Contents12 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
With fitness trackers, a bad buy rarely comes down to the sensors. It hides in the fine print. A subscription you only notice after unboxing. As a rule, a band with a display that shows everything essential without a membership is enough, such as the Fitbit Charge 6 or, much cheaper, the Xiaomi Smart Band 10.
Rings and bands without a screen are a matter of taste, not technical progress.
Four questions before you order
What does the device cost over time? Whoop is only available together with a membership. According to Oura, the ring and app also work without a subscription, but the analyses are then severely limited. Google and Garmin offer optional paid tiers. So always calculate over three years, not just the device price.
How long does the battery really last? Manufacturer figures apply to standard settings. Google itself writes that the always-on display and oxygen measurement send the Charge 6 to the charging cable more often. For the Smart Band 10, Xiaomi speaks of up to 21 days, up to 9 with the display permanently on.
Do you need a display? Without a screen, you lose the time, readable notifications and your heart rate during a run, as long as your phone stays in your pocket. With GPS, the situation is even clearer. Of the six devices below, only Google states built-in GPS for the Charge 6. If you run without your phone and still want the route, you quickly end up with a smartwatch or sports watch.
Ring or band? A ring barely bothers you at night, but it has to fit exactly. Oura includes a charger that matches the ring size, and according to the manufacturer the battery life also depends on the size.
Health readings are indications, not diagnoses
Heart rate, oxygen saturation, skin temperature, sleep stages: all the trackers here measure more than most people will ever analyze. The manufacturers are more cautious than their advertising. Google explicitly states that the Charge 6’s oxygen measurement is not intended for the diagnosis or treatment of diseases, and for skin temperature it only shows deviations from your own baseline. Treat such numbers as a trend. If you see worrying readings or have symptoms, have them checked by a doctor instead of trusting the app.
Your data sits with the manufacturer
A tracker collects health data around the clock, and under the General Data Protection Regulation that data counts as particularly sensitive. Find out in advance where this data goes. For Fitbit devices, Google requires a Google account and the Google Health App, and according to the data sheet the Fitbit Air even needs location permission on your phone to sync. Oura allows export as a CSV file even without a membership. This is exactly the point you should check. If you switch brands later, you will want to take the last few years of sleep data with you, and the GDPR provides a right to data portability in a machine-readable format.
The six candidates
| Model | Form factor | Battery according to manufacturer | Subscription | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fitbit Charge 6 | Band, AMOLED display, GPS | up to 7 days | optional | Training without a phone, Google users |
| Xiaomi Smart Band 10 | Band, 1.72-inch AMOLED | up to 21 days (always-on up to 9) | no subscription mentioned | Beginners on a small budget |
| Google Fitbit Air | Band without display, 12 g | up to 7 days | optional, 3-month trial | Sleep and everyday life, as unobtrusive as possible |
| Garmin CIRQA Smart Band | Band without display | up to 10 days | optional (Connect+) | Garmin users, long battery life |
| WHOOP 5.0 (Peak) | Band without display | up to 14 days | required | Athletes focused on recovery |
| Oura Ring 4 | Titanium ring | 5 to 8 days depending on size | strongly recommended | Sleep tracking without a band |
Fitbit Charge 6
The Charge 6 has been on the market since 2023. Next to the new bands, it looks almost conservative. That is exactly what speaks for it. It has an AMOLED display, built-in GPS according to Google, NFC and sensors compatible with the EKG-App (ECG app); according to Google, one charge lasts up to 7 days.
Google now lists its display successor, the Fitbit Edge, in its own store; so far it has not appeared on Amazon.de.
Xiaomi Smart Band 10
Price-wise, the band sits far below the other devices, and according to the manufacturer it lasts the longest. The AMOLED display measures 1.72 inches and, according to a report, reaches up to 1,500 nits; the housing is water-resistant to 5 bar. No built-in GPS is mentioned in the specifications. Steps, heart rate and sleep, nothing else? Then you hardly need more.
Google Fitbit Air
Google’s answer to Whoop does without any screen and, according to the data sheet, weighs 12 grams with the strap. One charge lasts up to 7 days, and according to the manufacturer five minutes of charging is enough for one day. Google promises the real added value through the coach in Google Health Premium, a subscription with a single-digit monthly fee. Without this subscription, what remains is a solid but plain band.
