Contents10 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
“0.1 g accuracy” is printed in large type, and then all anyone ever weighs is flour and sugar. That is how many expensive scales end up gathering dust. A flat scale with 1 g increments, a 5 kg maximum capacity, a smooth surface and a milliliter mode covers everyday cooking. Only if you measure yeast, spices or coffee to the gram do you also need a finer weighing surface.
What the numbers on the packaging really tell you
What is printed is almost always the display increment. That is the smallest step the display makes, not the accuracy. In the operating manual for one rechargeable model, ADE explicitly states a deviation of plus/minus 1 percent with a 1 g display increment. With 500 g of flour, that can be up to 5 g. The cake does not care. With 7 g of dry yeast, it is a different story.
With 1 g increments, you can weigh dough, vegetables and portions without any problems. Precision scales with 0.1 g are worth it for yeast, salt in bread dough, spice blends or coffee beans, but they usually only carry 500 g. As for maximum capacity, 5 kg is enough for almost every recipe. What people often forget is that the container counts too: a heavy mixing bowl or roasting pan quickly takes up a good part of that. A 20 kg scale helps with canning and will do for parcels in a pinch.
Every scale has tare and add-and-weigh. The button itself is more interesting: is it big enough, and does the device not switch off in the middle of adding ingredients? If a large plate hides the display, a hold function keeps the reading.
The liquid mode converts grams into milliliters, usually based on water. For milk, that is roughly right. For oil, it is not, because oil is lighter than water. According to the manual, Etekcity provides separate settings for water and milk.
- Surface: Glass looks calm and wipes clean quickly but shows every fingerprint. Stainless steel is more forgiving, scratches included. With both, dirt collects mainly in the gaps between the surface and the display.
- Power supply: Button cells (CR2032) last a long time but are rarely at hand. Every supermarket carries AAA batteries. A built-in rechargeable battery saves on batteries, but according to the manual, some models only manage around two hours of weighing time, and it is often not replaceable.
Counting carbohydrates with diabetes
Many people with diabetes use a kitchen scale to calculate bread units (Broteinheiten, 1 BE = 12 g of carbohydrates) or carbohydrate units (Kohlenhydrateinheiten, 1 KE = 10 g). diabetesDE advises weighing carbohydrate-containing foods at first and gradually learning your own estimating measures over time, for example a tablespoon of rolled oats. The calculation uses the value per 100 g from the label. Manufacturers‘ serving sizes are often on the small side.
A nutrition scale with an app takes over the calculations. It remains an aid. Its values come from a food database and may differ from your product. According to diabinfo.de, how much insulin is needed per KE varies from person to person and is determined with the diabetes team; nutritional counseling is part of every diabetes education program. So discuss using an app scale with your diabetes educator and compare the app values with the packaging at first.
5 kitchen scales currently on the market
| Model | Maximum capacity and increments | Surface and power | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Soehnle Page Profi 300 | 20 kg, 1 g | 27 x 20 cm, battery | Large bowls, canning |
| Tefal Optiss | 5 kg, 0.5 g up to 999 g, 1 g above that | Tempered glass, 2 x AAA | Everyday use with liquids |
| Salter 1035 SSBKDR | 5 kg, 1 g | Stainless steel, CR2032 | Those who prefer stainless steel |
| ADE KE2354 (two weighing surfaces) | 5 kg / 1 g and 500 g / 0.1 g | Battery, 3 x AAA | Bread baking, spices, coffee |
| Etekcity Smart Nutrition Scale ESN00 | 5 kg, 1 g | Bluetooth, 3 x AAA | Tracking nutritional values with an app |
Soehnle Page Profi 300: reserve capacity for large bowls
According to the retailer, the Page Profi 300 carries up to 20 kg with 1 g increments, and the weighing surface measures about 27 x 20 cm. It is operated via touch-sensitive fields, and tare and hold are included. According to the description, it can also be hung on the wall. In a single-person kitchen, that is more scale than you need. Families with a large mixing bowl will have peace of mind with it.
Tefal Optiss: half grams up to almost a kilo
According to Tefal, the Optiss displays in 0.5 g steps up to 999 g and in 1 g steps above that, with a maximum capacity of 5 kg. According to the manufacturer, the surface is made of scratch-resistant tempered glass, and the backlit display switches between grams and milliliters. This is not a precision scale. For baking powder and salt, though, half a gram is often enough.
