Black Friday Woche ab 19.11.: unsere Wahl je Ratgeber
Independent buying adviceEvery claim with a sourceNo paid verdictsIn 36 countries1,734 guides and reviews in German How we test
handgetestet
This page in 9 more languages

DeutschNederlandsFrançaisItalianoEspañolPolskiУкраїнськаTürkçeالعربية

Video Door Intercoms Compared 2026: 2-Wire or IP?

Buying a video door intercom: 2-wire or IP, indoor station and app, what applies in apartment buildings and what German data protection authorities require.

handgetestet editorial team · Updated November 16, 2026
Contents14 sections

This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.

When you buy a video door intercom, you first decide on the wiring in the wall, and only then on display, camera and app. If the house only has an old doorbell wire, a 2-wire system is almost always the answer, such as Bticino’s Classe 300EOS set. If you are building new or running network cable anyway, you can choose IP technology. And if you rent in an apartment building, you are usually not allowed to replace anything at the front door at all.

That sounds dry. But it saves more trouble than any comparison of screen sizes, because the systems of the major manufacturers cannot be mixed with one another.

Two conductors, one bus: how classic systems work

In the past, an intercom needed separate wires for the bell, voice, door opener and light. Modern bus systems send all of this over two wires: power, voice, control commands and, with video systems, the camera image too. Gira writes about its System 106, in essence, that the wiring of a simple doorbell system can usually be reused, even for video. That is exactly what makes it appealing in older buildings. Nobody has to cut channels into the hallway walls.

The bus, however, is proprietary. Siedle calls its version the In-Home bus, Bticino works with its own 2-wire technology, Gira with its own door communication system. A Gira indoor station does not understand a Siedle door station. If you later only want to replace the unit in the hallway, you therefore stay with the manufacturer of the outdoor station. In the data sheet for the Classe 300EOS, Bticino even explicitly points out that it only belongs in pure 2-wire systems.

With these systems, the door call reaches your smartphone via a gateway that connects the bus to the home network. With Bticino, the Wi-Fi is already built into the indoor station; with Gira and Siedle, it is a separate device.

IP systems: the home network as doorbell wire

An IP door station is essentially a small networked computer with a camera, microphone and call button. It is connected to a network cable and often gets its power through it as well, via Power over Ethernet (PoE). According to its data sheet, the Doorbird D2101V, for example, runs on PoE according to 802.3af or on a 15-volt power supply and speaks SIP, the protocol used by many internet phones. This means a door call can reach your landline phone as well as your smartphone if you wish.

The advantage is openness. Doorbird mentions an open interface and integrations with KNX, Loxone or AVM’s Fritzbox phones. If your house is already networked, this gives you more flexibility than a closed bus. You just need a network cable all the way to the front door. If there is only doorbell wire there, Doorbird offers a 2-wire transmitter that sends the network signal over the old line. That is a stopgap, not a long-term recommendation for a new build.

Gira also offers a variant, the System 106 IP, that draws power and data over a network cable.

What is different in an apartment building

In a single-family home, the entire system belongs to one household. In an apartment building, many apartments share one door station, one line and one power supply. The door station at the entrance is common property. Only whoever owns the system can replace it: the landlord or, in condominiums, the owners‘ association by resolution under § 20 of the German Condominium Act (WEG).

Technically, the effort grows with every household. Bticino notes for the Classe 300EOS that an additional power supply is needed in an apartment building. Siedle sells its Smart Gateway in two sizes: up to 10 IP participants with five user licenses, and the Professional version for up to 50 participants with two licenses. Additional licenses cost extra. In a building with eight households and two smartphones each, the small version fills up quickly.

Tenants have a different lever. Ring Intercom Video is connected to the existing apartment handset and, according to Ring, opens the building’s front door via app, but not the apartment door. The image comes from the camera of the building’s system, so it is only as good as that camera. Ring offers a check of which systems are compatible. Do this test first, because Ring itself says that not every intercom is compatible.

A camera at the front door: what data protection authorities require

A video door intercom films people. That is why the EU General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) applies, even to private individuals. The Bavarian State Office for Data Protection Supervision has listed the conditions in an information sheet (as of July 2026). According to it, a doorbell camera is generally only permissible if its sole purpose is to show who rang the bell. It may only be activated by the bell, may run for no more than two minutes and must then switch itself off. The sidewalk and neighboring property may only be in the picture as far as cannot be avoided. Recording images and having faces recognized are both ruled out, according to the State Office. In addition, a notice sign with the information required by Article 13 GDPR is needed.