Garmin CIRQA Smart Band
Garmin’s first band without a display arrived in summer 2026. According to the manufacturer, it should last up to 10 days. It measures heart rate, oxygen saturation and skin temperature; GPS is missing. According to Notebookcheck, most features work without a subscription, while some extras are reserved for Connect+.
The older vívosmart 5 with a small touch display still turns up at retailers, but it can no longer be found on Garmin’s website.
WHOOP 5.0
With Whoop, you are not buying a device but a membership. The hardware is included. There are three tiers from One to Life, and depending on the tier the annual fee is in the three-digit euro range. ECG and a blood pressure estimate, which according to reports is still in beta and has to be calibrated with a real measuring device, are only offered by the MG model in the most expensive tier. Casual athletes pay a lot for it and use little of it in everyday life.
Oura Ring 4
According to Oura, the ring is made of titanium inside and out, weighs 3.3 to 5.2 grams depending on size and is water-resistant to 100 meters. For sleep, this form factor is pleasant; during weight training, on the other hand, it is rather annoying. Factor in the monthly fee right away, because without it, according to Oura, the app shows very little.
From your own habits to the right device
A band with no ongoing costs that you can occasionally run with without your phone: that is the Fitbit Charge 6. If it is only about steps, heart rate and sleep on a small budget, the Xiaomi Smart Band 10 is enough. Hardly anyone needs more tracker than that.
If you already use Garmin Connect, for example with a smart scale, that speaks for the Garmin CIRQA, because the data stays in one place. Nothing on your wrist? Then the Oura Ring 4, provided the monthly fee is budgeted for. That leaves structured training, where recovery should be measured too. Here the Whoop 5.0 or Fitbit Air come into question, but only after you have worked out the subscription costs over three years.
The Garmin CIRQA Smart Band does without a display and without a mandatory subscription; Garmin states up to 10 days of battery life and, for size L/XL, a wrist circumference of 145 to 240 mm at 21.2 g.
Frequently asked questions
Do you need a subscription for a fitness tracker?
That depends on the manufacturer. Whoop is only available together with a membership. According to Oura, the ring and app also work without a subscription, but the analyses are then severely limited. Google and Garmin offer optional paid tiers. So always calculate over three years, not just the device price.
Which fitness tracker has built-in GPS?
Of the six devices in the comparison, only Google states built-in GPS for the Fitbit Charge 6. None is mentioned for the Xiaomi Smart Band 10, and the Garmin CIRQA lacks it. If you want to run without your phone and still record the route, you quickly end up with a smartwatch or sports watch.
How long does a fitness tracker battery really last?
Manufacturer figures apply to standard settings. Google itself writes that the always-on display and oxygen measurement send the Charge 6 to the charging cable more often. For the Smart Band 10, Xiaomi states up to 21 days, up to 9 with the display permanently on. The Oura Ring 4 lasts 5 to 8 days depending on size.
Which is better, ring or band?
A ring barely bothers you at night and is well suited to sleep tracking, but it has to fit exactly and is rather annoying during weight training. A band with a display, on the other hand, shows the time, notifications and your heart rate during a run, even when your phone stays in your pocket.
How accurate are the health readings?
They are indications, not diagnoses. Google explicitly states that the Charge 6's oxygen measurement is not intended for the diagnosis or treatment of diseases. Treat such numbers as a trend. If you see worrying readings or have symptoms, have them checked by a doctor instead of trusting the app.
Can I take my data with me when switching brands?
Check this before buying. Oura allows export as a CSV file even without a membership, and the GDPR provides a right to data portability in a machine-readable format. For Fitbit devices, Google requires a Google account and the Google Health App.
Sources
- Google Store: Fitbit Charge 6, technical specifications
- Google Store: Google Fitbit Air, technical specifications
- Google Store: Google Health Premium
- Notebookcheck: Garmin CIRQA
- Vodafone featured: Xiaomi Smart Band 10
- inside digital: Whoop 5.0 and MG
- Oura: Oura Ring 4
- Oura: Membership
- EUR-Lex: General Data Protection Regulation (EU) 2016/679
- Garmin CIRQA Smart Band L/XL black: product information
Where to buy
- Fitbit Charge 6Check price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Xiaomi Smart Band 10Check price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Google Fitbit AirCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Garmin CIRQA Smart BandCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- WHOOP 5.0 PeakCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Oura Ring 4Check price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Garmin CIRQA Smart Band L/XL SchwarzView at CoolblueAvailable in Germany: Coolblue