Black Friday Woche ab 19.11.: unsere Wahl je Ratgeber
Independent buying adviceEvery claim with a sourceNo paid verdicts1,732 guides and reviews in German How we test
handgetestet

Deutsch

Smart Roller Shutter Switches: Which One Fits Your Smart Home?

Smart roller shutter switches compared: Eve, Shelly, Homematic IP, FIBARO and Curry. Which one works with Apple Home, Matter, Alexa, homee or Homematic?

handgetestet editorial team · Updated November 17, 2026
Homematic IP roller shutter actuator for brand-name switches HmIP-BROLL-2 without rocker on a light backgroundImage: ELV (Pressebild)
Contents11 sections

This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.

A smart roller shutter switch can work flawlessly on the wall and still be the wrong one. Namely when it does not talk to the control system in the house and, in the evening, is the only shutter that stays up. Our line is therefore clear: if you already have a smart home, first check whether a switch fits into your existing hub, and only then look at design and price. If you are starting from scratch, you can choose more freely and stay most open with Matter, for example with the Eve Shutter Switch. The Shelly 2PM Gen3 costs little.

The hub first, then the switch

Roller shutter controls communicate in very different ways. Wi-Fi with its own app, Z-Wave, Homematic IP on 868 MHz, Thread with Matter on top. A hub only integrates a device if it speaks its language. How much that matters was shown in our review of the Curry Smarter Wi-Fi roller shutter switch. In the test household, 16 roller shutters run on FIBARO actuators, controlled by a homee hub. The Curry switch stayed outside. Our verdict: elegant, but an island, four out of five stars.

A few questions help before buying:

  • Which hub controls lighting, heating or other shutters today, and which wireless standards can it integrate?
  • Should the existing push button stay, or will a new switch with its own control panel go on the wall?
  • Is there a neutral wire in the switch box? Every device in this comparison needs one.
  • Is the box deep enough? For the FIBARO Roller Shutter 4, the manual requires at least 60 mm.

Actuator behind the button or an entirely new switch?

A flush-mounted actuator disappears into the box behind the old push button. From the outside, nothing changes. That is how the Shelly 2PM Gen3, the FIBARO Roller Shutter 4 and the Homematic IP HmIP-FROLL work. A complete switch, by contrast, replaces the button and cover, like the Curry Smarter and the Eve Shutter Switch. In between sits the HmIP-BROLL-2. It sits as an insert in the box and, via adapters, carries the rocker of your own switch range, according to ELV (German retailer) for example from Busch-Jaeger, Gira, Jung, Berker or Merten.

Installation is on 230 volts. That is life-threatening. The connection should therefore be made by a qualified electrician or a registered electrical installer, unless you have the necessary expertise yourself. FIBARO and Eve state this explicitly in their documentation.

Six roller shutter controls side by side

ModelDesign and wirelessWorks withPrice class (as of November 2026)For whom
Eve Shutter SwitchComplete switch, Matter over ThreadApple Home, Alexa, Google Home, SmartThings, Home Assistant; Thread border router required100-euro class (Eve’s recommended price)Fresh start, Apple households, mixed families
Shelly 2PM Gen3Actuator behind the button, Wi-Fi and BluetoothShelly app, Alexa, Google, SmartThings; Matter after firmware update20-euro class (retailer information)Small budget, lots of tinkering
Homematic IP Rollladenaktor für Markenschalter HmIP-BROLL-2Insert for your own switch range, Homematic IP 868 MHzHomematic IP app, Alexa, Google; Access Point or CCU3 required70-euro class (ELV)Homematic households with brand-name switches
Homematic IP Rollladenaktor Unterputz HmIP-FROLLActuator behind existing buttons, Homematic IP 868 MHzHomematic IP app, Alexa, Google; Access Point or CCU3 required50-euro class (ELV)Homematic households, button stays
FIBARO Roller Shutter 4Actuator behind the button, Z-Wave (800 series)Z-Wave Plus hubs, such as homeedepending on retailer (current offer via the link)Existing Z-Wave homes
Curry Smarter WLAN-RollladenschalterComplete glass switch, 2.4 GHz Wi-FiSmart Life, Alexa, Google; Siri only via Shortcut; no HomeKit, no MatterPredecessor in the 25 to 30-euro class (manufacturer)Fresh start without a hub

Homematic IP in the house: HmIP-BROLL-2 for your own switch range

If you already control heating or lighting with Homematic IP, you should stick with it. The HmIP-BROLL-2 takes the place of the old shutter button, and the rocker of your existing range goes on top via an adapter. That way the switch visually matches the light switches next to it. According to ELV, it drives tubular motors up to 500 VA and needs a neutral wire and an installation depth of 37 mm. Without a hub, however, nothing works: an Access Point, CCU3 or a partner solution is required. If you are new to the system, add the Access Point 2 from the 60-euro class. Alexa and Google Assistant connect via Homematic IP. Apple Home, on the other hand, does not out of the box; the only way there is a bridge from another vendor, such as the Matter bridge from mediola.

