Contents9 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
A water carafe often sits on the table all day and gets refilled every day. So what matters is less the shape than whether you can get it clean. If your hand reaches the bottom, residue and limescale are easy to wipe out. With slim carafes, on the other hand, the bottle brush is your only option, and anyone who has ever tried to get at a greenish ring at the bottom of a narrow carafe knows how tedious that becomes over time. We have been using a glass carafe with a wide opening and a stainless steel lid for quite a while and compare it here with four other models.
What matters
Opening: The most important point. Always. If a hand with a cloth fits inside, the carafe is clean in a minute. Slim carafes with a narrow neck look elegant but need a bottle brush and dry poorly on the inside.
Material: Borosilicate glass tolerates temperature changes better than ordinary glass, so you can also pour in warm tea. It is not protected against impacts, though, as we found out ourselves. Stainless steel does not break. In return, you see neither the fill level nor the limescale building up inside, and you have to rely on looking in regularly. Pressed glass, as used in classic open water jugs, is thicker and sturdier but cannot handle hot drinks.
Lid: Do you need one? Outdoors and in summer, yes, because a lid keeps out dust and insects. Stainless steel lids with a silicone or rubber ring sit tightly, and many have a strainer that holds back lemon slices or mint. The ring should be removable; otherwise dirt collects underneath.
Removing limescale and clouding
With hard water, a white ring quickly forms on the glass. The consumer advice center Verbraucherzentrale NRW in Germany names organic acids such as vinegar or citric acid as environmentally friendly descalers. Afterward, rinse thoroughly with clear water. If the glass still stays milky, according to the German consumer magazine Öko-Test it is often not limescale but glass corrosion caused by the dishwasher. That cannot be removed with acid. This is one reason many manufacturers recommend washing glass carafes by hand. Rubber rings on the lid do not hold up well to concentrated vinegar and should be removed before descaling.
Five carafes compared
| Model | Material and capacity | Lid | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| SUSTEAS Glaskaraffe 2,0 l | Borosilicate glass, 2.0 l, wide opening | Stainless steel with rubber ring and spout | Those who drink a lot and want to clean thoroughly (tested by us) |
| Arendo Glaskaraffe 2,0 l | Borosilicate glass, 2.0 l | Stainless steel with silicone seal and coarse filter | The same design, in the range of OTTO (German retailer) |
| Ritzenhoff & Breker Perfetto 1,4 l | Glass, 1.4 l, slim shape | Stainless steel with silicone lips, 360-degree spout with filter slots | Those looking for a narrow carafe for the fridge |
| WMF Wasserkaraffe Basic 1,5 l | Cromargan stainless steel, 1.5 l | Flip closure with strainer, opens when pouring | Those who want an unbreakable carafe |
| WMF Wasserkaraffe Basic 1 l | Glass, 1 l, large opening | Flip closure with strainer | Small households, guest table |
SUSTEAS Glaskaraffe 2,0 l
Our own. According to the listing, it is made of borosilicate glass for minus 20 to 150 degrees, with a stainless steel lid, rubber ring and spout. The wide opening lets a hand reach the bottom, so wiping out and descaling go quickly. Our first one did break, however, and we bought a replacement. We give it four out of five stars; the details are in our review of the SUSTEAS glass carafe.
Arendo Glaskaraffe 2,0 l
Almost identical in design. Borosilicate glass, 2 liters, a stainless steel lid with a silicone seal and a coarse filter opening that holds back ice cubes and fruit. That is how the listing describes it. It is also available with 1.7 and 2.5 liters. We did not measure how wide the opening is compared with the SUSTEAS.
Ritzenhoff & Breker Perfetto 1,4 l
A slim glass carafe whose stainless steel lid does not have to be removed for pouring: according to the manufacturer, the drink flows through a narrow annular gap, while fine slots hold back fruit and ice cubes. Narrow. It fits well in the fridge door. For cleaning? Your hand barely reaches the bottom, so it is brush time.
WMF Wasserkaraffe Basic
WMF offers the Basic in two versions. The 1.5-liter version is made of Cromargan stainless steel and is therefore unbreakable, but you cannot see the fill level. The glass version holds 1 liter. Both have the CloseUp closure, which according to WMF opens automatically when pouring and closes when you set the carafe down, with an integrated strainer. According to WMF, the carafes fit into the bottle compartments of standard refrigerators. Practical.
How we would choose
- A lot of water per day, thorough cleaning matters: a bulbous glass carafe with a wide opening such as the SUSTEAS or the Arendo.
- Little space in the fridge: Ritzenhoff & Breker Perfetto.
- Children in the house or worried about broken glass: WMF Basic in stainless steel.
- Small household, guest table: WMF Basic in glass with 1 liter.
For tea, a pot with an infuser is better suited than a carafe; models for that are in our teapot guide.
Frequently asked questions
How do you get limescale out of a glass carafe?
Soak it with diluted vinegar or citric acid, wipe it out and rinse thoroughly with clear water. Remove the rubber rings on the lid first.
Why does a glass carafe turn milky?
Often it is not a layer of limescale but glass corrosion from the dishwasher. According to Öko-Test, it cannot be removed with acid; washing by hand prevents it.
Is borosilicate glass shatterproof?
It tolerates temperature changes better than ordinary glass, but it is not protected against impacts. A stainless steel carafe will not break.
Which carafe is easiest to clean?
A bulbous carafe with a wide opening that lets a hand reach all the way to the bottom. With slim models, you need a bottle brush.
Sources
- Verbraucherzentrale NRW: Descaling the environmentally friendly way
- Öko-Test: When glasses turn milky
Where to buy
- SUSTEAS Glaskaraffe 2,0 lCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Arendo Glaskaraffe 2,0 lView at OTTOAvailable in Germany: OTTO
- Ritzenhoff & Breker Perfetto 1,4 lView at OTTOAvailable in Germany: OTTO
- WMF Wasserkaraffe Basic 1,5 lView at OTTOAvailable in Germany: OTTO
- WMF Wasserkaraffe Basic 1 lView at OTTOAvailable in Germany: OTTO
