Contents11 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
With a Christmas tree stand, things often go wrong before the tree is even bought. You take whatever stand happens to be at the hardware store and discover on Christmas Eve that the trunk is too thick or the water supply runs dry after one day. If you set up a tree up to about 2.5 meters, a stand with a foot pedal, single-cable system and a tank of around 3.5 liters is all you need, such as the Krinner Comfort Grip+ M. Larger trees need one thing above all: a wide base.
Measure the trunk first, then choose the stand
Every manufacturer specifies a maximum tree height. The real limit, however, is usually the trunk diameter. Most mid-range stands hold trunks up to 11 or 12 centimeters. A typical Nordmann fir in the living room fits. If you bring home a sturdy tree from the farm, measure at the bottom of the trunk after it has been freshly cut. One centimeter too much, and the knife comes out after all.
So choose the trunk diameter with a little margin. With a 12-centimeter limit, an 11-centimeter trunk fits comfortably.
Then the water tank. A real tree drinks a lot, especially in the first few days. A tank of three liters or more saves you from refilling under the branches every day. A water level indicator helps more than any liter figure.
The taller the tree, the wider the base should be. Krinner links the two visibly: 36 centimeters for a 2.5-meter tree, 52 centimeters for 4 meters. That leaves operation: a foot pedal and single cable can be handled by one person. Screws usually need two.
Single cable or screws?
With the single-cable system, a continuous cable runs through all the holding claws. When you step on the pedal, the claws close evenly around the trunk. Krinner considers itself the inventor of this principle and states that one person can set up and align the tree alone this way. The system plays to its strengths with crooked trunks: you loosen, readjust and step on the pedal again.
Classic screw stands hold the trunk with three or four wing screws. They are simply built, often of cast iron or steel, and rarely have a large tank. Aligning the tree takes patience because each screw has to be adjusted individually, and you usually need a second person to hold the tree. There is nothing wrong with one for a small tree on the balcony or as a decorative piece. For the two-meter fir in the living room, we would go with the pedal.
Six Christmas tree stands with manufacturer data
| Model | Tree height up to | Trunk up to / tank | Base | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Krinner Comfort Grip+ M | 2.5 m | 12 cm / 3.5 l | 36 cm | typical living room tree |
| Krinner Ultra Grip+ L | 2.7 m | 12 cm / 3.7 l | 37 cm | households with children or pets |
| Krinner Ultra Grip+ XXL | 4.0 m | 17 cm / 11 l | 52 cm | high ceilings in older buildings, stairwells |
| Krinner Kopenhagen | 2.5 m | 12 cm / no liter figure | 50 cm | those who want the stand to be seen |
| Star-Max Pro Nature 3 | 3.0 m | 13 cm according to retailers / no manufacturer figure | 37 cm | trees just under three meters |
| Star-Max Select 5 | 4.5 m | 17 cm according to retailers / no manufacturer figure | 50 cm | very large trees, 9 kg dead weight |
Krinner Comfort Grip+ M
The Comfort Grip+ M covers the normal case. According to the manufacturer, it holds trees up to 2.5 meters with trunks up to 12 centimeters, the tank holds 3.5 liters and the base measures 36 centimeters. A safety bell is not included in this class. If recycled plastic matters to you, you will find the same key specs in the Green-Line version.
Krinner Ultra Grip+ L
Barely larger, but better secured. According to Krinner, the L size holds trees up to 2.7 meters and has a 3.7-liter tank. It adds a safety bell that audibly signals that the claws are gripping, plus a safety strap. If children or a cat race past the tree, the extra cost over the Comfort Grip+ M is well justified.
Krinner Ultra Grip+ XXL
A stand for trees that touch the ceiling. According to the manufacturer, it handles up to 4 meters of tree height, a 17-centimeter trunk and an 11-liter tank on a 52-centimeter base. In a normal apartment, that would be overkill. In an older building with 3.5-meter ceilings or in an entrance hall, on the other hand, it is one of the few solutions with pedal operation.
