Contents13 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
With a green screen, it is rarely the material that goes wrong. Far more often, the cloth is simply too small. At a desk, while streaming or in video calls, a pull-down roller screen such as the Elgato Green Screen MT on the wall or ceiling is the most convenient solution. If you film standing up or the background has to come along, you need a stand system such as the Westcott X-Drop. And if whole people are to stand free down to the floor, there is hardly any way around seamless background paper on a support system.
Step one: set up the camera and measure
Place the camera where it will stand later. The green area has to fill the frame completely, even when you lean to the side. At a desk, a width of 1.5 meters is usually enough for this. Standing up and in a medium-wide shot, even two meters gets tight.
Step two: the type that suits the room
A roller screen is mounted permanently on the wall or ceiling and is down and away again in seconds. It does, however, require a load-bearing wall and stays where it is. If you do not want to drill, choose a pull-up case that stands on the floor and from which the fabric is pulled upward, at the price of several kilos of weight.
Collapsible frames are spring steel rings with fabric. They fold down to a fraction of their size and are inexpensively made, but smaller and less smooth at the edges.
Fabric on a stand remains the most flexible: size and height can be adjusted, the cloth is washable and travels with you. Its enemy is creases, which is why manufacturers advertise wrinkle-resistant fabric. Finally, background paper is wrinkle-free and matte and runs down to the floor as a sweep. It does crease easily, though, and needs a full-width support system.
Green or blue? Green is the standard, and software usually assumes it too. Blue helps with green clothing, plants or a green logo in the shot. A two-sided cloth makes the decision for you.
Step three: light before fabric
Even an expensive green screen is of little use if it is lit unevenly. The software looks for an even color tone; to it, shadows, wrinkles and hotspots appear as a different color and remain as patches. That is why you light the background separately from yourself, ideally with two soft panel lights from the left and right.
Keep your distance. The closer you stand to the cloth, the more green light bounces back onto your shoulders and hair, and the harder the software has to work on the edges. Suitable panel lights are presented in the article on continuous lighting and video lights.
The camera matters too, because heavy image noise makes the edges flicker. Tips on choosing one are in the webcam guide (in German).
Step four: software that costs nothing
For live streams, the free chroma key filter in OBS Studio is enough. According to the documentation, it is available on Windows, macOS and Linux, is preset to green and takes any other color on request. Three sliders do most of the work: Similarity determines how much green disappears, Smoothness softens the edges, and Key Color Spill Reduction removes green fringes on hair and shoulders. According to the manufacturer, Westcott includes 25 cutouts with the CloudKO Lite software with its X-Drop kits, intended for photos.
Video conferencing programs also hide backgrounds entirely without a green cloth. They calculate the outline from the image and reach their limits with fast movements, headphone headbands or fine hair sooner than a cleanly lit color key does. For occasional calls, that is enough.
Six background systems side by side
| Model | Type and area | Space and setup | For whom |
|---|---|---|---|
| Elgato Green Screen MT | Roller screen, approx. 200 × 180 cm, polyester | Wall or ceiling mount, rolled up 209 × 8 × 9.5 cm, 5.4 kg | Fixed spot at the desk |
| Neewer Greenscreen Pull-up | Pull-up, 152 × 197 cm, self-locking frame | Stands on the floor, aluminum base, 7.8 kg according to the listing | No drilling, changing rooms |
| Neewer 2-in-1 Faltgreenscreen mit Ständer | Collapsible frame, 1.5 × 2 m, green and blue | Stand 88 to 201 cm, bag for the cloth only | Little space, both colors |
| Westcott X-Drop Kit 5′ × 7′ | Fabric on a stand, approx. 1.5 × 2.1 m, washable | Footprint approx. 1.57 × 1.37 m, up to 2.29 m high, with bag | Mobile, interviews, portraits |
| Westcott X-Drop Pro Kit 8′ × 8′ | Fabric on a stand, approx. 2.4 × 2.4 m, washable | Footprint approx. 2.59 × 1.68 m, up to 2.54 m high | Standing shots, two people |
| Neewer Hintergrundsystem mit Grünkarton | Support system up to 3 m wide and 2 m high, paper roll 2.72 m | Two stands, four crossbars, bag | Full body, products, sweep |
Elgato Green Screen MT
Screwed to the wall or ceiling, pulled down by the handle. According to Elgato, the roll locks in any position, and a short tug lets the fabric retract into the metal housing. Around 200 × 180 cm covers the area behind a desk chair well. According to buyer reports, hooks and wall plugs are not included. Be careful with leftover stock: the manufacturer now lists the freestanding Elgato Green Screen and the Green Screen XL as discontinued, with no direct successor.
Neewer Greenscreen Pull-up
Without permission to drill, you place this case (a floor-standing pull-up green screen) behind your chair and pull the fabric up to 152 × 197 cm. According to the manufacturer, the frame locks itself. At almost eight kilos, it is not travel luggage. For moving it around the apartment, it is fine.
