Contents13 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
A ceramic grill isn’t a better kettle grill; it’s a charcoal oven with a grill grate. We’re not making a main recommendation here, because the independent hands-on review we rely on covers the Big Green Egg in size Large, and that model is missing from the comparison because we couldn’t find it as a separate listing on Amazon.de. So decide in this order: grate size, location, what’s included. The brand comes last.
Do you even need a kamado?
The difference lies in the wall. Thick ceramic stores a lot of heat, and two vents control the embers. The US editorial team Reviewed cooked on a Big Green Egg Large in everyday use for a week and got through six hours of smoking on one load, with charcoal still left in the firebox afterward. The range went from about 65 °C to around 370 °C. With the bottom vent half open, it settled at roughly 205 °C; with a gap of a little over one centimeter, the grill held 135 °C for an entire pork shoulder.
Numbers like these only matter if you use them. If you put sausages on twice a summer, you’re paying for capabilities that are never called on and are better served by a charcoal kettle grill (in German). Long cooking times without fiddling with vents are handled more comfortably by a pellet grill (in German). The kamado suits people who enjoy managing the fire and use it as grill, smoker and oven all at once.
How big does the grate need to be?
This is where most bad purchases happen, because the diameter sounds harmless. But the area grows with the square. Going from 38 to 46 centimeters means 21 percent more diameter and almost half again as much area.
Big Green Egg states 1,140 cm² and eight burgers for the Medium, 1,688 cm² and twelve for the Large, 2,919 cm² and twenty for the XL. That works out to pretty much exactly 140 to 145 cm² per burger. We applied this value as an assumption to the other models, so the counts in the table are calculated figures. Ribs or a whole chicken need space differently, and if the heat deflector is smaller than the grate, everything at the edge gets direct heat. Also calculate by the grate, never by the outer dimensions: some offers carry the body size in the name.
Five ceramic grills at a glance
| Model | Grate | Area | Burgers | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Big Green Egg Small | 33 cm | 856 cm² | 6 | 1–3 people according to the manufacturer |
| Big Green Egg Medium | 38 cm | 1,140 cm² | 8 | 2–5 people according to the manufacturer |
| Monolith Classic Pro Series 2.0 | approx. 44 cm | approx. 1,520 cm² (calculated) | approx. 10 | Families, stand included according to the listing |
| Kamado Joe Classic II | 46 cm | approx. 1,660 cm² (calculated) | approx. 11 | Families, size class of the Large |
| Yakiniku Kamado XL | 22 inches, approx. 56 cm | approx. 2,460 cm² | approx. 17 | Large gatherings |
The Big Green Egg figures come from the manufacturer, the other grate sizes from the Amazon listings. Check the version and what’s included in the respective listing before buying.
Big Green Egg Small
One chicken, six burgers or a pork shoulder; the manufacturer doesn’t list more. For two people, that’s enough. The height of 61 centimeters applies to the egg alone; a table or stand comes on top.
Big Green Egg Medium
For families of four, the manufacturer itself recommends this size; elsewhere it names the Large for four to six. With regular guests, we’d rather go for the bigger grate. Reviewed’s praise for temperature control concerns the Large; the design is the same, but the Medium wasn’t measured there. According to Reviewed, the heat deflector and stand are not included in the base price at Big Green Egg.
Monolith Classic Pro Series 2.0
According to the Amazon listing, this grill comes as a set with a stand, and the grate measures about 44 centimeters. That’s just under nine percent less area than at 46 centimeters. We didn’t have an independent review, so the assessment stays based on size and what’s included.
Kamado Joe Classic II
At 46 centimeters, it’s in the class of the Large. Reviewed only rated its sibling, the Classic III, praising the many accessories included in the price and the ash drawer in the firebox. Criticisms were a heavy lid that wouldn’t stay open, folding tables that sat at an angle, and a bottom vent without a screen. Whether this applies to the Classic II can’t be inferred from that. Look closely at these points in the listing.
Yakiniku Kamado XL
The listing states 22 inches, around 56 centimeters of grate. By calculation, that fits about 17 burgers. That much area only pays off if it’s regularly filled, and the weight rises with it: according to the manufacturer, even a Big Green Egg XL weighs 99 kilograms. For the Yakiniku, we lack reliable figures, as well as an independent assessment.
Where will the thing live?
According to the manufacturer, a Big Green Egg Large weighs 73 kilograms, not yet counting the stand, charcoal and food. On its rolling cart, according to Reviewed, it glides easily and can be locked in place. On a balcony, things get tricky: clarify the load capacity and permission for charcoal with the building management before you order. For that, the manufacturer names its small MiniMax, not the big eggs.
