Contents9 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
A catalytic fragrance lamp and a reed diffuser set solve the same task in two ways. The lamp spreads scent quickly throughout the whole room but needs supervision, because its burner glows and the cap gets hot. The reeds work without a flame and around the clock, but more slowly and more weakly. We have used both for years: lamps from Maison Berger and Ashleigh & Burwood, and reeds from Maison Berger.
How a catalytic fragrance lamp works
A burner head sits on a wick in the neck of the glass bottle. It is lit, burns briefly and is then blown out. After that, it keeps glowing without a flame and evaporates the fragrance liquid that rises up through the wick. According to Maison Berger, the principle goes back to Maurice Berger, a pharmacist’s assistant who developed a catalytic system for hospitals in the late 19th century. Today, the lamp serves as a home fragrance. Some manufacturers advertise odor neutralization or air purification; we have not had such claims independently verified.
Important: a manufacturer’s lamp and refills are matched to each other, which is worth keeping in mind when buying. Bottles of 500 ml and 1 liter are common, often along with a neutral, unscented liquid.
Reed diffusers: no flame
With reed diffusers, also called diffusers or bouquets, you put rattan or fiber reeds into a bottle of fragrance oil. The reeds soak up the oil and release the scent into the air. More reeds mean more scent, and you can adjust that at any time. Flipping them refreshes the scent. For hallways, bathrooms and bedrooms, this is the simpler choice, because nothing burns.
Safety and indoor air
The fragrance liquid of a catalytic lamp is flammable. The lamp belongs on a stable, heat-resistant surface, out of reach of children and pets, away from curtains and never unattended. Extinguish it with the snuffer cap, and refill only when the burner is cold. The manufacturer’s instructions on burning time and fill level apply. Home fragrance is a matter of taste and not really for people with asthma or fragrance sensitivity. It is no substitute for airing the room.
Seven products compared
| Model | Type | Contents according to the listing | Who it suits |
|---|---|---|---|
| Maison Berger Duftlampe Geschenkset Aroma Energy | catalytic fragrance lamp with refill | lamp and fragrance in a set | getting started with the original principle (used by us) |
| Maison Berger Raumduft-Set Essentielle Rund | catalytic fragrance lamp, set | round lamp with fragrance | simple shape |
| Ashleigh & Burwood Duftlampe Little Treasure | catalytic fragrance lamp, small | handmade, gold and silver | mosaic look, smaller rooms (brand used by us) |
| Ashleigh & Burwood Lampenduft Moroccan Spice 1000 ml | refill | 1 l | spicy fragrance for the manufacturer’s lamps (used by us) |
| Maison Berger Raumduft Bouquet | reed diffuser with refill | 100 ml | flameless, bathroom and hallway |
| IPURO Raumduft Black Bamboo 100 ml | reed diffuser | 100 ml | affordable way to start |
| Rituals Duftstäbchen Sweet Orange & Cedar Wood | reed diffuser | large set | if you already know Rituals fragrances |
Maison Berger
The Paris-based maker of the original offers lamps in many shapes, often as a set with a first bottle of fragrance, and a large selection of refills. We have used a Lampe Berger for years; more on that in our review of our fragrance lamps. The Bouquet system with reeds works without a flame.
Ashleigh & Burwood
The London-based manufacturer uses the same principle. What stands out are the lamps with handmade glass mosaic. According to the label, the fragrances are made in England and are available in 250 ml, 500 ml and 1 liter. We use these lamps ourselves as well.
IPURO and Rituals
There are many suppliers of reed diffusers without a lamp. IPURO offers small bottles from 50 ml with rattan reeds at low prices, Rituals larger sets with fragrances from its own body care lines. We have tested neither of them.
How we would choose
- Scent quickly throughout the room, lamp only under supervision: a catalytic fragrance lamp from Maison Berger or Ashleigh & Burwood.
- Continuous and without a flame: reed diffusers, such as the Bouquet from Maison Berger.
- Just trying it out first: a small IPURO bottle.
Electric devices with water and essential oil are covered in the guide to aroma diffusers, classic candles in the guide to scented candles.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a fragrance lamp and reed diffusers?
The catalytic lamp spreads scent quickly and strongly but needs supervision. Reed diffusers work continuously without a flame, but more weakly.
Where does the principle of the Lampe Berger come from?
According to Maison Berger, the pharmacist's assistant Maurice Berger developed a catalytic system for hospitals in the late 19th century.
Can you mix refills from different brands?
Manufacturers match lamp and fragrance to each other. We would stick with the lamp manufacturer's refills.
Does a fragrance lamp purify the air?
Some manufacturers advertise this; we have not had it independently verified. A fragrance lamp is no substitute for airing the room.
Sources
Where to buy
- Maison Berger Duftlampe Geschenkset Aroma EnergyView at OTTOAvailable in Germany: OTTO
- Maison Berger Raumduft-Set Essentielle RundView at OTTOAvailable in Germany: OTTO
- Ashleigh & Burwood Duftlampe Little TreasureCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Ashleigh & Burwood Lampenduft Moroccan Spice 1000 mlCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Maison Berger Raumduft BouquetView at OTTOAvailable in Germany: OTTO
- IPURO Raumduft Black Bamboo 100 mlView at OTTOAvailable in Germany: OTTO
- Rituals Duftstäbchen Sweet Orange & Cedar WoodView at OTTOAvailable in Germany: OTTO
