Contents13 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
A new band for your Galaxy Watch, Garmin or Pixel Watch rarely fails on taste. It fails on the attachment. With the Watch8, Samsung abandoned its familiar 20 mm connection, Garmin distinguishes between three widths, and Google keeps 41 and 45 mm strictly separate. Our recommendation is therefore to buy the watchmaker’s own sports band first and only experiment after that. For a Galaxy Watch9, that specifically means the Samsung Sport Band in the right length.
Which watch do you wear? Everything depends on it
At Samsung, the situation is split in two. According to Samsung, the Galaxy Watch8 uses a new, proprietary attachment and no longer accepts bands from earlier models. Bands for the Watch8 and Watch8 Classic are interchangeable, and Samsung explicitly lists the current bands for the Watch9 as compatible with the Watch8 and Watch8 Classic as well. The band is released with a button on the back of the watch; no tools are needed.
Older watches stick with the standard. According to Samsung, the Watch4 to Watch7 have a 20 mm connection width and can largely swap bands with each other. The Galaxy Watch Ultra is a special case with a 34 mm width and only its own bands. Samsung also warns that third-party 20 mm bands do not always sit cleanly because of the precise shape of the attachment.
Garmin works in widths. According to the spec sheet, the fēnix 9 takes a 20 mm QuickFit band in the 43 mm size, a 22 mm band in 47 mm and a 26 mm band in 51 mm. You swap it via a small latch on the band that hooks over the watch’s pin. Garmin also sells a separate line called Schnellwechsel-Armbänder (quick-release bands). If the description does not say QuickFit, read the list of compatible watches especially carefully.
Google keeps things simple. The Pixel Watch 3, 4 and 5 come in 41 and 45 mm, and according to Google, 45 mm accessories only fit the 45 mm models. Google’s 41 mm sports and leather bands, on the other hand, fit all the way back to the first Pixel Watch.
An Apple Watch has its own size groups. We explain them in our guide to Apple Watch bands.
Measure the length instead of guessing
A tape measure around your wrist where the watch sits. That’s all it takes. Google advises choosing the smaller size if in doubt and recommends wearing the watch two to three finger widths above the wrist bone during workouts, because the heart rate sensor needs skin contact. In its band guide, Garmin writes that a band that is too loose can make heart rate measurement less accurate. One finger’s width of space between band and skin is given there as a guideline.
The ranges differ more than you might think. A Samsung Sport Band in S/M covers 130 to 185 mm, a 22 mm Garmin silicone band 125 to 208 mm. With a 150 mm wrist, you are at the short end with Garmin and in the middle with Samsung.
Seven bands and what they fit
| Model | Fits (according to manufacturer) | Material and clasp | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Samsung Sport Band | Galaxy Watch9, Watch8, Watch8 Classic | soft sports band; S/M 130–185 mm, M/L 145–205 mm | Workouts and everyday wear |
| Samsung Fabric Band | Galaxy Watch9, Watch8, Watch8 Classic | Textile with hook-and-loop fastener; S/M 130–180 mm | Sleep tracking, infinitely adjustable length |
| Spigen DuraPro Armor | Galaxy Watch8 (40/44 mm), Watch8 Classic (46 mm) | TPU and nylon, metal connectors | rugged look as a third-party band |
| Garmin QuickFit 22 Silikon | Garmin watches with 22 mm QuickFit, e.g. fēnix 9 47 mm | Silicone; 125–208 mm | Running, cycling, swimming |
| Garmin QuickFit 22 Leder | Garmin watches with 22 mm QuickFit | Leather; walnut version 132–210 mm | Office, evenings |
| Google Active Sportarmband | Pixel Watch 1 to 5, per case size | Silicone, plastic clasp, stainless steel attachments | Sports with the Pixel Watch |
| Google Handgefertigtes Lederarmband | Pixel Watch 1 to 5, per case size | Italian leather, stainless steel; S 140–180 mm, L 175–215 mm | Everyday wear without sweat or water |
Samsung Sport Band
The band we would start with. Samsung describes it as light, slim and soft, designed for running and Pilates. It comes in two lengths, S/M for wrists from 130 to 185 mm and M/L for 145 to 205 mm. Because it fits the Watch9, Watch8 and Watch8 Classic alike, you can simply take it with you if you switch watches within this series.
Samsung Fabric Band
Here, a hook-and-loop fastener replaces a buckle. That allows any length in between, and Samsung explicitly promotes the band for wearing at night. If you track your sleep, you can loosen the band a little in the evening and tighten it again in the morning.
Spigen DuraPro Armor
A third-party band for Samsung’s new attachment, made of TPU and nylon with metal connectors. Spigen lists the Watch8 in 40 and 44 mm and the Watch8 Classic in 46 mm as compatible watches. The manufacturer makes no clear statement online about the Watch9, so check the model list before you buy. Visually, the band looks considerably more angular than the original.
Garmin QuickFit 22 Silikon
Garmin offers the 22 mm silicone band in numerous colors, and according to the manufacturer it fits wrists from 125 to 208 mm. In its own guide to the fēnix 9, Garmin recommends silicone for running, cycling and swimming because it absorbs hardly any moisture. Check your watch’s width first. A 22 mm band does not fit a 43 mm fēnix.
