Contents11 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
A large, thin steel fire bowl annoys the neighbors after the first evening and rusts through after the second winter. That is the price of buying on looks. If you live close to other houses, look at the design first and only then at the appearance. For an ordinary garden, we consider a double-walled stainless steel fire pit such as the Solo Stove Bonfire 2.0 the most sensible solution. If you only light a fire now and then, a simple fire basket from Esschert Design is enough, and it costs a fraction of that.
A fire pit is no substitute for a grill. Steaks every weekend? Then you are better off with a dedicated grill. What matters there is explained in our gas grill overview (in German).
The real problem is smoke, not the flame
An open wood fire smokes mainly when it gets too little air or the wood is damp. That is exactly where double-walled fire pits come in. Heated air rises between the inner and outer walls and exits again at the top rim, where the wood gases are supposed to burn off. Solo Stove and Petromax describe this principle as secondary combustion. How much smoke it saves, we only know from the manufacturers. We are not aware of any independent measurements.
The wood matters more than any technology. In the manual for the Cube, höfats calls for dry wood that has been stored for at least three years. No fire pit turns wet wood into a clean fire. How to store wood you split yourself is shown in our article on the firewood rack (in German).
There are clear differences in material. Stainless steel discolors but does not rust through. Corten steel deliberately forms a layer of rust that protects it but can stain light-colored paving. Cast iron is heavy and lasts a long time. And painted steel? Inexpensive, but it often loses its paint in the very first season.
A grill grate usually has to be bought separately. A height-adjustable grate like the one for the Cube is worth more in everyday use than a large surface. Removable ash pans save work. With the Cube, you can smother the fire by turning the basket over. According to the manufacturer, however, you should only turn it over once the wood has burned down completely.
Höfats designates the Cube for level, load-bearing and fireproof surfaces such as concrete paving and specifies a distance of at least three meters from combustible materials, explicitly including wooden decks. On a lawn, almost any fire pit leaves a brown patch. A heat shield like the one on the Petromax Tyropit is meant to protect the ground, but it does not make a wooden deck a suitable spot.
What neighbors, local authorities and fire safety rules require
In Germany, fire pits on private property generally do not require a permit or notification. That is what the fact sheet of the Augsburg district office (Landratsamt Augsburg) from May 2026 says, and the fact sheet of the Nuremberg fire department says the same. The fire is allowed as long as waste and fire safety laws are observed. Garden waste and treated wood therefore do not belong in it.
The Augsburg district office additionally relies on Section 4 (4) of the 1. BImSchV, the first ordinance implementing the German Federal Immission Control Act. The ordinance allows open fireplaces to be used only occasionally, and the office counts fire pits among them. Only untreated wood in pieces or wood briquettes may be burned. Anyone who burns anything else commits a regulatory offense, according to the fact sheet. Nighttime quiet hours apply from 10 p.m.; if smoke drifts into the apartment next door, neighbors can demand that you stop under the German Civil Code (BGB). The fact sheet advises letting neighbors know beforehand and paying attention to the wind direction.
The specific distances are governed by the law of each German state. In Bavaria, under Section 4 of the Bavarian Ordinance on Fire Prevention, grills and comparable fire sites may be operated at the distances specified by the manufacturer; the fire must be put out in strong wind, and an open fire needs constant supervision. Other states and many municipalities have their own rules, for example when there is a risk of forest fires. A quick call to the local public order office (Ordnungsamt) clarifies more than any forum.
Six fire pits side by side
| Model | Design and material | Size and weight | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Solo Stove Bonfire 2.0 | double-walled, 304 stainless steel, ash pan | Ø 49.5 cm, height 35.5 cm, around 10 kg | small gardens with neighbors close by |
| Petromax Tyropit | double-walled, stainless steel, heat shield | Ø 57.5 cm, height 35.5 cm, 12.1 kg | patio with stone paving, larger groups |
| höfats Cube | fire basket, Corten steel or black stainless steel | 43 × 43 × 44 cm, 13.7 kg (Corten) | if you want to extinguish, grill and sit |
| höfats Bowl 57 with star stand | tilting hemisphere, enameled steel | Ø 57 cm, grilling height 41 cm, around 5.6 kg | fire with a plancha or grate |
| Esschert Design Feuerschale XL (FF90) | open bowl, cast iron | Ø 77.9 cm, height 25.7 cm, 34.1 kg | permanent spot, large gatherings |
| Esschert Design 2in1 Feuerkorb (FF253) | basket or bowl, steel | 47 × 47 × 49.5 cm, 3.4 kg | occasional fires, small budget |
Solo Stove Bonfire 2.0: little smoke in little space
Among double-walled fire pits, the Bonfire is the best-known model. According to the manufacturer, airflow all around ensures secondary combustion; version 2.0 has a removable base with an ash pan. At just under 50 centimeters in diameter, it also fits on a small patio. In terms of price, it sits near the top. Solo Stove sells a grill grate only as an accessory.
