Contents16 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
With a solid wood bed, the type of wood has less impact on everyday life than two numbers that rarely appear at the top of the brochure: the height of the bed edge and the recess depth of the frame. For most couples, we consider the Hasena Trento Asti in oiled wild oak the most well-rounded choice, because width, length and leg height can be ordered to suit. If you want a high entry or are on the heavier side, take a look at the Erst-Holz 60.81-14. And if you need storage space, you will end up with the pine bed 60.33-14 with three drawers.
Oak, beech or pine: how big is the difference really?
Smaller than many people think. In the hardness table from the German building reference Baunetz Wissen, beech (3.8) and oak (3.7) are practically level, while spruce, a typical softwood, comes in at 1.6. Pine is not in the table but is also a softwood. If you are worried about dents from the vacuum cleaner tube, beech or oak is the better choice.
Visually, the woods differ more clearly. According to Hasena, wild oak shows natural knots, cracks and medullary rays, while heartwood beech shows its dark core. If you want a calm look, choose natural beech or light oak. Do not be put off by „glued laminated strips“: this means solid wood made from glued lamellas, as Erst-Holz states for its oak bed 60.88, not veneer. Color variants are a different matter: in some series, Hasena also offers MDF or a „beech imitation.“ So check the material line for every single version.
How high should the bed edge be?
The range is wide. Erst-Holz states a bed edge of 31.5 cm for the storage bed 60.33, around 37 cm for the oak bed 60.88, just under 40 cm for the beech bed 60.73 and a seat height of about 50 cm for the high model 60.81. The mattress comes on top of that. A simple test in the store, or on a chair of the same height, helps: if both feet rest flat on the floor while you sit and your knees are at roughly a right angle, it fits.
Hasena solves this with the legs. For the Asti and Ancona, there are 20 or 25 cm legs, and the frame itself is 16 cm high. Do not forget the clearance under the bed if a robot vacuum is supposed to drive underneath. With Erst-Holz, it ranges from about 22 to 30 cm depending on the model.
Will my mattress fit the frame?
This is where the most annoying bad buys happen. The recess depth tells you how much room remains between the support ledge and the top edge, and it varies between 13 cm on the oak bed 60.88 and 16 cm on Hasena and the Erst-Holz 60.81. If a 22 cm mattress sits on a slatted base in a 13 cm frame, it sticks out well above the edge. Conversely, a thin roll-up mattress almost disappears in a deep frame. You will find the right mattress in our mattress guide; then do the math.
From a width of 140 cm, the center beam comes into play. Ikea does not include one with the Tarva frame; it is recommended as an accessory. For any bed, ask whether a center rail and support leg are in the box. Without support in the middle, the frame alone carries the load on wide beds. Which slatted base fits underneath is covered in our slatted bed base guide (in German).
Which width for whom?
140 cm is comfortably enough for one person. For two, each gets 70 cm, narrower than the smallest single width Hasena offers for the Ancona (90 cm). Couples are much better off with 160 or 180 cm, and 180 cm has a practical advantage: two separate 90 cm mattresses fit, each with its own firmness. Taller people should look for a length of 210 cm, which Hasena offers for the Asti and Ancona.
Do I need bed drawers?
Only if you really lack closet space. On the Erst-Holz 60.33, one long and two short drawers run on casters, all 23.5 cm high, and the bottom is made of coated HDF board. In return, a bed like this carries less. Erst-Holz states 130 kg for this bed and 200 kg for the high beech bed. There is also less air circulation under a closed drawer unit. If you are looking for plenty of storage and an easy entry, read our box spring bed guide for comparison.
Oil or lacquer: which is less work?
Lacquer is more convenient. For lacquered solid wood, Hasena recommends a dust cloth and a damp cloth, but no harsh cleaners. Oiled wood feels warmer and scratches can be touched up in spots, but it needs attention: according to Hasena, apply a thin coat of a standard wood care oil with a cloth every one to three years, and never use sprays, polishes or silicone-based cleaners, because they leave stains. Brand-new bed? Wipe off excess oil and air the room well.
Untreated wood, as on the Ikea Tarva, is the third option. Ikea itself recommends oiling, staining or lacquering it to make it less delicate. That takes time before the first night.
Six solid wood beds compared
| Model | Wood and finish | Height and recess depth | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hasena Trento Asti | Natural wild oak, oiled; runners of metal and wood | Legs 20 or 25 cm, frame 16 cm | Couples who want to choose size and height freely |
| Hasena Trento Ancona | Wild oak or heartwood beech, oiled (also lacquered MDF) | Legs 20 or 25 cm, frame 16 cm | Single bed to double bed, 90 to 200 cm wide |
| Erst-Holz 60.88-14 | Solid oak, glued laminated strips, oiled | Bed edge approx. 37 cm, recess depth approx. 13 cm | Oak without a rustic look, thin mattresses |
| Erst-Holz 60.73-14 | Solid beech, natural lacquer | Bed edge 39.5 cm, recess depth approx. 15.5 cm | Easy-care beech bed with headboard |
| Erst-Holz 60.81-14 | Solid beech, clear lacquer | Seat height approx. 50 cm, recess depth approx. 16 cm | High entry, body weight up to 200 kg |
| Erst-Holz 60.33-14 | Solid pine, clear lacquer, bed drawers | Bed edge 31.5 cm | Small bedrooms with little closet space |
Hasena Trento Asti
The bed from the Swiss brand stands on curved runners of metal and wood and is available in widths of 140, 160, 180 and 200 cm and lengths of 200 or 210 cm. Besides natural wild oak, Hasena offers beech, light oak and walnut, all oiled. There is no bed drawer option. For us, this is the most balanced package, because you do not leave the sleeping height and size to chance.
