Contents14 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
When people buy a roof rack, they usually start by looking at brand and bar profile. The right order is the reverse: first identify the roof, then the foot, then the crossbar. For roof rails or fixed points, we recommend the Thule WingBar Evo with the matching foot pack; for bikes on the roof, the Thule ProRide. Whether the whole setup is actually allowed to carry the load, however, is not decided by the rack. Your car decides that.
If a rooftop tent is going on the rack, stricter rules apply, because people sleep in it. Which racks the tent manufacturers approve for this is covered in the rooftop tent guide (in German).
Raised or flush rails: what does my car actually have?
Look at the roof from the side. If a hand, or at least a few fingers, fit between the rail and the sheet metal, it is an open, raised rail. If the rail sits flat without a gap, it is called a closed, integrated or flush rail. Thule makes separate feet for each: the Evo Raised Rail for the raised type and the Evo Flush Rail for the flush type. With an open rail, the foot wraps around the tube. With a closed rail, it clamps onto the rail and needs a vehicle-specific fitting kit to do so.
Without rails, there are two cases. Some manufacturers place fixed points under small covers in the roof, meaning prepared threads or profiles. There, a Fixpoint foot bolts the rack directly in place. If those are missing too, what remains is a clamp foot that hooks into the door frame. That works, but it requires an exactly matching kit, and it is the design where a wrong part number shows up fastest.
The most reliable answer comes from the rack manufacturers‘ vehicle finders. Enter the model, model year and body style there. A wagon and a sedan from the same model series can need completely different parts.
How much can go on the roof? The figure is not in the registration document
A common misconception. The German registration certificate Part I (Zulassungsbescheinigung Teil I) lists the permitted gross vehicle weight and axle loads, but not the roof load. According to the ADAC, the German automobile club, you will only find it in the owner’s manual. The range is wide: the ADAC gives 25 kg for the Ford Puma 1.0 EcoBoost Hybrid ST PowerShift, 75 kg for the Audi A3 sedan and 100 kg for the Audi A6 Avant. Some models have no approved roof load at all.
Here is how to calculate it: the roof load minus the weight of the rack minus the weight of the attachment gives you what you can still load. A worked example with a 75 kg roof load: suppose the crossbars and feet weigh 6 kg together, plus two bike holders at 4.2 kg each. That leaves a little over 60 kg for the bikes. The load rating of the rack itself also applies. If the roof allows 100 kg but the rack only 75 kg, then 75 kg is the limit, as the ADAC calculates. And wet towels in the roof box weigh more than dry ones.
What does the law say, and how fast can I drive?
Section 22 of the German Road Traffic Regulations (StVO) requires that the load, including its securing devices, be stowed so that it does not slip, tip over or fall off even during emergency braking or a sudden evasive maneuver. It must not create avoidable noise either. Flapping tarps and loose strap ends are typical causes. The car and its load together may be no more than 4 m high. Up to a height of 2.50 m, nothing may protrude forward beyond the vehicle.
There is no statutory speed limit for roof loads in Germany. Your speed must, however, be appropriate for the load, and you should take any maximum speed in the rack’s instructions seriously, if only for liability reasons. The ADAC recommends a maximum of 130 km/h with a roof box. For bike carriers, it gives 120 or 130 km/h depending on the publication, unless the instructions specify otherwise. We consider the lower figure the more sensible one.
The differences in fuel consumption are significant. In the ADAC comparison from 2022, consumption rose by 34.2 percent at 130 km/h with two bikes on the roof of a VW Tiguan, but only by 6.3 percent with a carrier on the tow hitch. According to the ADAC, a roof box costs on average about 18 percent more at 130 km/h, or around one liter more per 100 km. If you have a tow hitch and regularly take bikes along, a tow hitch bike carrier is the better choice.
