Contents9 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
Christmas Eve, the goose is cleaned and ready, and the roaster is too small. Before Christmas, this bad purchase happens particularly often.
For a whole goose, plan on eight to nine liters and a good 40 centimeters in length; Riess calls exactly this size a goose roaster. If you cook poultry once or twice a year and roasts the rest of the time, you need nothing more than a stainless steel roaster like the WMF Extrabräter. Cast iron from Le Creuset or Staub weighs more and costs considerably more, but pays off if you braise all year round.
Measure the bird first, then the pot
Be careful with the centimeter figure in the product name. At Le Creuset and Staub, it usually does not stand for the length you have to fit in the oven. According to the manufacturer, the Staub Cocotte „37 cm“ measures 42.8 centimeters including handles, and its bottom is 28.6 centimeters long. What matters for your oven, then, is the liter figure and the outside dimensions. Not the name. For a duck or a pork roast, six to seven liters are enough; a larger goose needs more like eight to nine liters and a length of around 40 centimeters.
The material decides how much you will be lifting later. Enameled cast iron stores a lot of heat and braises evenly, but empty it easily tips the scale at six to nine kilograms. Stainless steel is half as heavy and usually dishwasher-safe. Enameled steel, as at Riess, is light and inexpensive, but the enamel does not tolerate knocks. And cast aluminum? Light, heats up quickly, but needs a coating and, for induction, an inserted steel base. All are oven-safe, but to different degrees. Le Creuset and Staub state up to 260 degrees Celsius, WMF up to 250 degrees. Riess recommends a maximum operating temperature of 220 degrees. All models below are induction-compatible according to the manufacturer or retailer. Oval bottoms only partially cover a round cooking zone, though, so a large roaster is only of limited use for searing on the stovetop.
That leaves the lid. A heavy cast lid keeps the steam in the pot. Through a glass lid you can see what is happening, but it is not always as oven-safe as the pot. Incidentally, a meat thermometer makes any guessing about cooking time unnecessary; we present suitable models among the grill and meat thermometers (in German).
Six roasters for goose, duck and roasts
| Model | Material and capacity | Oven, cooktop | Who it’s for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Le Creuset Signature oval roaster 31 cm | Enameled cast iron, 6.3 l, around 5.7 kg | up to 260 °C, induction | Duck, rolled roast, braised dishes |
| Le Creuset Signature oval roaster 35 cm | Enameled cast iron, 8.9 l, around 7.4 kg | up to 260 °C, induction | Goose, large roasts, cast iron fans |
| Staub La Cocotte oval 37 cm | Enameled cast iron, black interior, 8 l, around 8.7 kg | up to 260 °C (knob 250 °C), induction | Braising with little liquid, goose |
| WMF Extrabräter with metal lid | Stainless steel 18/10, 8.5 l, 41 × 28.5 cm, around 3.8 kg | up to 250 °C, induction | most households, goose and roasts |
| Fissler oval roaster 38 cm | Stainless steel, glass lid, 8.8 l, around 3.1 kg | Oven, induction | people who want to look in while braising |
| Riess Classic goose roaster 42 cm | Enameled steel, 9 l, around 3.5 kg | recommended up to 220 °C, induction | Goose once a year, small budget |
Le Creuset Signature: two sizes, a difference of 2.6 liters
Le Creuset makes the oval roaster in France in six sizes from 27 to 40 centimeters. According to the manufacturer, the 31 cm version holds 6.3 liters. Enough for duck or a roast; for a goose, it gets tight. With 35 centimeters and 8.9 liters, you are on the safe side. According to Le Creuset, the knob is heat-resistant up to 260 degrees. Price-wise, this is the premium class, and for one goose a year that remains a lot of money.
Staub La Cocotte oval 37 cm
Staub relies on black matte interior enamel and a pattern of drops under the lid that is meant to direct condensation back onto the meat. 8 liters capacity, just under 8.7 kilograms in weight: those are the manufacturer’s figures for the 37 cm cocotte. With a goose and fat inside, you have to be able to lift that out of the oven. In the Zwilling shop, the gray version was recently temporarily sold out; Amazon.de lists it in several colors. The 41 cm version with 12 liters offers even more room.
WMF Extrabräter with metal lid
With 8.5 liters and 41 centimeters in length, the WMF roaster made of Cromargan is easily big enough for a goose. Even so, according to WMF, it weighs only 3.8 kilograms. Turned upside down, the lid serves as a shallow pan. According to WMF, it is also dishwasher-safe. Stainless steel stores less heat than cast iron, which hardly matters for slow braising in a closed oven. Amazon.de also lists a version with a meat thermometer.
