Contents13 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
An electric belt winder rarely fails because of the motor. It fails because of the weight of the shutter curtain, the strap width or the outlet that is three meters too far away. We are not crowning a winner here: we know of no independent comparison of these devices, and all values come from the manufacturers. The choice follows from the shutter’s weight and the mounting type anyway. For up to 6 square meters of plastic, the 45 kg class is enough; heavy curtains need 60 kg. The eW320 battery winder from WIR elektronik solves the outlet problem but only carries 5.5 kg, so it only suits small windows.
Why 45 kilograms of pulling force does not mean a 45-kilo shutter
The big number on the box is misleading. Rademacher credits its flush-mount winders with a maximum pulling force of 45 kg but only allows around 6 square meters at 4.5 kg per square meter. That is 27 kg of shutter curtain. Schellenberg looks similar: 45 kg initial pulling load, 6 square meters of plastic, so also 27 kg. The gap presumably contains the reserve for friction and starting up; the manufacturers do not explain it. For your calculation, therefore, only the area in the manual’s table counts.
And that area depends on the material. WIR elektronik assumes 3.5 kg per square meter for plastic, Schellenberg 4.5 kg, and Rademacher also uses this value in its installation sheet. Aluminum is 5 kg at WIR and 10 kg at Schellenberg; wood is 10 kg at both. You can hardly weigh the curtain once it is installed. So it is better to calculate with the higher value.
Three everyday calculation examples
All dimensions are assumed; the weights follow from the manufacturers‘ values. At home, measure the curtain itself and not just the window opening, because part of it always hangs in the box.
- Child’s room window, 1.00 × 1.30 m, plastic: 1.3 square meters. At 3.5 kg per square meter, that weighs 4.6 kg; at 4.5 kg, already 5.9 kg. So the eW320, with its 5.5 kg pulling capacity, only fits if the curtain really is light.
- Balcony door, 0.90 × 2.20 m, plastic: just under 2 square meters, around 9 kg. Too much for the battery winder, no problem for any 230-volt winder in this comparison.
- Patio door, 2.40 × 2.20 m: 5.3 square meters. In plastic, the RolloDrive 65 is still enough; in aluminum it is not, because there it tops out at 3 square meters. That leaves the RolloTron Comfort Plus with around 6 square meters at 10 kg per square meter.
If your curtain exceeds that or is already hard to operate by hand, a stronger winder will not help. Then the drive belongs in the shaft, as our guide to the roller shutter motor with Nm and SW60 shaft (in German) shows. Schellenberg explicitly requires a system in perfect condition and advises also checking the aged belt pulley in the box after a long time.
Flush-mount, surface-mount or battery?
The flush-mount winder replaces the old recessed winder in the wall box. It looks tidy but depends on the box: Rademacher specifies a width from 36 mm for the RolloTron Comfort. For the RolloDrive 65, the dimensional drawing is in the manual.
The surface-mount winder sits next to the window or in the window reveal. Schellenberg writes that the drill holes of the old winder can often be reused for it. If the wall box is too small, this is the simpler route, just visible. Both designs depend on a power plug, and that is exactly what many people think of too late. In its manual, Schellenberg requires a freely accessible outlet at the place of use. The cable needs a clean path there, so a cable duct often belongs on the list too.
That leaves the battery. The eW320 stores 14.8 watt-hours. WIR elektronik quotes around eight weeks of operation on a 1.15 × 1.20 m plastic shutter with 120 runs, which is about two runs a day. Even so, it is not entirely outlet-free: for charging, it needs its power supply with a 1.8 m cable. If you let it run flat, it switches off to protect itself and only wakes up again on the power supply.
What else goes wrong before ordering
First, the strap width. Schellenberg divides straps into Mini at 14 mm and Maxi at 23 mm; the RolloDrive 65 only takes 23 mm. If the strap does not fit, it has to be replaced. Second, the strap length. The eW320 winds up 6.3 m of 1 mm strap, the RolloDrive 65 up to 8 m, but only 4.5 m with a 1.7 mm strap.
Third, the mounting height, which hardly anyone checks. According to the manual, the RolloDrive 65 must sit at least 850 mm above the floor. Fourth, the installation itself: the same manual names a qualified electrician for connection and installation, even though the device plugs into an outlet, and warns about the tensioned drum of the old winder. So wear gloves, and have a second person there when releasing it.
One more thing about automation. The travel area must be visible during operation, Schellenberg writes. On a patio door with children playing nearby, we would therefore think twice about the timer function. The manufacturer rules out mechanical locks of any kind for automatic operation. This also affects burglary protection, because the German police recommend securing roller shutters against being pushed up. How these fit together is best worked out together with your window security (in German). For simulating presence, on the other hand, the police explicitly name shutter control as a useful addition.
Six belt winders, six places to use them
| Model | Type | Pulling force according to manufacturer | Permissible area | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Schellenberg RolloDrive 65 Standard with sun sensor | Flush-mount, mains | 45 kg | 6 m² plastic, 3 m² aluminum or wood | Windows and balcony doors |
| Schellenberg RolloDrive 65 Premium | Flush-mount, mains, radio | 45 kg | 6 m² plastic, 3 m² aluminum or wood | Several shutters, smart home |
| RolloTron Comfort Plus 1705-UW | Flush-mount, mains | 60 kg | approx. 10 m² at 4.5 kg/m², approx. 6 m² at 10 kg/m² | Large and heavy curtains |
| Schellenberg RolloDrive 55 | Surface-mount, mains | 30 kg | 5 m² plastic, 2.5 m² aluminum or wood | Wall box too small |
| RolloTron premium surface-mount | Surface-mount, mains | 30 kg | approx. 5 m² at 4.5 kg/m², approx. 2.5 m² at 10 kg/m² | Surface-mount with swivel housing |
| WIR elektronik eWickler eW320 | Surface-mount, battery | 5.5 kg | 1.6 m² at 3.5 kg/m², 0.55 m² at 10 kg/m² | Small window without an outlet |
Schellenberg RolloDrive 65 Standard with sun sensor
Schellenberg describes it as TÜV-tested and lists blockage and obstacle detection. According to the Amazon listing, the 02266 sun sensor is included in this set. After a power failure, the switching times are retained but shift by the duration of the outage and have to be reset. The drawback is in the technical data: only two switching times and no radio. If you want different schedules on weekdays and weekends, this is the wrong choice.