For the fēnix 9 Pro, the manual contains a warning. Metal bands, or bands with metal parts close to the case, can interfere with reception of satellites, Bluetooth, Wi-Fi and LTE, and Garmin advises against third-party bands. Which Garmin watch suits you is covered in our Garmin comparison (in German).
Garmin QuickFit 22 Leder
The office counterpart. For the walnut version, Garmin specifies a wrist size of 132 to 210 mm. It doesn’t belong in the gym. Google, for example, explicitly classifies its leather bands as neither sweat- nor water-resistant. With QuickFit, though, switching takes only seconds, and that is exactly what the system is built for. Silicone in the morning, leather in the evening.
Google Active Sportarmband
Google’s perforated silicone sports band, with a plastic clasp and stainless steel attachments. According to Google, it is sweat- and water-resistant. Both lengths are included; on the 45 mm watch, the small one covers 150 to 180 mm and the large one 165 to 215 mm. Be sure to buy the version for your case size.
Google Handgefertigtes Lederarmband
Google’s handcrafted band of Italian leather with a stainless steel buckle and attachments, in two lengths from 140 to 180 and 175 to 215 mm. Google states clearly that it is neither sweat- nor water-resistant. A dry cloth is enough for cleaning; according to the instructions, you should not use leather cleaner. For a watch that goes straight from the desk to the restaurant, it is the more fitting choice.
Original or third-party, and what about your skin?
Google states openly in its help pages that third-party bands may not fit properly and may contain materials that cause skin irritation. Samsung likewise recommends its own bands for reasons of fit. For its own metal bands, Google states that any nickel content is below the limits of the European REACH regulation. If you already react to nickel, have a doctor clarify which materials are safe for you before buying.
One practical tip from Google’s care instructions applies to every watch. Take it off before applying sunscreen or insect repellent, and let the band and your wrist dry after a workout. Google cleans sports bands with warm water and, if needed, hypoallergenic soap, and leather only with a cloth.
How we would decide
- Galaxy Watch8 or Watch9 and sports: the Samsung Sport Band, length according to wrist size.
- Galaxy Watch and sleep tracking: the Fabric Band with hook-and-loop fastener.
- Galaxy Watch8 with a bolder look: Spigen DuraPro Armor, provided your model is listed.
- Garmin for workouts: QuickFit silicone in your watch’s width, never guessed.
- Garmin at the office: QuickFit leather as a second band.
- Pixel Watch: Active Sportarmband for sports, the leather band for everything else.
No watch yet? Then our smartwatch guide (in German) helps before the band question.
If a new watch is on the cards, our Black Friday smartwatch guide (in German) helps you compare the versions.
Frequently asked questions
Do old Samsung bands fit the Galaxy Watch8?
No. According to Samsung, the Galaxy Watch8 uses a new, proprietary attachment and does not accept bands from earlier models. Bands for the Watch8, Watch8 Classic and Watch9 are interchangeable. The Watch4 to Watch7, by contrast, have a 20 mm connection width, and the Galaxy Watch Ultra 34 mm.
What band width does my Garmin have?
Garmin works in widths. The fēnix 9 takes a 20 mm QuickFit band in the 43 mm size, a 22 mm band in 47 mm and a 26 mm band in 51 mm. A 22 mm band does not fit a 43 mm fēnix. If the description does not say QuickFit, read the list of compatible watches carefully.
How do I find the right band length?
With a tape measure around your wrist where the watch sits. The ranges differ: a Samsung Sport Band in S/M covers 130 to 185 mm, a 22 mm Garmin silicone band 125 to 208 mm. Google advises choosing the smaller size if in doubt.
Why is a loose band bad for heart rate tracking?
The heart rate sensor needs skin contact. Garmin writes that a band that is too loose can make heart rate measurement less accurate; one finger's width of space between band and skin is a good guideline. Google recommends wearing the watch two to three finger widths above the wrist bone during workouts.
Silicone or leather for a smartwatch?
Garmin recommends silicone for running, cycling and swimming because it absorbs hardly any moisture. Leather belongs in the office; Google explicitly classifies its leather bands as neither sweat- nor water-resistant. With QuickFit, switching takes only seconds: silicone in the morning, leather in the evening.
Are third-party bands safe?
Google writes that third-party bands may not fit properly and may contain materials that cause skin irritation. Samsung recommends its own bands for reasons of fit. If you react to nickel, have a doctor clarify which materials are safe for you before buying.
Sources
- Samsung: Galaxy Watch band compatibility
- Samsung: Sport Band (S/M) for the Galaxy Watch9
- Samsung: Fabric Band (S/M) for the Galaxy Watch9
- Spigen: DuraPro Armor band for the Galaxy Watch8
- Garmin: QuickFit bands (22 mm)
- Garmin: fēnix 9, technical specifications
- Garmin: Which fēnix 9 band suits you?
- Garmin: fēnix 9 manual, changing QuickFit bands
- Google: Pixel Watch and bands, technical specifications
- Google: Finding your band size and attaching the band
- Google: Cleaning and caring for your Pixel Watch
Where to buy
- Samsung Sport Band Galaxy Watch9 (S/M, Schwarz)Check price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Samsung Fabric Band Galaxy Watch9Check price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Spigen DuraPro ArmorCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Garmin QuickFit 22 SilikonCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Garmin QuickFit 22 LederCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Google Active SportarmbandCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Google Handgefertigtes LederarmbandCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
