Contents11 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
A shelf doesn’t sag on day one; it bends slowly under a constant load. So when you buy a bookcase, look at the load capacity per shelf first and at color and shape only after that. For most homes, we consider the modular Tojo hochstapler the most balanced compromise between load capacity, expandability and use as a room divider. Very heavy collections belong on the steel shelving unit from Schulte.
Kilograms per shelf, not per bookcase
A bookcase’s load capacity is stated per shelf. Books are heavy, and the weight sits on a small area. A shelf rated at 30 kg sounds like a lot, but that load is spread over a good 75 cm of width. The same figure on a 100 cm shelf is worth less. So calculate roughly in kilograms per 10 cm of shelf: IKEA Billy comes to just under 4 kg, the bümö office shelving unit to 2.8 kg and the Relaxdays industrial-style bookcase to around 1.7 kg. The Schulte steel shelving unit reaches 8.5 kg.
In its catalog, Schulte Regalwelt explains two terms that help with any bookcase. The shelf load applies to a single shelf with the weight evenly distributed. The bay load is the limit for the entire shelving bay. The sum of all shelf loads must not exceed the bay load. A coffee-table book sitting in the middle of a long shelf is therefore a different matter from an even row of paperbacks.
- Heavy volumes at the bottom, light ones at the top. Tojo states this explicitly in the instructions for its stell shelving.
- Long shelves need supports. For stell, Tojo recommends additional brackets from a length of 2.10 m.
- Choose the right depth: 28 to 32 cm is enough for most books; 40 cm is the depth for binders.
- Adjustable shelves save space, because you can match the shelf height to a paperback or a coffee-table book.
Tip-over protection isn’t optional
Tall bookcases can tip over. The manufacturers are very clear about it: IKEA labels Billy and Kallax with a tip-over warning and requires secure anchoring. In its instructions, Tojo calls for tall shelving to be fastened to the wall and explicitly recommends it for the hochstapler from five modules up. Relaxdays includes wall-mounting hardware with the Industrial bookcase.
According to IKEA, children between one and seven years old are at particular risk. According to the manufacturer, the included screws and anchors are suitable for most solid and hollow walls; in solid wood, you screw in without an anchor. With drywall or old plaster, though, the wall decides, not the bookcase. Which anchor goes where is covered in our guide to wall anchor sets (in German). Also leave some room at the top: IKEA points out that there must be enough space between Billy and the ceiling for the wall fastening.
Six bookcases, compared plainly
| Model | Dimensions (W × D × H) | Load per shelf | Material | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tojo hochstapler | 76 × 32 × 38.3 cm (base module), add-on module 35.2 cm high | max. 25 kg | Coated MDF, white or anthracite | Growing collection, room divider |
| bümö office shelving unit 100 cm | 100 × 40 × 200.4 cm | 28 kg | 19 mm particleboard, melamine-coated | Home office, books and binders |
| Schulte Regalwelt boltless shelving unit 4518-W | 100 × 35 × 200 cm | 85 kg (bay load 425 kg) | Steel, powder-coated, white | Large collections, basement, archive |
| Relaxdays Industrial bookcase, 4 shelves | 60 × 32 × 122 cm | approx. 10 kg | Iron, engineered wood | Light books and decor |
| IKEA Billy | 80 × 28 × 202 cm | 30 kg | Particleboard with foil | Classic wall of books |
| IKEA Kallax | 77 × 39 × 147 cm | 13 kg | Particleboard, paper honeycomb core | Boxes, records, light books |
Tojo hochstapler: the bookcase that grows with you
The hochstapler is made of modules that stack upward and sideways. The milled cutouts in the sides connect the elements, and because the shelf sits slightly below the cutout, nothing can slide sideways. According to the instructions, each shelf holds up to 25 kg. Four modules stacked on top of each other come to just under 144 cm. Tojo recommends fastening tall shelving to the wall, explicitly from five modules up. Inserts with six compartments and modules with doors are also available.
bümö office: office furniture with a talent for books
The 100 cm wide unit from the office series is built for five binder heights. According to bümö, the carcass is made of 19 mm particleboard, and the four shelves are height-adjustable and hold 28 kg each. With a depth of 40 cm, you can stand paperbacks in two rows if you have to. There are also leveling feet for uneven floors. It isn’t cozy. It is sturdy.
Schulte Regalwelt boltless shelving: when things get really heavy
A steel shelving unit in the living room? For a collection of coffee-table books or technical literature, it’s the most honest solution. The white boltless unit 4518-W measures 200 × 100 × 35 cm and has five metal shelves with a shelf load of 85 kg each; the bay load is 425 kg. It slots together without screws, and according to the manufacturer all you need is a screwdriver and a rubber mallet. For stability, the bottom shelf should sit about 10 cm above the floor and the top shelf should close off the frame.
