Contents9 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
If you choose a gate opener by motor power, you are starting at the wrong end. What matters is the type of gate, the weight and width of each leaf, and the question of who installs the opener. For the typical double-leaf driveway gate with leaves up to 2.5 meters and up to 220 kilograms, we consider the Hörmann RotaMatic the solid choice, because the manufacturer and the manual state the limits clearly. Heavier leaves and sliding gates need a different caliber.
Before you choose: three numbers and one quick check
Measure the width of each leaf separately and find out the weight, from the gate builder if necessary. Then do the quick check that ends many projects before they begin: does the gate open and close easily by hand? In the RotaMatic installation instructions, Hörmann explicitly states that the opener is not designed for stiff gates. A leaf that drags or sags gets repaired first.
The third number is wind. An opaque gate with a solid infill offers it a large surface. That is why Hörmann only states the high weight limits of its P openers with the caveat that they depend on gate size, mounting dimensions and regional wind loads. If you live on the coast or in open country, it is better to go one class higher.
With swing gates, the mounting dimensions at the post come into play as well, the A and B dimensions. They decide whether an opener fits at all. That is why Sommer offers the twist in an ML version with a longer stroke, intended for very wide or masonry posts.
Six openers for swing and sliding gates
| Model | Gate type | Limits according to manufacturer | For whom |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hörmann RotaMatic | Swing gate, single or double leaf | Leaf 1.0 to 2.5 m, up to 220 kg, height up to 2 m, 20 cycles a day | Classic driveway gate at a single-family home |
| Sommer twist M S3 | Swing gate, single or double leaf | Leaf up to 2.5 m, up to 300 kg, opening angle up to 120° | Somewhat heavier leaves, release from outside wanted |
| Sommer twist 350 | Swing gate | Leaf up to 4 m, up to 700 kg | Wide, massive gates |
| Hörmann LineaMatic | Sliding gate | Gate width 0.8 to 6 m, up to 300 kg (cantilevered 250 kg) | Light sliding gate, Hörmann radio already in the house |
| Sommer STArter S3+ | Sliding gate | Travel up to 8 m, up to 400 kg | Longer sliding gates with safety edges |
| CAME BXV | Sliding gate | depending on version 400 to 1,000 kg, 14 to 20 m | Heavy gates and frequent use |
You have a double-leaf swing gate
Here, looking at the weight of a leaf pays off more than any extra on the spec sheet.
Hörmann RotaMatic
For the standard RotaMatic, Hörmann specifies leaves from 1.0 to 2.5 meters, up to 220 kilograms and 2 meters high, designed for 20 cycles a day. For a home with two cars, that is enough. According to the manufacturer, the opener can be retrofitted with the HET-BLE Bluetooth receiver and then operated with the BlueSecur app; for power outages, the manual mentions an optional emergency battery. If you need to move more weight, choose the RotaMatic P within the same series or, for leaves up to 4 meters, the PL.
Sommer twist M S3
Sommer sets the limit at 2.5 meters, but at 300 kilograms. According to the manufacturer, the opener can be released by hand in any position, and from the outside via a Bowden cable if desired. That sounds like a minor detail. But if this gate is the only way onto your property, you would otherwise be locked out during a power outage.
Sommer twist 350
For leaves up to 4 meters and 700 kilograms. According to Sommer, up to a leaf width of 3.5 meters the opener holds the gate closed without an additional electric lock. For a 1.2-meter garden gate, that is far too much opener.
You have a sliding gate
Sliding gates need space at the side, but no swing area into the driveway. The opener stands on the ground and drives a gear rack on the gate. Pay attention to two weight figures: floor-guided and cantilevered.
Hörmann LineaMatic
Hörmann specifies a gate width of 0.8 to 6 meters, 300 kilograms for floor-guided and 250 kilograms for cantilevered gates. The HET-BLE receiver for the app is also available for this opener. It makes sense if a Hörmann garage door with the same radio technology is already installed on the house.
Sommer STArter S3+
Up to 8 meters of travel and 400 kilograms. For the Plus version, Sommer requires active safety edges at the main and secondary closing edges, and the opener only operates with a photo eye connected. That belongs in the budget. According to the manufacturer, the app also requires the SOMweb module.
CAME BXV
CAME builds the BXV with a 24-volt motor in several sizes, according to its brochure for gates from 400 to 1,000 kilograms and 14 to 20 meters in length. An emergency backup battery is available as an accessory, and for app control there is CAME Connect technology with a gateway. For a light 4-meter gate, this is oversized.
Install it yourself or hire a professional?
Here, the manuals are clearer than any advertising. Hörmann requires installation, maintenance and repair to be carried out by competent persons and only allows the electrical connection to be made by a qualified electrician. An all-pole mains disconnect device is required. After installation, the competent person declares conformity according to EN 13241-1. Schellenberg, too, writes in the manual for the TWIN 300 that electrical connections may only be made by an authorized specialist. Incidentally, Schellenberg no longer lists the TWIN 300 in its current range, which is why it is missing from our table.
