Contents11 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
Just before seven, fresh snow outside, and the sidewalk in front of the house has to be clear. That is the moment you find out whether the shovel suits the path. For a sidewalk one and a half meters wide, a blade of around 50 to 55 centimeters with a metal edge is enough, which is why most people end up with the WOLF-Garten SN-M 55 with an aluminum handle. If there is a long driveway too, add a snow pusher. Buying too wide is a common mistake.
A simple tool where a few details count
A snow shovel is a simple device. That is exactly why a few details decide whether it is still up to the job after the third winter or lies in the garage with a splintered edge.
First, the width. For sidewalks, landings and the path to the front door, 40 to 55 centimeters is enough. From about 70 centimeters, it counts as a snow pusher, which pushes snow instead of lifting it and tends to get in the way on narrow paths.
Plastic is the usual choice for the blade: light and rustproof. Reputable manufacturers state in degrees how much frost it can take; for the models here, between minus 28 and minus 40 degrees. If that figure is missing, it is a risk in severe frost. At the bottom, a strip of aluminum, stainless steel or galvanized steel protects the plastic blade and scrapes off packed snow better. Plastic edges are quieter but wear faster on paving.
That leaves the handle. A D-grip makes two-handed guiding easier, and a telescopic handle helps especially when people of different heights clear snow or the shed is full. With Gardena combisystem and WOLF-Garten multi-star, heads fit onto existing handles, which saves money and storage space. Conversely, it is worth a second look to check whether the handle is included at all.
When you have to clear snow is up to your municipality
There is no uniform nationwide rule for winter maintenance in Germany. Cities and municipalities transfer the duty to clear and grit to the owners of adjacent properties by local ordinance, and the details vary from place to place. One example is the street cleaning and fee ordinance of the city of Dortmund: there, the sidewalk must be clear to a width of at least 1.5 meters. Between 7 a.m. and 8 p.m., snow is cleared as soon as it has stopped snowing. Snow that falls after 8 p.m. must be removed by 7 a.m. on working days and by 9 a.m. on Sundays and public holidays. Gritting is done with abrasive materials such as sand or chippings; de-icing agents only where necessary to prevent danger.
According to the city of Dortmund, owners can pass the duty on through the lease or a property management company. So whether you have to clear snow as a tenant is stated in your contract. Which version applies where you live is set out in your municipality’s street cleaning ordinance, usually published on its website. Incidentally, the 1.5 meters are where the rule of thumb from the beginning comes from. With a 55-centimeter blade, that means three passes.
Six snow shovels and snow pushers side by side
| Model | Width | Blade, edge, handle | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| WOLF-Garten SN-M 55/ZM-AD 120 | 55 cm | Plastic to −30 °C, aluminum profile edge, aluminum handle with D-grip | Sidewalk and driveway, complete package |
| Gardena combisystem-Schneeschieber ES 50 | 50 cm | Plastic to −40 °C, stainless steel edge, handle sold separately | Anyone who already has a combisystem handle |
| Prosperplast Alpe 50 Eco Telescopic | 49 cm | Plastic, aluminum edge, telescopic handle 122–160 cm | Changing users, little storage space |
| Gardena Schneewanne | 70 cm | Plastic to −40 °C, galvanized steel edge, telescopic handle | Driveways and yards |
| Fiskars SnowXpert Schneewanne | 72 cm | Plastic blade, steel handle, around 150 cm long | Large areas, lots of fresh snow |
| Prosperplast Arctic | 80 cm | Plastic to −28 °C, aluminum edge, metal handle, wheels | Long, level driveways |
WOLF-Garten SN-M 55/ZM-AD 120
A shovel from the multi-star range, an aluminum handle with a D-grip, done. According to WOLF-Garten, the plastic blade is impact-resistant in cold down to minus 30 degrees and resistant to road salt, and an aluminum profile edge protects the underside. WOLF-Garten states a 35-year warranty. At 55 centimeters, the shovel clears passes quickly and still stays narrow enough for stair landings.
Gardena combisystem-Schneeschieber ES 50
Impact-resistant in cold down to minus 40 degrees and salt-resistant: that is how Gardena describes the plastic blade. According to Gardena, the rustproof stainless steel edge is intended for smooth surfaces such as concrete and asphalt. The handle, however, is missing; Gardena recommends a 130-centimeter combisystem aluminum handle. If you already have Gardena tools in the shed, you can hardly go wrong here. Starting from scratch means paying twice. According to Gardena, the 25-year warranty only applies after registration within three months.
We used the combisystem snow shovel ourselves in winter as part of our hands-on review of the Gardena combisystem. Gardena expressly recommends the fixed handle for it, not the short telescopic handle.