There’s another argument against the shed as a location. The ceramic stays hot for a long time, even after the embers have long gone out, and you shouldn’t move the grill in that state. Plan a fixed spot outdoors.
What else do you need after buying?
It’s not the grill alone that gets expensive. Reviewed already places the basic unit above most gas grills, and then come the stand, side tables and above all the heat deflector. Without it, there’s hardly any indirect heat on a round kamado, because the embers can’t be pushed into two zones. So never compare prices; compare what’s included. An overview of the rest is in our guide to grill accessories (in German); a wireless grill thermometer (in German) saves you long smoking nights at the lid, and if you want to bake, you’ll find the material question covered under pizza stone for the grill (in German).
In operation, though, the kamado is economical. Reviewed used about five to seven kilograms of charcoal in a week of burgers, chicken, ribs and pizza, because closing the vents quickly smothers the embers and leftovers burn again next time. According to Reviewed, almost all manufacturers recommend lump charcoal. If you want to use briquettes, read the warranty terms first. More on this in the guide to charcoal (in German).
Three things ceramic doesn’t forgive
Lighter fluid doesn’t belong inside. It soaks into the unglazed ceramic of the firebox and stays in the taste; use fire starter cubes. An open lid is the second point: unrestricted air can drive the embers so high that the ceramic gets damaged, which is why it stays closed even for burgers.
Be careful when opening. Because the grill seals almost airtight, fresh oxygen can trigger a flashback, so open the lid slowly, stand to the side, wear gloves. And don’t overshoot the temperature, because in thick ceramic it only comes down slowly.
That leaves maintenance. The fire ring and firebox made of unglazed ceramic chip easily when you take them out for cleaning. Many kamados lack an ash drawer; with the Big Green Egg, you scrape the residue out through the bottom vent with a dedicated tool. On the warranty, Reviewed cites a limited lifetime guarantee on ceramic parts for registered first owners in the US. Ask the retailer about the terms in Germany.
How we would decide
- Two people and little space: Big Green Egg Small, if large cuts of meat don’t matter.
- Small family, grilling on normal weekends: Big Green Egg Medium, provided guests rarely come.
- Four to six people: a 44 to 46 centimeter grate, meaning the Monolith Classic Pro Series 2.0 or Kamado Joe Classic II. Decide based on what’s included and the stand.
- Large gatherings on a regular basis: Yakiniku Kamado XL, once location and load capacity are sorted.
- Only occasional grilling: no kamado. The effort is too high for that.
Frequently asked questions
Is a kamado worth it for occasional grilling?
Hardly. If you put sausages on twice a summer, you're paying for capabilities that are never called on and are better served by a charcoal kettle grill. The kamado suits people who enjoy managing the fire and use it as grill, smoker and oven all at once.
What grate size does a ceramic grill need for a family?
For four to six people, a grate of 44 to 46 centimeters makes sense. The area grows with the square: going from 38 to 46 centimeters means almost half again as much area. Calculate by the grate, never by the outer dimensions, because some offers carry the body size in the name.
How heavy is a ceramic grill?
According to the manufacturer, a Big Green Egg Large weighs 73 kilograms and the XL 99 kilograms, not counting the stand, charcoal and food. On a balcony, clarify the load capacity and permission for charcoal with the building management beforehand. Plan a fixed spot outdoors, because the grill shouldn't be moved while hot.
What does a kamado cost on top of the grill itself?
A stand, side tables and above all the heat deflector are often extra. Without a heat deflector, there's hardly any indirect heat on a round kamado. According to Reviewed, the heat deflector and stand are not included in the base price at Big Green Egg. So compare what's included rather than bare prices.
How much charcoal does a ceramic grill use?
Not much. Reviewed used about five to seven kilograms in a week of burgers, chicken, ribs and pizza, because closed vents quickly smother the embers and leftovers burn again next time. Almost all manufacturers recommend lump charcoal; read the warranty terms before using briquettes.
What should you avoid with a kamado?
No lighter fluid, because it soaks into the unglazed ceramic and stays in the taste. Keep the lid closed, otherwise the embers can damage the ceramic. When opening, there's a risk of flashback: open slowly, stand to the side, wear gloves. Don't overshoot the temperature, because coming down only happens slowly.
Sources
- Reviewed: The Best Kamado Grills
- Reviewed: Big Green Egg hands-on review
- Reviewed: Kamado basics
- Big Green Egg: Size comparison
- Big Green Egg: convEGGtor with size chart
Where to buy
- Big Green Egg SmallCheck price at Amazon.de
- Big Green Egg MediumCheck price at Amazon.de
- Monolith Classic Pro Series 2.0 (rot, mit Gestell)Check price at Amazon.de
- Kamado Joe Classic IICheck price at Amazon.de
- Yakiniku Kamado XLCheck price at Amazon.de
