Black Friday Woche ab 19.11.: unsere Wahl je Ratgeber
Independent buying adviceEvery claim with a sourceNo paid verdictsIn 36 countries1,734 guides and reviews in German How we test
handgetestet

Deutsch

Concept2 RowErg or WaterRower? Rowing Machines Compared

Concept2 RowErg or WaterRower: air flywheel with PM5 and logbook, or wood with a water tank for the living room? Differences in noise, space, apps and care.

handgetestet editorial team · Updated November 17, 2026
Concept2 RowErg in the hands-on test by handgetestet.deImage: handgetestet.de
Contents7 sections

This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.

Where does the machine stand when nobody is rowing? That question decides this duel faster than any spec sheet. If you want to measure your performance, compare yourself with others and split the machine into two parts after your workout, go for the Concept2 RowErg. If you want a rowing machine that can stay in the living room and gently splashes instead of whooshing while you train, go for the wooden WaterRower.

Both are the classics in our guide to rowing machines with air, water or magnetic resistance, which also covers Hydrow, Sportstech and Kettler.

Whooshing or splashing

Inside the RowErg, a flywheel with fan blades spins. The harder you pull, the more the air pushes back. A vent on the wheel, the damper, also changes the feel of the stroke. It sounds like a powerful fan. In an older building with wooden floorboards and neighbors below, that is a real issue at six in the morning.

Inside the WaterRower, a paddle turns in a tank of water. Here, too, resistance increases with speed, but what you hear is an even sound of rushing water. One detail from the manual is interesting: according to WaterRower, more or less water in the tank does not change the resistance but the mass in motion, so it is more like the feel of a heavier or lighter boat. The workout only gets harder if you pull faster.

Two concepts, one table

ModelResistanceDimensions and storageMonitor and appsPower
Concept2 RowErgAir, damper on the flywheel244 × 61 cm, 26 kg (standard legs); splits into two parts without tools, wheelsPM5 included, Bluetooth for the free ErgData apptwo D-cell batteries, the flywheel also powers the monitor while rowing
WaterRower oak with S4 monitorWater, paddle in the tankaround 210 × 56 cm; can be stood upright, then needs about the floor space of a chairS4 monitor; Bluetooth only with the add-on ComModulebatteries in the monitor

Concept2 also lists two seat heights: 36 centimeters with standard legs and 51 centimeters with tall legs, which can make getting on and off more comfortable. The manufacturer has tested the RowErg for users up to 227 kilograms; under the European standard EN 20957-7, it is 135 kilograms.

Measuring and comparing

This is where the RowErg is clearly ahead. The PM5 monitor is included, connects to ErgData via Bluetooth and records sessions in an online logbook. In the logbook, you can see how your 2,000-meter time develops from month to month. If you are working toward a number, that is exactly what you need.

The WaterRower shows its figures on the S4 monitor. It only reaches apps with the ComModule Bluetooth module, which comes as an accessory; it does not work with first-version S4 monitors. Check this if you are buying a used machine.

A piece of furniture that needs care

The WaterRower is made of solid wood and looks more like furniture than gym equipment. Stood upright, it takes up roughly the floor space of a chair, according to the manual. In return, the water needs looking after. You fill it with normal tap water and add a purification tablet, which WaterRower recommends replacing about every six months. Pool chlorine or bleach are off-limits; they permanently damage the tank.

The RowErg is taken apart rather than stood up. For the machine stored upright with standard legs, Concept2 gives a footprint of 63.5 × 83.8 centimeters at a height of 137 centimeters. It looks like sports equipment in any corner.

Set up, both need more than two meters of length, and the RowErg even needs a 274 × 122 centimeter area during training.

Price and warranty

Concept2 lists the RowErg in its German shop in the 1,200-euro class (as of November 8, 2026), with a 30-day return policy. For the WaterRower, the price depends heavily on the type of wood and the version; the purchase box shows the current price of the oak version. With the RowErg, read carefully whether a cheap offer really includes the PM5 and not an older monitor.

Take the RowErg if … the WaterRower if …

Take the Concept2 RowErg if you train by the numbers, want to use apps without accessories, put the machine away after your workout and noise is not a problem, for example in the basement or garage. For ambitious athletes, it is our pick.

We have been rowing on the RowErg ourselves since June 2025; you can read about it in Concept2 RowErg review, with five out of five stars. Wood and water, on the other hand, are no promise of quality: a folding oak model from Sportplus went back after less than six months with us, see Sportplus water rowing machine review.

Take the WaterRower if the machine stands in your living space, if wood and the sound of water matter more to you than personal bests, and if you remember the tablet twice a year. For music or classes while rowing on the louder RowErg, good headphones help; models are listed in the overview of noise-canceling headphones.

If you have health complaints, please check with a doctor beforehand whether rowing is suitable for you.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between the Concept2 RowErg and the WaterRower?

The RowErg works with air resistance via a flywheel with a damper, the WaterRower with a paddle in a water tank. The RowErg comes with the PM5 monitor with Bluetooth for the free ErgData app and can be split into two parts. The WaterRower is made of solid wood and can be stood upright.

Is the Concept2 RowErg loud?

It sounds like a powerful fan. In an older building with wooden floorboards and neighbors below, that is an issue early in the morning. The WaterRower produces an even sound of rushing water.

How much space does a rowing machine need?

Set up, both need more than two meters of length; according to Concept2, the RowErg needs a 274 × 122 centimeter area during training. When stored, the RowErg stands split apart on 63.5 × 83.8 centimeters, the WaterRower upright on roughly the floor space of a chair.

Does more water in the WaterRower change the resistance?

According to the WaterRower manual, no. More or less water in the tank changes the mass in motion, so it affects the feel of the stroke more than anything. As with the RowErg, resistance increases with speed.

How do you care for a WaterRower's water tank?

You fill it with normal tap water and add a purification tablet, which WaterRower recommends replacing about every six months.

What user weight is the Concept2 RowErg designed for?

Concept2 has tested it for users up to 227 kilograms; under the European standard EN 20957-7, it is 135 kilograms. With tall legs, the seat sits at 51 instead of 36 centimeters, which makes getting on and off easier.

Sources

Where to buy

Shop in:

Sale, delivery, warranty and product safety are the sole responsibility of the respective retailer and manufacturer. All information without guarantee; prices and availability may change.

Links marked as affiliate links earn us a small commission if you buy through them. The price stays the same for you, and our verdict stays independent. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.