Petromax Tyropit: double-walled with protection underneath
Petromax also builds the Tyropit double-walled with air holes and includes a charcoal grate, an ash pan with a spark dome and a heat shield. According to Petromax, the shield is meant to reduce heat transfer downward. It is somewhat larger and heavier than the Bonfire and sits in the same price class. Petromax offers a matching grill plate and a cover in a set.
höfats Cube: the basket that puts itself out
Turned over, it smothers the embers because gravity keeps the fire bowl level; when cold, it serves as a stool or side table. The grill grate is available as an accessory and is height-adjustable. According to the manual, no more than three kilos of wood may go in, so on long evenings you have to add wood often.
höfats Bowl 57: fire bowl with a cooking plate
The enameled hemisphere can be tilted, and the star stand is made of stainless steel. Höfats promises a low-smoke fire thanks to double ventilation and cites certification under the European grill standard EN 1860. The plancha, grate and warming ring cost extra and quickly make the set as expensive as the stainless steel fire pits. For cooking over the fire, this model has the most extensive accessories here.
Esschert Design Feuerschale XL: heavy and large
A good 34 kilos of cast iron with a diameter of almost 78 centimeters: you set this bowl down once and leave it there. The manufacturer notes that it develops a patina over time. Esschert lists a round XL grill grate as a separate accessory. There is no low-smoke technology. This is a classic open fire.
Esschert Design 2in1 Feuerkorb: the affordable way in
A plain steel basket that you turn over to use as a shallow bowl. It costs a fraction of what the stainless steel models cost and, according to Esschert, weighs just under 3.4 kilos. Material this thin will not last decades outdoors. The design does nothing against smoke.
How we would decide
- Row house, neighbors close by: Solo Stove Bonfire 2.0 or Petromax Tyropit, along with truly dry wood.
- Fire and grill in one: höfats Bowl 57 with a plancha or the Cube with a grate.
- Large garden with a permanent fire spot: Esschert Design XL in cast iron.
- Just a few evenings a year: Esschert Design 2in1 Feuerkorb. Ideas for the seating area around it are in our article on the garden lounge.
Whichever model you choose, a bucket of sand next to the fire pit is part of the setup. Höfats explicitly recommends it in its manual.
Frequently asked questions
Which fire pit produces little smoke?
Double-walled fire pits such as the Solo Stove Bonfire 2.0 or the Petromax Tyropit channel heated air upward between the walls, where the wood gases are supposed to burn off. How much smoke this saves is only known from the manufacturers. No fire pit turns wet wood into a clean fire.
Which fire pit material lasts a long time?
Stainless steel discolors but does not rust through. Corten steel forms a protective layer of rust that can stain light-colored paving. Cast iron is heavy and lasts a long time. Painted steel is inexpensive but often loses its paint in the very first season.
Are you allowed to use a fire pit in your garden?
In Germany, no permit is usually required on private property as long as waste and fire safety laws are observed. Only untreated wood in pieces or wood briquettes are allowed, no garden waste. Distances are governed by the law of each German state, and a call to the local public order office clarifies the local rules.
Where can a fire pit be placed?
Höfats designates the Cube for level, load-bearing and fireproof surfaces such as concrete paving and specifies a distance of at least three meters from combustible materials, explicitly including wooden decks. On a lawn, almost any fire pit leaves a brown patch, and a heat shield does not make a wooden deck a suitable spot.
Can you grill on a fire pit?
Yes, but a grill grate usually has to be bought separately. A height-adjustable grate like the one for the höfats Cube is worth more in everyday use than a large surface. The höfats Bowl 57 offers a plancha, grate and warming ring as accessories; if you grill steaks every weekend, a dedicated grill makes more sense.
What belongs next to the fire pit?
A bucket of sand, which höfats explicitly recommends in its manual. Plus dry wood that has been stored for at least three years. An open fire needs constant supervision, and it must be put out in strong wind. Let your neighbors know beforehand and pay attention to the wind direction.
Sources
- Augsburg district office: Fact sheet on grill fires and fire pits in the garden (May 2026)
- Nuremberg fire department: Fact sheet on grills and fire pits
- 1. BImSchV (German ordinance), Section 4
- Solo Stove: Bonfire 2.0 with stand
- Petromax: Tyropit fire bowl
- höfats: Cube fire basket, Corten steel
- höfats: Cube user manual
- höfats: Bowl 57 with star stand
- Esschert Design: Feuerschale XL FF90
- Esschert Design: Reversible fire basket/fire bowl FF253
Where to buy
- Solo Stove Bonfire 2.0Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Esschert Design 2in1 Feuerkorb FF253Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Petromax TyropitCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- höfats Cube FeuerkorbCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- höfats Bowl 57 mit SternfußCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Esschert Design Feuerschale XL FF90Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
