Contents13 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
When it comes to hearing protection, DIYers like to reach for the highest number on the package. SNR 37 sounds like maximum safety, but in a hobby workshop it is often too much of a good thing. For saws, sanders and rotary hammers, in our assessment a solid earmuff around SNR 32, such as the uvex K2, is enough, plus a pack of foam earplugs for the loud exceptions. If you need music or phone calls, go for a Bluetooth earmuff that limits the sound itself.
Why not simply go for the maximum? Because then you no longer hear anything. Neither your coworker nor the sound that announces a workpiece is jamming in the saw blade.
When noise starts damaging your hearing
Noise damage cannot be repaired. The German Social Accident Insurance (DGUV) calls noise-induced hearing loss an irreversible disease, and its Institute for Occupational Safety and Health lists it as the most common recognized occupational disease. For workplaces, the German Noise and Vibration Occupational Safety and Health Ordinance sets two thresholds: the lower action value is a daily noise exposure level of 80 dB(A) or a peak level of 135 dB(C), the upper one 85 dB(A) or 137 dB(C). From 80 dB(A), employers must provide hearing protection; above 85 dB(A), wearing it is mandatory according to the DGUV.
The ordinance does not apply to private workshops. Your ears do not know that difference, though, so the values serve as a guideline. And the DGUV stresses one more thing: even shorter periods without protection cause damage. If you take off the earmuff for a call while the miter saw is running next to you, you give away part of the effect.
SNR, H, M, L: what the numbers on the package mean
The SNR value is an average across all frequencies. The three letters next to it are more precise. H stands for attenuation of high-frequency noise, M for medium and L for low frequencies. Screeching metal tends to sit at the top, a droning motor more at the bottom. So anyone dealing with low droning should look at the L value.
In the lab, hearing protection sits perfectly. In everyday use, it does not. German DGUV Rule 112-194 therefore subtracts a real-world deduction from the M or L value: 5 dB for earmuffs and pre-molded earplugs, 9 dB for foam earplugs that are rolled before insertion, and 3 dB for custom-molded earplugs. Whatever remains is subtracted from the noise level. According to DGUV Information 212-024, 70 to 80 dB(A) should then reach the ear under the hearing protection. Less than 70 dB(A) is considered overprotection, because speech and warning signals get lost, and workers are then more likely to reject the protection.
A worked example with an assumed daily level of 95 dB(A) and medium-frequency noise: according to the manufacturer, the uvex K2 has an M value of 29 dB. Minus 5 dB leaves 24, so about 71 dB(A) reaches the ear. With the 3M Peltor X5A (M 35), it would be around 65 dB(A). That is more quiet than the work calls for.
Seven hearing protectors and their attenuation values
| Model | Type | Attenuation according to manufacturer | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| uvex K2 | Earmuff, headband | SNR 32 (H 37, M 29, L 21) | Hobby workshop, garden, saw and sander |
| 3M Peltor X4A | Earmuff, twin headband, 234 g | SNR 33 (H 36, M 30, L 22) | Longer jobs with loud tools |
| 3M Peltor X5A | Earmuff, twin headband, 351 g | SNR 37 (H 37, M 35, L 27) | Very loud environments, low droning |
| 3M WorkTunes Connect 90570 | Earmuff with Bluetooth 5.3, rechargeable battery | SNR 33 (H 34, M 31, L 25) | Music and phone calls while working |
| Howard Leight Impact Sport | Earmuff, electronic, level-dependent | SNR 25 (H 27, M 22, L 18) | Hearing conversations and warning signals, moderate noise |
| Moldex Spark Plugs 7800 | Foam earplugs, disposable | SNR 35 (H 35, M 32, L 31) | Backup, glasses wearers, combination with earmuffs |
| Alpine WorkSafe | Earplugs with filter, reusable | SNR 23 (H 22, M 20, L 20) | Moderately loud work with conversations |
uvex K2: the solid middle ground
According to uvex, the K2 from Fürth, Germany, attenuates with SNR 32, and with 37 dB at high frequencies. The headband is length-adjustable and padded, the cushions are made of memory foam, and it is certified to EN 352-1:2020. For the typical home workshop, it lands in the recommended range without shutting everything out. According to uvex, the sealing cushions should be replaced every six months.
3M Peltor X4A: slim and somewhat stronger
According to the 3M data sheet, the X4A attenuates with SNR 33 and weighs 234 g. The twin headband is electrically insulated, and the wide sealing rings are meant to reduce clamping pressure. If you buy used, you should know that 3M recalled X4 series earmuffs made between March 2020 and September 2022 because cracks could form in the cups. According to the British product safety authority, the design has since been changed.
3M Peltor X5A: only when it really drones
With SNR 37 and an L value of 27 dB, the X5A is the strongest headband earmuff in the X series. According to 3M, though, it also weighs 351 g and is bulky. In a normal hobby workshop, the calculation above argues against it. It makes sense with sustained, low, very loud noise.
3M WorkTunes Connect 90570: Bluetooth with a limit
According to 3M, the WorkTunes Connect pairs with your phone via Bluetooth 5.3, lasts more than 40 hours and charges over USB-C. It is protected against splashing water and sweat to IP44 and switches itself off after four hours. One sentence in the data sheet is crucial: the music signal is limited to 82 dB(A) at the ear. That way, you do not turn the noise protection into its opposite via the volume, and you do not have to take the earmuff off for a call.
