Contents10 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
A kayak on the car roof needs three things: a base rack that fits the car, a carrier that fits the boat, and straps that hold. It rarely fails because of the carrier; roof load and overhang are far more likely to be the problem. If you alternate between a kayak and a SUP, the Thule DockGrip serves you well, because its two saddles carry both. If you only paddle occasionally and do not need theft protection, the simple Menabo Tago supports will do.
How much can go on the roof at all?
According to the German automobile club ADAC, the permitted roof load is not stated in the registration certificate but only in the car’s owner’s manual. From that figure, subtract the weight of the base rack and the carrier; only the rest is left for the boat. On top of that comes the load capacity of the roof rack itself. The ADAC gives the example of a car with a 100 kg roof load whose rack can only take 75 kg: in that case, the 75 kg applies.
Do the math honestly. According to Thule, a Hull-a-Port Aero weighs 6.9 kg, and the base rack has its own weight. If the boat weighs 25 kg according to its data sheet, almost 32 kg are already accounted for, not counting the base rack. With a second boat, that almost doubles. A look at the boat’s data sheet spares you nasty surprises here.
May the boat overhang at the front and rear?
At the front, practically not. Section 22 of the German Road Traffic Regulations (StVO) allows no forward overhang beyond the vehicle up to a height of 2.50 m. So the boat may extend over the windshield but not past the bumper. To the rear, 1.50 m is allowed, and on trips of up to 100 km even 3 m. If the end extends more than one meter beyond the rear reflectors, it must be marked, for example with a light red flag of at least 30 × 30 cm. This flag may not hang higher than 1.50 m above the road surface, which on the roof of a station wagon means: hanging down on a cord.
With a 4.50 m kayak on a 4.40 m station wagon, none of this is an issue. With a small car 3.70 m long, things look different, especially if the boat is pushed far forward. The vehicle and load may not exceed a height of 4 m or a width of 2.55 m. And remember your own garage, as the ADAC rightly advises, as well as underpasses and entrances.
Lying flat, on edge or on supports?
There are three designs. J-shaped carriers such as the Hull-a-Port Aero hold the kayak on its side, which saves width for a second boat or a bike carrier. Saddle carriers such as the DockGrip or the K-Guard let the hull rest flat, which suits wide recreational kayaks and SUP boards better. Simple supports such as the Menabo Tago are the lightest solution and cost the least, but offer no protection against theft. For SUP boards, there are also dedicated pads with adjustable width.
Seven carriers compared
| Model | Design | Load capacity, own weight | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Thule DockGrip | 2 rotating saddles, T-slot | 40 kg, 3.1 kg | Kayak or SUP up to 90 cm wide |
| Thule Hull-a-Port Aero | J-profile, folding, lockable | 34 kg, 6.9 kg | one kayak, room for more on the roof |
| Thule K-Guard | Saddle, tilting, lockable | 45 kg, 4.3 kg | heavier kayaks, theft protection |
| Thule SUP Taxi XT | Board pads 70 to 86 cm, lockable | 25 kg, 7.6 kg | SUP boards with a lock |
| Menabo Niagara | J-profile, folding | 50 kg, 4.8 kg according to the retailer | heavy boats, small budget |
| Menabo Tago | 4 supports, 20 mm T-slot | 50 kg according to the retailer, 1 kg | occasional paddlers |
| Atera Connexo | Universal carrier, lying flat or upright | 50 kg according to the retailer, 1.6 kg | Kayak, SUP and bulky items |
Values according to Thule and Menabo, otherwise according to the data sheet of the retailer Rameder (German retailer). The carrier’s load capacity is an upper limit. What counts in the end is your car’s roof load.
Why the Thule DockGrip suits many people
Two saddles that rotate independently and can be adjusted in angle. According to Thule, this lets the DockGrip adapt to different hull shapes and also take a SUP board, as long as it is no wider than 90 cm and no heavier than 40 kg. It mounts in the T-slot of the base rack; square bars require an adapter. The central tie-down straps have buckle protection so the paint stays intact. The DockGrip cannot be locked. If you leave the car with the boat parked outside your vacation rental, factor that in.
Hull-a-Port Aero and K-Guard: when it needs to be locked
The Hull-a-Port Aero holds the kayak on edge and is folded up and down via a handle at the front. That way it does not get in the way when no boat is along. The included locks secure it to the roof rack, but the boat itself remains unsecured. Thule states a load capacity of 34 kg. The K-Guard goes a step further: according to Thule, the kayak can be locked to the carrier with a steel-reinforced strap, and the carrier to the roof rack. It tilts far down for loading and carries 45 kg. For expensive composite boats, this is the more reassuring solution.
