Contents11 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
A casserole dish rarely fails because of its material. It fails because of the oven, since it is 42.5 centimeters long including the handles, or because of the freezer, from which, according to the manufacturer, it is not supposed to go straight into the heat at all. For two to four people, we consider a ceramic set in two sizes the most sensible choice, such as the Staub Ceramique set with 1.1 and 2.4 liters; if you regularly cook for guests, add a large dish of three liters or more.
Everything else is fine-tuning. But fine-tuning with consequences.
Ceramic, glass or cast iron: what the material says about handling
Ceramic and stoneware are the norm. They retain heat, look good when serving and are dishwasher-safe. Even so, the rules of use vary widely, even for similar dishes. According to its product page, Emile Henry allows a dish at −20 °C to go straight from the freezer into a hot oven. Le Creuset advises against exactly that for its stoneware: frozen food goes into a cold oven and heats up with it, an empty dish should not go into an oven above 205 °C, and liquid should only be poured into the hot dish after it has cooled briefly. Two dishes made of fired clay, two opposite instructions. What counts, therefore, are the instructions for the specific model, not the type of material.
Glass has a practical advantage that is easy to underestimate: you can see whether the potatoes on the bottom are already browning. Pyrex advertises high thermal shock resistance for borosilicate glass. How large a temperature difference a given set can handle is stated in its instructions, and you should check them before a frozen dish goes into a hot oven. The manufacturer makes no promise for larger jumps. So stick to the values in the instructions, even when you are in a hurry.
Cast iron is a special case. An enameled cast iron dish from Staub can go on any stovetop, including induction, and then into the oven. Onions and meat are seared in the same vessel in which everything is later baked. In return, the 30-centimeter dish weighs 3.2 kilograms empty, and Staub states 240 °C as the upper limit in the oven. That is less than the same manufacturer’s ceramic dishes can handle.
Porcelain, for example from Villeroy & Boch, looks the most refined and doubles as a serving platter. For gratins, it is perfectly adequate.
How big, how many, and why a set makes sense
A single large dish is usually too much for everyday use. A gratin for two spreads out so thinly in four liters that it dries out before the cheese browns. Conversely, a lasagna for six overflows a 2-liter dish. That is why sets with two sizes are worth a look. The manufacturer specifications help as a guide: Emile Henry calculates 10 to 12 servings for its four-liter dish, and Le Creuset offers its stoneware in 0.72, 1.4 and 3.2 liters.
Measure before you buy. The outer dimension with handles is what counts, not the length of the baking surface. Small secondary ovens in particular get tight, as our overview of mini ovens shows. And if you bake cakes and bread, you will find the right pans in our guide to bakeware (in German); a casserole dish does not replace a springform pan.
Six dishes side by side
| Model | Material | Size / capacity | Temperature according to the manufacturer | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Staub Ceramique set, 2 pieces, rectangular | Ceramic, glazed | 20 × 16 cm (1.1 l) and 27 × 20 cm (2.4 l) | −20 to 300 °C, broiler-safe too | Households of two to four people |
| Le Creuset stoneware casserole dish, 32 cm | Stoneware | 3.2 l (also 18 and 25 cm) | −23 to 260 °C | Families who like color on the table |
| Emile Henry large rectangular oven dish | Ceramic | 42.5 × 27.5 cm outside, 4 l | −20 to 270 °C | Dinner for guests, lasagna for many |
| Pyrex Essentials glass set, 35 × 23 and 40 × 27 cm | Borosilicate glass | two rectangular dishes | ovenproof, temperature changes according to the instructions | Anyone who wants to see how the food is cooking |
| Staub baking dish 30 × 20 cm, cast iron | Cast iron, enameled inside | 3.15 l, 3.2 kg | −20 to 240 °C, all stovetop types | Braised dishes with searing |
| Villeroy & Boch Clever Cooking 34 × 24 cm | Porcelain | 34 × 24 cm | up to 260 °C according to the Amazon listing | Dishes that go straight to the table |
Staub Ceramique set: two sizes, one stack
The two dishes nest inside each other, which matters more in the kitchen cabinet than any glaze. Zwilling, which owns Staub, states heat resistance up to 300 °C and suitability for the broiler, microwave, freezer and dishwasher; the dishes are made in France. The product page says nothing about going directly from the freezer into a hot oven. Some colors are temporarily sold out at the manufacturer.
