Contents13 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
Which console should it be when there is only room for one in the living room? Our answer is almost always the same: the standard PlayStation 5 with a disc drive. It has the widest selection of big games, takes discs and costs significantly less than the Pro. Families with younger children should look at the Nintendo Switch 2 first. If saving money is the priority, the Xbox Series S comes into play.
By the way, people rarely go wrong with the brand. It gets annoying when the most powerful console is hooked up to a TV that cannot show off its strengths at all.
PlayStation vs. Xbox vs. Nintendo: three worlds compared head to head
Behind the three brands are three different ideas of what a console should be. Sony builds the PlayStation around big games from its own studios. Microsoft thinks of the Xbox in terms of subscriptions and also brings its games to the PC, and some, such as Forza Horizon 5, now even to the PlayStation. Nintendo combines handheld and living room in one device and relies on its own franchises such as Mario and Zelda, which are only available there.
| PlayStation 5 | Xbox Series | Nintendo Switch 2 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Strength | big exclusive games from Sony | Game Pass, games on PC too | Nintendo franchises, play on the go |
| Play on the go | no | no | yes, as a handheld |
| Disc drive | standard yes, Digital and Pro can be upgraded | Series X yes, Series S no | Game cards |
| Online subscription | PlayStation Plus | Game Pass | Nintendo Switch Online |
| Suits | most households | subscription gamers and PC owners | families and commuters |
The rule of thumb: first ask where your friends, or your children’s friends, play. Playing online together usually only works on the same platform, and in many families that matters more than any table.
Does the hardware even matter that much?
Not really. With consoles, performance specs are secondary; what counts is what you and your family want to play, because many well-known franchises are exclusive to one platform. Mario and Zelda come from Nintendo. Sony’s own studios release for the PlayStation first, while Microsoft also brings its games to the PC.
You should still factor in the TV. 4K at 120 Hz only helps if the set supports HDMI 2.1; which models do is covered in our guide to OLED TVs. Big games also take up a lot of space. 512 GB is tight. With 1 TB, you have to clean up less often.
Do I need a disc drive?
Without a drive, you save when buying, but you lose the used market for games. According to Sony, a drive can be bought separately for the PS5 Digital Edition and PS5 Pro. The Xbox Series S cannot do that.
What does the subscription cost over the years?
Playing online against others requires a subscription on all three platforms, and that belongs in the calculation. Sony requires PlayStation Plus for it. Even the smallest tier, Essential, is enough; Extra adds a game catalog, and Premium adds classics and cloud streaming on top. According to Sony, free-to-play games such as Fortnite usually run online without a subscription as well.
Microsoft divides Game Pass into Essential, Premium and Ultimate; only Ultimate includes new Microsoft games right at launch, plus EA Play and cloud gaming. At Nintendo, the subscription is called Nintendo Switch Online, and according to Nintendo, a family membership covers up to eight Nintendo Accounts. Honestly calculated, the top tiers at Sony and Microsoft cost more over a console generation than the console itself did. It adds up. If you buy two or three new games a year, you are often better off with the smallest tier. Sony and Microsoft changed their subscription prices in 2025 and 2026. The respective store shows the current status.
How do I protect children on the console?
In Germany, the USK, the country’s age rating body for games, assigns age ratings from 0 to 18 years, supplemented by notes on things such as chats or in-game purchases. The USK advises activating the console’s parental controls right during setup. Age ratings, play time per day or week, and purchases can be limited on all three systems. The USK has reviewed the Xbox parental control system and recognized it as suitable. On the Switch 2, parents control much of this via the Nintendo Switch Parental Controls app, including approval for the voice and video chat GameChat. Which device supports which setting is shown by the German initiative medien-kindersicher.de.
Five consoles compared
| Model | Storage | Disc drive | Resolution according to the manufacturer | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sony PlayStation 5 (Slim, Standard) | 1 TB | yes, detachable | up to 4K | most households |
| Sony PlayStation 5 Pro | 2 TB | no, can be added | 4K with PSSR upscaling | large 4K TV, high expectations |
| Nintendo Switch 2 | 256 GB, microSD Express up to 2 TB | Game cards | Handheld 1080p, TV up to 4K | Families, on the go |
| Microsoft Xbox Series X | 1 TB (2 TB as a special edition) | yes (Digital Edition without) | up to 4K, up to 120 fps | Game Pass players with a 4K TV |
| Microsoft Xbox Series S | 512 GB or 1 TB | no | 1440p, upscaled to 4K | small budget, second console |
PlayStation 5: the safe choice
In the current Slim housing, the standard version comes with 1 TB of storage according to Sony and a drive that plays PS5 and PS4 games on Blu-ray. So the old PS4 collection on the shelf remains usable. Sony lists the Digital Edition without a drive at 825 GB. It only makes sense if you are sure you do not want to buy discs.
