Contents11 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
Whether a smart light switch turns out to be a good buy comes down to a single wire. If there is a neutral wire in the switch box, usually blue, then a small in-wall relay such as the Shelly 1PM Mini Gen4 is the sensible solution in most cases. If it is missing, you are left with the Shelly 1L Gen3 with bypass, a wireless button or a switch insert installed by an electrician. If you don’t know this before buying, it is easy to order the wrong device.
Especially in older houses, often only the live wire and the wire to the lamp reach the switch box. That is enough for a normal switch. A wireless module, on the other hand, needs constant power. Without a neutral wire, that only works with workarounds.
Four questions before you order
Is there a neutral wire? The device category depends on it. Devices without a neutral wire draw their power through the lamp and usually need a minimum load or a bypass that sits in parallel with the light fixture. And how full is the box? Behind a switch with many wires, space gets tight, and flat modules have the advantage there.
Which radio standard, which hub? Wi-Fi relays work without an additional box. Zigbee, DECT and Thread need a bridge, the FRITZ!Box or a Thread border router; our guide buying a smart home hub explains what suits you. Matter, in turn, is not a radio standard of its own. It is a common language that lets a relay show up equally in Apple Home, Google Home, Alexa or Home Assistant.
Relay or button? A relay switches the power to the lamp. A wireless button merely sends a command, for example to smart lamps or smart plugs.
Who installs it? A relay behind the light switch is an intervention in the building’s electrical installation. Under Section 13(2) of the German Low Voltage Connection Ordinance (Niederspannungsanschlussverordnung), the installation, extension and modification of the system downstream of the service fuse may only be carried out by the grid operator or by a company registered in the installer directory. Pure maintenance work is exempt. In our assessment, an additional wireless module with a bypass is not maintenance. So leave the installation to a qualified electrician. Mistakes at 230 volts are life-threatening and, in the event of damage, can cost you your insurance coverage. Of the devices here, the only one you mount yourself is the FRITZ! button, which is glued or screwed to the wall.
Seven solutions for the switch box
| Model | Neutral wire | Radio and hub | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shelly 1PM Mini Gen4 | required | Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, Matter or Zigbee | Boxes with a neutral wire, open systems |
| Shelly 1L Gen3 | not required, bypass included | Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, Matter via update according to the manufacturer | Older buildings without the blue wire |
| Philips Hue wall switch module | not required (battery) | Zigbee, Hue Bridge required | Households with Hue lamps |
| FRITZ!DECT 440 | no wiring | DECT ULE, FRITZ!Box with DECT base station | FRITZ! households, renters |
| Homematic IP switch actuator with power metering for brand-name switches | required | Homematic IP, Access Point or hub | Keeping an existing switch range |
| Eve Light Switch | required | Thread, Bluetooth, Apple Home | iPhone households |
| Gira System 3000 Bluetooth control attachment (Bedienaufsatz BT) with electronic switch insert | with and without | Bluetooth, Gira System 3000 app | New builds or renovations with an electrician |
Shelly 1PM Mini Gen4: small, open, with power metering
At 29 by 34 by 16 millimeters, the module fits behind almost any switch, according to the manufacturer. It switches up to 8 amps, measures consumption and communicates via Wi-Fi and Bluetooth. Out of the box it runs in the Matter profile; at the press of a button it switches to Zigbee. One condition, however, is not negotiable. Live and neutral wires must both be present.
Shelly 1L Gen3: the solution for older buildings
The 1L Gen3 makes do with the live wire alone. In return, an included bypass sits in parallel with the lamp, which Shelly says is mandatory with LED lights. The limit is 200 watts. The module can handle a ceiling light, but a halogen floor uplighter in the living room probably not. The manufacturer promises Matter via a firmware update; there is no power metering.
Philips Hue wall switch module: no power, just commands
A CR2450 coin cell powers the module, which disappears behind the existing switch. It does not switch power. It tells the Hue lamps what to do, and they need constant power for that. Philips requires a Hue Bridge. Without Hue lamps in the house, the module is simply the wrong product.
FRITZ!DECT 440: the button that keeps your screwdriver away from the circuit
FRITZ! does not have an in-wall relay in its range. The 440 is a wireless button with four freely assignable keys, an e-paper display, a temperature and humidity sensor and two AAA batteries. It sticks to a magnetic wall mount and, according to the data sheet, controls the FRITZ!DECT 200 and 210 smart plugs as well as the FRITZ!DECT 500 LED bulb. It requires a FRITZ!Box with a DECT base station. Renters often do best with it because no wiring is touched. Suitable smart plugs are presented in our smart plug (in German) guide.
Homematic IP switch actuator with power metering for brand-name switches
This actuator replaces the switch insert and, via adapters, takes over the frame and rocker of many brand-name switch ranges. It switches up to 1,150 watts. Because it measures whether the lamp is on, it also works in two-way and intermediate circuits. According to the data sheet, a neutral wire and a Homematic IP Access Point or a hub are required. Without an existing Homematic IP setup, buying this actuator means buying an entire wireless system including a hub.
