Contents11 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
A bag on the back of the front seat protects the upholstery from children’s shoes and keeps the coloring book, snacks and stuffed animal within reach. You should not expect more from it than that. For families with kids in the back seat, we consider a simple fabric bag such as the Walser Multibag the most sensible choice, and for the trunk a collapsible box that you place against the back seat and strap down. Anything heavy, hard or made of glass belongs loose in neither one nor the other.
Why is the cabin such a tricky place?
Because everything in it goes flying. According to ADAC Nordrhein, a regional branch of the German automobile club ADAC, in a head-on collision at 50 km/h every unsecured object shoots forward with 30 to 50 times its own weight. A one-liter water bottle then weighs as much as a 50-kilogram sack of potatoes. The club therefore advises against keeping glass bottles in the cabin.
The tablet is an issue, too. When a tablet, DVD player or laptop is not running during the drive, it has to be stowed securely, according to the ADAC, otherwise it can turn into a projectile in an accident. The side pocket on the seat back is a makeshift solution for this, not a safe.
Legally, the situation is clear. Section 22 of the German Road Traffic Regulations (StVO) requires that cargo does not shift, tip over or fall even during emergency braking or a sudden evasive maneuver. Anyone who violates this pays a warning fine, according to the ADAC; if someone is endangered or an accident occurs, the amount goes up, and on top of that comes a point in Germany’s central driving-offense register in Flensburg. Comprehensive car insurance (Kasko) does not have to cover damage caused by shifting cargo.
What actually helps in the trunk?
Being organized is not enough. The box also has to stay in place. The ADAC recommends packing without gaps, placing heavy and compact items at the bottom and as close as possible to the back seat, and securing everything to the existing lashing eyes with nets or ratchet straps. The club considers elastic bungee cords unsuitable for this. Loose small items belong in boxes.
That leads to a simple rule for buying one. A trunk box is good if it can be pushed up against the seat back and held with a strap, and if it lies flat in the trunk when empty. If you haul the weekly grocery run, put the heavy bottles at the bottom of the box and the eggs on top. Sounds obvious. In everyday life, though, the six-pack still quickly ends up on the bag with the bread.
Six organizers, sorted by where they go
| Model | Type and mounting | Dimensions and material (manufacturer) | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Walser Multibag | Seat-back bag, elastic straps | approx. 64 x 40 cm, 215 g, PVC-coated polyester | Families who mainly want to protect the upholstery |
| Walser Lucky Tom | Seat-back bag, strap with snap fastener around the headrest | 330 g, PU-coated polyester, three pockets with snap fasteners | Kids who grab books and lunch boxes themselves |
| Walser Maxi with tablet holder | Seat-back bag, strap around the headrest, hooks under the seat | approx. 51 x 38.5 cm, 290 g, tablets up to 10 inches | Long trips with a movie in the back seat |
| Britax Römer Rückenlehnen-Tasche (backrest bag) | Seat-back bag on the front seat | Britax Römer does not list dimensions or material online | Anyone who already uses a Britax Römer seat |
| Thule Go Box Medium / Large | Collapsible box with lid, no fastening | 61 x 36 x 30 cm or 61 x 46 x 30 cm, polyester | Station wagon, van, motorhome, gear with rain protection |
| Walser Toolbag L | Trunk bag, hook-and-loop strip | approx. 50 x 16 x 21 cm, 430 g, needle felt | Warning triangle, jumper cables, breakdown gear |
Walser Multibag: simple and light
At around 64 by 40 centimeters, the Multibag covers most of a front seat back. According to Walser, it is made of PVC-coated polyester, weighs 215 grams and hangs from elastic straps. Several large and small pockets hold books, sippy cups and toys. It may be hand-washed at a maximum of 40 degrees Celsius. We would pick it for the back seat. It does little, and it does it well.
Walser Lucky Tom: pockets that stay shut
Three of the pockets close with snap fasteners, and at the bottom there is a large open pocket for magazines or children’s books. The bag is attached with an adjustable strap that runs around the headrest. According to the manufacturer, the material is PU-coated polyester. The snap fasteners are an advantage if small items would otherwise slide out in every curve. Walser does not state the dimensions clearly on the product page, so measure your own seat back before buying.
Walser Maxi: organizer with a window for the tablet
At the top, the tablet sits behind a touch-sensitive protective film; according to Walser, devices up to 10 inches fit inside. At the back, a cable routing leads to the charging cable. Below that are pockets for toys. The bag is held at the top by a strap around the headrest and at the bottom by hooks under the front seat, so at two points instead of just one.
A screen at eye level has another side effect. The ADAC points out that children should not look down for too long so they do not get carsick. When no movie is playing, the tablet should still come out of the film sleeve and be stowed securely. Which device is suitable for kids is covered in our guide to kids‘ tablets (in German).