Fissler oval roaster 38 cm
Fissler offers an oval stainless steel roaster with 38 centimeters and 8.8 liters, according to the listing with a glass lid, induction-compatible and dishwasher-safe. According to buyer reports, the glass lid has no steam vent. When filled to the top on the stovetop, it can therefore boil over at the rim.
In the oven, that does not matter. On the stovetop, however, you should not fill the pot to the brim.
Riess Classic goose roaster 42 cm
Riess is an enamel works from Austria, and the goose roaster belongs to its Classic line. Enameled steel, 42 centimeters, 9 liters, and according to the retailer the whole thing weighs only around 3.5 kilograms. It costs a fraction of a cast iron roaster. According to the retailer, the lid can also be used as a shallow roasting dish. Its weak point is the enamel, which can chip on impact; a few buyers report damage at the rim on delivery.
Uncoated cast iron is available from the Swedish manufacturer Skeppshult: oval roasters with 6 liters, seasoned with rapeseed oil. It is currently not reliably available new at Amazon.de, so it is missing from the table. If you cook over embers, you are better equipped with a Dutch oven for outdoors (in German).
Which roaster belongs in which kitchen
If you want goose and roasts without anyone having to haul heavy iron, then the WMF Extrabräter: big enough, light, dishwasher-safe. If goose only comes to the table once a year and the budget is tight, the Riess goose roaster is enough. Treated with care, it lasts a long time.
If you braise all year round, go for the Le Creuset Signature 35 cm or the Staub 37 cm; for duck and goulash, the Le Creuset 31 cm is enough. Looking in without lifting the lid works with the Fissler and its glass lid.
Before you order: measure the interior width of your oven. And think of the red cabbage and dumplings. Regular pots are enough for the side dishes; more on that among the cookware sets (in German). Braised dishes can also be cooked under pressure and in less time; the appliances for that are covered under multicookers (in German).
According to retailer information, the round Staub La Cocotte at 28 cm holds 6.7 liters and weighs 6.9 kg; for a whole goose, the oval shape is the better choice, while the round one is enough for braised dishes.
Frequently asked questions
How big does a roaster need to be for a goose?
A larger goose needs more like eight to nine liters and a length of around 40 centimeters; for duck or pork roast, six to seven liters are enough. Be careful with the centimeter figure in the name: according to the manufacturer, the Staub Cocotte "37 cm" measures 42.8 centimeters including handles. Measure the interior width of your oven beforehand.
What is the difference between cast iron and stainless steel in a roaster?
Enameled cast iron stores a lot of heat and braises evenly, but empty it easily weighs six to nine kilograms. Stainless steel is about half as heavy and usually dishwasher-safe. That it stores less heat hardly matters for slow braising in a closed oven.
Up to what temperature is a roaster oven-safe?
That varies by manufacturer. Le Creuset and Staub state up to 260 degrees Celsius, 250 degrees for the Staub knob. WMF states 250 degrees, and Riess recommends a maximum operating temperature of 220 degrees for its enameled goose roaster. A glass lid is not always as oven-safe as the pot.
Is a roaster suitable for induction?
All models presented are induction-compatible according to the manufacturer or retailer. Oval bottoms only partially cover a round cooking zone, though, so a large roaster is only of limited use for searing on the stovetop. Cast aluminum needs an inserted steel base for induction.
Is an inexpensive goose roaster made of enameled steel worth it?
For one goose a year on a tight budget, the Riess Classic goose roaster is enough: 42 centimeters, 9 liters, around 3.5 kilograms according to the retailer. Its weak point is the enamel, which can chip on impact. Treated with care, it lasts a long time.
Sources
- Le Creuset: Oval cast iron roaster with Signature knob
- Zwilling/Staub: La Cocotte 37 cm oval
- Zwilling/Staub: La Cocotte 41 cm oval
- WMF: Extrabräter with metal lid
- Riess Classic goose roaster 42 cm (retailer information)
- Skeppshult oval roaster 6 l (retailer information)
- Staub round cocotte/roaster 28 cm black: product information
Where to buy
- WMF Extrabräter mit MetalldeckelCheck price at Amazon.de
- Riess Classic Gänsebräter 42 cm 0442-012Check price at Amazon.de
- Le Creuset Signature Bräter oval 35 cm (kirschrot)Check price at Amazon.de
- Le Creuset Signature Bräter oval 31 cm (kirschrot)Check price at Amazon.de
- Staub La Cocotte oval 37 cm (graphitgrau)Check price at Amazon.de
- Fissler Bräter oval 38 cm EdelstahlCheck price at Amazon.de
- Staub Runder Schmortopf/Bräter 28 cm SchwarzView at Coolblue
