Contents13 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
A first pair of climbing shoes rarely fails because of the rubber. It fails because of the size. If you buy two sizes below your street shoe size because that is supposedly how it has to be, you will be sitting on the mat after twenty minutes in the gym, taking your shoes off. To start out, a model with a flat sole and no downturn that fits snugly but still relatively comfortably is enough; that is also how the German Alpine Club (Deutscher Alpenverein) describes it. For beginners, we therefore recommend the Ocun Crest, which is available with Velcro and with laces.
What do tension, downturn and asymmetry mean?
Three terms show up in every product description, and they are related. Tension means that the rand and the last push the foot forward and put the toes in a slightly curled position. Downturn is the visible downward curve of the sole. Asymmetry means that, seen from above, the toe points toward the big toe so the force lands on a small area.
A strongly curved shoe shifts the load into the toes. On overhangs, that helps, because your feet stay on tiny footholds and your fingers are relieved. On a long route, on the other hand, the same shape quickly tires the foot. Ocun also points out that flat shoes have an advantage on friction slabs because more rubber touches the rock. If you are still learning on vertical walls in the gym, you do not need this curve. It only costs comfort.
Gym or rock: do you need two pairs?
Not at first. In the gym, you often take your shoes off between two routes, and Velcro saves time there. On rock, what matters more is how long your foot stays in the shoe. On a multi-pitch route, that can easily be two hours without a break, and then the shoe should fit more loosely than for bouldering. For the approach to the base of the wall, by the way, you should wear sturdy hiking or approach shoes (in German), not climbing shoes.
A shoe like the Scarpa Origin VS is explicitly built for the gym, according to the manufacturer. Ocun, by contrast, classifies the Crest for rock, bouldering, multi-pitch and the gym. For beginners, that range is worth more than any specialized detail.
Velcro or laces?
A matter of taste, with a real difference. Laces can be tightened along the whole length of the foot and therefore give the most precise fit, especially for narrow feet or feet of different widths. Velcro opens in seconds. If you mostly boulder, you will appreciate that. In crack climbing on rough rock, however, the lower eyelets and laces are exposed; OutdoorGearLab describes exactly this kind of wear on the Tarantulace.
Which size is right?
This is where the advice differs most. For the Momentum, Black Diamond recommends half a size to a full EU size below your street shoe size for a comfortable fit, and two to two and a half sizes below for maximum performance. For the Striker, Ocun writes that most climbers choose their street size or half a size to a full size smaller. The material shifts the calculation further. Unlined leather stretches, by about half a size to a full size on the Tarantulace according to OutdoorGearLab. Synthetic material barely stretches and has to fit from day one.
Too tight has consequences. The German Alpine Club names shoes that are too tight, such as climbing shoes, as one factor that can promote splayfoot and, with it, hallux valgus. An article by Gerhild Weichberger published by the Austrian Alpine Club (Österreichischer Alpenverein) states that 87 percent of climbers accept foot pain because they wear shoes two to three sizes too small. If you already have problems with the big toe joint, you should have a doctor clarify which shape is suitable before buying. Ocun also advises putting on every shoe twice, because the second try often feels different.
Six climbing shoes compared
| Model | Closure | Shape | Sole | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ocun Crest QC / LU | Velcro (QC) or laces (LU) | flat, almost no asymmetry | CAT 1.1, 4 mm | beginners, gym and rock |
| Black Diamond Momentum | two Velcro straps | neutral, flat | Black Label | long gym days, slabs, multi-pitch |
| Scarpa Origin VS | one Velcro strap | flat, neutral, not asymmetric | S72, toe M50 | gym and bouldering |
| La Sportiva Tarantulace | laces | flat, neutral (OutdoorGearLab) | FriXion RS | beginners who want a leather shoe |
| Red Chili Ventic Air | two Velcro straps | moderate downturn, slight tension | RX-2 Techgrip | after the first few months |
| La Sportiva Solution | Velcro | aggressive downturn, high asymmetry (OutdoorGearLab) | Vibram XS Grip2, 3.5 mm | bouldering, steep sport routes |
Ocun Crest: built flat, for indoors and outdoors
Ocun describes a flat last with almost no asymmetry and a comfortable heel. The sole is made of 4 mm CAT rubber, and a rubber cap at the front protects the toes. Ocun gives the QC with Velcro a weight of 192 g and lists no weight for the LU with laces. A shoe that does not try to do anything special. That is exactly why it suits beginners.
Black Diamond Momentum: knit and two straps
According to the manufacturer, the Momentum sits on a neutral, flat last; the upper is microfiber suede and the tongue is recycled knit fabric. Black Diamond names long gym days, slabs, cracks and multi-pitch as its uses. The website describes the midsole once as TPU and once as rubber; that changes little about its classification as a comfortable all-round shoe.
