Black Friday Woche ab 19.11.: unsere Wahl je Ratgeber
Independent buying adviceEvery claim with a sourceNo paid verdictsIn 36 countries1,734 guides and reviews in German How we test
handgetestet

Deutsch

Buying a Smart Speaker 2026: Alexa, Siri, Google, Matter

Buying a smart speaker in 2026: Echo, HomePod, Sonos and Bose compared. Which assistant, how much of a smart home hub, and where the microphone switches off.

handgetestet editorial team · Updated November 17, 2026
Sonos Era 300 in blackImage: Coolblue (Pressebild)
Contents13 sections

This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.

Sound and looks? With a smart speaker, those are the wrong first questions. The voice assistant matters more, because it determines the entire system: lamps, plugs, routines, even which phone fits. In most households, the Amazon Echo Dot Max is the most sensible place to start. It brings Alexa, a built-in smart home hub and decent sound together in one compact device. For iPhone users, the Apple HomePod mini 2 is the fit, and if you mainly want to listen to music, you are better off with the Sonos Era 100.

Alexa, Siri or Google: do I have to commit?

Yes. Alexa, Siri and Google do not understand each other, and if you switch later, you usually have to set up routines and devices again. What is already in the house therefore often sets the direction.

Alexa is built into the Echo devices and also runs on speakers from Sonos and Bose. According to Amazon, the enhanced version Alexa+ launched in Germany on May 7, 2026, as an early access program. According to the manufacturer, Prime members get it at no extra charge; everyone else pays monthly.

Siri only listens in the HomePod. It requires an iPhone or iPad and shows its strengths with Apple Music and the Home app.

With Google, the situation is confusing right now. According to the trade press, the company has discontinued the Nest Audio. Its successor, the Google Home Speaker with Gemini, has been sold in Germany since August 2026 but has not yet appeared on Amazon.de. If you want to talk freely with Gemini Live, you also need a Google Home Premium subscription.

Sonos and Bose work differently. There, sound comes first, and the assistant is an addition. If there should be no microphone in the room at all, that leaves the Sonos Era 100 SL. It does without microphones and voice control entirely.

Do I need a smart home hub in addition to the speaker?

It depends. According to Amazon, the Echo Dot Max and Echo Studio have a built-in smart home hub with Zigbee, Thread and Matter. The HomePod mini 2 and HomePod serve as a home hub for HomeKit and Matter accessories and communicate via Thread. Sonos and Bose, on the other hand, only control devices through the assistant in the cloud. They lack a radio hub of their own.

For a few smart lamps and plugs, a speaker with Thread is often enough. If heating, roller shutters and sensors are to run automatically, it reaches its limits. At that point at the latest, a dedicated smart home hub belongs in your plans. The speaker then serves only as a microphone and remote control.

Is the speaker always listening?

It waits for its wake word; every device of this kind does. Only then is the request processed, with Alexa, Siri and Gemini in the manufacturer’s cloud. What the manufacturers promise when it comes to switching off differs, however.

Amazon mentions a button that turns off the microphones, and a light indicator. It shows when Alexa is listening and sending requests to the cloud. You set how long voice recordings are stored in the Alexa app. Processing voice commands only on the device has no longer been possible since March 2025. Amazon discontinued the option, which had only been offered for a few devices in the USA anyway.

Apple says it assigns Siri requests to a random identifier, not to the Apple Account. A hardware switch for the microphone is not listed in the technical specifications. Sonos builds a switch into the back of the Era 100 and Era 300 which, according to Sonos, disconnects the microphone hardware. Bose relies on a mute button, with a red light indicating that the microphone is off. According to the manufacturer, Google’s Home Speaker has a two-stage hardware switch.

A real switch is worth more than a setting in a menu. And if you switch off the microphone almost all the time anyway, an ordinary Bluetooth speaker (in German) may be all you need.

Seven smart speakers compared

ModelAssistantSmart homeMicrophone offBest for
Amazon Echo Dot MaxAlexa, Alexa+Hub for Zigbee, Thread, MatterButtonGetting started with a smart home hub
Amazon Echo Studio (2025)Alexa, Alexa+Hub for Zigbee, Thread, MatterButtonAlexa households with high sound standards
Apple HomePod mini 2SiriThread, home hub for Matterno switch listediPhone households, small rooms
Apple HomePod (2nd Gen.)SiriThread, home hub for Matterno switch listedApple users with a living room
Sonos Era 100Alexa, Sonos Voice Controlvia AlexaHardware switchMusic first, multiroom
Sonos Era 300Alexa, Sonos Voice Controlvia AlexaHardware switchDolby Atmos for music
Bose Lifestyle Ultra SpeakerAlexavia AlexaMute buttonBose home theater, AirPlay and Google Cast

Amazon Echo Dot Max

The Dot Max is the first Echo Dot with a built-in smart home hub. According to Amazon, instead of a single driver, a two-way system with a woofer and tweeter does the work. According to the manufacturer, it delivers almost three times as much bass as the fifth-generation Echo Dot. In the kitchen and bedroom, that is a sensible compromise. It will not fill a living room.

