Contents12 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
30 colors, three of them used. That’s surprisingly often how a big eyeshadow palette ends up. So look first at the ratio of matte to shimmer shades and only then at the number of colors. Usually, a palette with warm or rosy neutrals and at least twice as many matte shades as shimmers is the right fit, for example the Modern Renaissance from Anastasia Beverly Hills. On a small budget, Catrice offers solid starter palettes.
How much shimmer does a palette need?
An eye look almost always consists of a light base, a transition shade in the crease and a darker color for depth. These are usually all matte shades. Shimmer, metallic or glitter mostly goes only on the center of the lid or in the inner corner of the eye. A palette with four matte and ten shimmer shades looks gorgeous in the store. In everyday life, it’s hard to use up.
Which color family suits me?
There are warm shades such as copper, terracotta and gold, cool ones such as taupe, gray and mauve, and then rosy nudes. If you’ve mostly worn brown so far, you rarely go wrong with a warm neutral palette.
Count the finishes. Many manufacturers list the breakdown online on the product page, and before you buy, that’s the most reliable information. Next comes pan size, not the number of colors: four large pans last longer than 18 small ones with barely enough room for a brush. And for a handbag or travel, a flat palette with a mirror is more practical than a heavy block.
On pigmentation, all you have before buying is the manufacturer’s claim. „Highly pigmented“ is printed almost everywhere, including on cheap palettes. Reviews from customers who specifically write about color payoff, crumbling and blending are more telling.
What’s in eyeshadow?
As far as we know, there is no current Öko-Test of eyeshadow palettes. The German consumer magazine’s kohl eyeliner test from February 2025 is revealing, because kohl is also worn on the eye. Öko-Test found only traces of arsenic, lead and mercury, but in almost half of the 19 pencils more nickel than its own limit of 5 mg/kg. According to Öko-Test, nickel is the most common trigger of contact allergies. Talc was downgraded as a precaution. If you’re allergic to nickel, it’s best to have a doctor check eye makeup with you beforehand. A second issue is mica, the mineral behind almost every shimmer. In 2023, Öko-Test reported on child labor in illegal mines in India and Madagascar. The ingredient list doesn’t reveal where it comes from. Synthetic mica (Synthetic Fluorphlogopite) is an alternative some brands use. Purely matte palettes often get by with less mica. The INCI list will tell you.
Five palettes from budget to luxury
| Model | Shades and finish according to the manufacturer | Color family | Price range | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Anastasia Beverly Hills Modern Renaissance | 14 shades, 11 matte, 2 metallic, 1 satin | Warm, beige to raspberry and red-brown | Mid-range to upscale | Day and evening from one palette |
| Urban Decay Naked3 Mini | 6 shades, 2 matte, 2 shimmer, 2 with a light sheen | Rosy nudes, mauve | Mid-range | Those who prefer rosé to brown |
| Natasha Denona Glam | 15 shades, matte, metallic, Chroma Crystal | Cool to neutral | High | A gift with ambition |
| Charlotte Tilbury Luxury Palette | 4 shades, 2 matte, 2 satin shimmer, 5.2 g | Depends on version, e.g. Pillow Talk rosy | High for four colors | Travel, gifts, beginners |
| Catrice The Dusty Matte | 8 matte shades, 9 g | Muted nude and rosé shades | Entry level | Small budget, matte-only looks |
Anastasia Beverly Hills Modern Renaissance
Eleven matte shades, two metallic and one satin, according to the manufacturer, plus a large mirror and a dual-ended brush. The color range runs from light beige through terracotta to raspberry and deep red-brown. That lets you create a subtle office look and a smoky evening look from the same palette. With a very cool skin undertone, though, the red shades can be too much.
Urban Decay Naked3 Mini
The Naked3 Mini is the small version of the rosy palette from the well-known line. Six shades, from light ivory through peach champagne and muted rosé to a dark taupe-brown with a hint of violet, according to the manufacturer. Two of them are matte, two shimmer and two have a light sheen. If you wear matte almost exclusively, two matte shades won’t get you far. The full-size Naked3 with twelve shades was recently unavailable at Amazon.de.
Natasha Denona Glam
Fifteen cool and neutral shades in three textures, in magnetic pans that, according to the manufacturer, can be rearranged. The brand also suggests arrangements for light, medium and deep skin tones. Natasha Denona is priced well above the other brands here. As a gift for someone who is very into makeup, that’s understandable; as a first palette, hardly.
Charlotte Tilbury Luxury Palette
Four colors, two matte and two with a satin shimmer, 5.2 g net weight. According to the manufacturer, the pans carry color codes so it’s clear which shade goes where. The best-known version is Pillow Talk in rosé and rose gold. Per color, it’s the most expensive palette in this comparison. But if you’re unsure about applying makeup or want an elegant, flat case for travel, you get a selection that doesn’t demand any decisions.