This affects features that manufacturers advertise. Bticino mentions a video answering machine, Ring stores recordings for up to 180 days with a paid subscription, and Doorbird offers a visitor history and a motion sensor. After installation, check which of these are switched on.

In a rental building, the rights of the neighbors come into play too. Under § 554 of the German Civil Code (BGB), tenants can demand that the landlord permit structural changes for burglary protection, and condominium owners can demand something similar under § 20 WEG. Whether a video intercom falls under this cannot be said with certainty without examining the individual case. Ask in writing beforehand.

Do it yourself or call an electrician?

A retrofit module such as Ring Intercom is designed for self-installation and runs on a battery. With a real system, things are different. As soon as the power supply or gateway needs space in the distribution board or a new 230-volt line is required, the situation changes. Under § 13 of the German Low Voltage Connection Ordinance (NAV), work on the electrical installation behind the main service fuse may generally only be carried out by the grid operator or a registered installation company. Siedle, for example, offers its partner companies dedicated services for commissioning and maintenance. So factor in the installation from the start.

Five systems and retrofit solutions compared

ModelTechnologyIndoor station / appWho it suits
Bticino Classe 300EOS with Netatmo Set (363915)2-wire, indoor station with Wi-Fi5-inch touchscreen, Home + Security app, Alexa built inSingle-family home with existing doorbell wiring
Gira System 106 with Video AP 7 indoor stationGira door communication, modular metal door station7-inch display; Gira TKS mobil app via TKS IP gatewayOwners who want a durable brand-name system installed by a professional
Siedle Smart Gateway set CVUSG 850-1Siedle In-Home busSiedle app, licenses per userHouses with an existing Siedle system
Doorbird D2101VIP, PoE or 15 V, optional 2-wire transmitterDoorbird app, SIP, open interface, RFIDNew build or networked single-family home
Ring Intercom VideoRetrofit module on the existing apartment handset, batteryRing app, open the front door via appTenants in apartment buildings

Bticino Classe 300EOS with Netatmo

The set consisting of the Classe 300EOS indoor station and the Linea 3000 outdoor station uses the existing two conductors and brings Wi-Fi along. Bticino mentions a 5-inch touchscreen, built-in Alexa and the Home + Security app, which also manages Netatmo cameras. To replace an old doorbell in a single-family home, we would choose this set. Pay attention to the set number when ordering, because there are several combinations with other outdoor stations.

Gira System 106

Gira assembles the door station from modules, from the call button module to the camera, in frames for one to five modules. According to Gira, the Video AP 7 indoor station has a 7-inch display and can switch between up to 20 cameras. The image only reaches your phone with the TKS IP gateway and the TKS mobil app. That gets expensive. In return, the door station grows module by module, for example with a keypad or fingerprint reader.

Siedle with Smart Gateway

If you have a Siedle system in the house, you do not have to rip it out for the app. The Smart Gateway connects the In-Home bus to the network, and the Siedle app turns your smartphone into an additional indoor station. For video calls to your phone, the system must already support video. This only makes sense where Siedle is already installed. On Amazon, the Smart Gateway set CVUSG 850-1 is currently unavailable (as of November 9, 2026); electrical wholesalers can order it.

Doorbird D2101V

The station from Berlin is designed for houses with one unit and one call button. According to the data sheet, it films in 720p with a 180-degree diagonal field of view and has an RFID reader, two relays for door and gate, and infrared night vision. 720p sounds modest in 2026. For tinkerers with home automation, it still remains the more open choice, and that comes at a price.

Ring Intercom Video

Not a replacement for a system, but an add-on. Ring states that installation takes less than 45 minutes and that the device comes with you when you move. Without a subscription, you get notifications but no recording. If the internet connection does not work, the old intercom continues to work normally, according to Ring.

Abus used to offer the PPIC35520, a Wi-Fi door station with a Full HD camera, but now lists it in the archive on its own website. Inexpensive complete sets with a 2-wire bus from brands such as Metzler or Goliath are also available; there is hardly any reliable information about their durability and spare parts.

