Contents15 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
Before we talk about apps, let’s talk about your door. Almost all smart locks are mounted on the inside over the existing lock cylinder, and that cylinder often needs an emergency and danger function (so the door can be unlocked from outside even with a key inserted on the inside). If the cylinder stays and Wi-Fi should sit directly in the lock, the Nuki Smart Lock Pro and the Yale Linus L2 are the candidates.
If the old cylinder is unsuitable or you want to make the door more secure at the same time, the Nuki Smart Lock Ultra comes with a certified cylinder. If you use Bosch Smart Home, take the Linus set with Bosch integration. And before you order, call your home contents insurer. We explain why below.
Step one: a ruler against the cylinder
Measure how far the cylinder protrudes on the inside. For the Linus L2, Yale requires at least 3 mm. Tedee and Aqara require a cylinder with an emergency function, otherwise the door can no longer be opened from outside with the key once the lock is mounted on the inside.
Step two: retrofit or replace the cylinder?
Here lies a common misconception. A retrofit lock merely turns your key. According to Nuki, the door’s security class stays the same; it only improves with a new, certified cylinder.
Step three: how does the lock get online?
There are three routes to remote access. Either Wi-Fi is built into the lock, or a bridge plugged into an outlet near the door takes over, or a Thread router in the house does. Matter simplifies integration into Apple Home, Google Home, Alexa and other systems. Over Thread, though, only if a suitable border router is present. More on how it all fits together in Buying a smart home hub (in German). Then there’s everyday life. A built-in rechargeable battery usually charges right at the door; replaceable batteries are quick to swap but cost money again and again. Children, guests and anyone who leaves their phone behind get in with a keypad via code or fingerprint; almost everywhere, that’s an accessory. A door sensor reports whether the door is really closed. And the app log shows who opened it and when.
Step four: ask your insurer
The German consumer advice center (Verbraucherzentrale) draws attention to this problem; you won’t read about it in product descriptions. If someone opens an electronic lock by manipulation, no signs of a break-in remain. The home contents insurer can then refuse to pay.
So get written confirmation of whether your policy covers this case. Nuki does state that a retrofit lock doesn’t change the door’s security class and doesn’t need to be reported. But what applies are your policy terms. Not a manufacturer’s help page. Also turn on the log and have the door lock automatically when you leave.
Seven locks for the euro profile cylinder
| Model | Installation | Power | Remote access and Matter | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nuki Smart Lock Ultra | with Universal Cylinder (SKG***) | Rechargeable battery, charges at the door | Wi-Fi built in, Matter over Thread | Anyone who wants to replace the cylinder |
| Nuki Smart Lock Pro (5th gen.) | on existing euro profile cylinder | Rechargeable battery, charges at the door | Wi-Fi built in, Matter over Thread | Retrofitting without a bridge |
| Yale Linus Smart Lock L2 | on euro profile cylinder (min. 3 mm protrusion) | Rechargeable battery, USB-C | Wi-Fi built in, Matter over Wi-Fi | Renters, Yale users |
| Bosch Smart Home + Yale Linus Smart Lock | on existing cylinder | 4 AA batteries | via Yale Connect WiFi Bridge | Bosch Smart Home households |
| tedee PRO | on cylinder, also in a set with cylinder | Rechargeable battery 3,000 mAh | via tedee Bridge, Apple Home directly | Apple Home users |
| tedee GO 2 | on euro profile cylinder with emergency function | 3 × CR123A | Matter over Thread or bridge | Affordable entry point |
| Aqara Smart Lock U200 | on euro profile cylinder with emergency function | Rechargeable battery, alternatively 4 AA | Matter over Thread | Apple households that want a keypad |
Nuki Smart Lock Ultra
Of all seven locks, only the Ultra can actually make the door more secure. The package includes the Nuki Universal Cylinder and three new keys; according to the manufacturer, the cylinder is rated SKG*** and certified to EN 1303 and DIN 18252. One limitation concerns doors with glass through which the lock is visible. There, according to Nuki, the certification only applies with P4A laminated glass. Wi-Fi and Matter over Thread are built in, so no bridge is needed. Price-wise, the Ultra belongs to the top tier.
Nuki Smart Lock Pro (5th gen.)
The Pro mounts on your existing euro profile cylinder, and Wi-Fi is on board. Nuki charges nothing extra for remote access. With Wi-Fi, Nuki states four to six months of battery life, without remote access up to nine. Cheaper is the Nuki Smart Lock Go, a simpler offshoot with AA batteries. But there, remote access costs a one-time extra, and the price advantage shrinks.
Yale Linus Smart Lock L2
Wi-Fi (2.4 and 5 GHz) and Bluetooth are built in. According to Yale, Matter runs directly over Wi-Fi, and no accessories are needed. The battery should last up to six months, Yale says, and charges via a USB-C port. Installation requires no modification to the door, a strong argument for renters.
Bosch Smart Home + Yale Linus Smart Lock
Bosch doesn’t make its own smart lock.