Le Creuset stoneware: reliable, with clear rules
Le Creuset gives a ten-year warranty on its stoneware dishes and states −23 to 260 °C. Under the broiler, at least 6.5 cm of clearance from the heat source should remain. They are made in Thailand. The 2-piece set with 25 and 32 cm was most recently out of stock at the manufacturer, but the individual dishes were available. If you like to cook ahead and freeze, you have to be fine with the cold-oven rule.
Emile Henry: the large dish for guests
Inside, the dish measures 35.5 × 25.5 cm with a depth of 7 cm, plenty of room for a large lasagna. According to Emile Henry, the ceramic can handle 270 °C, the broiler and going directly from the freezer into a hot oven. Ten-year warranty, made in France. With an outer length of 42.5 cm, however, it does not fit in every oven. Measure first.
Pyrex Essentials: glass you can see through
The set of two rectangular glass dishes is the most no-frills solution here. For the limits on oven temperature and temperature changes, Pyrex refers to the instructions for each set. On the table, glass looks plainer than glazed ceramic. For make-ahead meals and weeknight casseroles, that hardly matters.
Staub cast iron baking dish: from stovetop to oven
This dish is more of a shallow roaster than a classic casserole dish. Sear on induction, deglaze, add cheese, into the oven. At 3.2 kilograms empty, it becomes a two-handed job when full. We would not buy it just for gratins; if you like braised dishes, you get two steps in one vessel.
Villeroy & Boch Clever Cooking: porcelain for the table
The 34 × 24 cm dish is made of premium porcelain and, according to the Amazon listing, is heat-resistant up to 260 °C as well as microwave- and dishwasher-safe. It is also available with a lid, which, according to Villeroy & Boch, can be used as a flat baking pan.
How we would decide
- Two to four people, gratins and casseroles during the week: the Staub Ceramique set with two sizes.
- Large family or frequent guests: Emile Henry at 42.5 cm, provided your oven has room for it.
- Cooking ahead and freezing: Emile Henry, because the manufacturer explicitly allows going straight from the freezer; with Pyrex, read the set’s instructions first, and with Le Creuset the cold-oven rule applies.
- Searing and baking in one vessel: the Staub cast iron dish.
- A dish that doubles as a serving platter: Villeroy & Boch or Le Creuset.
By the way, you do not need to replace your cookware set for this; what our guide to cookware sets covers applies to the stovetop, not the oven.
Frequently asked questions
Can a casserole dish go straight from the freezer into a hot oven?
That depends on the model, not the material. Emile Henry allows going directly from the freezer into a hot oven. Le Creuset advises against it for its stoneware; frozen dishes go into a cold oven there. What counts are the instructions for the specific dish.
Ceramic, glass or cast iron: which casserole dish is right?
Ceramic retains heat, looks good when serving and is dishwasher-safe. Glass shows whether the bottom of the casserole is already browning. Enameled cast iron can go on any stovetop and then into the oven, but weighs considerably more.
What size should a casserole dish be?
A single large dish is usually too much for everyday use: a gratin for two spreads out so thinly in four liters that it dries out. Conversely, a lasagna for six overflows a small dish. That is why sets with two sizes are worth it.
Does a large casserole dish fit in every oven?
Not necessarily. The large Emile Henry dish measures 42.5 cm long including the handles. What matters is the outer dimension with handles, not the baking surface. Small secondary ovens in particular get tight, so measure before you buy.
What is a cast iron casserole dish good for?
For braised dishes that are seared first and then baked. The Staub baking dish also works on induction. It weighs 3.2 kilograms empty, and Staub states 240 °C as the upper limit in the oven, less than for the same manufacturer's ceramic dishes.
Sources
- Le Creuset: Classic rectangular stoneware casserole dish
- Le Creuset: Set of two Classic rectangular casserole dishes
- Emile Henry: Large Rectangular Oven Dish
- Zwilling: Staub Ceramique oven dish set, 2 pieces, rectangular
- Zwilling: Staub baking dish 30 × 20 cm, cast iron
- Pyrex: Essentials rectangular glass roaster
- Villeroy & Boch: Clever Cooking rectangular baking dish with lid
Where to buy
- Staub Ceramique Auflaufform Set 2-tlg. rechteckigCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Le Creuset Auflaufform Steinzeug rechteckig 32 cm (kirschrot)Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Emile Henry große rechteckige AuflaufformCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Pyrex Essentials Glas-Auflaufformen Set 35 x 23 und 40 x 27 cmCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Staub Ofenform Gusseisen 30 x 20 cm (schwarz)Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Villeroy & Boch Clever Cooking Backform 34 x 24 cmCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
