Contents12 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
Expensive facial toning devices end up unused in the bathroom cabinet remarkably often. A silicone cleansing brush such as the FOREO LUNA 4 usually makes more sense, because it takes over a task that comes up every day anyway. According to the available studies, microcurrent and radiofrequency can bring small changes. Nothing more. If you spend a lot of money on them, you are mainly buying hope and a routine you have to keep up for weeks.
What the research shows and what is marketing
The most thorough review of home devices for facial skin appeared in 2024 in the journal Clinical, Cosmetic and Investigational Dermatology. The authors led by Bu evaluated 18 clinical studies, most of them on radiofrequency and only a single one on microcurrent. Their verdict is cautious: the devices may improve signs of skin aging „to some extent.“ At the same time, they openly name the weaknesses. Only five of the studies were randomized and controlled, only three had more than 50 participants, and none ran longer than twelve weeks. So nobody knows whether any effect lasts.
The manufacturers sound different. NuFACE cites percentages from its own study after 60 days, and FOREO advertises results „after one week“ for the BEAR 2. How many people took part and how the studies were designed is not stated on the product pages. We therefore read such figures as manufacturer claims, not as proof. The „FDA-cleared“ label also says less than it promises: NuFACE itself explains in its magazine that this US clearance mainly certifies equivalence with devices already on the market and does not apply the same standards to effectiveness.
And the cleansing brush? There are hardly any studies on its effect on the skin, but there is a clear statement from the American Academy of Dermatology (AAD) on mechanical exfoliation. Brushes, pads and sponges can irritate dry, sensitive or acne-prone skin too much. For darker skin tones or dark spots after acne, the AAD advises against vigorous mechanical exfoliation, and anyone using retinoids or benzoyl peroxide should be especially cautious. With rosacea, the professional association recommends skipping exfoliation altogether.
Before you buy: clarify skin type, patience and contraindications
- Skin type determines the brush. FOREO offers the LUNA 4 in versions for balanced, sensitive and combination skin. According to the instructions for use, one minute is enough, and it should not be more than three minutes a day.
- Electric current on the face has limits. In the BEAR 2 manual, FOREO lists implanted medical devices, epilepsy, cancer, rosacea and open wounds, among other things, as contraindications, and states that safety during pregnancy has not been established. NuFACE lists similar warnings. If you have a pacemaker, are pregnant or have a skin condition, check with a doctor first.
- Gel is part of it. Microcurrent devices only work with a conductive gel or serum.
- Radiofrequency means heat. The devices warm the skin to around 40 to 43 degrees Celsius. The review mentions a recall of a home device over possible low-temperature burns. After peels, laser treatments or injectable fillers, CurrentBody itself advises a three-month break.
Six devices, four principles
| Model | Principle | Key specs according to the manufacturer | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| FOREO LUNA 4 | Silicone brush with sonic pulsations | 16 intensity levels, up to 600 uses per charge, massage function, three skin-type versions | Daily cleansing, if you want to fine-tune the intensity |
| FOREO LUNA 4 go | Silicone brush with sonic pulsations | 8 intensity levels, up to 300 uses per charge, one brush head for all skin types | Smaller budget, travel |
| NuFACE TRINITY+ | Microcurrent | Expandable with attachments, conductive gel required | If you want to give microcurrent a serious try |
| NuFACE MINI+ | Microcurrent | More compact design, conductive gel required | Getting started with microcurrent, on the go |
| FOREO BEAR 2 | Microcurrent | Up to 680 µA, anti-shock system, levels 1 to 10, serum required | Tech enthusiasts who control the levels via app |
| CurrentBody Skin RF | Radiofrequency | Regulates skin temperature automatically; according to the manufacturer, use once a week for eight weeks | If you want heat treatments at home and have patience |
FOREO LUNA 4: the solid basic equipment
The LUNA 4 cleanses with silicone touchpoints instead of bristles and therefore needs no replacement heads; according to FOREO, one charge lasts up to 600 uses. Three cleansing modes and 16 intensity levels let you start very gently with sensitive skin. The back serves as a massage surface. FOREO bases its claim that it firms the skin on consumer surveys, not on a study.
FOREO LUNA 4 go: half the price, same basic idea
At FOREO itself, the go costs about half as much as the full-size LUNA 4. In return, you get eight instead of 16 intensity levels, only one brush head for all skin types and up to 300 uses per charge. If you have very sensitive skin, the LUNA 4 in the sensitive-skin version is the better choice.
NuFACE TRINITY+: the classic among microcurrent devices
NuFACE describes the principle like this: weak electrical impulses delivered through a gel are supposed to stimulate the facial muscles. The TRINITY+ can be expanded with further attachments, for example for the eye and lip area. The evidence on microcurrent, however, is the thinnest in the whole field. The 2024 review found exactly one study. On Amazon.de, customer reviews are rather mixed.
