. Within the Power for All alliance, Gardena, Husqvarna and Flymo also use the same 18-volt battery. Check beforehand whether the right lawn mower and hedge trimmer are part of the system.
Do Bosch Green batteries fit blue Bosch tools?
No. Green DIY tools and blue professional tools belong to two separate systems with their own alliances, Power for All for Green and AMPShare for Blue. If you mix both colors, you need two sets of batteries.
Is 18 volts enough, or do I need 40 or 54 volts?
18 volts is the broad standard; 12 volts stands for compact, lightweight tools. Higher classes such as 40 or 54 volts are only worth the extra cost for saws, cut-off saws and heavy rotary hammers. At home, with Makita for example, LXT is almost always enough.
What should you look for in the warranty for cordless tools?
Almost all manufacturers extend the warranty only if the tool is registered online within four weeks or 30 days. Batteries and chargers are often covered for a shorter period or excluded entirely. The retailer's statutory warranty remains unaffected.
Buy a kit or a bare tool?
It makes sense to buy the first tool as a kit with two batteries and a charger, and everything after that as bare tools. Batteries and charger are often the biggest cost item in the first kit; after that, a well-chosen system saves money with every bare tool. If you already have batteries in the basement, stick with them.
Is Hilti Nuron worth it for DIYers?
Hardly. Nuron is a single 22-volt platform with more than 100 tools, and all batteries fit all tools. But Hilti clearly targets businesses, for example with its own service models such as fleet management. For private use, the system makes little sense.
Sources
- Bosch Professional: AMPShare
- Bosch Professional: 18V system
- Bosch Professional: PRO360 and warranty
- Bosch DIY: POWER FOR ALL ALLIANCE
- Bosch DIY: MyBosch warranty
- Cordless Alliance System (CAS)
- Makita: LXT
- Makita: XGT
- Makita: Manufacturer’s warranty
- Milwaukee: M18
- Milwaukee: M12
- Milwaukee: Warranty conditions
- DeWalt: XR FlexVolt
- DeWalt: MyDEWALT and registration
- Hilti: Nuron 22 V system
- Milwaukee: ONE-KEY
- Bosch Professional: GCY 42 Bluetooth module
- Einhell: Power X-Change
- Einhell: Battery warranty
- Ryobi: ONE+
Where to buy
- Bosch Professional GSR 18V-45 Set mit 2 Akkus (2 × 2,0 Ah, L-BOXX)Check price at Amazon.de
- Bosch UniversalDrill 18V-60 Set (2 × 2,0 Ah, Koffer)Check price at Amazon.de
- Makita DDF485RTJCheck price at Amazon.de
- Milwaukee M12 BDD-202CCheck price at Amazon.de
- DeWalt DCD796P2View at CoolblueCheck price at Amazon.de
- Einhell TE-CD 18/40 Li BL Kit (2 × 2,0 Ah)Check price at Amazon.de
- Ryobi ONE+ R18DD3-220SCheck price at Amazon.de
