Contents9 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
A paper star hanging outside on the porch canopy in December? After the first rain, it’s done for. If the illuminated star is to work both indoors and outdoors, you need plastic, and the A4 from Herrnhuter Sterne GmbH is our first choice for that. For a window alone, a paper star such as the Dot 70 from Star Trading is enough.
Five stars at a glance
| Model | Size and material | Use according to the manufacturer | For whom |
|---|---|---|---|
| Herrnhuter Sterne Kunststoffstern A4 | approx. 40 cm, plastic, lighting sold separately | indoors and outdoors | Front door, balcony, window |
| Herrnhuter Sterne Kunststoffstern A7 | approx. 68 cm, plastic, lighting sold separately | indoors and outdoors | House wall, gable, large rooms |
| Herrnhuter Sterne Papierstern I4 | approx. 40 cm, paper, for self-assembly | indoors only | Living room window, fans of handcraft |
| Star Trading Papierstern Dot 70 | 70 × 70 cm, paper, E14 up to 25 W, 3.5 m cable | indoors only (IP20) | Large window star without outdoor use |
| Konstsmide 3D-Kunststoffstern 3er-Set 4466-270 | three stars of 40 cm each on stakes (90, 110, 130 cm), G4 bulbs included | outdoors (IP44, transformer too) | Front yard, house entrance, flower bed |
Indoors, outdoors, with which light?
Paper and plastic look similar in the catalog. In everyday use, almost everything separates them. The manufacturer expressly lists the Herrnhuter paper stars for indoor use, whereas it lists the Kunststoffsterne (plastic stars) A4, A7 and A13 as weatherproof for indoors and outdoors. At Star Trading, the Papierstern (paper star) Dot is intended for indoor use only according to its data sheet, with protection rating IP20.
Outdoors, the protection rating is what counts. The star, cable and power supply should each have one that the manufacturer itself states; IP44 means protection against splashing water from all directions. Konstsmide states it for its stars and transformer. Herrnhuter describes its plastic stars as „weatherproof,“ but no IP rating appears on the manufacturer’s website. If there is no information at all, the star belongs under a roof or indoors.
Some stars come without any electrics. Herrnhuter sells the lighting for the A4 and A7 separately, and while Star Trading supplies the Dot with cable and E14 socket, it includes no bulb. An LED bulb with an E14 base gets less warm than an incandescent bulb. Inside a paper star, that is reassuring.
On size: 40 cm already looks large in a normal living room window, while 68 to 70 cm is better suited to tall windows in older buildings, stairwells or the outside wall of a house. And before the star goes up, it should be clear where the cable to the outlet will run. For the A4 and A7, Herrnhuter offers cables 5 and 10 m long, a separate 5 m cable for indoors and a wall bracket.
A word about the name. „Herrnhuter Stern“ (Moravian star) is often used in retail as a generic term. Herrnhuter Sterne GmbH says it has been making paper stars by hand in Herrnhut for more than 160 years. Stars without an identifiable manufacturer also appear in online stores. If you want exactly this manufacturer, the manufacturer details in the listing are what count.
Herrnhuter Sterne Kunststoffstern A4
Of the five stars, the A4 is the most versatile. Weatherproof, around 40 cm in size and in eight colors from yellow through red to opal: that is how the manufacturer describes it. It is supplied for self-assembly and without lighting. So it needs a matching cable for the A4 and A7. If you want to hang the star outdoors in winter and in the hallway next year, you get both in one piece here. So plan for the star and the cable, not the star alone.
Herrnhuter Sterne Kunststoffstern A7
Same design, but 68 cm in diameter. That is a different league. On a single-family house or in a stairwell, it makes an impact from a distance; in an apartment window, it tends to overwhelm. In stores, it is also offered as a set with lighting. Check in the listing whether cable and bulb are really included. You can go even bigger with the A13, which measures 130 cm according to the manufacturer.
Herrnhuter Sterne Papierstern I4
The paper star from Upper Lusatia (Oberlausitz). According to the manufacturer, it is made by hand, measures about 40 cm and is assembled at home. It belongs exclusively indoors. Light through paper falls more softly than through plastic, and that is exactly what this star is about. Here too, the lighting is not included. If you want to fill more space, you will find the same design as the I6, I7 and I8 at 60, 70 and 80 cm.