Hasena Trento Ancona
Plainer, with slim legs and considerably more widths, from 90 to 200 cm. That lets you furnish a guest bed and the main bedroom in the same look. Pay attention to the finish when ordering: besides oiled wild oak, heartwood beech and walnut, white lacquered MDF is also on the list.
Erst-Holz 60.88-14
An oak double bed with 8 cm thick posts and a headboard just over 75 cm high. Erst-Holz specifies a maximum load of 190 kg per side. The recess depth of 13 cm is tight; very thick mattresses look perched on top here.
Erst-Holz 60.73-14
A classic beech bed with a 75 cm headboard and a 40 cm footboard, natural lacquer and weighing around 52 kg. According to the manufacturer, it carries up to about 150 kg. If you do not feel like re-oiling, this is the right bed, but you also do not get any special grain.
Erst-Holz 60.81-14
With 10 × 10 cm posts and a weight of 55 kg, the sturdiest of the four Erst-Holz frames. The seat height of about 50 cm makes getting up noticeably easier, and the clearance under the bed is around 30 cm. The manufacturer states a body weight of up to 200 kg. For shorter people, it may be too high.
Erst-Holz 60.33-14
Pine in country-house style, with a valance panel and a three-part drawer unit on casters. The low edge of 31.5 cm suits younger people and sloped ceilings. At 130 kg, however, Erst-Holz states the lowest load capacity of its four beds here.
And Team 7, Thielemeyer or Ikea?
Team 7 treats its surfaces exclusively with natural oil and manufactures in Upper Austria with its own sawmill; it sells through its own stores and dealers, with an online configurator. Thielemeyer builds, for example, the Cubo bed in solid wild ash or wild oak, also through specialist retailers and in custom sizes on request. Both are bought with advice in the store. The counterpart is the Ikea Tarva in untreated solid pine with 20 cm of floor clearance, a solid blank for people who like to oil it themselves.
How we would decide
- Couple, 160 or 180 cm, and the wood should be visible: Hasena Trento Asti in wild oak, 25 cm legs.
- Single bed or guest room in the same look: Hasena Trento Ancona in 90 or 100 cm.
- Oak without a knotty look and with sturdy posts: Erst-Holz 60.88-14; do not choose too thick a mattress.
- Low maintenance: Erst-Holz 60.73-14 in lacquered beech.
- Knee or back problems, higher body weight: Erst-Holz 60.81-14.
- Storage in a small room: Erst-Holz 60.33-14 with bed drawers.
If you want an upholstered frame, the upholstered bed guide will help.
What load capacity specifications really mean is explained in our guide to heavy-duty solid wood beds.
Frequently asked questions
Which wood is harder: oak, beech or pine?
The difference is smaller than you might think. In the hardness table from Baunetz Wissen, beech at 3.8 and oak at 3.7 are practically level, while spruce, a typical softwood, comes in at 1.6. Pine is also a softwood. If you are worried about dents from the vacuum cleaner tube, beech or oak is the better choice.
How high should the bed edge be?
A simple test helps: if both feet rest flat on the floor while you sit and your knees are at roughly a right angle, the height is right. For the beds mentioned, the range runs from 31.5 cm on the Erst-Holz 60.33 to a seat height of about 50 cm on the 60.81, plus the mattress. Hasena adjusts the height with 20 or 25 cm legs.
Will my mattress fit any bed frame?
Not necessarily; the recess depth is what counts. It varies between 13 cm on the Erst-Holz 60.88 and 16 cm on Hasena and the 60.81. A 22 cm mattress on a slatted base sticks out well above the edge of a 13 cm frame, while a thin roll-up mattress almost disappears in a deep frame.
What bed width do couples need?
At 140 cm, each person gets only 70 cm, narrower than the smallest single width of 90 cm for the Hasena Ancona. Couples are much better off with 160 or 180 cm. At 180 cm, two separate 90 cm mattresses fit, each with its own firmness. Taller people should also look for a length of 210 cm.
Which is easier to care for: oiled or lacquered wood?
Lacquer is more convenient: for it, Hasena recommends a dust cloth and a damp cloth, but no harsh cleaners. Oiled wood feels warmer and scratches can be touched up in spots, but according to Hasena it needs a thin coat of wood care oil every one to three years. Sprays, polishes and silicone-based cleaners leave stains on oiled wood.
Does a wide bed need a center beam?
From a width of 140 cm it matters, because without support in the middle the frame alone carries the load. Ikea does not include one with the Tarva frame and recommends it as an accessory. So for any bed, ask whether a center rail and support leg are in the box.
Sources
- Hasena: Asti bed (Trento)
- Hasena: Ancona bed (Trento)
- Hasena: Care tips
- Erst-Holz: Oiled oak double bed 60.88-14
- Erst-Holz: Solid beech bed 60.73-14
- Erst-Holz: High beech double bed 60.81-14
- Erst-Holz: Double bed with storage drawers 60.33-14
- Team 7: Natural wood furniture
- Thielemeyer: Cubo
- Ikea: Tarva bed frame, pine
- Baunetz Wissen: Brinell hardness
Where to buy
- Hasena Trento Asti Wildeiche (180 x 200 cm)Check price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Hasena Trento Ancona WildeicheCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Erst-Holz 60.88-14 Eiche geöltCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Erst-Holz 60.73-14 Buche naturCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Erst-Holz 60.81-14 hohes Doppelbett BucheCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Erst-Holz 60.33-14 mit StaukastenCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
