Contents10 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
One pair of cut-resistant gloves for everything: that is the typical purchase at the start of a big project. It usually goes wrong. Sorting screws takes feel in your fingertips, cutting sheet metal takes a high cut level, and stacking firewood in January is mostly about keeping your hands warm. For the workshop and garden, we therefore recommend a thin, coated assembly glove such as the uvex phynomic wet, plus a second pair that matches the one dangerous job exactly.
Gloves are cheap. Stitches in a finger are not.
What the numbers on the glove tell you
Protection against mechanical hazards is tested under the European standard EN 388; the current version is EN 388:2016+A1:2018. Next to the pictogram you will find four digits, a letter and sometimes a P, always in this order:
- Abrasion, level 1 to 4
- Cut in the Coupe test with a rotating circular blade, level 1 to 5
- Tear, level 1 to 4
- Puncture, level 1 to 4
- Cut according to EN ISO 13997 with a straight blade, letter A to F
- P, if the glove was tested for impact protection
An X means: not tested. With modern cut-resistant yarns containing glass or steel fibers, it often appears in the second position, because such fibers dull the circular blade. In that case the letter at the end counts. It states the force at which a straight blade cuts through the material in a single stroke; according to uvex, A starts at 2 newtons, B at 5, C at 10, D at 15, E at 22 and F at 30 newtons. The two methods cannot be converted into each other. A 5 in the Coupe test is not an F.
For protection against cold, EN 511 applies. As described by Suva, the Swiss accident insurance institution, it covers convective and contact cold down to minus 50 degrees Celsius and additionally requires at least level 1 for abrasion and tear under EN 388. According to Ejendals, the three digits stand for convective cold (0 to 4), contact cold (0 to 4) and water resistance (0 or 1). Convective means cold air and wind. Contact means you grab something cold, such as a frozen fence post or tools that spent the night in the van. Neither standard has a digit for touchscreen compatibility; for that you have to rely on the manufacturer’s information.
Six pairs, four kinds of work
| Model | Rating (manufacturer information) | Design | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| uvex phynomic foam | EN 388: 3121X | Polyamide/elastane, aqua-polymer foam, dry to slightly damp | Fine assembly, sorting, furniture assembly |
| Ansell HyFlex 11-840 | EN 388: 4131A | Nitrile foam, 15 gauge, latex-free, touchscreen-compatible | Assembly with a phone or tablet within reach |
| uvex phynomic F XG | EN 388: 4X43F, EN 407: X1XXXX | Glass fiber, HPPE, steel; nitrile grip for oil; touchscreen-compatible | Sheet metal, glass, sharp-edged parts |
| uvex phynomic wet | EN 388: 3131X | Water-repellent aqua-polymer foam for wet conditions | Garden, wet workshop, maintenance |
| Showa 451 | EN 388: 2241X, EN 511: 01X | Thermal knit, rough natural latex palm | Cool days on the job site and in the yard |
| Tegera 517 | EN 388: 1121X, EN 511: 111 | Synthetic leather, fleece lining, waterproof and windproof | Wet and cold in winter |
Fine assembly in dry conditions: uvex phynomic foam
uvex hardly makes anything thinner. The polyamide and elastane knit is covered with an aqua-polymer foam on the palm and fingertips, and uvex lists fine assembly, inspection work and sorting as its uses. The 3121X rating, however, also shows its limit: cut level 1, no ISO value. When you are filing away a new screw assortment (in German), nobody minds. On sheet metal, you will.
Assembly with a display in hand: Ansell HyFlex 11-840
According to the retailer, the 11-840 is rated 4131A, meaning the highest abrasion level plus cut level A. The nylon-elastane knit is fine at 15 gauge and coated with nitrile foam, and according to Ansell the glove contains no latex. It is interesting for people who keep swiping through instructions on their phone during assembly or check the charge levels of their tools on a tablet in the workshop. Anyone currently thinking about a single battery platform (in German) knows the back and forth.
Sheet metal, glass, utility knife: uvex phynomic F XG
uvex itself specifies level F for very sharp-edged parts in metal and glass processing, and that is exactly where this glove belongs. Its rating is 4X43F, and the knit contains glass fiber, HPPE and steel. According to the manufacturer, the XtraGrip nitrile coating also grips on oily parts, you can operate touchscreens with it, and under EN 407 it is rated for contact heat up to 100 degrees Celsius. For weeding it would be a waste.