Schellenberg RolloDrive 65 Premium
Mechanically the same, plus radio at 868.4 MHz. The manufacturer states a maximum range of 20 m inside the building, and the manual describes pairing with the company’s own smart home system. A radio control unit is not included. The extra cost only makes sense if several shutters really should move together; the system question is covered in our guide to smart roller shutter control (in German).
RolloTron Comfort Plus 1705-UW
According to the installation sheet, Rademacher’s Plus series manages 60 kg and winds up to 15 m of strap, almost twice as much as the 45 kg version. The Comfort series also offers an illuminated display, random and astro programs. The installation dimensions differ from the 45 kg variant.
Schellenberg RolloDrive 55
According to the manufacturer, this surface-mount winder works with Mini and Maxi straps, which makes it interesting for older shutters with a narrow strap. With 5 square meters of plastic, there is enough for the balcony door. It measures 245 mm high and 101 mm wide. That is clearly visible.
RolloTron premium surface-mount
At 30 kg, Rademacher’s surface-mount class is on par with the RolloDrive 55. Its winding capacity, however, ends at 5 m with a 1 mm strap and at 4 m with 1.3 mm. That is likely not enough for tall doors, but it is for windows.
WIR elektronik eWickler eW320
A specialist, not an all-rounder. A display, astro function with lockout time, weekday and weekend programs and a button lock are on board, and you do not have to run a cable. In return, it only carries 5.5 kg, so a wooden shutter only up to 0.55 square meters. The technical data does not mention a radio connection for a smart home in a rented apartment (in German). On dormer windows, guest bathrooms and small kitchen windows, it makes sense. On the balcony door, it does not.
How we would decide
- Outlet within reach, plastic curtain up to 6 square meters: the 45 kg class, such as the RolloDrive 65 Standard.
- Several shutters that should move together: RolloDrive 65 Premium, provided you budget for radio accessories.
- Aluminum or wood over 3 square meters: RolloTron Comfort Plus 1705-UW.
- Wall box too narrow or a narrow strap: RolloDrive 55.
- Small window, no outlet, curtain definitely under 5.5 kg: eW320. Do the math first.
If you want to control shutters smartly without a belt winder, via a switch in the wall, you will find installation and limitations in our review of the Curry Wi-Fi roller shutter switch.
Frequently asked questions
How much pulling force does an electric belt winder need?
The number on the box is misleading. At Rademacher and Schellenberg, 45 kg of pulling force only allows around 6 square meters of plastic, i.e. about 27 kg of shutter curtain. What counts is the permissible area in the manual. Since the curtain can hardly be weighed, calculate with the higher weight per square meter.
What is the difference between flush-mount and surface-mount belt winders?
The flush-mount winder replaces the old recessed winder in the wall box and looks tidy, but needs enough space in the box. The surface-mount winder sits next to the window and, according to Schellenberg, often uses the old drill holes. Both need a freely accessible outlet at the place of use.
How long does a battery belt winder last?
WIR elektronik quotes around eight weeks for the eW320 on a 1.15 × 1.20 m plastic shutter with 120 runs. For charging, it needs its power supply with a 1.8 m cable. If the battery runs flat, it switches off to protect itself and only wakes up again on the power supply.
Which strap width fits an electric belt winder?
Schellenberg distinguishes between Mini at 14 mm and Maxi at 23 mm; the RolloDrive 65 only takes 23 mm. If the strap does not fit, it has to be replaced. Also check the strap length: the RolloDrive 65 winds up to 8 m with a 1 mm strap, but only 4.5 m with a 1.7 mm strap.
When is a belt winder no longer enough?
If the curtain exceeds the permissible area or is already hard to operate by hand, a stronger winder will not help. Then the drive belongs in the shaft as a tubular motor. Schellenberg requires a system in perfect condition and advises also checking the aged belt pulley in the box.
What should you watch for when installing a belt winder?
According to the manual, the RolloDrive 65 must sit at least 850 mm above the floor, and it names connection and installation as work for a qualified electrician. Be careful with the tensioned drum of the old winder: wear gloves and get a second person to help when releasing it.
Sources
- Schellenberg: RolloDrive 65 Standard manual
- Schellenberg: RolloDrive 65 Premium manual
- Schellenberg: RolloDrive 55
- Schellenberg: electric belt winders
- Rademacher: RolloTron installation dimensions
- Rademacher: RolloTron Comfort
- WIR elektronik: eWickler eW320 manual
- ELV (German retailer): eWickler eW320, retailer information
- German police: living safely
Where to buy
- Schellenberg RolloDrive 65 Standard mit SonnensensorCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Schellenberg RolloDrive 65 PremiumCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- RolloTron Comfort Plus 1705-UWCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Schellenberg RolloDrive 55Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- RolloTron premium AufputzCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- WIR elektronik eWickler eW320View at ELVAvailable in Germany: ELV