Seven roof racks and bike holders for the roof
| Model | Roof or use | Load rating according to manufacturer | Own weight | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Thule WingBar Evo with Evo Raised Rail | open, raised rails | 100 kg | foot pack 1.91 kg plus crossbars | wagons and SUVs with freestanding rails |
| Thule Evo Flush Rail | closed, flush rails | 75 kg | 1.13 kg (foot pack) | cars with flush rails, kit required |
| Thule Evo Fixpoint | fixed points in the roof | 100 kg | 1.9 kg (foot pack) | cars with mounting points and no rails |
| Mont Blanc Xplore ReadyFit 204 | integrated rails, pre-assembled | 100 kg | not specified | anyone who wants to mount without tools |
| Thule ProRide 598 | bike, frame holder | 20 kg per bike | 4.2 kg | bikes up to 20 kg, including thick frame tubes |
| Thule FreeRide 532 | bike, frame holder | 17 kg per bike | 3.5 kg | lighter bikes up to 29 inches |
| Mont Blanc Roof Sprinter | bike, frame holder | 15 kg per bike | 3.44 kg | road bikes and light touring bikes |
Thule WingBar Evo with Evo Raised Rail
According to Thule, the aluminum wing profile carries up to 100 kg and has a T-slot on top for a roof box, ski carrier or bike carrier. The Raised Rail foot wraps around the open rail, is rubber-coated and is secured with One-Key locks, which are included. According to an Amazon listing, the system is also available as a vehicle-specific complete set, which shortens the parts search. The foot pack itself carries the number 710410 and is not tied to a particular car model. Thule’s vehicle finder shows which crossbar length your roof needs.
Thule Evo Flush Rail
The foot for flush rails fits the WingBar Evo, SquareBar Evo, ProBar Evo and SlideBar. Thule limits it to 75 kg, which is less than the versions for open rails and fixed points. It cannot be mounted without the right kit for your model. Check the kit number before you order.
Thule Evo Fixpoint
For cars with fixed points, a T-profile or their own rack mounts. According to Thule, the foot pack carries 100 kg and comes with a key that indicates the correct torque. According to the manufacturer, no kit is needed; a cover for faster mounting is available as an accessory. We like this solution because nothing is clamped; everything is bolted.
Mont Blanc Xplore ReadyFit 204
Mont Blanc supplies the Xplore racks pre-assembled and attaches them with a tool-free lever clamping system. The crossbars are 112 and 106 cm long, the load rating is 100 kg, and Mont Blanc cites ISO 11154 and a passed City Crash test. The 204 is intended for integrated rails. The vehicle list also includes some models with open rails, so look up your own car there.
Thule ProRide 598
The bike holder takes round tubes from 22 to 80 mm and oval tubes up to 80 x 100 mm, tires up to 3 inches and wheelbases up to 1,235 mm. A torque limiter on the frame holder signals when it is tight enough. For carbon frames, Thule requires a separate protective adapter. It is approved for up to 20 kg per bike, and that is the figure where many e-bikes fall short.
Thule FreeRide 532
The simpler sibling. It carries 17 kg, weighs 3.5 kg and holds round tubes up to 70 mm and oval ones up to 65 x 80 mm. It is sufficient for wheels from 16 to 29 inches. If you ride a trekking bike with a thick down tube, measure it first with a folding ruler.
Mont Blanc Roof Sprinter
At 15 kg per bike, the lowest rating here. In return, according to Mont Blanc, it fits steel and aluminum crossbars spaced 50 to 100 cm apart and locks the bike and holder with two locks. That is usually enough for a road bike. Put a mountain bike on the scale first.
Does the e-bike belong on the roof?
In most cases, no. In the ADAC crash test at 30 km/h, a 22.4 kg e-bike stood on a roof system rated for 20 kg, about ten percent over the limit. The mount tore out of the T-slot, the aluminum profile buckled and the bike fell off the roof. The system had previously survived braking and evasive maneuvers without problems. The ADAC therefore advises knowing your bike’s weight and, for heavy bikes, choosing holders with U-brackets that fully enclose the rack profile. Loading almost always takes two people, all the more so with an SUV.