PlayStation 5 Pro: only with the right TV
Sony gives the Pro a 2 TB SSD, Wi-Fi 7, enhanced ray tracing and PSSR upscaling, which lifts an image from 1440p to 4K, for example. There is no drive; it is sold separately. The differences mainly become visible on a large, good 4K TV, and even there only in games that have been optimized for it. In the vast majority of living rooms, you get too little to see for the extra cost.
Nintendo Switch 2: family and couch
A handheld and a living room console in one. Nintendo specifies a 7.9-inch LCD with 1920 × 1080 pixels, HDR10 and up to 120 Hz; on the TV, up to 4K at 60 frames per second is possible. The 256 GB of storage can only be expanded with microSD Express cards; older microSD cards do not work. Most Switch 1 games still run, though according to Nintendo, some do not. In families, Nintendo’s game lineup carries more weight than any performance figure.
Xbox Series X: powerful, but with games on the PC too
For the Series X, Microsoft specifies 4K gaming at up to 120 frames per second and 1 TB of storage, with a 4K UHD Blu-ray drive in the standard version. There is also a Digital Edition without a drive and a special edition with 2 TB. The console plays to its strengths mainly with Game Pass Ultimate. If you already have a powerful computer under your desk, many Microsoft games run there too, and our gaming PC guide (in German) helps you weigh it up.
Xbox Series S: small and affordable, with compromises
No console here is cheaper than the Series S. Microsoft targets 1440p with it and upscales to 4K. It has no drive, and one cannot be added either. Because the 512 GB version fills up quickly, Microsoft also sells a 1 TB version and storage expansion cards. A sensible choice as a second console in a child’s room or for pure Game Pass players.
So which one should I get?
Usually the PlayStation 5 (Slim, Standard) with a disc drive, plus the smallest PS Plus tier if you play online. For children under twelve, the Nintendo Switch 2 comes out ahead, and the parental controls app gets connected right during setup. Whether a bundle with a game is worth it during the sales weeks is calculated in our guide Black Friday game consoles.
Tight budget? Xbox Series S, ideally with 1 TB. If there is a large 4K TV in the living room and you play a lot, the PlayStation 5 Pro or Xbox Series X are options, depending on which games appeal to you.
Often forgotten is the sound, which usually remains the weakest part when it comes from the TV. To improve it: soundbars at a glance (in German).
If you also want to explore virtual worlds with your console, our VR headset guide shows which headset works with the PS5, a Windows PC or without any computer at all.
Frequently asked questions
Which console is right for children under twelve?
For children under twelve, the Nintendo Switch 2 comes out ahead, because in families Nintendo's game lineup carries more weight than any performance figure. It is a handheld and a living room console in one. Connect the Nintendo Switch Parental Controls app right when you set it up; it also lets you approve GameChat.
Is the PlayStation 5 Pro worth it?
Only with the right TV. The Pro brings 2 TB of storage, Wi-Fi 7, enhanced ray tracing and PSSR upscaling. The differences mainly become visible on a large, good 4K TV and in games optimized for it. In most living rooms, you get too little to see for the extra cost.
Do I need a console with a disc drive?
Without a drive, you save when buying, but you lose the used market for games. According to Sony, a drive can be bought separately for the PS5 Digital Edition and PS5 Pro, but not for the Xbox Series S. The standard PS5 also plays PS4 games on Blu-ray, so your old collection remains usable.
Do I need a subscription to play online?
Yes, playing online against others requires a subscription on all three platforms: PlayStation Plus, Game Pass or Nintendo Switch Online. With Sony, the Essential tier is enough. According to Sony, free-to-play games such as Fortnite usually run online without a subscription as well. If you buy two or three new games a year, the smallest tier is often enough.
How much storage does a game console need?
Big games take up a lot of space. 512 GB is tight; with 1 TB, you have to clean up less often. That is why the Xbox Series S is also available with 1 TB. On the Switch 2, only microSD Express cards expand the 256 GB; older microSD cards do not work.
How do I set up parental controls on the console?
The USK, Germany's age rating body for games, advises activating parental controls right during setup. On all three systems, you can limit age ratings, play time per day or week, and purchases. The USK has reviewed the Xbox parental control system and recognized it as suitable. Which device supports which setting is shown at medien-kindersicher.de.
Sources
- Sony: PlayStation 5 models
- Sony: PlayStation 5 Pro
- Sony: PlayStation Plus
- Nintendo: Switch 2 specifications
- Nintendo: Switch 2 features
- Nintendo: Family memberships
- Microsoft: Xbox Series X
- Microsoft: Xbox Series S
- Microsoft: Xbox Game Pass
- USK (German age rating body for games): Technical protection in games
- USK: Certification of the Xbox parental control system
- Xbox Wire: Forza Horizon 5 for PlayStation 5
Where to buy
- Sony PlayStation 5 Slim StandardCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Microsoft Xbox Series S (512 GB)Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seCheck price at Amazon.comCheck price at Amazon.ca
- Sony PlayStation 5 ProCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seCheck price at Amazon.comAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Nintendo Switch 2View at CoolblueAvailable in Germany: Coolblue
- Microsoft Xbox Series XCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seCheck price at Amazon.comAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de