Howard Leight Impact Sport: hear what is happening around you
The Impact Sport is electronic hearing protection. According to Honeywell, directional microphones reproduce ambient sounds, while loud impacts and bangs are limited to 82 dB. It comes with an AUX input for music and a folding headband. With SNR 25, it attenuates noticeably less than the passive earmuffs. That is not always enough for continuous work at the table saw, but for jobs where you need to hear people calling out, it is the better choice.
Moldex Spark Plugs 7800: foam for your pocket
On paper, these disposable earplugs attenuate more than the K2. SNR 35, and with L 31 also at low frequencies. However, rolled foam earplugs carry the largest real-world deduction of 9 dB, because they only work when they are seated deeply and properly. Moldex specifies a shelf life of four years from manufacture. They belong in every toolbox, if only as a backup.
Alpine WorkSafe: earplugs with a filter
The WorkSafe are made of a soft, silicone-free thermoplastic and have an acoustic filter. Alpine specifies SNR 23, tested to EN 352-2. A cord and an extended grip make them easier to remove while wearing gloves. The attenuation is deliberately moderate: conversations remain intelligible. For a rotary hammer or chainsaw, that is too little.
Earmuffs, earplugs or both?
Earmuffs are seated correctly in seconds and are easy to check. Earplugs are lighter and do not get warm. According to DGUV Rule 112-194, if you also wear glasses, you should tend toward earplugs; with earmuffs, wide, soft cushions and the flattest possible eyeglass temples help. More on the right glasses is in our safety glasses guide (in German).
For extreme noise, earplugs and earmuffs can be combined. The attenuation values do not add up, though. In professional settings, the DGUV requires tested combinations with a known overall attenuation; roughly the higher value of the two products is what counts. In a hobby workshop, you rarely need this.
How we would decide
- Hobby workshop with saw, sander and router: uvex K2, supplemented by Moldex Spark Plugs.
- Long days with loud tools: 3M Peltor X4A; when buying used, check the cups for cracks.
- Low, very loud droning for hours: 3M Peltor X5A.
- Music or phone while working: 3M WorkTunes Connect 90570.
- Conversations and shouts should come through: Howard Leight Impact Sport or, with quieter tools, Alpine WorkSafe.
Which machines run at which volume depends on the tool. Tips on that are in our guides to the table saw and the cordless chainsaw. Whichever model you choose: cushions and foam inserts age. For the Impact Sport, Honeywell recommends replacing them every six to eight months, or after three to four with intensive use or moisture. Hard, cracked cushions no longer seal.
How loud it really is at the machine is covered in our guide to the sound level meter (in German).
Frequently asked questions
At what decibel level do you need hearing protection?
The German Noise and Vibration Occupational Safety and Health Ordinance sets the lower action value at 80 dB(A) and the upper one at 85 dB(A). From 80 dB(A), employers must provide hearing protection; above 85 dB(A), wearing it is mandatory. The ordinance does not apply to private workshops, but the values still serve as a guideline.
What do SNR, H, M and L mean on hearing protection?
The SNR value is an average across all frequencies. H stands for attenuation at high frequencies, M at medium and L at low frequencies. Screeching metal tends to sit at the top, a droning motor more at the bottom. So if you deal with low droning, look at the L value.
Can hearing protection attenuate too much?
Yes. According to DGUV Information 212-024 (German Social Accident Insurance), 70 to 80 dB(A) should reach the ear under the hearing protection. Less is considered overprotection, because speech and warning signals get lost. Assuming 95 dB(A), the uvex K2 ends up at about 71 dB(A) after the real-world deduction, and the 3M Peltor X5A at around 65 dB(A).
Earmuffs or earplugs: which is better?
Earmuffs are seated correctly in seconds and are easy to check. Earplugs are lighter and do not get warm. For people who wear glasses, DGUV Rule 112-194 tends to recommend earplugs. Foam earplugs carry the largest real-world deduction of 9 dB, because they only work when seated deeply and properly.
Can you listen to music under hearing protection?
With a suitable model, yes. According to the data sheet, the 3M WorkTunes Connect 90570 limits the music signal to 82 dB(A) at the ear, so the noise protection is not undermined by the volume. Calls go over Bluetooth without taking off the earmuff, because according to the DGUV even short periods without protection cause damage.
How often do you need to replace the cushions on hearing protection?
Cushions and foam inserts age. For the K2, uvex recommends replacing them every six months; for the Impact Sport, Honeywell recommends every six to eight months, or after three to four with intensive use or moisture. Hard, cracked cushions no longer seal.
Sources
- German Noise and Vibration Occupational Safety and Health Ordinance (LärmVibrationsArbSchV), Section 6 action values
- DGUV Arbeit & Gesundheit: Preventing noise-induced hearing loss
- DGUV IFA: Noise
- DGUV Rule 112-194 Use of hearing protection, Section 6
- DGUV Information 212-024 Hearing protection in practice, Appendix 2
- uvex: K2 earmuffs
- 3M: Technical data for Peltor X series earmuffs (PDF)
- GOV.UK: Recall of 3M Peltor X4 series
- 3M: WorkTunes Connect 90570 data sheet (PDF)
- Honeywell: Howard Leight Impact Sport
- Moldex: Spark Plugs
- Alpine: WorkSafe product information (PDF)
Where to buy
- uvex K2 (schwarz/gelb)Check price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- 3M Peltor X4ACheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- 3M Peltor X5ACheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- 3M WorkTunes Connect 90570Check price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Howard Leight Impact SportCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Moldex Spark Plugs 7800Check price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Alpine WorkSafeCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