What is left for DIYers? The mechanical preparation: getting the gate to move freely, checking the posts, laying conduit for the cable. The 230-volt line to the control box and the acceptance check belong in professional hands. Our position: a kit from the internet is fine if an electrician and a competent installer connect and adjust it.
Photo eye, force limitation and EN 12453
DIN EN 12453 (the European standard as adopted by the German Institute for Standardization) governs the safety in use of power-operated gates, including in residential settings. In the RotaMatic manual, Hörmann warns of the risk of crushing at the main and secondary closing edges. Within the scope of the standard, automatic closing may only be activated if at least one photo eye is added to the built-in force limitation. Schellenberg warns that a higher force setting than the factory setting can cause very serious injuries; afterwards, a competent person must check and document the force limits.
Our advice: always buy a photo eye along with it. According to Hörmann, push buttons belong at least 1.5 meters high and within sight of the gate. Children do not play at the gate.
App, smart home and solar
Almost every manufacturer offers an app, but usually via an add-on module. According to its own website, Hörmann integrates driveway gate openers into the mediola system via Homematic IP, while Sommer refers to SOMweb. If you already have a system, check beforehand whether it talks to the opener; our guide to smart home hubs can help. If you also want to control the garage door, you will find tips in our guide to smart garage doors (in German). And if you want to see who is at the gate, combine the opener with a video doorbell.
Without a power connection at the gate, the solar version remains. Hörmann offers the RotaMatic as a battery-solar opener, but for leaves up to 120 kilograms and five cycles a day. For a gate that runs several times a day, that is not enough. If you have to dig anyway, it is better to lay a cable.
How we would decide
- Double-leaf swing gate up to 2.5 m and 220 kg per leaf: Hörmann RotaMatic.
- Same width, but heavier leaves or a need for release from the outside: Sommer twist M S3.
- Leaves over 2.5 m: Sommer twist 350.
- Light sliding gate up to 6 m: Hörmann LineaMatic; longer ones up to 8 m with safety edges: Sommer STArter S3+.
- Heavy sliding gate over 400 kg: CAME BXV in the right size.
- No power at the gate and infrequent use: RotaMatic battery-solar; otherwise, have a cable laid.
Frequently asked questions
What do I need to check before buying a gate opener?
Measure the width of each leaf separately and find out the weight, from the gate builder if necessary. Then check whether the gate opens and closes easily by hand, because according to Hörmann the RotaMatic is not designed for stiff gates. With swing gates, the mounting dimensions at the post also determine whether an opener fits.
Which opener suits heavy leaves?
At the same width of 2.5 meters, the Sommer twist M S3 handles up to 300 kilograms and can be released by hand in any position, from the outside as well if desired. For leaves up to 4 meters and 700 kilograms, Sommer names the twist 350. With a solid infill and a lot of wind, it is better to go one class higher.
Which opener is suitable for a sliding gate?
For light sliding gates up to 6 meters, Hörmann names the LineaMatic with 300 kilograms floor-guided and 250 kilograms cantilevered. The Sommer STArter S3+ manages up to 8 meters of travel and 400 kilograms, but requires safety edges and a photo eye. For heavy gates, CAME builds the BXV, according to its brochure for 400 to 1,000 kilograms.
Can I install a gate opener myself?
The mechanical preparation, yes: getting the gate to move freely, checking the posts, laying conduit. Hörmann, however, requires installation and maintenance to be carried out by competent persons and the electrical connection by a qualified electrician; afterwards, conformity is declared according to EN 13241-1. Schellenberg also states that electrical connections may only be made by an authorized specialist.
Does a driveway gate need a photo eye?
For automatic closing, yes. According to Hörmann, within the scope of DIN EN 12453 it may only be activated if at least one photo eye is added to the force limitation. There is a risk of crushing at the main and secondary closing edges. According to Hörmann, push buttons belong at least 1.5 meters high and within sight of the gate.
Is a solar-powered gate opener worth it?
Only for infrequent use. Hörmann offers the RotaMatic as a battery-solar opener, but for leaves up to 120 kilograms and five cycles a day. For a gate that runs several times a day, that is not enough. If you have to dig anyway, it is better to lay a cable.
Sources
- Hörmann: Driveway gate openers
- Hörmann: RotaMatic manual (PDF)
- Hörmann: Smart home
- Sommer: twist M / ML
- Sommer: twist 350
- Sommer: STArter S3 / S3+
- CAME: BXV
- CAME: BXV brochure (PDF)
- Schellenberg: TWIN 300 installation instructions (PDF)
- Baunetz Wissen: DIN EN 12453
Where to buy
- Hörmann RotaMaticCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Sommer twist M S3Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Sommer twist 350Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Hörmann LineaMatic BiSecurCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Sommer STArter S3+Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- CAME BXV SchiebetorantriebCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