Scarpa Origin VS: the gym shoe
Scarpa states a flat, neutral profile without asymmetry and a two-part tension system that puts the heel and toe under tension. The whole sole is made of S72, according to Scarpa the grippiest rubber in its own range, and the toe of soft M50 for toe hooks. If you boulder almost exclusively in the gym, you get a shoe tailored precisely to that use.
La Sportiva Tarantulace: lace-up leather
OutdoorGearLab describes the Tarantulace as a flat, neutral shoe with unlined leather and a FriXion RS sole. The testers criticize the limited feel for small footholds and the empty space in the heel. It is good enough for vertical gym walls and moderate slabs, but it reaches its limits on overhangs.
Red Chili Ventic Air: one step further
Red Chili describes a moderate downturn with slight tension, an upper made of polyester knit, a hemp footbed and plenty of room for the foot. According to the manufacturer, the shoe is intended for climbers who are still relatively new and want a bit more performance. Even so, we would not buy it as a very first shoe.
La Sportiva Solution: only for steep terrain
Aggressive downturn, high asymmetry, a pointed toe and Vibram XS Grip2 at 3.5 mm: that is how OutdoorGearLab lists the Solution. Its strength lies on small edges and pockets on steep terrain. According to the review, it is not made for long routes, and the narrow toe box and stiff heel cup press on wide feet. If you have not yet climbed for a full season, what you mainly buy with it is pain.
How we would decide
- First season, gym and occasionally rock: Ocun Crest, with Velcro for bouldering, with laces for narrow feet.
- Long gym days, slabs or multi-pitch: Black Diamond Momentum, preferably in the comfortable size.
- Almost only bouldering in the gym: Scarpa Origin VS.
- Prefer leather that adapts: La Sportiva Tarantulace, then buy it snug and factor in the stretch.
- After the first few months, steeper angles: Red Chili Ventic Air.
- Overhangs and hard boulders: La Sportiva Solution, as a second pair alongside a comfortable shoe.
Shoes, harness and chalk bag fit together in a sports bag with a separate shoe compartment. That way, the rest does not smell like the gym.
Frequently asked questions
What do downturn, tension and asymmetry mean?
Tension pushes the foot forward and puts the toes in a slightly curled position. Downturn is the downward curve of the sole, and asymmetry means the toe points toward the big toe. That helps on overhangs; on vertical gym walls, it only costs beginners comfort.
How much smaller should climbing shoes be?
The advice varies. For a comfortable fit, Black Diamond recommends half a size to a full size below your street shoe size. Ocun writes that most climbers choose their street size or half a size to a full size smaller. Unlined leather stretches; synthetic material has to fit from day one.
Can climbing shoes that are too tight harm your feet?
The German Alpine Club (Deutscher Alpenverein) names shoes that are too tight, such as climbing shoes, as one factor that can promote splayfoot and, with it, hallux valgus. If you already have problems with the big toe joint, you should have a doctor clarify which shape is suitable before buying.
Velcro or laces?
Laces can be tightened along the whole length and give the most precise fit, especially for narrow feet or feet of different widths. Velcro opens in seconds, which counts when bouldering. In crack climbing on rough rock, however, eyelets and laces are exposed.
Do I need two pairs of climbing shoes for the gym and rock?
Not at first. Ocun classifies the Crest for rock, bouldering, multi-pitch and the gym; for beginners, that range is worth more than any specialized detail. On long routes on rock, the shoe should fit more loosely than for bouldering.
Is the La Sportiva Solution suitable for beginners?
No. Aggressive downturn, high asymmetry and a pointed toe are made for small edges and pockets on steep terrain, not for long routes. The narrow toe box and stiff heel cup press on wide feet. It works as a second pair alongside a comfortable shoe.
Sources
- German Alpine Club (Deutscher Alpenverein): Equipment for indoor climbing
- German Alpine Club (Deutscher Alpenverein): Foot problems, hallux valgus
- Austrian Alpine Club (Österreichischer Alpenverein) Hartberg-Vorau: Injuries and overuse in climbing (PDF)
- Ocun: How to choose the right climbing shoes
- Ocun Crest QC
- Ocun Crest LU
- Ocun Striker QC (sizing advice)
- Black Diamond Momentum
- Scarpa Origin VS
- Red Chili Ventic Air
- OutdoorGearLab: La Sportiva Tarantulace
- OutdoorGearLab: La Sportiva Solution
- OutdoorGearLab: Climbing shoe buying advice
Where to buy
- Ocun Crest QCCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Ocun Crest LUCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Black Diamond MomentumCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Scarpa Origin VSCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- La Sportiva TarantulaceCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Red Chili Ventic AirCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- La Sportiva SolutionCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