Catrice The Dusty Matte
Eight muted matte shades in 9 g, which according to the listing are vegan, fragrance-free, free of microplastic particles and oil-free. Price-wise, it’s entry level. A fraction of what the luxury brands cost. In reviews, buyers praise the color payoff, but some report crumbling pans. As a first palette or as a matte addition to a shimmer palette, it’s a sensible choice.
Premium, mid-range, entry level
The price of the most expensive palette here is many times that of the cheapest. So here are three classes with one palette each.
- Premium: Natasha Denona Glam. Fifteen cool and neutral shades in three textures; according to the manufacturer, the magnetic pans can be rearranged. For anyone who is very into makeup.
- Mid-range: Anastasia Beverly Hills Modern Renaissance. Fourteen warm shades, eleven of them matte, with a mirror and a dual-ended brush. Suits most people who want to do day and evening looks from one palette.
- Entry level: Catrice The Dusty Matte. Eight matte shades for a fraction of what the luxury brands charge. As a first palette or as a matte addition to a shimmer palette.
So which one should I get?
If one palette needs to cover everything and warm shades suit you, the Anastasia Beverly Hills Modern Renaissance is the right fit. If you prefer rosé to brown, the Urban Decay Naked3 Mini is an option, though with only two matte shades. The Natasha Denona Glam is made for cool shades. If you want to spend little or just try things out first, go with the Catrice The Dusty Matte. As a gift, the Charlotte Tilbury Luxury Palette suits beginners, the Natasha Denona Glam connoisseurs.
With luxury brands, many listings on Amazon.de come from third-party sellers, and some versions are temporarily unavailable. Before ordering, check who sells and ships the product. How to spot counterfeit cosmetics is explained in our guide to beauty gift sets (in German). If you’d like to give several small products, you’ll find ideas among the beauty advent calendars (in German), and for care around the eyes there’s our guide to eye cream (in German).
Frequently asked questions
How many shimmer shades does an eyeshadow palette need?
Only a few. An eye look usually consists of a light base, a transition shade in the crease and a dark color for depth, and these are usually matte shades. Shimmer, metallic or glitter only goes on the center of the lid or in the inner corner of the eye. A palette with four matte and ten shimmer shades is hard to use up in everyday life.
Which color family suits me?
Warm shades are copper, terracotta and gold; cool shades are taupe, gray and mauve; and then there are rosy nudes. If you've mostly worn brown so far, you rarely go wrong with a warm neutral palette. For rosé instead of brown, the Urban Decay Naked3 Mini fits; for cool shades, the Natasha Denona Glam.
What should I look for in an eyeshadow palette besides color?
Count the finishes; many manufacturers list the breakdown online. Next comes pan size: four large pans last longer than 18 small ones with barely enough room for a brush. For a handbag or travel, a flat palette with a mirror is more practical. On pigmentation, customer reviews tell you more than the words "highly pigmented."
Which ingredients in eye makeup are a concern?
There is no current Öko-Test of eyeshadow palettes. In its kohl eyeliner test from February 2025, Öko-Test, a German consumer magazine, found more nickel than its own limit in almost half of the 19 pencils; according to Öko-Test, nickel is the most common trigger of contact allergies. If you're allergic to nickel, have a doctor check eye makeup with you beforehand.
What is the problem with mica in eyeshadow?
Mica is the mineral behind almost every shimmer. In 2023, Öko-Test reported on child labor in illegal mines in India and Madagascar, and the ingredient list doesn't reveal where it comes from. Synthetic mica is an alternative some brands use. Purely matte palettes often get by with less mica; the INCI list will tell you.
Which eyeshadow palette makes a good gift?
For beginners, the Charlotte Tilbury Luxury Palette fits: four colors with color codes on the pans, a flat case and a selection that doesn't demand any decisions. For connoisseurs who are very into makeup, the Natasha Denona Glam with magnetic, rearrangeable pans fits. It's priced well above the other brands.
Sources
- Anastasia Beverly Hills: Modern Renaissance Eyeshadow Palette
- Urban Decay: Naked3 Mini Eyeshadow Palette
- Natasha Denona: Glam Eyeshadow Palette
- Charlotte Tilbury: Luxury Palette Pillow Talk
- Catrice: The Dusty Matte Eyeshadow Palette
- Öko-Test: kohl eyeliner test, February 2025 (in German)
- Öko-Test: the mineral mica, February 2023 (in German)
Where to buy
- Natasha Denona GlamCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Anastasia Beverly Hills Modern RenaissanceCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Catrice The Dusty MatteCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Urban Decay Naked3 MiniCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Charlotte Tilbury Luxury Palette (Pillow Talk)Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