Britax Römer Rückenlehnen-Tasche: an accessory from the seat maker
Britax Römer lists the bag as an accessory for its child seats, from the Baby-Safe Pro infant carrier to the King Pro. It attaches to the front seat, protects it from dirty feet and keeps toys, drinks and snacks within reach. The manufacturer does not list dimensions, number of pockets or material online. That makes comparison difficult. If you are ordering the bag with the seat anyway, you get a matching add-on; if you are free to choose, Walser provides more information. For help with the seat itself, see our guide to child car seats.
Thule Go Box: collapsible box with lid
The Go Box comes in two sizes, both 61 centimeters long and 30 centimeters high. Medium is 36 centimeters wide, Large 46. Thule describes the polyester as water-repellent, the foldable lid is meant to protect against rain, and a side pocket holds delicate items. When empty, the box folds flat. According to the manufacturer, it is designed for motorhomes, caravans, vans and minivans.
Thule does not mention any fastening or non-slip underside. In the trunk, that means: push it against the back seat, fill the gaps and hold it to the lashing eyes with a ratchet strap, just as the ADAC describes. The box is not made for skis or bulky items; a roof box (in German) is the better help there.
Walser Toolbag L: felt bag that grips the carpet
According to Walser, the Toolbag is made of felt (60 percent polyester, 40 percent polypropylene) and in size L measures about 50 by 16 by 21 centimeters at 430 grams. On the back is a long hook-and-loop strip; alternatively, there are snap fasteners with a self-adhesive counterpart. That is enough room for a warning triangle, first aid kit and jumper cables. Besides L, Walser offers sizes S and XXL.
How we would decide
- Small children, shoes against the seat back, stuff within reach: Walser Multibag; for small items that should not fall out, the Lucky Tom with snap fasteners.
- Long trips with a movie: Walser Maxi, and stow the tablet after the movie.
- Britax Römer seat already in the car: the manufacturer’s Rückenlehnen-Tasche, if the missing dimensions do not bother you.
- Groceries and gear in a station wagon or van: Thule Go Box, strapped down against the back seat.
- Breakdown gear that should not slide around: Walser Toolbag L.
And regardless of the model: glass bottles, tools and full thermoses do not go in the seat-back bag.
For a clean footwell in winter, the guide to car floor mats compares rubber, carpet and tray mats with high edges.
Frequently asked questions
Why are loose objects in a car dangerous?
According to ADAC Nordrhein, the regional branch of the German automobile club, in a head-on collision at 50 km/h every unsecured object shoots forward with 30 to 50 times its own weight. A one-liter water bottle then weighs as much as a 50-kilogram sack of potatoes. The club advises against keeping glass bottles in the cabin.
Can the tablet stay in the seat-back bag?
When a tablet, DVD player or laptop is not in use, it has to be stowed securely, according to the ADAC, otherwise it can become a projectile in an accident. The side pocket is a makeshift solution at best. Even with the Walser Maxi with tablet holder, the device comes out once the movie is over.
How do I secure a trunk box properly?
The ADAC recommends packing without gaps, placing heavy items at the bottom and close to the back seat, and securing everything to the lashing eyes with nets or ratchet straps. The club considers elastic bungee cords unsuitable. The Thule Go Box has no fastening of its own, so push it against the back seat and strap it down.
Which seat-back bag is practical for children?
At around 64 by 40 centimeters, the Walser Multibag covers almost the entire seat back and weighs 215 grams. On the Walser Lucky Tom, three pockets close with snap fasteners so small items do not slide out in curves. For the Britax Römer bag, the manufacturer does not list any dimensions online.
What does the law say about luggage in the cabin?
Section 22 of the German Road Traffic Regulations (StVO) requires that cargo does not shift or fall even during emergency braking or an evasive maneuver. If someone is endangered or an accident occurs, the ADAC says you face a point in Germany's central driving-offense register in Flensburg. Comprehensive car insurance (Kasko) does not have to cover damage caused by shifting cargo.
Where should the warning triangle and jumper cables go?
In a trunk bag that does not slide around. The Walser Toolbag L, made of felt, measures about 50 by 16 by 21 centimeters and holds onto the carpet with a long hook-and-loop strip. That is enough room for a warning triangle, first aid kit and jumper cables.
Sources
- ADAC: Securing cargo
- ADAC Nordrhein: The art of loading properly
- ADAC: Car trips with children
- Walser: Multibag
- Walser: Lucky Tom
- Walser: Maxi with tablet holder
- Walser: Toolbag L
- Britax Römer: Rückenlehnen-Tasche
- Thule: Go Box Medium
- Thule: Go Box Large
Where to buy
- Walser MultibagCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Walser Lucky TomCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Walser Maxi mit Tablet-HalterCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Britax Römer Rückenlehnen-TascheCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Thule Go BoxCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Walser Toolbag LCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