Amazon Echo Studio (2025)

Around 40 percent smaller than the original model, says Amazon, and still with 3D audio and Dolby Atmos. Inside the housing, a woofer and three full-range drivers do the work. With a compatible Fire TV, up to five devices can be paired into a home theater. For Alexa households that want more sound, it is the right choice. For voice commands alone, it would be too big.

Apple HomePod mini 2

Apple has given the second generation of the small HomePod Wi-Fi 6E, Bluetooth 6 and Thread, as well as temperature and humidity sensors. Inside the sphere are three microphones, a full-range driver and two passive radiators. Two devices of the same generation form a stereo pair. Without an iPhone or iPad, though, it is of little use.

Apple HomePod (2nd generation)

A 4-inch woofer and five tweeters work inside the large HomePod. It measures the room acoustics itself and plays back Dolby Atmos. At 2.3 kilograms, this is a serious speaker. Its weak point is Wi-Fi to 802.11n, a fairly old standard. It is enough for music. It no longer feels current.

Sonos Era 100

According to Sonos, stereo sound comes from a single enclosure, with two angled tweeters and one midwoofer. Trueplay tunes the sound to the room, including with Android phones. Bluetooth and AirPlay 2 are built in. A source with a 3.5 mm jack connects via the separately available line-in adapter. For multiroom, Sonos offers the broadest system.

Sonos Era 300

Built for spatial sound. The drivers fire forward, to the sides and upward, and it plays music in Dolby Atmos, provided the streaming service delivers it. As a smart speaker, it can do no more than the Era 100. If you mainly use it for voice commands, you are paying for sound you do not need.

Bose Lifestyle Ultra Speaker

Bose introduced the speaker in May 2026. According to the manufacturer, TrueSpatial spreads the sound all around, plus there are AirPlay 2, Google Cast, Spotify Connect and Bluetooth 5.3. You activate Alexa in the Bose app; Bose lists Alexa+ only for the USA. As a surround speaker, it works exclusively with the Lifestyle Ultra Soundbar. In a home theater, that limits your options.

So which one is right for me?

If it is your first smart speaker and your smart home is still being built, the Amazon Echo Dot Max is the obvious choice, because the radio hub comes included. If Alexa is also to handle movies and music in the living room, the Echo Studio fits, ideally as a pair with Fire TV. If there is an iPhone in the household, the HomePod mini 2 belongs on the list, and the HomePod for larger rooms. If music comes before voice control, take the Sonos Era 100, and the Era 300 for spatial sound. No microphone in the room? Sonos Era 100 SL or a conventional speaker. And if you have or are planning a Bose soundbar, go for the Bose Lifestyle Ultra Speaker.

Frequently asked questions

Do you have to commit to Alexa, Siri or Google?

Yes. The three assistants do not understand each other, and if you switch later, you usually have to set up routines and devices again. What is already in the house therefore often sets the direction. Siri only listens in the HomePod, which requires an iPhone or iPad.

Do you need a smart home hub in addition to the smart speaker?

For a few smart lamps and plugs, a speaker with Thread is often enough. According to Amazon, the Echo Dot Max and Echo Studio have a built-in hub for Zigbee, Thread and Matter, and HomePods control HomeKit and Matter accessories. If heating, roller shutters and sensors are to run automatically, a dedicated hub belongs in your plans.

Is a smart speaker always listening?

It waits for its wake word; only then is the request processed, with Alexa, Siri and Gemini in the manufacturer's cloud. Amazon mentions a button that turns off the microphones, and Sonos builds a hardware switch into the Era 100 and Era 300. A real switch is worth more than a setting in a menu.

What does Alexa+ cost?

According to Amazon, Alexa+ launched in Germany on May 7, 2026, as an early access program. According to the manufacturer, Prime members get the enhanced version at no extra charge; everyone else pays monthly. For the Bose Lifestyle Ultra Speaker, Bose lists Alexa+ only for the USA.

Is there a smart speaker without a microphone?

The Sonos Era 100 SL does without microphones and voice control entirely, which makes it the option for rooms where there should be no microphone at all. If you switch off the microphone almost all the time anyway, an ordinary Bluetooth speaker may also do the job.

Which Google speaker is currently available?

The situation is confusing. According to the trade press, Google has discontinued the Nest Audio. Its successor, the Google Home Speaker with Gemini, has been sold in Germany since August 2026 but has not yet appeared on Amazon.de. Talking freely with Gemini Live also requires a Google Home Premium subscription.

Sources

Where to buy

Shop in:

Sale, delivery, warranty and product safety are the sole responsibility of the respective retailer and manufacturer. All information without guarantee; prices and availability may change.

Links marked as affiliate links earn us a small commission if you buy through them. The price stays the same for you, and our verdict stays independent. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.