Relaxdays Industrial: nice and light
Metal frame, engineered-wood shelves, adjustable feet. The Industrial bookcase with four shelves is 122 cm tall, and its shelves measure about 60 × 28 cm. Relaxdays rates the load at around 10 kg per shelf, and only 5 kg for the narrow six-shelf version. That’s enough for a row of paperbacks, some plants and a few photos. Encyclopedias belong somewhere else.
IKEA Billy and Kallax: only at the furniture store
Billy is 80 cm wide, 28 cm deep and 202 cm tall; according to IKEA, each shelf holds 30 kg, and the shelves can be repositioned. Kallax is built differently: the panels are filled with a honeycomb of recycled paper, one shelf holds 13 kg and the top 25 kg. That’s enough for records, boxes and paperbacks, but not really for heavy volumes.
USM Haller, hülsta and Tojo stell: through specialist dealers
USM Haller is a modular system of chrome-plated balls, steel tubes and sheet steel that has been around since 1965. It is sold through the configurator, USM’s own shop and specialist dealers. Hülsta is once again selling its living-room ranges such as Madera and Latus in brick-and-mortar stores; there, the dealer provides the technical data. Ask for the permitted load per shelf in writing. Finally, Tojo stell is a floor-standing shelving system made of brackets and shelves up to 198 cm long, which Tojo sells through retailers and its own shop. If you need to fit books and clothes into one room, our wardrobe guide will also help you plan the floor space.
How we would decide
- Growing collection, and the bookcase should also divide the room: Tojo hochstapler, ideally fastened to the wall.
- Home office with a mix of binders and books: bümö office at 100 cm wide.
- Lots of heavy volumes or an archive in the basement: Schulte boltless shelving unit with 85 kg per shelf.
- A few books and some decor in the hallway: Relaxdays Industrial, but only fastened to the wall and with light contents.
A classic mistake is using a cube shelf as a wall of books. 13 kg per shelf is fine for comics and paperbacks, but not for art books. Before you buy, check two numbers: kilograms per shelf and shelf width. And plan for the wall anchor right away.
Frequently asked questions
How much weight does a bookshelf need to hold?
Calculate roughly in kilograms per 10 cm of shelf, because the same load rating is worth less on a wide shelf. IKEA Billy comes to just under 4 kg, the bümö office shelving unit to 2.8 kg and the Relaxdays Industrial to around 1.7 kg. The Schulte steel shelving unit reaches 8.5 kg.
What is the difference between shelf load and bay load?
According to Schulte Regalwelt, the shelf load applies to a single shelf with the weight evenly distributed. The bay load is the limit for the entire shelving bay, and the sum of all shelf loads must not exceed it. A coffee-table book in the middle of a long shelf puts a different strain on it than an even row of paperbacks.
Does a bookcase need to be fastened to the wall?
Tall bookcases can tip over. IKEA labels Billy and Kallax with a tip-over warning, and Tojo explicitly recommends wall mounting for the hochstapler from five modules up. According to IKEA, children between one and seven years old are at particular risk. With drywall or old plaster, the wall determines the anchor.
How deep should a bookcase be?
28 to 32 cm is enough for most books; 40 cm is the depth for binders. With the 40 cm deep bümö office, you can stand paperbacks in two rows if you have to. Adjustable shelves also save space, because the shelf height can match a paperback or a coffee-table book.
Is a Kallax suitable as a bookcase?
Only for light books. The panels are filled with a honeycomb of recycled paper, and according to IKEA one shelf holds 13 kg. That's enough for comics, records and paperbacks, but not for art books. Using a cube shelf as a wall of books is a classic mistake.
Which bookcase can hold a heavy collection?
The Schulte Regalwelt boltless shelving unit 4518-W has five metal shelves rated at 85 kg each, with a bay load of 425 kg. It slots together without screws. For coffee-table books or technical literature, a steel shelving unit is the most honest solution, even in the living room.
Sources
- Tojo: hochstapler, product information
- Tojo: hochstapler assembly instructions with safety information
- Tojo: stell, product information
- Tojo: stell assembly instructions
- bümö: office file shelving unit 100 cm, 5 binder heights
- Schulte Regalwelt: boltless shelving unit 200 × 100 × 35 cm, white
- Schulte Regalwelt: main catalog with an explanation of shelf load and bay load
- Relaxdays: industrial-style bookcase
- IKEA: Billy bookcase
- IKEA: Kallax shelving unit
- IKEA: anti-tip protection for furniture
- USM: USM Haller
- hülsta: living-room ranges
Where to buy
- Tojo hochstapler GrundmodulCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- bümö office Regal 100 cmCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Schulte Regalwelt Steckregal 4518-WCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Relaxdays Bücherregal Industrial, 4 FächerCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