How we would decide

  • Single-family home, old doorbell, two wires in place: Bticino Classe 300EOS.
  • New build with network cable to the front door and your own home automation: Doorbird D2101V.
  • Owners who want metal instead of plastic and will hire an electrician: Gira System 106.
  • House with a working Siedle system: retrofit the Smart Gateway instead of replacing everything.
  • Rented apartment: Ring Intercom Video, after the compatibility check and with recording switched off.

A battery-powered video doorbell is often the smaller solution; what it can and cannot do is explained in our overview of video doorbells (in German). If the apartment door should also open via app, you need a separate lock. Which models are suitable is covered under smart locks (in German).

The models of one IP brand are sorted out in detail in our guide to DoorBird door stations (in German).

If you want to retrofit without a bus, you will find the checks for doorbell wire and door opener in our guide to retrofitting a Wi-Fi video door intercom (in German).

What belongs in the conduit before plastering in a new build is covered in our guide to flush-mounted video door stations (in German).

Black Friday: a cheap set only helps if it fits the system

Door intercoms are also discounted around Black Friday on November 27, usually as a set of outdoor and indoor station. Because the systems of the major manufacturers cannot be mixed, a deal is only a deal if it fits the wiring in your wall and the existing system. Compare the system name and set number, not the photo. And arrange the appointment with the electrician before the package arrives.

If a retailer in Germany advertises a price reduction, it must state the lowest price of the last 30 days (§ 11 of the German Price Indication Ordinance, PAngV). In the table, you will also find the DoorBird D2101V with a price at our partner ELV (German retailer). Deals from our partner retailers are collected on our Black Friday 2026 (in German) page.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between 2-wire and IP door intercoms?

2-wire systems send power, voice, control commands and video over two conductors, and the wiring of an old doorbell can usually be reused. IP door stations are connected to a network cable and often receive power via PoE. They are more open, for example with SIP and integration with KNX or Loxone, but need a network cable all the way to the front door.

Can door intercoms from different manufacturers be combined?

No, the bus is proprietary. Siedle uses its In-Home bus, Bticino its own 2-wire technology, Gira its own door communication system. A Gira indoor station does not understand a Siedle door station. If you only want to replace the unit in the hallway, stick with the manufacturer of the outdoor station.

As a tenant, may I install a video door intercom?

The door station at the entrance is common property; only the landlord or, in condominiums, the owners' association by resolution can replace it. Tenants can connect a retrofit solution such as Ring Intercom Video to the existing apartment handset, which opens the building's front door via app. Do the compatibility check first, because not every system fits.

What does data protection law allow for a doorbell camera?

According to the Bavarian State Office for Data Protection Supervision, it may only show who rang the bell. It only activates when someone rings, runs for no more than two minutes and then switches off. The sidewalk and neighboring property only as far as unavoidable, no recording, no facial recognition. In addition, a notice sign according to Article 13 GDPR is required.

Can I install a video door intercom myself?

A retrofit module such as Ring Intercom is designed for self-installation and runs on a battery. If the power supply or gateway needs space in the distribution board or a new 230-volt line is required, under § 13 of the German Low Voltage Connection Ordinance (NAV) only a registered installation company may generally do this. Factor in the installation from the start.

How does the door call reach the smartphone?

With 2-wire systems, via a gateway that connects the bus to the home network. With Bticino, the Wi-Fi is already built into the indoor station; with Gira and Siedle, it is a separate device. Siedle sells the Smart Gateway with a limited number of user licenses, so in an apartment building the small version fills up quickly. IP stations such as Doorbird come with the app built in.

Which video door intercom works with an old doorbell wire?

If the house only has an old two-conductor doorbell wire, a 2-wire system is almost always the answer, such as Bticino's Classe 300EOS set. IP systems use the home network and are mainly an option if network cable is being run anyway, for example in a new build. If you rent in an apartment building, you are usually not allowed to replace anything at the front door.

Sources

Where to buy

Shop in:

Sale, delivery, warranty and product safety are the sole responsibility of the respective retailer and manufacturer. All information without guarantee; prices and availability may change.

Links marked as affiliate links earn us a small commission if you buy through them. The price stays the same for you, and our verdict stays independent. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.