Contents9 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
What happens to my money if the tour operator goes bankrupt? For a package holiday, the answer is reassuring, as long as you have a Sicherungsschein (insolvency protection certificate). The law requires every tour operator to protect your payment against its insolvency. Separately booked flights and hotels lack this protection. Hence our clear recommendation: if you transfer a lot of money in advance, book a package holiday and do not pay until the certificate has arrived.
What the law protects
This is regulated in Section 651r of the German Civil Code (BGB). If the tour operator becomes insolvent and services are not provided as a result, you get back the travel price you paid. If transport is part of the trip, the agreed return journey is also protected, including accommodation until then. So if you are already at the hotel, you do not have to fly home at your own expense.
Where you live, where the trip starts and where you booked make no difference.
Since November 1, 2021, larger tour operators have protected themselves through an approved Reisesicherungsfonds (travel protection fund). Smaller ones with less than 10 million euros in revenue may also use insurance or a bank guarantee. The protection provider can offer to continue the trip. If you ask for your money instead, it must pay without undue delay. There is a limit only for very small tour operators with less than 3 million euros in revenue, whose insurer or bank may cap liability at one million euros per insolvency case. If that is not enough to cover all claims, the individual claims are reduced proportionally. According to the law, the opening of insolvency proceedings and the rejection of the petition for lack of assets are treated the same as insolvency.
The Sicherungsschein is your proof
The certificate gives you a direct claim against the protection provider. Under Section 651t BGB, the tour operator may only demand a deposit once an effective protection contract is in place and you have been given the name and contact details of the protection provider, clearly highlighted. The Verbraucherzentrale (German consumer advice center) sums it up briefly: no Sicherungsschein, no deposit. If the deposit demanded is more than 20 percent, it recommends seeking legal advice. Take the certificate with you on the trip.
| Booking | If the tour operator becomes insolvent | What to look out for |
|---|---|---|
| Recommended: package holiday with flight and hotel | travel price refunded, return journey and accommodation protected | Sicherungsschein before the deposit |
| Package holiday without a flight | travel price refunded | for example, hotel with rental car |
| Package holiday through an agent | protection through the tour operator, not the agent | standard information form with the protection provider’s contact details |
Where the protection ends
What is covered is the tour operator going bankrupt. If only an airline becomes insolvent, the Sicherungsschein does not apply. It also matters who your contracting party is. An agent only sells other companies‘ services; you then have several contracts with individual providers and no tour operator who is liable for the whole package. Since July 2018, however, the agent must also provide a standard information form with the contact details of the protection provider. The Verbraucherzentrale advises checking the terms and conditions before booking to see who acts as the tour operator.
How big is the fund?
The Reisesicherungsfondsgesetz (German Travel Protection Fund Act) sets out the calculation. At a minimum, the fund must cover the case of the tour operator with the highest revenue and one of medium size failing at the same time. If the two together do not reach a 15 percent market share, further providers are added. It is assumed that the claims to be protected amount to 22 percent of their revenue. The law does not specify a fixed amount in euros.
Tour operators based abroad
If the tour operator is based in another EU or EEA country, it may arrange protection under that country’s law, as long as that law implements the EU Package Travel Directive (Section 651s BGB). In that case, too, there is a protection provider. Just make sure that its name and contact details appear on the standard information form. According to the Verbraucherzentrale, a provider based in Germany cannot escape German law by calling itself an “agent.”
Linked travel arrangements: the protection in between
Between a package holiday and individual bookings there is a third form. If a provider arranges two types of travel services during the same contact, which you select and pay for separately, or deliberately follows up with a second service within 24 hours, Section 651w BGB refers to linked travel arrangements. If the agent accepts your money in the process, it must protect it against its own insolvency. A provider that merely forwards you to another website is not covered by this.
How to check before you pay
- Check the offer to see who is named as the tour operator.
- Request the standard information form and the Sicherungsschein with the name and contact details of the protection provider. According to the Verbraucherzentrale, the certificate should be available online.
- Check the amount of the deposit. For more than 20 percent, the Verbraucherzentrale recommends seeking legal advice.
- Only pay once you have the certificate. According to the Verbraucherzentrale, the provider may not charge fees for paying by card.
- Print out the certificate or save it on your phone and take it with you on holiday.
If the tour operator actually goes bankrupt, contact the protection provider named on the certificate with your Sicherungsschein, booking confirmation and proof of payment. It owes you a refund without undue delay and cannot claim that its contract with the tour operator ended after your booking.
Frequently asked questions
Am I protected if an airline goes bankrupt?
Not if you only booked a flight. According to the Verbraucherzentrale, the Sicherungsschein only applies if the tour operator becomes insolvent.
Do I have to take the trip if the protection provider wants to continue it?
No. The protection provider may offer to continue the trip. If you ask for your money instead, it must pay.
Does the protection also apply to a vacation home?
Only if it is part of a package holiday. For separately booked vacation homes, the Verbraucherzentrale advises paying a deposit of no more than 10 percent by direct debit or credit card and settling the rest on site if possible.
What should I do if I am already at my destination?
If the flight is part of the package holiday, the return journey and accommodation until then are protected. Contact the protection provider and keep all receipts. What applies to defects during the trip is explained in the guide Travel defects and price reduction (in German).
Whether a combination of hotel and additional service counts as a package holiday at all is explained in our guide Booking a package holiday. If you want to back out before departure, the guide Canceling a package holiday will help.
Frequently asked questions
What happens to my money if the tour operator goes bankrupt?
For a package holiday, under Section 651r of the German Civil Code (BGB) you get back the travel price you paid if services are not provided because of the insolvency. If transport is part of the trip, the return journey and accommodation until then are also protected. Where you live or where you booked makes no difference.
Why do I need a Sicherungsschein?
The certificate gives you a direct claim against the protection provider. Under Section 651t BGB, the tour operator may only demand a deposit once an effective protection contract is in place and you have been given the name and contact details of the protection provider. The Verbraucherzentrale (German consumer advice center) puts it briefly: no Sicherungsschein, no deposit.
Does the Sicherungsschein also protect you if an airline goes bankrupt?
No. What is covered is the tour operator going bankrupt. If only an airline becomes insolvent, the Sicherungsschein does not apply. So before booking, check the terms and conditions to see who acts as the tour operator and is liable for the whole package.
What is the difference between a tour operator and an agent?
An agent only sells other companies' services; you then have several contracts with individual providers and no tour operator who is liable for the whole package. Since July 2018, however, the agent must also provide a standard information form with the contact details of the protection provider. Who the tour operator is can be found in the terms and conditions.
How high can the deposit for a package holiday be?
If the deposit demanded is more than 20 percent, the Verbraucherzentrale recommends seeking legal advice. In any case, you only pay once you have the Sicherungsschein. Also take the certificate with you on the trip.
Sources
- Section 651r BGB: Insolvency protection
- Section 651t BGB: Repatriation, advance payments
- Verbraucherzentrale: Online travel agencies, avoiding problems when booking a holiday
- Section 651s BGB: Insolvency protection by tour operators in other EU countries
- Section 651w BGB: Facilitation of linked travel arrangements
- Section 5 Reisesicherungsfondsgesetz: Target capital
Where to buy
- Pauschalreise mit Flug und HotelView at CHECK24Available in Germany: CHECK24
- Pauschalreise ohne FlugView at CHECK24Available in Germany: CHECK24
- Pauschalreise über einen VermittlerView at CHECK24Available in Germany: CHECK24