Neewer 2-in-1 Faltgreenscreen mit Ständer
A spring steel frame (collapsible green screen with stand) with a green and a blue side on a stand that can be adjusted between 88 and 201 cm. Be careful when transporting it, because according to the listing only the cloth fits in the bag, not the stand. In addition, a round collapsible frame rarely stretches the fabric as smoothly at the corners as a roller screen.
Westcott X-Drop Kit 5′ × 7′
Stand, wrinkle-resistant polyester cloth and bag come in one kit that, according to Westcott, weighs less than 2.3 kg. The cloth can go in the washing machine at a low temperature. The manufacturer plans a footprint of about 1.57 × 1.37 m. If you fold in the rear leg, the depth shrinks to around 51 cm.
Westcott X-Drop Pro Kit 8′ × 8′
The larger version comes with around 2.4 × 2.4 m of cloth with grommets and a pole pocket. According to Westcott, the stand reaches a height of up to 2.54 m and also takes the narrower 5-foot cloths. In return, the kit needs space; the room has to offer a good 2.6 m of width. For a seat at the computer, that is a lot of effort for little return.
Neewer Hintergrundsystem mit Grünkarton
Two stands, four crossbars, one bag: this background support system with green paper carries up to 3 m in width and 2 m in height, and therefore also a paper roll of 2.72 m. Paper has no wrinkles and runs onto the floor as a sweep, which helps when keying out feet and products; only shoe prints and creases stay forever. The well-known Colorama-Karton in Chromagreen (Colorama background paper) is currently listed as unavailable on Amazon, but green rolls from other suppliers are available.
In the end: your room decides
A fixed desk and a free wall? Then the Elgato Green Screen MT, which stays invisible as long as nobody needs it. In a rented apartment without drilling, the Neewer Pull-up is a good fit, and with very little space the collapsible frame with stand. On the road and at clients‘ premises, a lot speaks for the Westcott X-Drop Kit 5′ × 7′; standing, with two people or in a medium-wide shot, for the X-Drop Pro 8′ × 8′. If the whole person including the floor is in the shot or it is about products, the support system with paper remains, plus at least two lights for the background.
One more thought for streaming. A good picture with an echoing voice comes across worse than the other way around, which is why the USB microphone for streaming (in German) also belongs in the planning.
Frequently asked questions
How big should a green screen be?
The green area has to fill the frame completely, even when you lean to the side. So place the camera where it will stand later and measure. At a desk, a width of 1.5 meters is usually enough. Standing up and in a medium-wide shot, even two meters gets tight.
Green or blue background: which is better?
Green is the standard, and software usually assumes it too. Blue helps with green clothing, plants or a green logo in the shot. A two-sided cloth, such as the Neewer 2-in-1 Faltgreenscreen (collapsible green screen), makes the decision for you.
Why does my green screen look patchy?
Usually it comes down to the lighting. The software looks for an even color tone; shadows, wrinkles and hotspots remain as patches. Light the background separately from the person, ideally with two soft panel lights from the left and right. Keeping your distance from the cloth prevents green fringes on shoulders and hair.
What software do you need for chroma key?
For live streams, the free chroma key filter in OBS Studio on Windows, macOS and Linux is enough. Three sliders do most of the work: similarity, smoothness and key color spill reduction against green fringes. According to the manufacturer, Westcott includes 25 cutouts with CloudKO Lite for photos with the X-Drop kits.
Roller screen, fabric on a stand or paper: which fits?
A roller screen is down and away again in seconds, but needs a load-bearing wall. Fabric on a stand is flexible, washable and travels with you; its enemy is creases. Background paper is wrinkle-free and runs down to the floor as a sweep, but it creases easily and needs a full-width support system.
Do you even need a green screen for video calls?
For occasional calls, not necessarily. Video conferencing programs also blur or replace backgrounds without a green cloth. They calculate the outline from the image and reach their limits with fast movements, headphone headbands or fine hair sooner than a cleanly lit color key does.
Sources
- Elgato: Green Screen MT
- Elgato: Green Screen (discontinued)
- Elgato: Green Screen XL (discontinued)
- Westcott: X-Drop Backdrop Kit Chroma-Key Green 5′ × 7′
- Westcott: X-Drop Pro Backdrop Kit Chroma-Key Green 8′ × 8′
- Westcott help: Footprint of the X-Drop and X-Drop Pro
- Neewer: Pull-up Green Screen
- Neewer: 2-in-1 Collapsible Backdrop Blue/Green
- OBS Studio: Chroma Key Filter
Where to buy
- Elgato Green Screen MTCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Neewer Greenscreen Pull-up 152 x 197 cmCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Neewer 2-in-1 Faltgreenscreen mit StänderCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Westcott X-Drop Kit 5' × 7'Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Westcott X-Drop Pro Kit 8' × 8'Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Neewer Hintergrundsystem mit GrünkartonCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Hintergrundkarton Grün 2,72 mCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