Instead, it offers the Yale Linus with Yale Connect WiFi Bridge, integrated into the Bosch app, where locking can, for example, arm the alarm system; Bosch also mentions time-limited access and auto-lock. Watch out for confusion: this is the older Linus with four AA batteries, not the L2.
tedee PRO
Small and round, and according to the data sheet for indoor use only. The battery has 3,000 mAh and, according to tedee, lasts six to ten months, longer than many competitors. For remote access you need the tedee Bridge, but the lock pairs directly with Apple Home. The PRO is also available in a set with a matching cylinder.
tedee GO 2
The GO 2 slides over the existing euro profile cylinder, which needs an emergency function. According to the manufacturer, three CR123A batteries last six to eight months. A free update added Matter over Thread, which according to tedee makes remote access possible without a bridge. If you already have a Thread network at home, this is the cheapest way to remote access.
Aqara Smart Lock U200
Also Matter over Thread, also a euro profile cylinder with emergency function; an adapter set is included. According to Aqara, the battery lasts up to six months, and in an emergency four AA batteries will also do. Nicely solved for older buildings: the keypad draws power from batteries or from an existing doorbell wire.
Why eufy is missing here
E30, E110, C220: according to the manufacturer’s pages, these eufy models are built for North American deadbolts. We’re not aware of a eufy attachment for the euro profile cylinder common in Germany, which is why the brand doesn’t appear in the table. If you already use eufy cameras or a video doorbell (in German), integrate a different smart lock via Matter or Alexa.
At the end of the road: your door, your lock
Just a retrofit, no bridge in the outlet? Then the Nuki Smart Lock Pro or Yale Linus L2. If the old cylinder is unsuitable or getting on in years anyway, the Nuki Smart Lock Ultra with Universal Cylinder remains the consistent solution; anything else would be a half-measure at this point.
In Bosch households with an alarm system, the Bosch set with Yale Linus belongs on the door. Compact for Apple Home: tedee PRO. If a Thread network is already in place, the tedee GO 2 and Aqara U200 are the affordable routes.
And if you also want a camera at the door, read on at Buying a video doorbell (in German).
If your front door has a motorized lock, a cylinder drive is usually the wrong approach; see the guide Making a motorized lock smart (in German).
A route without replacing the cylinder: the Homematic IP door lock drive (in German) with a measuring aid for the cylinder protrusion.
How often sensors get it wrong and what matters for emergency opening is covered in the guide to the fingerprint door lock (in German).
If a key to a rented apartment gets lost, not every personal liability policy covers it; what to look for is in the guide on personal liability insurance (in German).
If you’re planning door lock and doorbell together, also read the guide to the video intercom; it explains which wiring in the house allows which system.
Frequently asked questions
Will a smart lock fit my door?
Measure how far the cylinder protrudes on the inside; Yale requires at least 3 mm for the Linus L2. Tedee and Aqara require a cylinder with an emergency function, otherwise the door can no longer be opened from outside with the key once the lock is mounted on the inside.
Does a smart lock make the door more secure?
A retrofit lock merely turns your key. According to Nuki, the door's security class stays the same. It only improves with a new, certified cylinder, like the SKG*** Universal Cylinder that comes with the Nuki Smart Lock Ultra.
Will home contents insurance pay with a smart lock?
The German consumer advice center (Verbraucherzentrale) points this out: if someone opens an electronic lock by manipulation, no signs of a break-in remain, and the insurer can refuse to pay. Get written confirmation of whether your policy covers this case. Your policy terms apply, not a manufacturer's help page.
Do I need a bridge for a smart lock?
Not always. Remote access works via Wi-Fi in the lock, a bridge plugged into an outlet near the door, or a Thread router in the house. The Nuki Ultra, Nuki Pro and Yale Linus L2 have Wi-Fi built in. The tedee GO 2 and Aqara U200 manage with Matter over Thread if a Thread network is available.
Which smart lock is suitable for renters?
The Yale Linus L2 is installed without modifying the door, has Wi-Fi and Bluetooth built in, and runs over Matter directly via Wi-Fi. According to Yale, the battery should last up to six months and charges via USB-C. The Nuki Smart Lock Pro also sits on the existing cylinder.
Why is there no eufy smart lock for German doors?
According to the manufacturer's pages, the eufy models E30, E110 and C220 are built for North American deadbolts. We are not aware of an attachment for the profile cylinder common in Germany. With eufy cameras, you can integrate a different smart lock via Matter or Alexa.
Sources
- Nuki: Smart Lock Ultra
- Nuki: Smart Lock Pro (5th gen.)
- Nuki: Smart Lock Go
- Nuki help: Burglary and insurance
- Yale: Linus Smart Lock L2
- Bosch Smart Home: Yale Linus Smart Lock
- tedee: PRO in a set with cylinder and bridge
- tedee: GO 2 and Matter
- Aqara: Smart Lock U200, technical specifications
- Verbraucherzentrale: Burglary – when does home contents insurance pay? (German)
Where to buy
- Nuki Smart Lock UltraView at CoolblueCheck price at Amazon.de
- Nuki Smart Lock Pro (5. Gen.)Check price at Amazon.de
- Yale Linus Smart Lock L2 (schwarz)Check price at Amazon.de
- Bosch Smart Home + Yale Linus Smart LockCheck price at Amazon.de
- tedee PROCheck price at Amazon.de
- tedee GO 2Check price at Amazon.de
- Aqara Smart Lock U200Check price at Amazon.de