Homematic IP, and the button stays: HmIP-FROLL

If the familiar button is to stay on the wall, the HmIP-FROLL is the less conspicuous route. It disappears into the box, and two standard push buttons connect to its inputs. ELV specifies a neutral wire and 500 VA here as well, and the installation depth is 41 mm. In price, it stays one step below the actuator for brand-name switches. The same applies to the hub as above.

Z-Wave with homee and others: FIBARO Roller Shutter 4

Our own test house is a Z-Wave house, and we described the predecessor in detail in our review of the FIBARO Roller Shutter 3. The Roller Shutter 4 communicates with an 800 series chip, encrypted to S2, measures power consumption and, according to the manual, works with any Z-Wave Plus hub. It sits behind the existing button. The box must be at least 60 mm deep, and the motor needs electronic or mechanical limit switches. With homee, users report that the module is recognized, but the slats of external venetian blinds cannot be tilted. For regular roller shutters, that does not matter. If you have venetian blinds, ask your hub’s vendor beforehand. In Apple Home, the module only shows up if the hub builds a bridge to it.

Starting fresh and staying open: Eve Shutter Switch

If you are starting fresh or your household mixes iPhone and Android, Matter commits you the least. The Eve Shutter Switch is a complete switch with its own control panel. According to Eve, it fits into existing 55 mm frames, but the old rockers cannot be reused. It speaks Matter over Thread and, according to the manufacturer, works with Apple Home, Alexa, Google Home, SmartThings and Home Assistant. That requires a hub with a Thread border router. Because the switch is permanently powered, it also relays data from other Thread devices. Eve itself gives a recommended price in the 100-euro class. That is a lot of money for one roller shutter. In return, you do not have to rip it out if you change systems later.

Little money, lots of leeway: Shelly 2PM Gen3

The small module measures 37 × 42 × 16 mm and fits behind the existing button. It communicates via Wi-Fi and Bluetooth, has its own roller shutter mode according to Shelly and can even adjust slats. It supports Alexa, Google and SmartThings without an additional device. Shelly added roller shutters over Matter with firmware 1.6.1; on the Gen3, Matter is only switched on via an update. In stores, the module sits in the 20-euro class. If you enjoy configuring things, you get the most device for your money here. For the successor Gen4, Shelly lists Matter out of the box, but has not yet described the roller shutter function over it.

Beautiful, but on its own: Curry Smarter WLAN-Rollladenschalter

The glass front with illuminated symbols looks really good on the wall. The 8th-generation switch (SC102) communicates over 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi and runs via Smart Life, Alexa and Google. Siri only reaches it through a Shortcut. HomeKit and Matter are missing, and it cannot be integrated into homee. The 8th generation is not yet listed in the manufacturer’s shop; the predecessors 6.1 and 7 sit there in the 25 to 30-euro class (as of November 8, 2026). If you are starting without a hub and live with Alexa or Google, you get a lot of switch for the money. It does not fit into an existing system.

How we would decide

  • Homematic IP is already running: HmIP-BROLL-2 if the switch range is to stay, otherwise HmIP-FROLL behind the old button.
  • Z-Wave hub such as homee: FIBARO Roller Shutter 4. With venetian blinds, clarify the slat question first.
  • Fresh start or Apple Home as the center: Eve Shutter Switch, provided there is a Thread border router in the house.
  • Tight budget and a taste for setup: Shelly 2PM Gen3.
  • No hub, only Alexa or Google, and looks are what counts: Curry Smarter.

No hub at all yet? Then it is worth looking at the control system itself before the first shutter goes smart. Our guide to the smart home hub helps you choose.

Frequently asked questions

Are there smart roller shutter buttons that match my existing switch range?

Yes, in two ways. The Homematic IP HmIP-BROLL-2 sits as an insert in the wall box and, via adapters, carries the rocker of your own switch range, according to ELV for example from Busch-Jaeger, Gira, Jung, Berker or Merten. Or an actuator disappears behind the existing push button, which is how the Shelly 2PM Gen3, FIBARO Roller Shutter 4 and HmIP-FROLL work; from the outside, nothing changes. The Eve Shutter Switch does fit into existing 55 mm frames, but the old rockers cannot be reused.

What can I control with a smart roller shutter button?

First the shutter itself: on the wall as usual, plus via app and voice command through Alexa or Google, and with the Shelly 2PM Gen3, according to the manufacturer, also the slats. Via a hub, the shutter becomes part of the rest of the smart home with lighting, heating and other shutters. The FIBARO Roller Shutter 4 also measures power consumption, and the Eve Shutter Switch, as a Thread device, relays data from other devices. What of this works is decided by the hub that can integrate the device.

Sources

Where to buy

Shop in:

Sale, delivery, warranty and product safety are the sole responsibility of the respective retailer and manufacturer. All information without guarantee; prices and availability may change.

Links marked as affiliate links earn us a small commission if you buy through them. The price stays the same for you, and our verdict stays independent. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.