Salter 1035 SSBKDR: stainless steel, nothing else
Stainless steel platform, 5 kg in 1 g steps, liquid measurement in ml (Aquatronic), one button cell. The Salter needs nothing more. Salter advertises a 15-year guarantee; according to the manufacturer, it only applies after registration within 30 days. This is the right choice if you want a durable surface without an app or extras.
ADE KE2354: standard and precision scale in one
A large surface for up to 5 kg in 1 g steps, and next to it a small one for up to 500 g in 0.1 g steps. If you bake bread or weigh coffee and do not want to store a second scale, you get both this way. The compromise is the size of the small surface; a bowl only fits on it to a limited extent.
Etekcity ESN00: nutritional values only with an account
According to the manual, the ESN00 weighs up to 5 kg in 1 g steps, measures volume for water or milk and pairs with the VeSync app via Bluetooth. It only shows nutritional values in combination with the app, and for that Etekcity requires a personal account. Without an account, you are left with an ordinary scale that you paid more for. If you would rather not create an account, you should know this beforehand, because with this model the app is the real reason to choose it.
From cooking style to the right scale
You cook and bake in the usual way? Then the Tefal Optiss or the Salter 1035 is enough. The Tefal offers tempered glass and finer steps up to almost 1 kg, the Salter a stainless steel surface.
For bread, yeast, spices and coffee, the ADE KE2354 comes out ahead because the 0.1 g surface is built right in. Large quantities and heavy bowls are a job for the Soehnle Page Profi 300; if you weigh in a stand mixer with a large mixing bowl, you do not need to worry about maximum capacity.
Want to track nutritional values and carbohydrates? The Etekcity ESN00 can do that. But only in consultation with your diabetes educator, and the database values deserve a critical look.
Our position is clear. In everyday use, a flat, easy-to-read 5 kg scale beats any device with features nobody touches after two weeks. And if you run out of recipes: our guide to cookbooks can help. If you cook plant-based, you weigh legumes, tofu and nuts more often anyway; our article on vegan cooking collects ideas for that.
Frequently asked questions
What does 0.1 g accuracy on a kitchen scale's packaging mean?
What is printed is almost always the display increment, in other words the smallest step on the display, not the accuracy. For one model with 1 g increments, ADE states a deviation of plus/minus 1 percent. With 500 g of flour, that can be up to 5 g; with 7 g of dry yeast, it matters more.
What maximum capacity does a kitchen scale need?
For almost every recipe, 5 kg is enough. What people often forget is that the container counts too: a heavy mixing bowl or roasting pan quickly takes up a good part of that. For large quantities and canning, the Soehnle Page Profi 300 carries up to 20 kg with 1 g increments, according to the retailer.
When is a precision scale with 0.1 g worth it?
Precision scales with 0.1 g are worth it for yeast, salt in bread dough, spice blends or coffee beans, but they usually only carry 500 g. The ADE KE2354 combines a surface for up to 5 kg in 1 g steps with a small one for up to 500 g in 0.1 g steps, though a bowl only fits on it to a limited extent.
Glass or stainless steel for a kitchen scale?
Glass looks calm and wipes clean quickly but shows every fingerprint. Stainless steel is more forgiving, scratches included. With both, dirt collects mainly in the gaps between the surface and the display. The Tefal Optiss has tempered glass, the Salter 1035 a stainless steel platform.
Does a nutrition scale with an app help with diabetes?
A nutrition scale such as the Etekcity ESN00 takes over the calculations but remains an aid; its database values can differ from your product. It only shows nutritional values with the app and a personal account. Discuss using it with your diabetes educator and compare the values with the packaging at first.
Button cell, AAA battery or rechargeable battery in a kitchen scale?
Button cells last a long time but are rarely at hand. Every supermarket carries AAA batteries. A built-in rechargeable battery saves on batteries, but according to the manual, some models only manage around two hours of weighing time, and it is often not replaceable.
Sources
- Tefal: Optiss kitchen scale
- Salter: stainless steel kitchen scale
- Etekcity: Smart Nutrition Scale ESN00 manual
- ADE: KE2301 kitchen scale operating manual (rechargeable model)
- Fust: Soehnle Page Profi 300 data sheet
- diabetesDE: calculating bread units and carbohydrate units
- diabinfo.de: nutrition with type 1 diabetes
Where to buy
- Soehnle Page Profi 300Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Tefal Optiss KüchenwaageCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Salter 1035 SSBKDRCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- ADE KE2354 Duale KüchenwaageCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Etekcity Smart Nutrition Scale ESN00Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