Krinner Kopenhagen
The Kopenhagen series combines a foot pedal and single-cable system with a housing in a wood, concrete or black-and-white look. The key specs match the Comfort Grip+ M, but at 50 centimeters the base is considerably wider. Krinner does not give a liter figure for the water supply in its overview. If you hide the stand under a tree skirt anyway, you are mainly paying for looks here.
Star-Max Pro Nature 3
Star-Max is the stand brand of F-H-S from Mönchengladbach. According to the manufacturer, the Pro Nature 3 holds trees up to 3 meters and has a foot lever, single-cable system, child safety lock and a mechanical water level indicator. F-H-S cites German TÜV GS certification and a five-year warranty. The manufacturer’s website does not give the trunk diameter. Retailers state 3 to 13 centimeters, which you should check on the packaging before buying.
Star-Max Select 5
According to F-H-S, the large Star-Max model is built for trees up to 4.5 meters, stands on a 50-centimeter base and weighs 9 kilograms. Here, too, there is a foot lever and single cable. An alternative to the Krinner XXL if you can make do with a slightly smaller base. Check the tank and trunk figures on the specific offer before buying; the manufacturer’s website only mentions a „large water tank.“
How we would decide
- Tree up to 2.5 meters, trunk up to 12 centimeters: Krinner Comfort Grip+ M. A typical living room needs nothing more.
- Children, pets or a heavily decorated tree: Krinner Ultra Grip+ L with safety bell and strap.
- Tree around three meters: Star-Max Pro Nature 3, if the trunk fits according to the packaging.
- Trees from 3.5 meters: Krinner Ultra Grip+ XXL or Star-Max Select 5. Here, ceiling height decides, not price.
- Stand as a visible piece of furniture: Krinner Kopenhagen.
Not in the mood for needles and watering cans? Then the artificial Christmas tree remains an alternative. When it comes to lighting, smart Christmas lights and LED candles instead of real flames are worth considering, especially on a dry real tree.
If you set up an artificial tree instead of a real fir, our review of the Balsam Hill Nobilistanne covers five Advent seasons of experience with assembly and lighting.
Frequently asked questions
What should I look for when buying a Christmas tree stand?
The real limit is usually not the height of the tree but the trunk diameter. Most mid-range stands hold trunks up to 11 or 12 centimeters. Measure at the bottom of the freshly cut trunk and choose with a little margin. Add a tank of three liters or more.
What is the single-cable system?
A continuous cable runs through all the holding claws. When you step on the pedal, the claws close evenly around the trunk. According to Krinner, one person can set up and align the tree alone this way. With crooked trunks, you loosen, readjust and step on the pedal again.
Single-cable or screw stand?
Screw stands hold the trunk with three or four wing screws, rarely have a large tank, and each screw has to be adjusted individually, usually with a second person. There is nothing wrong with one for a small tree on the balcony. For the two-meter fir in the living room, the guide would go with the pedal.
Which stand for a very tall tree?
For trees from 3.5 meters, the Krinner Ultra Grip+ XXL or the Star-Max Select 5 are options. According to the manufacturer, the Krinner holds trees up to 4 meters, takes a 17-centimeter trunk and has an 11-liter tank on a 52-centimeter base. Here, ceiling height decides, not price.
How much water does a Christmas tree need?
A real tree drinks a lot, especially in the first few days. A tank of three liters or more saves you from refilling under the branches every day, and a water level indicator helps more than any liter figure.
Sources
- Krinner: Christmas tree stands, model overview with technical data
- Krinner: Ultra Grip+ L
- Krinner: Ultra Grip+ XXL
- F-H-S International: Star-Max Pro Nature 3
- F-H-S International: Star-Max Select 5
Where to buy
- Krinner Comfort Grip+ M (Black Edition)Check price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Krinner Ultra Grip+ LCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Krinner Ultra Grip+ XXLCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Krinner KopenhagenCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Star-Max Pro Nature 3Check price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Star-Max Select 5Check price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