NuFACE MINI+: smaller, but the same question
The MINI+ is the more compact version with the same working principle. NuFACE markets it as a portable set, and it is suitable for a first try with microcurrent.
FOREO BEAR 2: lots of tech, lots of promises
FOREO states up to 680 microamperes for the BEAR 2, plus a system that measures skin resistance 200 times per second and adjusts the current. At first, only levels 1 to 5 are available; the stronger ones can be unlocked via the app. A maximum of three minutes per zone is intended. The list of contraindications in the manual is long and should be read before buying, not after.
CurrentBody Skin RF: heat instead of current
Radiofrequency warms deeper layers of the skin. According to the manufacturer, the CurrentBody device continuously measures skin temperature and switches off when the target value is reached; depending on the country page, the stated figure varies between 40 and 43 degrees Celsius. Radiofrequency is the most frequently studied method in the review, but here too the studies were small and short. So a high price for a small, uncertain effect.
And what about Clarisonic, Philips and the electric gua sha?
Clarisonic no longer exists; L’Oréal discontinued the brand. For existing devices, Michael Todd Beauty offers compatible replacement brushes; to our knowledge, there is no official successor. If you want to switch, you will usually end up with a silicone brush like the LUNA today. Philips also lists several versions of its VisaPure line as no longer available, which is why it is missing here.
Electric gua sha stones with heat, vibration and often LED light as well are available in large numbers on Amazon.de, almost exclusively from little-known sellers. We found no evidence for the advertised firming effect.
Which device, if any?
- More thorough cleansing for non-sensitive skin: FOREO LUNA 4, or the LUNA 4 go on a smaller budget.
- Sensitive skin or rosacea: better no brush at all. For sensitive skin, the AAD considers a washcloth and a mild chemical exfoliant gentler, and with rosacea it advises against exfoliating altogether. If you have a skin condition, check with a doctor first.
- Trying microcurrent: NuFACE MINI+ as a starting point. Expect weeks of daily use and ongoing costs for gel.
- Interested in radiofrequency: CurrentBody Skin RF only if you can keep up the effort for two months and have no contraindications.
Light instead of current? We have compiled the evidence on that in our guide to LED face masks (in German). What creams can do against wrinkles is covered under anti-aging creams (in German).
Frequently asked questions
Do microcurrent devices for the face work?
Little is proven. A 2024 review evaluated 18 clinical studies on home devices, only a single one of them on microcurrent. The devices may improve signs of skin aging to some extent, but no study ran longer than twelve weeks. Whether any effect lasts remains open.
Which skin types should avoid a cleansing brush?
The American Academy of Dermatology warns that brushes can irritate dry, sensitive or acne-prone skin too much. For darker skin tones or dark spots after acne, it advises against vigorous mechanical exfoliation, and with rosacea against exfoliating altogether. If you have a skin condition, check with a doctor first.
How long should you use a facial brush?
According to the FOREO LUNA 4 instructions for use, one minute is enough, and it should not be more than three minutes a day. FOREO offers the brush in versions for balanced, sensitive and combination skin, and the 16 intensity levels allow a very gentle start for sensitive skin.
What is the difference between the LUNA 4 and the LUNA 4 go?
At FOREO, the LUNA 4 go costs about half as much. In return, it has eight instead of 16 intensity levels, only one brush head for all skin types and up to 300 instead of 600 uses per charge. For very sensitive skin, the LUNA 4 in the sensitive-skin version is the better fit.
Who should avoid microcurrent on the face?
In the BEAR 2 manual, FOREO lists implanted medical devices, epilepsy, cancer, rosacea and open wounds, among other things, as contraindications, and states that safety during pregnancy has not been established. If you have a pacemaker, are pregnant or have a skin condition, check with a doctor first.
What does FDA-cleared mean for beauty devices?
Less than it promises. NuFACE itself explains in its magazine that this US clearance mainly certifies equivalence with devices already on the market and does not apply the same standards to effectiveness. Percentages from manufacturer studies remain manufacturer claims, not proof.
Sources
- Bu P. et al.: Home Beauty Devices for Facial Rejuvenation, Clin Cosmet Investig Dermatol 2024
- American Academy of Dermatology: How to safely exfoliate at home
- American Academy of Dermatology: Rosacea skin care tips
- FOREO: LUNA 4
- FOREO: LUNA 4 manual
- FOREO: LUNA 4 go
- FOREO: BEAR 2
- FOREO: BEAR 2 manual
- NuFACE: TRINITY+
- NuFACE: Which device is right for you?
- CurrentBody: Skin RF
- CurrentBody: Radiofrequency explained
- GCI Magazine: Replacement brushes for Clarisonic
- Philips: VisaPure Advanced
Where to buy
- FOREO LUNA 4Check price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- FOREO LUNA 4 goCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- NuFACE TRINITY+Check price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- NuFACE MINI+Check price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- FOREO BEAR 2Check price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- CurrentBody Skin RFCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