Star Trading Papierstern Dot 70
Star Trading supplies its Dot with a 3.5 m cable and an E14 socket for bulbs up to 25 W. The star measures 70 × 70 cm at a depth of only 16 cm. According to the data sheet, it is rated IP20 and suitable for indoor use only. If 70 cm is too much, the manufacturer also lists the Dot at 54 cm, and for very tall windows there is a 100 cm version. Cable included from the factory, flat star, nothing else.
Konstsmide 3D-Kunststoffstern 3er-Set 4466-270
This star doesn’t hang, it stands. In this 3D-Kunststoffstern 3er-Set (set of three 3D plastic stars), Konstsmide mounts three white plastic stars, each 40 cm wide, on stakes 90, 110 and 130 cm high. According to the manufacturer, the stars and transformer are rated IP44, the light is warm white at 2,700 kelvin, and the three G4 bulbs are included and replaceable. A dimmer is part of the set, and the supply cable is 10 m long. That works well for a front yard or house entrance. It does not belong on a facade or in a window.
Which star goes where
- One star that works indoors and outdoors: Herrnhuter Kunststoffstern A4 plus outdoor cable, in eight colors.
- Large star on a house or gable: Herrnhuter A7, ideally as a set with lighting.
- Soft light in the living room window: Herrnhuter Papierstern I4, if handcraft matters to you.
- Large star for indoors only: Star Trading Dot 70 with an E14 LED bulb.
- Stars in the garden, without ladder or hooks: Konstsmide 3er-Set on stakes.
A star alone rarely makes the whole decoration. We present flameless additions for the window in the guide to LED candles. Balconies and gardens are covered in the article on outdoor string lights. Stars controlled by app or timer? More on that under smart Christmas lighting.
A star in the window goes well with a pre-lit tree indoors: our review of the Balsam Hill Nobilistanne shows an artificial fir with built-in LEDs after five winters.
Frequently asked questions
Can a paper star hang outdoors?
No, paper stars belong indoors. Herrnhuter expressly lists its paper stars for indoor use, and according to its data sheet, the Star Trading Dot only has protection rating IP20. Outdoors, you need plastic, such as the Herrnhuter Kunststoffsterne A4, A7 or A13.
What should I look for in an illuminated star for outdoors?
The star, cable and power supply should have a protection rating that the manufacturer itself states. IP44 means protection against splashing water from all directions, and Konstsmide states it for its stars and transformer. If there is no information at all, the star belongs under a roof or indoors.
Is the lighting included with the Herrnhuter star?
Not with the A4 or the Papierstern I4; Herrnhuter sells the lighting separately. The A7 is also available in stores as a set with lighting, and you should check in the listing whether cable and bulb are included. Star Trading supplies the Dot with cable and E14 socket, but no bulb.
Which size fits in a window?
40 cm already looks large in a normal living room window. 68 to 70 cm is better suited to tall windows in older buildings, stairwells or the outside wall of a house. Besides 70 cm, the Star Trading Dot is also available in 54 and 100 cm.
Is every Herrnhuter Stern made by the manufacturer in Herrnhut?
Not necessarily. "Herrnhuter Stern" is often used in retail as a generic term, and stars without an identifiable manufacturer also appear in online stores. If you specifically want Herrnhuter Sterne GmbH, the manufacturer details in the listing are what count.
Which stars are suitable for the front yard?
The Konstsmide 3er-Set 4466-270 stands on stakes 90, 110 and 130 cm high. According to the manufacturer, the stars and transformer are rated IP44, the G4 bulbs with warm white light are included, along with a dimmer and a 10 m supply cable. It does not belong on a facade or in a window.
Sources
- Herrnhuter Sterne: Plastic stars
- Herrnhuter Sterne: Paper stars
- Herrnhuter Sterne shop: Accessories for A4/A7
- Star Trading: Papierstern Dot 231-22
- Star Trading: Paper stars with cable
- Konstsmide: 3D-Kunststoffstern, 3er-Set 4466-270
Where to buy
- Herrnhuter Sterne Kunststoffstern A4 (weiß)Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Herrnhuter Sterne Kabel A4/A7Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Herrnhuter Sterne Kunststoffstern A7 mit BeleuchtungCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Herrnhuter Sterne Papierstern I4Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Star Trading Papierstern Dot 70Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Konstsmide 3D-Kunststoffstern 3er-Set 4466-270Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