Garden and wet workshop: uvex phynomic wet
At first glance, a twin of the foam. According to uvex, however, the charcoal coating stays grippy in damp and wet areas and repels water; the rating is 3131X. Repotting plants, carrying wet boards, cleaning the mower at the end of the season: that is what it is built for. Thorny roses are another matter; puncture level 1 speaks for itself.
Cool mornings on the job site: Showa 451
A classic thermal knit glove with a seamless liner of acrylic, cotton and polyester and a rough natural latex palm. Showa lists EN 388 2241X and EN 511 01X in its data sheet. That means level 0 against cold air, level 1 against contact cold, and water was not tested. For bricklaying on an October morning that is enough. In freezing weather, probably not. If you have a latex allergy, it is out.
Frost and sleet: Tegera 517
Ejendals sells the 517 as a lightweight winter glove with a synthetic leather palm, polyester back and fleece lining. EN 511 111 stands for level 1 each against convective and contact cold plus a passed water test, and according to the manufacturer it is also waterproof and windproof. Mechanically, at 1121X, it remains modest. It is a good fit for loading the trailer in December; if, on the other hand, you stand still for hours in sustained frost, take a look at heated gloves.
And Engelbert Strauss, the German workwear brand? It carries a large selection of its own gloves, but on Amazon.de, the German Amazon store, they are only available from third-party sellers whose standard ratings contradict each other. Individual models show up there only through third-party sellers, some with contradictory standard information in the listing, which is why the brand is missing from the table.
Four jobs, four answers
- Assembly: In dry conditions, the uvex phynomic foam is enough. If a display is constantly in use, go for the Ansell HyFlex 11-840.
- Cutting: Sheet metal, glass and utility knives call for a high ISO letter, such as the uvex phynomic F XG with level F. An X in the second position is not a flaw here.
- Cold: In cool, dry air, the Showa 451 is enough. Once it gets wet and frosty, the Tegera 517 with its passed water test is the better fit.
- Garden: The uvex phynomic wet covers soil, water and the workshop. It is hardly suitable for thorns.
Our advice: two suitable pairs rather than one mediocre pair for everything. And before you order, read the rating on the glove first, then the name.
Frequently asked questions
What do the EN 388 numbers on work gloves mean?
The four digits stand for abrasion, cut in the Coupe test, tear and puncture, followed by a letter A to F for cut resistance according to EN ISO 13997, sometimes with a P for impact protection. An X means not tested. The two cut methods cannot be converted into each other; a 5 in the Coupe test is not an F.
Is an X in the second position a flaw?
No. Modern cut-resistant yarns with glass or steel fibers often show an X there, because such fibers dull the circular blade used in the Coupe test. In that case the letter at the end counts; it states the force at which a straight blade cuts through the material, which according to uvex is 30 newtons or more for F.
Which gloves for sheet metal and glass?
For very sharp-edged parts, uvex itself specifies cut level F. The uvex phynomic F XG, rated 4X43F, contains glass fiber, HPPE and steel, grips even on oily parts according to the manufacturer and lets you operate touchscreens. For weeding it would be overkill.
What does EN 511 cover for winter gloves?
It applies to protection against cold. According to Ejendals, the three digits stand for convective cold, meaning cold air and wind, for contact cold when touching cold objects, and for water resistance. The Tegera 517 achieves 111, while the Showa 451 is rated 01X, without a water test.
Which work gloves for fine assembly with a phone?
The Ansell HyFlex 11-840 is finely knitted at 15 gauge, coated with nitrile foam, latex-free and touchscreen-compatible according to the manufacturer. According to the retailer, it is rated 4131A. For dry assembly work without a display, the thinner uvex phynomic foam is enough.
Do garden gloves protect against thorns?
The uvex phynomic wet covers soil, water and the workshop, but only has puncture level 1. That makes it a poor choice for thorny roses. Before buying, read the rating on the glove first, then the name.
Sources
- uvex: cut protection gloves and levels according to EN ISO 13997
- uvex: EN 388:2003 compared to EN 388:2016
- uvex Australia: marking according to EN 388:2016
- Ejendals: EN 511 protection against cold
- Suva: standards for heat and cold protection gloves
- uvex phynomic foam
- uvex phynomic wet
- uvex phynomic F XG
- Ansell HyFlex 11-840
- Showa 451, data sheet
- Ejendals Tegera 517
Where to buy
- uvex phynomic wetCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- uvex phynomic foamCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Ansell HyFlex 11-840Check price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- uvex phynomic F XGCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Showa 451Check price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Tegera 517Check price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
