How we test
handgetestet.de examines products the way you would use them: in everyday life, over a longer period and with everything that goes with it – from unpacking and setting up to the first defects. We write down what we have experienced ourselves, not what is on the data sheet.
Alongside reviews, we publish buying guides. How they are made and where their information comes from is explained under How our buying guides are made.
Tried out ourselves, photographed ourselves
Every product in our reviews was in our hands. The photos and videos are taken during the review itself – no press photos, no renderings. What breaks, gets scratched or does not work, we show just as much as what impresses.
Who tests
Our reviews are written by Christian Blank, media producer and freelance journalist. He tests technology and computers, smart home and building services, photo, video and recording studio gear, musical instruments, garden and fitness equipment and remote-controlled models. Ines Blank looks after the topics of home, personal care and garden in the editorial team and talks to manufacturers who offer us products for testing. Who wrote a review is stated below the article; who is responsible for what in the editorial team is set out on the page The editorial team.
Over months, not over a weekend
We use many of the products in our reviews for months or years in our own everyday lives before we reach a verdict. If a product stays with us for longer, we add to the review when something comes up: wear, an update, a case for customer service. How long a product was in use with us is stated in the review.
What we record
Most of our reviews include a table with the technical data, or with the product data for personal care products and household goods. Above it we state where the information comes from – as a rule from the manufacturer, otherwise from the retailer’s listing or from the product itself. This keeps it separate from what we have experienced and measured ourselves. Our impressions are subjective, and that is how we write them. We pass on the manufacturer’s warnings and safety instructions unchanged.
How to recognise a review
A review carries our own photos and a verdict in words, usually with stars or a rating as well as pros and cons. A buying guide carries no stars and states right at the beginning where its information comes from and that we have not tested the products in it ourselves. We only write visit reports about restaurants, hotels and places to visit where we have been ourselves.
What comes after the review
Below many reviews, readers can indicate whether they kept the product or sent it back. We show these votes separately from our verdict – they do not change it, but once enough votes have come together, they add the experience of many people.
How a verdict is reached
- First impression: packaging, scope of delivery, build quality, instructions.
- Assembly and setup: how long it takes, what is missing, where things get stuck – for smart home devices, also integration into common systems.
- In practice: actual use, for as long as it takes for strengths and weaknesses to emerge.
- Service: if something goes wrong, we describe how the manufacturer or retailer responded.
- Verdict: a clear verdict in words, plus – where appropriate – stars from 1 to 5 or a rating, as well as pros and cons.
How our buying guides are made
For us, a review and a buying guide are two different things. In a review, the product was in our hands: used by us, photographed by us, with our own verdict. A buying guide assesses a topic on the basis of research. It says what matters when buying, gives a recommendation with reasons and limitations and backs up its information with sources. We have not tested the products in it ourselves, and the buying guide says so.
Sources
We take technical data from the manufacturers – from product pages, data sheets and instructions – and label it as manufacturer information. In addition, there are authorities and consumer protection bodies (such as the Verbraucherzentralen, the Bundesinstitut für Risikobewertung, the Umweltbundesamt), standards and legal requirements, as well as test results from independent institutes such as Stiftung Warentest or Öko-Test, which we cite with source and date. Other comparison and buying guide websites are not a source for us. All sources used are listed at the end of each buying guide.
Criteria for each product type
For each product type, we define what makes the difference in everyday life. For a television, for example, that is picture technology, brightness and connections; for a wood-burning stove, efficiency, emission values and room size. We compare the models in the table according to these criteria and justify the recommendation.
Checking before publication
We check every key statement against its source. Anything that cannot be backed up is left out. We only state effects and safety issues to the extent that a reputable source supports them.
Prices and availability
Prices come from the retailers‘ product data and carry a date; where none are available, we give a price range with a date. If a recommended model is no longer available, an available alternative moves to the front.
Monthly review
We go through every buying guide again each month. New models are added, discontinued ones are removed. The “Last updated” date shows when we last revised a buying guide.
Affiliate links and independence
Many purchase links lead to partner retailers and are marked. If you buy there, we receive a commission; your price stays the same. Nobody can buy a place in a buying guide, and a commission does not change our assessment.
Independent – and open when money is involved
Manufacturers have no influence on the text or the verdict. If a review is paid for, this is clearly labelled as advertising above the article. If a manufacturer provides us with a test device free of charge, this is noted in the review. That is not advertising: nobody pays us anything for the review, and the verdict remains our own. Some links lead to retailers such as Amazon; if you buy there, we receive a small commission – the price stays the same for you, and the verdict does not depend on it. Such links are marked accordingly.
Why we ask for your support: independent reviews of this quality cost time, equipment and often the product itself. We can only finance them if readers shop via our affiliate links. It costs you nothing extra and makes future reviews possible. Thank you.
Found an error?
If a product changes or we have made a mistake, we correct the review or buying guide and note the date. Write to us at redaktion@handgetestet.de – every comment is read and checked. Would you like to have a product of your own tested? Everything you need to know is under Offer a product for testing.