Contents12 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
Hair soap or solid shampoo? The two look the same but are fundamentally different. Hair soap is real, traditionally made soap. A solid shampoo is shampoo without the water. Knowing the difference spares you a frustrating first few weeks. We have been washing our hair with hair soap from Loona’s since 2021 and have tested it ourselves. On Amazon, there are comparable natural soaps from brands such as Savion or Kleine Auszeit Manufaktur.
Soap is not shampoo
The German consumer advice center Verbraucherzentrale NRW explains it like this: like any soap, hair washing soaps contain fatty acid salts as cleansing agents, usually with less free fat than moisturizing body soaps. Shampoo bars, on the other hand, are soap-free and work with surfactants similar to those in bottled shampoo. The result of washing with a shampoo bar is therefore comparable to what you are used to. Hair soap is not.
Why? The pH value. Hair soaps are more alkaline than shampoos. In hard water, lime soaps also form, which can make hair look dull or straw-like. That is why hair soap almost always goes hand in hand with an acidic rinse.
The acidic rinse
After washing, you pour highly diluted acid over your hair, leave it on briefly and, depending on preference, either rinse with clear water or simply leave it in, because the slight smell of vinegar fades as your hair dries. According to the Verbraucherzentrale, online forums recommend one to two tablespoons of vinegar per liter of water, or alternatively highly diluted citric acid. There is no official guideline for this. With very hard water, you tend to need a little more, with soft water less. Trying it out helps. Really.
What the percentage on the soap means
Many soaps carry a percentage, such as 6 or 8 percent. This refers to superfatting: the share of oil that remains after the soap is made and provides care. For hair, the values are usually lower than for body soaps, because too much fat weighs hair down. Loona’s lists 3 to 15 percent for its soaps, depending on hair type. According to the listing, Kleine Auszeit specifies 4 percent for its coffee hair soap.
Five soaps and shampoos compared
| Model | Type | According to the seller | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Savion Haarseife Schafmilch | Hair soap | Sheep’s milk, wheat germ oil, castor oil, shea butter, palm-oil-free, 85 g | Normal to dry hair |
| Kleine Auszeit Manufaktur Kaffeehaarseife | Hair soap, cold-process | 4% superfat, vegan, palm-oil-free | Normal hair to hair that gets greasy quickly |
| Savion 2-in-1 Reiseseife | Hair and body soap | Vegan, palm-oil-free, 85 g, made in Germany | Sports and travel, one bar for everything |
| GREENDOOR Waschnuss-Haarseife | Hair soap | Soapnut, vegan, palm-oil-free, 100 g | Gentle care |
| LOGONA Festes Shampoo | Solid shampoo with surfactants | Organic hemp, lava clay, vegan, 60 g | Those who want to switch without an acidic rinse |
Loona’s: tested by us
Our pick. Since 2021, we have been washing our hair only with hair soap from Loona’s in Saarbrücken, and we use their body soaps for the body. According to the manufacturer, they are handmade, palm-oil-free, vegan, free of silicones, sulfates and preservatives, 120 g each. There is one catch: Loona’s only sells through its own shop. Everything else is in our review of the Loona’s soaps.
Savion Haarseife Schafmilch
A hair soap (Haarseife) with sheep’s milk (Schafmilch) from a German soap maker. According to the listing, it contains wheat germ oil, castor oil and shea butter and is intended for normal and dry hair and a dry scalp. Because of the sheep’s milk, it is not vegan.
Kleine Auszeit Manufaktur Kaffeehaarseife
A coffee hair soap (Kaffeehaarseife), cold-process, with 4 percent superfat according to the listing, vegan and palm-oil-free. Intended for hair that gets greasy again quickly. The low superfat level suits that, because if your hair gets oily fast, you need little extra oil on your scalp.
Savion 2-in-1 Reiseseife
One travel soap (Reiseseife) for hair and body, just like the Amber Woods soap from Loona’s. Handy for the gym bag and travel; according to the seller, it is vegan, palm-oil-free and made in Germany.
GREENDOOR Waschnuss-Haarseife
A hand-made hair soap with soapnut (Waschnuss), vegan and without palm oil, 100 g. Mild. For anyone looking for a gentle hair soap who likes working with natural cosmetics.
LOGONA Festes Shampoo
Not a soap. A solid shampoo (Festes Shampoo). It is here for everyone who wants the plastic-free advantage, but no adjustment period and no acidic rinse. According to the listing, it contains organic hemp and lava clay, is vegan and weighs 60 g.
How we would choose
- Real hair soap, handmade, from a small shop: Loona’s.
- Hair soap on Amazon, dry hair: Savion Schafmilch.
- Hair that gets greasy quickly: Kleine Auszeit Kaffeehaarseife.
- One bar for hair and body: Savion 2-in-1.
- Switching without an adjustment period: LOGONA Festes Shampoo.
Soaps are alkaline, and essential oils can irritate sensitive skin. Try new soaps on a small area first, keep them out of your eyes and stop using them if irritation occurs. More on hair care is in our hair care guide.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between hair soap and solid shampoo?
Like any soap, hair soap contains fatty acid salts, while a solid shampoo contains soap-free surfactants like bottled shampoo. That is why washing with a solid shampoo feels more familiar.
How do you mix the acidic rinse?
According to the Verbraucherzentrale NRW, online forums recommend one to two tablespoons of vinegar per liter of water, or alternatively highly diluted citric acid.
What does superfatting mean?
The share of oil that remains after the soap is made. For hair that gets greasy quickly, a low superfat level of around 4 percent is suitable.
Who is solid shampoo better for?
For anyone who wants to wash plastic-free but does not want an adjustment period or an acidic rinse.
Sources
- Verbraucherzentrale NRW: What is the difference between shampoo soaps and shampoo bars?
- Loona’s: shop and manufacturer information
Where to buy
- Savion Haarseife SchafmilchCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Kleine Auszeit Manufaktur KaffeehaarseifeCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Savion 2-in-1 ReiseseifeCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- GREENDOOR Waschnuss-HaarseifeCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- LOGONA Festes ShampooCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