How we would decide
- Raised rails: Thule WingBar Evo with Evo Raised Rail, most easily as a complete set for your model.
- Flush rails: Thule Evo Flush Rail with the matching kit, factoring in the 75 kg load rating. Mont Blanc Xplore ReadyFit if your car is on the vehicle list and you want to mount it without tools.
- Fixed points in the roof: Thule Evo Fixpoint.
- Bike up to 20 kg: Thule ProRide 598. Light bikes up to 17 or 15 kg: Thule FreeRide or Mont Blanc Roof Sprinter.
- E-bike or more than two bikes: better on the tow hitch.
Two habits for afterward. Check bolts and straps after about 50 km, as the ADAC recommends. And take the rack off when it carries nothing for weeks. Even empty, it gives the airstream surface to push against. If you take skis along in winter, you will find suitable attachments in the ski carrier guide (in German), and for luggage there is our roof box guide (in German).
If you prefer to carry bikes at the rear, our comparison of the Thule EasyFold XT 934 and the Uebler i31 puts two tow hitch carriers through a hands-on test.
Frequently asked questions
How can I tell whether my car has raised or flush roof rails?
Look at the roof from the side. If a hand or at least a few fingers fit between the rail and the sheet metal, it is an open, raised rail. If the rail sits flat without a gap, it is closed or flush. Thule makes separate feet for each: the Evo Raised Rail and the Evo Flush Rail.
Where can I find my car's permitted roof load?
Not in the vehicle registration document. The German registration certificate Part I lists the gross vehicle weight and axle loads, but not the roof load. According to the ADAC (German automobile club), it is only given in the owner's manual. The range runs from 25 kg for the Ford Puma to 100 kg for the Audi A6 Avant, and some models have no approval at all.
How fast can I drive with a roof rack?
There is no statutory speed limit for roof loads in Germany, but your speed must suit the load. The ADAC recommends a maximum of 130 km/h with a roof box and, depending on the publication, 120 or 130 km/h for bike carriers. We consider the lower figure the more sensible one.
Can an e-bike go on a roof rack?
In most cases, no. In an ADAC crash test at 30 km/h, a 22.4 kg e-bike on a system rated for 20 kg tore out of the T-slot and fell off the roof. For e-bikes or more than two bikes, a carrier on the tow hitch is the better choice.
How much more fuel does a car use with bikes on the roof?
Considerably more. In the ADAC comparison from 2022, the fuel consumption of a VW Tiguan with two bikes on the roof rose by 34.2 percent at 130 km/h, but only by 6.3 percent with a tow hitch carrier. Even when empty, a rack gives the airstream surface to push against.
What is the difference between the Thule ProRide and FreeRide?
The ProRide 598 is approved for bikes up to 20 kg and takes round tubes from 22 to 80 mm; a torque limiter signals when it is tight enough. The FreeRide 532 carries 17 kg and holds round tubes up to 70 mm. If your down tube is thick, measure it first.
Sources
- ADAC: Roof load
- ADAC: Bike carriers for tow hitch, roof or rear
- ADAC: Bike carrier comparison (2022)
- ADAC: Driving with a roof box
- ADAC: Transporting bikes safely
- Section 22 StVO (German Road Traffic Regulations): Loads
- Thule WingBar Evo
- Thule Evo Raised Rail
- Thule Evo Flush Rail
- Thule Evo Fixpoint
- Thule ProRide
- Thule FreeRide
- Mont Blanc Xplore ReadyFit 204
- Mont Blanc Roof Sprinter
Where to buy
- Thule WingBar Evo mit Evo Raised Rail (Fußsatz 710410, Traverse nach Fahrzeug)Check price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Thule Evo Flush RailCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Thule Evo FixpointCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Mont Blanc Xplore ReadyFit 204Check price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Thule ProRide 598View at RamederAvailable in Germany: RamederCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Thule FreeRide 532View at RamederAvailable in Germany: RamederCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Mont Blanc Roof SprinterCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