Thule SUP Taxi XT: for boards only
The two pads extend telescopically to board widths of 70 to 86 cm. Steel-reinforced straps with a lock secure the board, and it mounts with a tool-free clamping system. According to Thule, the Taxi carries no more than 25 kg. That is easily enough for an inflatable board; a heavy hardboard is worth weighing beforehand. Incidentally, a folded inflatable SUP also fits in the trunk.
Menabo and Atera: the simpler routes
Menabo makes the Niagara from steel; it folds up and, according to the manufacturer, tilts by about 100 degrees, and Menabo states its load capacity as 50 kg. The Tago is simpler still: four rubber-coated steel supports that sit in the rack’s slot with 20 mm T-bolts. Menabo itself lists a higher load capacity in its data sheet than the retailer does; we go with the more cautious figure. Neither model has a lock. The Atera Connexo is a universal carrier that, according to the retailer, can be mounted lying flat or upright, with a torque wrench, two straps and a bag. Pay attention to the version when ordering: it is available for aluminum profile bars with a T-slot and for square bars with an adapter.
What we would buy in your place
- Kayak and SUP in rotation, carrier often stays mounted: Thule DockGrip.
- An occasional kayak, short trips, little money: Menabo Tago, and never leave the boat unattended on the roof.
- Expensive boat, overnight stops on the road: Thule K-Guard.
- Two boats, or a boat plus a bike on the roof: Thule Hull-a-Port Aero.
- SUP boards only: Thule SUP Taxi XT.
Nothing works without a base rack. Which one fits your car is explained in our roof rack guide, and the basics of straps and tensioning force are in our cargo securing guide. If you are still looking for a board, you will find it in our SUP board guide (in German), and for boats that do not need to go on the roof at all, there is our inflatable kayak guide.
Frequently asked questions
How much roof load does a kayak on a car need?
According to the German automobile club ADAC, the permitted roof load is only stated in the car's owner's manual. From that, subtract the weight of the base rack and the carrier; only the rest is left for the boat. According to Thule, a Hull-a-Port Aero weighs 6.9 kg, so with a 25 kg boat almost 32 kg are already accounted for, not counting the base rack.
How far may a kayak overhang the car?
To the front, up to a height of 2.50 m, not beyond the vehicle at all (Section 22 of the German Road Traffic Regulations, StVO); it may extend over the windshield but not past the bumper. To the rear, 1.50 m is allowed, and on trips of up to 100 km even 3 m. The vehicle and load may not be higher than 4 m or wider than 2.55 m.
Which kayak carrier also works for a SUP?
The Thule DockGrip. Its two saddles rotate independently and, according to Thule, adapt to different hull shapes; a SUP board may be up to 90 cm wide and weigh up to 40 kg. For boards only, there is the Thule SUP Taxi XT with a lock for widths of 70 to 86 cm.
J-cradle or saddle for the kayak?
J-shaped carriers such as the Hull-a-Port Aero hold the kayak on its side and save width for a second boat or a bike carrier. Saddle carriers such as the DockGrip or K-Guard let the hull rest flat, which suits wide recreational kayaks and SUP boards better.
How do you secure a kayak on the roof against theft?
With the Hull-a-Port Aero, the locks only secure the carrier to the roof rack; the boat itself remains unsecured. The Thule K-Guard goes further and is intended for expensive boats and overnight stops on the road, and on the SUP Taxi XT, steel-reinforced straps with a lock secure the board.
Sources
- Thule: DockGrip
- Thule: Hull-a-Port Aero
- Thule: K-Guard
- Thule: SUP Taxi XT
- Menabo: Niagara
- Menabo: Tago
- Rameder: Atera Connexo (retailer information)
- German Road Traffic Regulations (StVO) § 22: Load
- ADAC: Roof load
Where to buy
- Thule DockGripView at RamederAvailable in Germany: RamederCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Menabo TagoView at RamederAvailable in Germany: Rameder
- Thule Hull-a-Port AeroView at RamederAvailable in Germany: RamederCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Thule K-GuardView at RamederAvailable in Germany: Rameder
- Thule SUP Taxi XTView at RamederAvailable in Germany: RamederCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Menabo NiagaraView at RamederAvailable in Germany: RamederCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Atera ConnexoView at RamederAvailable in Germany: Rameder