Prosperplast Alpe 50 Eco Telescopic
The Polish manufacturer combines a 49-centimeter plastic blade with an aluminum edge and a telescopic handle that, according to the data sheet, adjusts between 122 and 160 centimeters. Practical when teenagers and adults take turns clearing snow. This Eco version has no temperature rating. A two-year warranty is considerably less than with WOLF-Garten or Gardena.
Gardena Schneewanne
Built for driveways, not narrow paths: a 70-centimeter working width. Gardena states a cold-resistant plastic blade down to minus 40 degrees, a galvanized steel edge and a telescopic handle that adjusts in three stages by around 30 centimeters in total. Gardena says nothing about the weight.
Fiskars SnowXpert Schneewanne
The Fiskars snow pusher is 72 centimeters wide and just under 150 centimeters long. It is expressly designed for pushing large amounts, not lifting, and that fits its weight of around four kilograms, which you feel at the snow pile. For a single sidewalk, you are better off with the shovel.
Prosperplast Arctic
Wider than the other five: 80 centimeters. Prosperplast states a powder-coated metal handle, an aluminum edge, wheels for easier pushing, cold resistance down to minus 28 degrees and a three-year warranty. On long, level driveways, the wide blade plays to its strengths. On cobblestones, steps or narrow paths, it quickly becomes unwieldy.
Which shovel for which path
In front of a townhouse with a normal sidewalk, we would take the WOLF-Garten SN-M 55 with handle. Width, edge and cold resistance are right, and you do not have to buy anything extra. If Gardena handles already hang on the shed wall, the combisystem-Schneeschieber ES 50 is the obvious choice; without an existing handle, it becomes a hassle.
If several people clear snow and space is tight, the Prosperplast Alpe 50 Eco Telescopic fits, with the shorter warranty as the trade-off. For a double garage or a yard, add a snow pusher from Gardena or Fiskars on top of the shovel. The pusher cannot replace the shovel. And the long, smooth driveway is the territory of the Prosperplast Arctic with wheels, which is oversized for normal sidewalks.
Whatever the model: store it dry and check the edge before winter sets in. Gardena sells a worn strip as a spare part. And because leaves cover the same areas in the fall, the leaf blower is the counterpart for the other season.
Frequently asked questions
How wide should a snow shovel for the sidewalk be?
For sidewalks, landings and the path to the front door, 40 to 55 centimeters is enough. If a sidewalk has to be cleared to a width of 1.5 meters, that means three passes with a 55-centimeter blade. From about 70 centimeters, it counts as a snow pusher, which tends to get in the way on narrow paths.
Which edge makes sense on a snow shovel?
A strip of aluminum, stainless steel or galvanized steel protects the plastic blade and scrapes off packed snow better. Plastic edges are quieter but wear faster on paving. It is worth checking the edge before winter; Gardena sells a worn strip as a spare part.
What is the difference between a snow shovel and a snow pusher?
A snow pusher is about 70 centimeters wide or more and pushes the snow instead of lifting it. It belongs to the double garage, the yard or the long driveway. The Fiskars SnowXpert weighs around four kilograms and is expressly designed for pushing large amounts; for a single sidewalk, the shovel is the better fit.
Do I have to clear snow as a tenant?
That is stated in your lease. In Germany, municipalities transfer the duty to clear and grit to property owners by local ordinance, and according to the city of Dortmund, owners can pass it on through the lease or a property management company. Which rules apply where you live is set out in your municipality's street cleaning ordinance.
Is a snow shovel without a handle worth it?
The Gardena combisystem-Schneeschieber ES 50 comes without a handle; Gardena recommends a 130-centimeter aluminum handle. If you already have combisystem handles in the shed, it is the obvious choice and saves storage space. If you are starting from scratch, however, you pay twice and are better off with a complete package.
When does a telescopic handle make sense?
A telescopic handle helps when people of different heights clear snow or the shed is full. According to the data sheet, the Prosperplast Alpe 50 Eco Telescopic adjusts between 122 and 160 centimeters. The drawbacks the guide mentions are the shorter two-year warranty and the missing temperature rating.
Sources
- WOLF-Garten: Snow shovel SN-M 55/ZM-AD 120
- Gardena: combisystem-Schneeschieber ES 50
- Gardena: Schneewanne
- Gardena: Replacement stainless steel edge 50 cm
- Prosperplast: Alpe 50 Eco Telescopic
- Prosperplast: Arctic
- Fiskars: SnowXpert Schneewanne
- City of Dortmund: Winter maintenance, gritting and clearing duty (street cleaning and fee ordinance)
Where to buy
- WOLF-Garten SN-M 55/ZM-AD 120Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Gardena combisystem-Schneeschieber ES 50Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Prosperplast Alpe 50 Eco TelescopicCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Gardena SchneewanneCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Fiskars SnowXpert SchneewanneCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Prosperplast ArcticCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