Eve Light Switch: designed for Apple Home
Eve replaces the entire switch and supplies its own 55 mm cover; according to the manufacturer, existing switch plates do not fit. It communicates via Thread and Bluetooth. The device handles 1,150 watts and understands commands from an existing two-way or intermediate circuit. Without a neutral wire, nothing works. Eve does not mention Matter on its German product page for this version. If you use Google Home or Alexa, you are better off with Shelly.
Gira System 3000 with Bluetooth attachment
With Gira, the technology and the controls are separate. According to the data sheet, the electronic switch insert 5405 00 works with and without a neutral wire. Without one, it switches using the dimming principle; LED lamps must then be dimmable, and the minimum load for incandescent bulbs rises to 50 watts. The Bluetooth control attachment (Bedienaufsatz BT) stores up to 40 switching times, has an astronomical timer function and is set up via Bluetooth using the Gira System 3000 app. There is no Matter. The system makes sense where Gira switches are already installed and an electrician is being hired anyway.
Which approach suits your switch box
If there is a neutral wire and you have not yet committed to a platform, go for the Shelly 1PM Mini Gen4: small, with power metering and Matter. If the blue wire is missing but a normal lamp is connected, the Shelly 1L Gen3 with bypass fits, as long as the load stays below 200 watts.
With Hue lamps in the house, the Hue wall switch module is the logical choice. The old switch then no longer cuts power to the lamps. In a rented apartment with a FRITZ!Box, reach for the FRITZ!DECT 440 and combine it with smart plugs or FRITZ! lamps.
If the switch range is to stay and Homematic IP is already running, the switch actuator with power metering for brand-name switches is the right choice. Apple Home-only households with a neutral wire end up with the Eve Light Switch. And for a renovation with Gira switches, there is System 3000 with the Bluetooth attachment, installed by an electrician.
Want the lights outdoors to switch smartly too? Lights and motion sensors for that are covered in our smart outdoor lighting guide.
Frequently asked questions
Why is the neutral wire so important for a smart light switch?
A wireless module needs constant power. In older houses, often only the live wire and the wire to the lamp reach the switch box. Devices without a neutral wire draw their power through the lamp and usually need a minimum load or a bypass that sits in parallel with the light fixture.
Can I install a smart light switch myself?
A relay behind the light switch is an intervention in the building's electrical installation. Under Section 13(2) of the German Low Voltage Connection Ordinance (Niederspannungsanschlussverordnung), only the grid operator or a registered company may do this. Mistakes at 230 volts are life-threatening and can cost you your insurance coverage. Of the devices presented, only the FRITZ!DECT 440 can be mounted yourself.
What is the difference between a relay and a wireless button?
A relay switches the power to the lamp. A wireless button merely sends a command, for example to smart lamps or plug-in adapters. The Philips Hue wall switch module runs on a coin cell and tells the Hue lamps what to do; the lamps need constant power for that.
Which smart light switch is suitable for renters?
Renters often do best with the FRITZ!DECT 440 because no wiring is touched. The wireless button sticks to a magnetic wall mount and controls FRITZ! smart plugs and the FRITZ!DECT 500 LED bulb. It requires a FRITZ!Box with a DECT base station.
Do I need a hub for a smart light switch?
Wi-Fi relays such as those from Shelly work without an additional box. Zigbee, DECT and Thread need a bridge, the FRITZ!Box or a Thread border router. Matter is not a radio standard of its own but a common language that lets a relay show up in Apple Home, Google Home, Alexa or Home Assistant.
Can I keep my existing switch range?
The Homematic IP switch actuator with power metering for brand-name switches takes over the frame and rocker of many brand-name switch ranges via adapters and also works in two-way and intermediate circuits. It needs a neutral wire and an Access Point or a hub. With the Eve Light Switch, by contrast, existing switch plates do not fit according to the manufacturer.
Sources
- German Low Voltage Connection Ordinance (NAV), Section 13 Electrical installation
- Shelly: 1PM Mini Gen4
- Shelly: 1L Gen3
- Philips Hue: wall switch module
- FRITZ!DECT 440 data sheet
- Homematic IP: data sheet for the switch actuator with power metering for brand-name switches
- Eve: Light Switch
- Gira: data sheet for the System 3000 electronic switch insert
- Gira: data sheet for the System 3000 Bluetooth control attachment
Where to buy
- Shelly 1PM Mini Gen4Check price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Shelly 1L Gen3 mit BypassCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Philips Hue Wandschalter-ModulCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- FRITZ!DECT 440Check price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Homematic IP Schalt-Mess-Aktor für MarkenschalterCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Eve Light SwitchCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Gira System 3000 Bedienaufsatz BTCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de

